Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

God speaks...

By CosmicConservative
To Pat Robertson again...
BREITBART.COM - Robertson Predicts 'Mass Killing' In what has become an annual tradition of prognostications, religious broadcaster Pat Robertson predicted Tuesday that a terrorist attack on the United States would result in "mass killing" late in 2007. "I'm not necessarily saying it's going to be nuclear," he said during his news-and-talk television show "The 700 Club" on the Christian Broadcasting Network. "The Lord didn't say nuclear. But I do believe it will be something like that."
So, while he had him on the horn, did Pat think to ask why God hadn't warned him about 9/11? I mean if I had God on the phone, I'd be asking LOTS of questions.

Comments (22)

mtnlurker
I'm sorry but anyone who says that God talked to them is not entirely sane. I mean praying is bad enough but getting verbal answers is too much.
Dadman
Many consider prayer a form of meditation. What's wrong with that? If you're going to imply there is something not quite sane about prayer, please justify your position.
CosmicConservative
Uh oh, time to get the boxing gloves out. ;) I don't mind the talking to God, it's just that I don't understand why it's never a DIALOGUE. It's always a person talking to God, or God talking to a person, never talking to each other. I'm pretty serious about the whole "I'd have a lotta questions for God" thing. If he said "You listen, you do not ask questions" I'm afraid I'd probably say "fine, go find yourself another prophet. I don't work for bosses who don't respect me."
mtnlurker
When I said I had a problem with prayer I meant praying to God for a specific purpose and expecting something to happen. I don't have a problem with meditation. It's purpose is to calm and renew the person. Praying with that purpose is more like going through a ritual or performing some familiar task, such as gardening or whittling, in order to get into that calm state.
CosmicConservative
Not sure I'm on the same page as mtnlurker on this one. Meditation is not just about renewal and calmness. Even in the nominally atheistic zen buddhist model, it's about connecting with the deeper reality of the universe in a spiritually fulfilling way. I think I tried to make a distinction between spirituality and religion in other threads. I think it's a key distinction. And I think "prayer" is actually one of the fundamental things that moves a person from "spiritual" to "religious". So I would agree that prayer can be a "kind of meditation" long as its understood to be a religiously motivated kind of meditation. Having said that, I do not see prayer itself as a sign of instability or mental deficiency. No more than I see meditation that way. I see both as ways that people try to reach a higher purpose in their lives, and even though I am fundamentallly skeptical of the probability of succes of such endeavors, I have plenty of respect for people who attempt them.
Dadman
mtnlurker: Then you believe praying to God for no specific purpose and expecting nothing to happen is more rational? People who have no faith in God just can't seem to grasp the positive force faith, prayer and affirmative action based on that faith has in the lives of those who believe...and they are annoyingly quick to dismiss it... Now, as someone who believes in God and tries to live my life accordingly, I've always struggled with faith and prayer. I am not a natrually faithful person; I'm a natrually skeptical person. As a result, there are times I feel downright agnostic. I try to approach religion as rationally as possible, but where rationality collides with faith and dogma I've always struggled. But the struggle has not shaken my basic belief that this universe has meaning, our lives have meaning and we are simply not the result of some gigantic cosmic accident....
CosmicConservative
Reality is not constrained to one of two opposing poles in the spiritual dimension. It is not "a gigantic cosmic accident" or else "created by God." There is a continuum of possibilities that are possible, ranging from "created by a God who did so by accident" to "It's all a big dream, none of it is really real anyway". In between you have an infinite number of possible ways that reality and spirituality co-exist (or don't). Even if the universe is a great cosmic accident, the power of religion and the positive effects of prayer and devotion to a religion are well documented and although at times my basic agnosticism does sometimes result in comments that can be dismissive about spirituality in general and religion specifically, I do understand the powerfully positive aspects that religion has provided the human race. But I understand the powerfully negative ones too. And my personal opinion is that the balance of positive vs. negative is not clear in the final analysis. Just my opinion.
