Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Environmentalism as Religion

By Dadman
So, while Cosmic plugs away on his novel, I'll try to fill the void with some posts of my own... Michael Crichton is one of my favorite authors. I enjoy the prescient subjects of his novels, and I like his perspective on some of the most important topics of our time. He's been very vocal on the issue of global warming specifically and contemporary environmentalism in general. His novel, State of Fear, is a clear attack on the dubious science of human-induced global climate change and the politics that seem to have hijacked objective science, in particular environmental science. You should check out a speech he delivered to the Commonwealth Club in San Francisco a few years ago: Environmentalism as Religion Here's a brief morsel of the speech to pique your curiosity:
How will we manage to get environmentalism out of the clutches of religion, and back to a scientific discipline? There's a simple answer: we must institute far more stringent requirements for what constitutes knowledge in the environmental realm. I am thoroughly sick of politicized so-called facts that simply aren't true. It isn't that these "facts" are exaggerations of an underlying truth. Nor is it that certain organizations are spinning their case to present it in the strongest way. Not at all---what more and more groups are doing is putting out is lies, pure and simple. Falsehoods that they know to be false.
When you're done reading this speech you should check out some of his other speeches. I must say that Mr. Crichton is a voice of reason in the hysterical wilderness of modern environmentalism.

Comments (21)

qwerty182764
"Posted by Marc Morano 202-224-5762 marc_morano@epw.senate.gov (8:50pm ET) The Weather Channel’s most prominent climatologist is advocating that broadcast meteorologists be stripped of their scientific certification if they express skepticism about predictions of manmade catastrophic global warming. This latest call to silence skeptics follows a year (2006) in which skeptics were compared to "Holocaust Deniers" and Nuremberg-style war crimes trials were advocated by several climate alarmists. " (Monty Python Accent) Burn the witch! (/Monty Python Accent). http://epw.senate.gov/public/index.cfm?FuseAction=PressRoom.Blogs&ContentRecord_id=32abc0b0-802a-23ad-440a-88824bb8e528
Rick Larson
Yadayadyada, on and on and on. Lets see, pull a petal - the world will end, pull a petal, the world will not end. Last petal shows the truth. Actually, I am a big fan of Hari Seldon, and think, his predictions were accurate Because of the concerns he raised, instead of ignoring people to inaction. So, because of Y2K concerns, the code problem was solved. So, because there were people who believed the stock market would crash to zero, there were people left with money to buy in. So, because people know of the harmfull effects of burning fossil fuels, they will find clean renewable fuels. Prepare for the worst and hope for the best.
Dadman
Rick: I think the science, logic and reason behind the proposition that my SUV is not going to destroy the earth is just a tad more sophisticated than eeny meeny miney mo, or plucking flower petals. The problem with the notion of human-induced global warming, aside from the fact that I think it is being trumped up for political purposes, is that the science behind it - science that should be purely objective and subject to honest inquiry and debate - seems to be moving into the realm of rank political correctness that simply cannot and should not be questioned. Science should never be viewed as some kind of ideological orthodoxy. I suggest you read some of Crichton's speeches and the references posted by qwerty. You need some enlightenment.
qwerty182764
"So, because of Y2K concerns, the code problem was solved." Well, the problem with Y2K, as Crichton pointed out in one of his speeches, is that there was no problem. All that fear, all that hysteria, over what turned out not to do anything at all. What happened to my computer back in 2000? Nothing. What happened to all but the most outdated dinosaurs of computers? Nothing. A lot of things we consider "problems" today are like that. What I object to about global warming (hey, the earth might even be warming, even though the graphs I've seen are still terribly variable with respect to the average temp rise) are the calls for radical actions, eco-dictatorships, or silencing of skeptics. People who are right don't NEED to silence skeptics. They merely have to show their data and make their case, and trust that other people looking for the truth will probably arrive at concurrent data and concurrent conclusions. The only people who need these shrill calls for orthodoxy are people trying to grab power or push other people around. Once you call for the silencing of "skeptics" (with big evil quotation marks), stop calling yourself a scientist or a liberal, you're a priest of a new state religion.
