Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Prodigy or fraud?

By Dadman
This is interesting...at least I think it is. The Sundance Film Festival is showing a documentary film entitled My Kid Can Paint That featuring a young girl named Marla Olmstead who is purported to be an artistic prodigy. I recall seeing a documentary on 60 Minutes about this kid that raised questions of fraud. In spite of this, Marla and her family have made hundreds of thousands of dollars selling Marla's artwork to eager art collectors. The Olmstead's have very slickly marketed their daughter and her art as you can see at this website: www.marlaolmstead.com. The filmmaker, Amir Bar-Lev, is decidedly non-commital with respect to Marla's authenticity as a prodigy. You can read more about Bar-Lev's experience making the film here. What do you think? I know Cosmic has some strong opinions about what constitutes art and is particularly opinionated when it comes to abstract art. I think there is something very fishy about this story.

Comments (3)

Cullen
Well, there is definitely something amazing about the art. I'm not too into that kind of work, but I can see the depth of talent that is on the canvas. I want to believe that she was solely responsible, so I'll choose to believe that she did them herself.
Dadman
What makes me very suspicious is that her creative 'process' has never been captured on film from start to finish. The filmmaker mentioned in the post tried, but failed. 60 Minutes tried and failed. It was becoming a huge thorn in Marla's credibility. Just recently the family posted a video of Marla creating a painting from start to finish - available in full only to collectors and media. There's a brief teaser of the new video on the site now. Having watched it, I'm still very skeptical. I think her parents are behind this in a very big way...
CosmicConservative
Abstract art... I once defined "abstract expressionism" something like this: "An attempt by urban elitists to distance themselves from the rest of humanity through the acceptance of radical 'art' forms." I still pretty much feel that way 30 years later. I don't "get" abstract expressionism for the most part. I can see the "energy" and the "forms" embedded in the art and can even appreciate some of the sensations that viewing the work can produce. But I can't get beyond well documented cases such as the man who held a canvas behind his mule and dipped the mule's tail in different colors of paint, then tickled its butt. The resulting "abstract expressionist" painting won a contest. When one of the judges was asked how he had managed to judge the tail swipes of a mule as the best piece of art he said something like "what can I tell you, that mule has talent." I am not opposed to abstract art, and some of it I find agreeable. But when an "artist" sells a cross dunked in urine and makes an international name for himself, or when an "artist" paints a Campbells soup can and becomes internationally famous, or when an "artist" hangs a used urinal on a wall, or when an "artist" spreads garbage all around a room... See, that's when I get a little lost in what the word "art" is supposed to mean. In many cases I think it means "con artist." And that may be what's going on here. I don't know.