Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Rationality vs. Religion

By CosmicConservative
I use the tagline "Rational Conservatism from the Rocky Mountains" for a reason on CosmicConservative. It is primarily to separate my brand of conservatism from that of fundamentalist Christians. I do that for two reasons: 1. Because I am not personally religious myself and don't want people to assume that I am just because I promote a conservative viewpoint. 2. Because it has become so common on the left to see conservative values as being driven by religion that many on the left have never entertained a non-religious argument in support of conservative issues such as abortion, embryonic stem cell research or euthanasia. My intention in setting up this blog was to demonstrate that conservatism is more rational and logical than liberal ideas are. But I sometimes take that too far and end up attacking religion and religious values myself, as I did recently where I compared "God" to a sort of "uber-Claus" concept of Santa Claus. Now if roles were reversed and I were on the receiving end of such a comment, I would be deeply offended. It implies that Christians are not serious nor contemplative about their spirituality, which is demonstrably untrue. I've read the works of CS Lewis and although I do not agree with many of his premises or conclusions, I clearly recognize that his was a great mind and he was deeply rational as well as deeply devout. I know also that the Vatican has an observatory that does solid astronomical science and that the priests who run it (Jesuits, I think) are held in high regard by the astrophysics community. I also know that non-Christians are every bit as irrational and dogmatic about their views as any Christian or Muslim or any other denomination is. For those out there who find spirituality to be a powerful force in their lives, I envy you. I have never been able to manage that. I can see that in many cases those who have a spiritual connection with the universe are better able to deal with life than I am, and that strength is demonstrable whether the individual is Hindu, Muslim, Christian or any other faith. To discount that powerful force as "superstition" or to ridicule it as "irrational" is unforgivable when it so clearly provides such a powerful force for good in so many people's lives. Rationality and Religion are not mutually exclusive concepts, and I sincerely apologize for any comments I've made here that imply that they are. I have deep respect for those who can pursue a spiritual life, so long as they can also maintain a rational perspective about the world. But to say that religious people have a monopoly on dogma and irrationality, or that non-religious people have a monopoly on rationality and logic is simply and demonstrably untrue. So, I'll try to tone down the comments that come across as dismissive of religion or religious people. I certainly know that my mind doesn't compare to that of Albert Einstein, Isaac Newton, CS Lewis, JRR Tolkien or a host of others I could name whose intellect would far outshine my own, but who were deeply and profoundly religious themselves. I certainly acknowledge that my own personal perspective on life is far too limited to draw such sweeping conclusions about others.

Comments (11)