CosmicConservative
Because I question the overall balance of good vs. evil that religion has done on this world does not mean I am questioning whether the good is worthwhile. I don't know of anything that doesn't have two sides to it. I could say the same thing about politics, art, science, etc... I'm not "dissing" religion to say that there are good and bad aspects and that the balance is difficult to calculate. I'm just saying that there is good and bad. There is no doubt that for perhaps the majority of the population, religion has a powerfully positive impact on their personal lives. I absolutely recognize that.
Dadman
The universe and life are either the result of random, natural forces or they are not. I believe the universe and life exist for a specific purpose and behind that purpose is an intelligent catalyst. What that purpose is is subject to debate. Who or what the intelligent catalyst is is subject to debate. Religion tries to explain both and is admittedly both a positive and negative force in the world. Spirituality, I think, is more about recognizing we are but a small part of a larger 'thing'. I just think that 'rational conservatives' (and I do consider myself more a rational conservative than a religious conservative) need to avoid being as dismissive, condescending and sneering toward religion and faith as our ideological enemies on the left.
CosmicConservative
Heh, Dadman. I'm trying not to be sneering, condescending and dismissive, but while still acknowledging the range of possibilities that exist when considering the natural vs. the supernatural. Thought Experiment: Let's say for a moment that there is no God. That the universe is a random thing with no purpose. Let's say that for people to believe there is purpose makes their life more valuable for them, makes them better people and makes them happier. Is it good then for people to believe in something that is not true? Is that an "ends justifies the means" argument? Just asking. Not judging.
Dadman
Heh, Cosmic. I think it's a cynical argument. I don't know for certain if there is a God or not. Neither do you or anyone else. But, to answer the question, I generally don't believe it's a good thing for people to believe in something that is not true, even if it happens to make them happier, better people. I believe people need to live their lives on a basis of truth. But I also believe faith and intuition are important variables in the equation of our lives, and I happen to believe it is true that this universe, my life, and your life have a definitive purpose. I believe the spark that started it all is God.
CosmicConservative
I think it's a very profound, philosophical question. (Heh, I would, since I asked it, right?) But seriously, if there is no God, but faith "works" then that would imply some sort of spiritual placebo effect. But if it works, hey, why not, right? I am agnostic. I try not to be overly hostile to either atheists or religionists, but I have to admit that both sides get my dander up and I tend to be dismissive of some aspects of both sides. But straddling a fence just chaps your buttox. One of these days I need to pick a side in this fight.
Dadman
But neither of us know why faith often seems to work. I think God has something to do with it, you think it's a placebo effect. Back to square one...
CosmicConservative
I proposed a thought experiment, I didn't venture my opinion. As an agnostic I think it could be either a spiritual effect based on divine activity or a placebo effect (or something else, like I said, it's not an either/or, it's a choice among a continuum of possibilities). I don't know which. Many options seem equally plausible to me. However, when I consider that many different faiths, some of which have diametrically opposed dogma, all seem to provide the very same benefits of faith; that can easily be explained by the placebo effect, and not quite so easily by the premise that only one of them is right.
CosmicConservative » Welcome Walleye Central visitors!
[...] The subjects here vary quite a bit. Mostly though I post on political current events, technology news, and personal interests (guitars, astronomy, sports, gaming, etc.) Every now and then we get a good metaphysical discussion going, and I would love to see more join in the fun. [...]
Dadman
Faith is essentially optimism that things we can't necessarily prove are true, are true. I would argue that most of the positive things we accomplish in life are based on a hope or faith we can actually do it. Sometimes we know, but often we just simply believe things will turn out the way we hope they will. When I talk about faith it's not necessarily faith in God I am talking about; I'm talking about faith in ourselves as well. I believe the universe is governed by certain immutable principles or laws and when we abide by those laws or principles we can expect certain things to happen. If you drop an apple it will fall to the ground. If you live a life of faith and optimism it will yield beneficial outcomes in your life. Love is better than hate, etc. None of this is religion or dogma dependent. It's principle dependent, so it doesn't concern me when adherents to other religions enjoy similar benefits when they live a life of faith and optimism, or the benefits associated with living any other correct principle. My own personal spirtual journey is all about identifying correct 'religious' principles and separating them from all the incorrect principles or doctrines that so many religions espouse. Admittedly, it's a very personal journey and it is sometimes disconcerting that it is such a subjective path. So be it. It's the path I'm on and quite comfortable with it...
