Movie Review: Eragon
By CosmicConservativeSo we watched Eragon last night. I was disappointed that the audience was so small, I had expected a larger audience.
I had read the book a few years ago, and it's sequel "Eldest" so I'm pretty familiar with the story and knew what to expect.
I think there are two different types of experiences for this movie, that of people like me who have read the book, and that of people who have not. I would almost like to go see it again so I could approach it from the perspective of the latter, because I was definitely in the perspective of the former last night.
And I think that's a problem. I can't quite put my finger on it, or how to say it, but the movie never jolted me out of my "how does this compare to the book" mode and into "just enjoy the movie for what it is" mode.
If I were ranking the elements of the movie from best to worst, I'd definitely start with the special effects, which were nearly Lord of the Rings level (but not quite). There were some scenes of Eragon and Safira (the dragon) that were absolutely beautiful.
Next I'd put the cinematography, although there were some scenes that appeared to be rushed and not polished. I was particularly bothered in a few scenes by lens reflections that distracted from the action. These days such cosmetic blemishes are so easy to brush out with software that there is no excuse for leaving them in such a major motion picture. But there were also beautiful shots both with and without the CGI dragon in them.
Next I'd put the score, not so much because I thought it was great, but because I didn't think it was bad. So consider this to be the "mediocre" level, and everything below is worse than that.
Then I'd put the acting. Jeremy Irons as Brom, the sage who schools Eragon, seemed distracted and at times bothered by his script. The "King", John Malkovich, seemed bored and his lines were delivered with a straight-faced lack of conviction that made his threats ring hollow. The "shade" Durza (Robert Carlyle) was alternately quietly menacing and maniacally insane. The hero, Eragon (Edward Speleers) spent a great deal of time looking heroic. The elf-warrior woman Arya (Sienna Guillory) spent most of the movie on her back (now, now, that's not what I mean) in a prison cell being tortured by Durza, and finally the voice of the dragon Safira (Rachel Weisz) was too calm and sensible for such an impetuous young dragon.
Then I would put the writing. A poor script may not have given the actors much to work with, so perhaps I am being too hard on the actors. The writing is sometimes inane and sometimes reflects the naivitee of a young teenager, which is not surprising since the book was written by a teenager. Still, they should have improved the dialogue before putting this on the big screen.
Finally I would have to say the directing and editing is the worst aspect of the movie. It is choppy, forced, badly paced and does not provide a coherent story line. One has to wonder what was left on the cutting room floor. For one such as me who has read the story, I was at least able to follow the basic story line, but I can imagine that some who have not read the book would have found the story almost incomprehensible.
I've read several reviews of the movie and almost all of them sneer at the "derivative elements" of the story, making comparisons to Star Wars, Narnia and Lord of the Rings. I'm not quite as bothered by that as others might be. When Star Wars came out it was called deriviative, as was Lord of the Rings itself. In fact J. R. R. Tolkien freely admitted that he borrowed heavily from mythology, particularly Norse mythology, from where he retrieved even the names of several characters (most notably the dwarves). Star Wars was compared to Arthurian legend, Lord of the Rings was compared to the Odyssey, Narnia was compared to all of the above. I don't mind so much that there are repetitive elements to the story, I mostly want to have the story be a GOOD repetition.
Anyway, I was not blown away by Eragon. In fact I would have to say that I was a bit disappointed by the movie. And what is sad about that is that the things that disappointed me are really the core elements of good movie making. Had the script been better, the acting been better and the directing been better, this could have been a great winter fantasy flick.
As it is, it is a decent diversion for a weekend of Christmas shopping.
I give it a 3 on a scale of 5, mostly for the CGI and the beautiful camera work.
Comments (1)