Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

'Peace mom' turns attention to Guantanamo - CNN.com

By CosmicConservative
'Peace mom' turns attention to Guantanamo - CNN.com HAVANA, Cuba (AP) -- American "peace mom" Cindy Sheehan called for the closure of the U.S. military prison in Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, as she and other activists arrived in Cuba on Saturday to draw attention to the nearly 400 terror suspects held at the remote site. Sheehan is among 12 human rights and anti-war activists who will travel across this Caribbean island next week, arriving at the main gate of the Guantanamo base in eastern Cuba on Thursday -- five years after the first prisoners were flown in.
Man, when is her fifteen minutes going to run out? Of course, Cuba seems a logical place for her to be. I wonder if she'll decide to stay there?

Comments (12)

troutaholic
Totally agree.....this puppet is the white female Jesse Jackson!!!!
CosmicConservative
I don't see her as a Jesse Jackson. More of a Tawana Brawley. She is definitely getting used, but she seems to love the spotlight so much that she doesn't really care.
Rick Paffenroth
I suppose the popular conservative opinion is that she is being used by the liberal media to fuel their anti war/anti Bush agenda? She might just be a grieving mother who has the strength to stand up and state her opposition to a war she never agreed with in the first place, so no other parent has to go through what she did. While I certainly do not agree with all her opinions, I do respect her right to voice them. The "white female Jesse Jackson" comment is just what I would expect to find on your website. I hope I'm wrong, and meaningful/respectful discourse is the norm here, not mindless/hurtful name calling.
CosmicConservative
Rick: There are going to be partisan comments here from time to time. But what I try to do is keep the partisanship rational. I think it is fair to suggest that Cindy Sheehan is both being used by the left (not necessarilyl the liberal media) and that she has become an indiscriminate media-hound. Her actions in Venezuala and Cuba are reminescent to me of the actions of Jane Fonda or John Kerry in the Vietnam War. Any American who hugs and openly praises Hugo Chavez on national network news is a fair target for those who view Hugo Chavez (accurately in my opinion) as a dangerous enemy of the United States who is working towards a soviet-style socialist state in South America. You may think she's "just a grieving mother." That's fine. But I disagree. I think she is a rabid peace activist who disagreed with her son's choices and who dishonors her son's memory both by using his death for political purposes with which he personally disagreed, and by working daily to make his death meaningless by undermining the goals of the war in which he died. Those are fair criticisms. And they are far less distasteful than the stuff I hear on the left about Bush and Cheney lying us into war to enrich their oil buddies and wreak personal revenge on Saddam for trying to kill his "daddy."
Rick Paffenroth
I missed Cindy getting face time with Hugo. I did see the one with Danny Glover. As I said in my post earlier, I don't agree with everything she has said and done, but I do agree with her right to voice her opinion. I wish you would explain the part about her working daily to make his death meaningless by undermining the goals of the war in which he died. You see I have a hard time connecting the dots between the war in Iraq and the global war on terror. I don't believe going into Iraq and removing Sadam had anything to do with keeping us safe. And I also believe there is no chance in hell of Iraq ever becoming a democracy. I think there were much better options available to us at the time we blundered into Iraq. So if I never agreed with the war, or any of the goals as set forth by our president, am I also guilty of besmirching the memory of the more than 3,000 men and women who have given their lives?
CosmicConservative
Rick: How is criticizing her actions in any way interfering with her right to voice her opinions? Please explain this tired old canard from the left. I see this all the time. Someone on the right says "John Murtha is advocating defeat and retreat." and the left screams "He has a right to his opinion! Stop trying to silence him!" and I always say "What? Umm... two people in this exchange have a right to voice their opinions. John Murtha and CosmicConservative. We both did. What's your problem?" I understand that some people have a hard time "connecting the dots" to the war in Iraq. That doesn't mean the dots are not connectible or that others have not successfully done so. That's a difference of opinion, and I think you are wrong about it. You say going into Iraq had nothing to do with keeping us safe. I disagree. I point to five years without an attack on the U.S. and say that Iraq has something to do with that. You disagree. I think that's one of the dots that is connected. You don't. The only "fact" in all of that is that we haven't been attacked in five years. If you are working actively to undermine the war effort and leave Iraq a state in chaos with the potential result of massive genocide such as occurred in southeast Asia when we abandoned Vietnam, then yes, I believe you are guilty of besmirching the memory of more than 3,000 men and women who have given their lives. Just as I believe John Kerry and Jane Fonda besmirched the memory and sacrifice of more than 50,000 Americans who gave their lives in Vietnam. I don't want Iraq to be another Vietnam, I don't want the blood of a million people killed in genocide on our hands again as it was in Cambodia with Pol Pot when the U.S. turned its back on our commitments in Vietnam. That's my opinion. As you say I have a right to it. And I have as much right to say it as you or Cindy Sheehan does. I believe I support that opinion with facts and logic. And I'm more than willing to engage you, Cindy Sheehan or Jimmy Carter in open debate on the subject to see who has more facts, data and logic on their side. That's how it works. When it works anyway.