Drax
I tend to agree with people who are having birthdays, lol.... Seriously, I think that the belief in a supernatural force responsible for the creation of the universe is not irrational. Until someone gets past "first cause" with an explanation which does NOT require the existence of the supernatural (one I can understand anyway), I will refrain from taking pot shots at those who believe that "God Exists." But when RELIGION hits the board; when one group of persons tells the rest of us that WE have THE answer to "life, the universe, and everything," I get a bit ticked off.
CosmicConservative
Drax: Thanks for acknowledging another Cosmic year gone by... sigh. When you say that religion has a problem because they propose an answer to "life, the universe and everything" you're pretty much attacking religion itself, since that's really the role of religion. I try to make a distinction between "religion" and "spirituality", although it's pretty hard to draw the line sometimes. To me "religion" is when you say you KNOW the TRUTH of the universe, wehre "spirituality" is when you say that there are things that transcend what we know as the laws of physics and that those transcendent things can affect a person's life directly. The two blur together whenever someone introduces a "road map' that says "Spirituality comes from this, is for this purpose and directs us to live in this way." I admit that it is when spirituality starts to morph into religion that I start to get concerned. But there is a fairly compelling argument that there are similar dogmatic foundations to the origin and lifecycle of the universe that are held by non-religious people as well, particularly atheists. When someone says that the "Big Bang" is just as much dogma as the Creation Story, they aren't wrong, there is a lot of dogma in the current theories of the origin of the universe. And frankly, the further astro-physicists go into the field of String Theory, the more it looks like faith, and the less it looks like science. There is no doubt that there are many, perhaps even the great majority, of religious individuals who do not deeply examine their beliefs and rationally examine the basis of their beliefs. But I would say that is true of non-religious individuals too. So to suggest that religious people are somehow less rational than non-religious people is just demonstrably untrue. In fact it may be that religious people in general do more self-examination than non-religious people. People search for meaning and for answers. Some search harder than others. Some answers resonate with people and provide them with a means to live their lives. That isn't bad. And it is certainly praiseworthy when the result is a better life, a nicer person and a better society.
Drax
I draw a distinction between a religion and those who follow it. Most who follow a particular belief tend to follow only that which accords with their own "religion" (or "spirituality" if you prefer). Very few actually willingly adhere to every tenent of their "religion," instead, willingly and with great joy intentionally and repeatedly violate those tenents with which they disagree. Their actions, their failure to adhere to all the tenents of their religion, however, does nothing to alter the religion itself.
Dadman
As a practitioner of a particular brand of faith, I can tell you that the tension between the 'religion' and 'spirituality' is very real. The religious, dogmatic aspects of my faith frankly make me uncomfortable. Dogma in any form makes me uneasy - whether it's dogmatic Christianity, dogmatic science or dogmatic secularism - because dogma and objective, rational inquiry often seem mutually exclusive. I derive benefit from my faith not in it's dogma, but in the spiritual guidance it provides with respect to how I live my life on a daily basis - love and serve others, be humble, don't covet, forgive often, lose yourself to find yourself, work hard and reap the corresponding rewards, etc. I consider these spirtual principles that yield tangible, positive results when applied. That has been the case in my life. But it is true that religious dogma and obnoxious pronouncements of dogmatic TRUTH often obscure the more sublime spiritual elements of religion not only for those outside of that particular religion, but those within it too. Perhaps it should be illegal to practice religion without a license...
CosmicConservative
Maybe we should just practice it until we get it right.
Drax
When someone "figures it all out," one of a few things happen. Most of the time, that person simply lives out his life adhering to the principles that he, himself, has "figured out." Generally, that person continues to belong to a particular "religion" which has tenents with which he disagrees and has no intention of following, "belonging" to that religion in name only. Other times, the person who has "figured it out" will look around and find that no religion accords with what he has decided is the meaning of life, the universe, and everything and withdraw entirely from the "religious" path, and follow his inner voice exclusively. Once in a while, however, the person who has "figured it out" wants others to come to the same revelation that he has and begins to preach to others. Since, the vast, vast, vast majority of people are unwilling to spend the time and effort required to "figure it out," they, instead, listen to others who supposedly, in the past, have already done so. This is why organized religions exist for the most part -- a meeting place of people of "like mind," even if most of the people who meet have the contents of their minds fed to them by a select few. The problem is when people actually adhere to a "religion" without any independent thought, when they just blindly follow the dictates of the one (whether living or dead) who has "figured it out."
CosmicConservative
I agree that people following religion blindly and without independent thought is a source of many of the great ills of the world, but I don't think that is restricted to religion. I think that is true for everything from school learning to national goal-setting. People following communism blindly led to the deaths of more people than any other single cause in human history. So I think the issue of people being sheeple is an issue about people, not about religion itself.
Drax
I agree that the "lemming effect" isn't exclusive to religion. However, I do think that such blind adherence does greater damage than, say, the blind adherence to .... liberalism, since, no matter what "non-religious" credo one adheres to, unlike Religion, it does not promise eternal life after death.... That really makes for a whole new ballgame.
CosmicConservative
I disagree Drax, and I'll again use the specific example of the Communist "purges" in the Soviet Union and China, which virtually every trustworthy historian says were the two most destructive events towards human life in the history of the human race. Millions of people were starved to death, murdered, or thrown into gulags, where they then were starved to death or murdered, all in the name of "collectivism". Nothing in the history of religion that I know of is comparable to that pain and suffering. And that's not even adding Nazism to the mix, which killed millions more.
Drax
Argh. You're right, I think. Communism, in its many forms, has wreaked havoc throughout the world and expressly excludes the possiblity of "life everlasting...."
qwerty182764
"Perhaps it should be illegal to practice religion without a license… " You want to reduce dogmatism right? Encrusting any profession with liscencing and self-selecting guild-masters isn't likely to help on that front. "I agree that the “lemming effect” isn’t exclusive to religion. However, I do think that such blind adherence does greater damage than, say, the blind adherence to …. liberalism, since, no matter what “non-religious” credo one adheres to, unlike Religion, it does not promise eternal life after death…." "I disagree Drax, and I’ll again use the specific example of the Communist “purges” in the Soviet Union and China, which virtually every trustworthy historian says were the two most destructive events towards human life in the history of the human race." Well, yes and no to both. There is nothing that a secular regime could offer you that would make you, say, raise your children for the sole purpose of sacrificing them in a suicide bomb attack on your neighbor's childrens' schoolbus, or killing your daughter with your own hands for the "crime" of being raped, then having a feast to celebrate with the rapist. But then again, secular regimes aren't exactly fettered themselves. When people go fanatical for any cause, when the feedback loop with reality and common human decency gets cut, then watch out. They're derailed freight trains barreling through the city square. There's something in mankind that wants to substitute terrifying power and unaccountable authority for what is really right or wrong, true or false, and responsible. Different people just want to sub in different things. Some of them pick God, others pick their own particular view of human "destiny".