qwerty182764
Also, note the oscillating doomsday scenarios as time goes on. First we were calling for mandatory sterilizations and breeding quotas because of a "population bomb" back in the 80s. I actually read Ehrlich's book "Limits to Growth", and I think you should too. The same calls for dictatorship and radical seisures of power to avert doom that never came to pass. What was predicted in that book doesn't even remotely resemble what happened in reality. And yet, at the time, it was lights out for humanity because of what these people were predicting. You'd have to see a tree in a museum. The earth would be depleted of metals and farmland. ect. Now we are beginning to loudly complain about "aging America". Same with global cooling->global warming->global warming that might induce a sudden catastrophic ice age->"climate change" (change, just to be sure we're covering all possible variations in the weather). Prophets of doom are fond of drawing straight tangents to local oscillations and declaring that the end is near unless we repent and put them in charge.
qwerty182764
Oh, and the ozone hole! Who could forget the ozone hole? We'd all have to go outside in tinfoil hats. Everyone would be dying of cancer from UV exposure (nevermind that most of our young people are paying good money for UV exposure). And it was all due to our evil R-12 refrigerant (as opposed to the "good" R-134a refrigerant that we replaced it with, which, btw, is less efficient). We just freaked out when we discovered the hole growing. Now that we've been looking at it a while, lo and behold, we find that it opens and closes regularly. It just oscillates. Furthermore, don't you find it odd that it's over the south pole and not, say, anywhere near a country that uses a lot of refridgerators and R-12? How much R-12 were we even putting in to the air in the first place? Certainly not anywhere near the amount of CO2 we put into the air, and yet it was supposed to clear the atmosphere of ozone thousands of miles away. Was the "crisis" averted due to forward thinking, or was this all just a big sacrifice to placate the volcano god over a newly discovered natural phenomenon?
Rick Larson
I've read some Crighton, and have considered both sides of the debate; and decided to direct my thoughts towards more the natural man. Spending time hunting, fishing, and enjoying the environment. Sadly, many don't care about the more simple things in life and would rather pass off a more harmonious participation with his surroundings for a fast-paced resource wasting at the expense of the environment lifestyle. And this is the point I will always make in this climate change debate. It could be humans because they have traded a natural life for concrete to run those SUV's in the biggest waste of a limited natural resource that future generations are sure to proclaim was criminal in nature. Criminal in waste, criminal in the exhaust created by it's use, and perhaps, criminal in that it has changed weather patterns.. And don't bother with that same old argument of past climate changes not cause by humans, as my question is why is there more species of plants and animals added to the extinct list in the last decade, than ever during these periods you type people continue to site? Think clearly my fellow internet conversationists; you can not possibly be a conservative without first being a conservationist. And I still continue to examine claims of impending doom - it is my nature. :-)
Dadman
Your arguments are all over the map, Rick. I can barely follow them. First, I do consider myself a conservationist and a conservative. I can be both and still be skeptical of catastrophic human-induced global warming. It's good to live in harmony with the environment as much as possible. I'm all for that. But there is not necessarily a correlation between living out of harmony (whatever that might mean) and end-of-the-world-as-we-know-it climate change. A large number of extinctions in the past decade (if that is indeed true) does not prove humans are melting the glaciers. That's a very weak argument. Plus, it seems like I see a lot of reports of NEW species being discovered all the time. I guess those species like global warming. So, if SUVs are a criminal waste of natural resources should we throw SUV drivers in jail? Would you support such a law? My personal take on gas-guzzling SUVs is that the more we drive them, the quicker we'll use up our petroleum reserves, and the quicker the evil internal combustion engine will be made obsolete. That would be a good thing, eh? I think you libs need to base more of your convictions on fact and logic and less on feelings and emotion. Just because you think 'it could be' humans that are causing global warming because you FEEL humans don't live in harmony with the environment don't make it so...