lance
Back to the origional post regarding Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, I hope more people take interest in this topic. GB is a national discrace, and contradicts American ideals and importantly, our law. It's time for us to assume a position of individual responisbility in this country again, and some of that means admitting to ourselves that "big daddy" government is not going to protect us from the bad people. It's an illusion that allows our government to trample our individual rights and provides no real security. -lw
CosmicConservative
Lance: The question of whether Guantanamo Bay Cuba is violating U.S. Law has been debated by far more knowledgeable folks than you and me. The issue is more complicated than most people understand. First and foremost is the fundamental issue that non-US citizens are not afforded citizens rights by the US Constitution, so the whole "unconstitutional" argument is so blatantly wrong that it blows my mind that people even propose it. The further argument that it violates the Geneva Convention demonstrates both a deep misunderstanding of what the Geneva Convention is (an agreement between countries who engage in "lawful war") and what it was for (to encourage countries to follow the military goals of the convention such as wearing uniforms, not using civilians as human sheilds, carrying flags, etc.). The argument that giving insurgents and terrorists Geneva Convention protections while at the same time absolving them of those very same Geneva Convention responsibilities actually encourages our enemies to engage in unlawful war is a powerful one. I understand that a US Court has ruled that we should provide Geneva Convention protections to those held in Gitmo, but that is being challenged as we speak and the jury is still out on the final decision. I believe that history and common sense is on Bush's side on this, not your side. But I've been surprised by the SCOTUS before and may be again. Please tell me which of your individual rights the government under GW Bush has "trampled." Especially any that GW Bush has trampled that Bill Clinton (who also challenged the FISA act's legality and who engaged in actual domestic electronic surveillance as opposed to the foreign surveillance Bush has been doing) has not trampled. Most of the Patriot Act simply gives the federal government the same sorts of powers to fight terrorism that the RICO laws gave the government to fight organized crime. Did you scream about the government "trampling your individual rights" when Clinton signed the RICO act into law? If not then I would argue that you are being either ignorant or hypocritical since there is virtually no difference between the actual impact on an average citizen in the two cases. You assert things that have not been proven and take those assertions as a license to personally attack another human being. There is a term for that sort of behavior. It is called "character assassination" and it reveals a lot more about the accuser than about the accused. If you have proof that GW Bush is doing something illegal, please send it to Nancy Pelosi or Harry Reid. I am sure they would dearly love to get their hands on such proof. If you have no proof, then be prepared to be called on your lack or proof when you make public statements of the sort you have made.
Rick Paffenroth
I was not trying to say that your criticism and your arguments were trying to silence her. Sorry if you took it that way. I just think she deserves the chance to say so in public and in the media without being demonized, that's all. As far as my stand on the war, I just have to wonder if the country can ever be stabilized without the support of American troops, and whether the massive genocide that is predicted will happen regardless if we leave now, or 5 or 10 years from now. How many more American lives is that worth? And if we stay in Iraq, and prevent it from becoming a haven for terrorists as Bush states, aren't there plenty more countries in that area willing to give AlQuida safe haven? I would rather see us take a course of action that uses our advanced intelligence capability to find terrorists and their training camps and then go in with air power and missles. We should be doing that in Iran and Syria now. Does anyone really believe that these two countries are not breeding grounds for terrorism? You and I will choose to disagree about the war in Iraq as being a reason that we have not been attacked since 9/11. I would attribute it to a massive world wide effort of cooperation, intel sharing etc. Many plots have been foiled by actions of countries that have nothing to do with Iraq, and would have been foiled whether we invaded Iraq or not. Please do not interpret my opposition to the war to being soft on terrorism. I just believe that there was a much smarter way to fight the terrorists without endangering thousands of more American lives.
CosmicConservative
So why can Cindy Sheehan demonize GW Bush but I can't demonize Cindy Sheehan? That's even assuming that I am demonizing her, which I deny. I am simply pointing out aspects of her behavior and why I think they are relevent and important. One of the most common complaints I hear from the Left is how GW Bush has alienated the entire world so much that they all hate us now. And here you are saying that GW Bush has presided over what has to be viewed as an unprecedented and almost completely successful effort to coordinate worldwide efforts to share intel and cooperate. Either you are out of touch with the others on the Left, or you are simply using an argument now about international cooperation because it suits your purpose to attack the war on Iraq, and in some other context you'll trot out the "the whole world hates us because of Bush and won't work with us" meme the first chance you get. Frankly from where I'm sitting it's a win-win. Either Bush has stopped attacks through putting troops in Iraq, or he has stopped them through unprecedentedly successful international cooperation. I think it's a combinatino of both. And frankly I think the Left is actively working against BOTH of them. Part of the unprecedented international success are efforts like the international financial efforts that the NY Times leaked over the objections of Democrats and Republicans alike. I wonder where you stand on that issue, since you think those are the sorts of things that make us safe. I have to assume you must be as upset with the NY Times as I was for publishing details of some of that very cooperation you speak of. Is that true? By the way, I have never argued that the Iraq war was necessary or was beyond criticism. I can respect the opinion that it made sense to go into Afghanistan but not into Iraq. I recognize the power of the arguments on both sides. In my opinion the biggest argument against the war in Iraq is that we squandered our opportunity to go to war with Iran, which I believe is a much larger threat.