CosmicConservative
And insofar as most religions share some basic principles, I agree that makes it plausible that there may be a divine source behind them. So as you said, we're right back where we started, I still remain firmly agnostic (which is not atheistic, nor is it anti-religious, it's just "I dunno-ish"). And I still have some level of envy for those who can live lives of faith. I find that admirable in some ways, although I can't seem to comprehend it.
walleyeman1
Dadman and cosmic, I know ther is a God and His creation screems out everyday that He is ther. when Adam and Eve sinned, it tore his plan in for the world in too. I will only preach for a few minutes but I hope you get something out of it. I was 14 years old and had a simple little in grown toe nail. No big deal, only thing is that I let it go for like 9 months until I couldnt even walk on my foot anymore. Well my parents finally took me to the doctor and he pulled off my toe nail. He told my parents that he was affraid that gangoreen (spelling) had set in my toe. He was afraid that he was going to have to cut my toe or my whole foot off. I grew up in a Christian home were Jesus is real and alive. Well that very day we came back from the doctors my dad read a verse from the Bible that says "If you annoint the body with oil and pray over the person that you will be healed" (paraphrased). Well my Dad did exactly what the Bible tells us to do, and when we went back to the doctor, my toe was totally healed. Now it wasnt the oil that healed my toe, it was the faith that we showed by doing what the Bible says to do. It was my faith that God would heal me if I trusted and acted upon that faith. Sorry for being long. But true Christians dont just pray in the air. We pray to our Lord and He hears us. Now as to pat robertson, he is not a prophet of God. Im really concerned that he truely even knows the Lord that I know in the Bible. He says that God has talked to him like the old testament Prophets. Well ther is one big dfference between the true old test Prophets and pat robertson. THe old test prophets were right 100% of the time with ther prophecies. Pat robertson is hardly ever right. He is way to general on his prophecies. God knows the future so if he used PR to send messages to people, it would be detailed and specific. Not generalazations and conjures.... He really gives Christ a bad name. And we have been warned in the Bible to not follow false Prophets. People will come in my name that are false. That is what Jesus told us and PR is a prime example. And a whole lot of t.v. people are that way.... sorry to be long!!!! I hope that you got something out of this... God is real and He showed us who He is in His Son Jesus..... If you read the Bible Jesus only condemd the religious leaders of His day. The people who were suppose to be representing Him. The PR of His time. But to the common people, He would just love them and not condem them. This is what us as Christians should be doing now. Instead of judging people for all the sinnes they have ( I sin to), we should be telling people ther is hope in everyone as long as they have faith in our Lord. Thanks guys, I got to preachy though.....
CosmicConservative
walleyeman1: Thanks for the thoughtful post. I certainly appreciate the deeply held convictions you have demonstrated. Unfortunately I've never been able to hold that kind of conviction myself for a variety of reasons. As I told Dadman, there's no doubt in my mind that faith is beneficial to people. I just struggle with why it seems to help no matter which faith you happen to believe.
Rick Larson
This is not surprising as his prediction follows a poll where a majority of Americans believe this. It is good for donations. http://www.editorandpublisher.com/eandp/news/article_display.jsp?vnu_content_id=1003526258
CosmicConservative
I find most polls these days to be so manipulative by the polling company that it is pretty much impossible to take them seriously. There was a recent major poll taken by the NY Times or the AP which was run two days in a row with the following headlines: Americans optimistic about 2007 Americans pessimistic about 2007 You see things like GW Bush is one of the most admired and the most hated man in America at the same time. Religious poll results are particularly suspiscious in my opinion because a lot of people just say what they think they are supposed to say.