qwerty182764
Well, on a less harsh note, I'm a big advocate of living as far out of harmony with nature as possible. I don't live anywhere close to the way we lived before machinery began to improve our lives, and I don't think you do either, unless you are posting from the mountains of Nepal. In the big scheme of things, even If I drove a stretch hummer, I wouldn't be that further away from natural harmony than you would, driving a hybrid car (which don't get that much better gas mileage than diesels, btw). You still use plastics, electricity, modern plumbing and water treatment, modern medicine. The pesticides you probably curse as poison keep your food free of far more serious diseases that afflicted our grandparents, and they are getting greener all the time. The GM crops you probably also curse as an aberration of nature can grow free of these diseases without the use of pesticides at all! You probably use a thousand energy consuming processes a day, from heating your food (without wood - would it be better if 300 million people took axes to trees to heat their homes?) to washing your clothes. You are fantastically richer than any pre-industrial peasant possibly could be because you have hundreds of machines laboring for you 24/7, doing work that you don't have to do, that you couldn't do alone. Recycling of our raw materials itself is an energy intensive process that couldn't happen in a pre-industrial context. Do we really use energy at that different a rate on account of our cars? Which brings me to my next point - if you couldn't live comfortably without technology, why is being out of harmony with nature evil? You seem to think our prosperity is somehow wasteful and wrong even apart from the idea that our current energy source produces CO2 which might be a major factor climate change. In 3rd world countries, where you can still find people living in some imagined pre-industrial golden age, they are struggling to survive, to feed themselves, to escape their serfdom to the inner cities where maybe, just maybe, they can get a job with an eeeevil multi-national corporation that, even though it's pennies per hour by our standards, will pay them ten times more than they could make scratching a rice paddy with a stick! Nature isn't all that grand, and people all over the world are voting with their feet to get as far away from it as possible.
qwerty182764
PS. I too am worried about running out of oil someday (far more so than global warming. An industrialized society can easily deal with a climate shift. A society without energy can't deal with sustaining 300 million people, even under the best of conditions). But to replace oil with a "hydrogen economy" or any other type of energy storage medium (advanced batteries, ect) is going to require re-embracing nuclear energy on a large scale. Before you can replace the storage medium, you have to have the energy source to charge it, and pinwheel farms just aren't going to cut it. I've blogged about this before.
Dadman
In his Environmentalism as Religion speech, Crichton does a nice job of debunking the romance of primitive societies who live in harmony with nature. You're right, qwerty, I would never want to live that way. But I sorta know where Rick is coming from. We do waste a lot and we should never take the health of our environment for granted.
Rick Larson
There isn't enough uranium to replace the power of oil either. It will take a combination of all sustainable fuel types. And I resent the implication that I am a liberal. Recently we (local conservatives) have agreed to host Republican Congressman Roscoe Bartlett to speak about Peak Oil here in Manitowoc mid-August. I am very proud to have been instrumental in hosting this event and wish to snap you faker conservatives out of the loop as Roscoe is the most conservative member of Congress. If you read the link and find yourself in deep thought about your hidden liberal tendencies, please click into the C-Span website store and order the interview they had with Roscoe. So get with the program, or buy yourself a Democratic Party membership!
Rick Larson
Link: http://www.globalpublicmedia.com/interviews/397
Dadman
What? Faker conservatives? On what basis do you accuse qwerty and I of being faker conservatives with liberal tendencies? It's absurd. Perhaps you are a conservative, Rick, but not when it comes to the issue of catastrophic global warming. On that issue you are squarely on the same page with the most loony moonbat environmentalists. And I'm not implying it, I'm saying it...
Rick Larson
Doesn't feel good to be a conservative but called a liberal huh? Please refer where I made a quote about catastrophic global warming. You can't, but you certianly have put words into my ideas to demonize my position. Shame. Agreeing with the idea of Global Warming is not being on the same page as environmentalist wackos who want to reduce the human population by 90%.
qwerty182764
I don't get it. There's easily enough uranium to power civilization for tens of thousands of years. There just may not be enough high grade deposits, like there were when we were picking it up off the desert sands during our initial explorations. For a hundred dollars a pound, the supply is far far huger than it is for fifty dollars a pound. Did you know (the Japanese ran this experiment, btw) that you can filter the trace uranium out of sea-water and react it for a positive return on the energy investment? Not economical by any means so long as there are any land-based uranium deposits, but try to guess how much of a fuel supply that would be! And then there are breeder reactors - allowing us to use the other 99% of the uranium (the 238) rather than just the 235. And then you can add the thorium breeder reactors which burn thorium. No. There's easily the supply of uranium to power civilization, and I think it's one of the only ones practical when you're talking about driving huge electrolysis plants to output billions of gallons of hydrogen a year.
qwerty182764
PS - about the liberal thing, sorry if I assumed too early based only off your environmental position. It's too easy to do these days.
Rick Larson
Well, I could be wrong on this uranium thing, but proven reserves are really only proven once they are in hand. Think you should consider this: http://www.energybulletin.net/21625.html