Rick Paffenroth
While I will say that on a lot of issues, I do tend to side with the left (mostly social), I don't agree with some of the things coming from that side of the spectrum. For example, I don't think the residents of Gitmo have any constitutional rights, or rights under the Geneva Convention. The argument from the right about this issue makes good sense. I also have no problem with "racial profiling" in airports, etc. Why should a 70 year old grandma from Iowa have to be questioned and searched before boarding a plane? I also don't feel that illegal immigrants should be allowed to remain in this country, and to be rewarded for breaking our laws. I do not agree with your assertion that the war in Iraq and the success of the program of international cooperation in the war on terror is a win/win situation. I believe we could have achieved the same results without losing 3,000 more lives, and at the same time spent the money that has gone into the war on more people and technology to protect our own borders and make us safer. I remember right after 9/11 there were many discussions about how to make our country safer from attack. The answers that came from the Bush administration was "too expensive". Yet they continue to spend billions upon billions of dollars on a war that IMHO has been a complete failure with little chance of success. I completely agree that Iran is a huge threat, and our insistence on going into Iraq in the first place, and continuing to pour our money and troops over there, has greatly affected our ability to fight the fight elsewhere. I would not be opposed to reinstating the draft, as long as it was done with no deferments. There is nothing wrong with serving your country for 2-4 years. Even though I was fervently opposed to the war in Vietnam, I was prepared to go on my 18th birthday in 1970. I went for physicals twice and was given a 4F deferment because of high blood pressure. Uncle Sam didn't want me. The New York Times issue is a daunting one for me. Trying to balance the freedom of the press with national security is a difficult issue to me. It strikes me as being ripe with the possibility of abuse, and I think the press wins out here. It's the slippery slope thing to me. I find it interesting that I made assumptions about you, and you made assumptions about me, and the more civil discussions we have, there is more common ground to be found.
CosmicConservative
I hope the discussion has been civil the entire time. I endeavor to be civil. Although I sometimes do get hot under the collar. I was too cavalier about the 3,000 dead in my comment about "win-win". I wasn't really referring to the impact of the war, but to the effectiveness of the strategy. I do believe that by making Iraq a magnet for terrorists we have reduced terrorism elsewhere. I am not one who believes that the situation in Iraq is "manufacturing terrorists." The logic of that escapes me when history tells us pretty unambiguously that Al Qada grew exponentially when the U.S. effectively ignored their attacks and appeased them and their sponsor states, and in fact grew large and powerful enough to strike us in New York City. All of that growth and hatred was done in what is now seen by some as the idyllic reign of Bill Clinton. I don't see any evidence that we are creating more terrorists today than we were then. However I DO see lots of evidence that we're killing a whole lot more of them in Iraq. In the long run, is our Iraq policy creating more terrorists than those we are killing + those that would have been created anyway following the policies of the previous decade of exponential terrorist growth? My opinion is, probably not. So was it worth 3,000 dead U.S. soldiers to be where we are? Maybe it was. At least soldiers are combatants, not innocent civilians. We lost almost as many innocent civilians in one terrorist attack. The numbers are even more comparable when you remove the non-combat fatalities in Iraq that are added in as if a military helicopter accident in Iraq is more tragic, or more connected to Bush's policies, than one in Virginia. My bottom line on the war in Iraq is simple. It was a huge gamble. It was taken with the full knowledge that it was an effort to shake up middle east policies that had stalemated for fifty years, with the single significant change being the exponential growth of global terrorism as a tactic in the conflicts, culminating in 9/11, and threatening to turn nuclear or biological in the future. The gamble was that by overthrowing an international criminal who harbored terrorists and paid terrorist's families for suicide bombings in Israel, perhaps the overall dynamic in the middle east would change, and for the better. The risk was that it might make the worlds most unstable and despotic area a little more unstable and despotic. In the long term will the Iraq gamble pay off? I have said since the invasion began that we will not know for at least a decade. So to me that means we are still a long way off knowing the real answer. Was it worth it? Like all gambles it depends on the outcome. Was it justified? At the time I thought it was, based on what I knew, and I haven't seen anything yet to change my mind about the fundamental question of whether it was a justifiable gamble. I do think there were some assumptions that were naive, but that is always the case in any conflict. To suggest that our Iraq endeavor was somehow more naive and more idealistic than any of our other conflicts reveals a deep ignorance of the motivations we have had for all of our wars. Abraham Lincoln may be revered today, but in 1861 he was pretty much universally reviled, so public opinion polls mean very little to me. I'm still seeing positives and negatives in the situation. I'm still hoping that it will end better than it is now. I still think that is a possibility. And the one thing that will guarantee that it end horribly is exactly the strategy that is being proposed by people like Cindy Sheehan and John Murtha.