Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Ethics at the top of the world...

By CosmicConservative
So, the Cosmic wife and I have been watching a special on the Discovery channel (I think that's right) about climbing Mt. Everest. It's been quite instructive about human nature. One of the things I've been noticing in the series is that Climbing Mt. Everest may have once been a personal challenge against a mountain, but now that is only part of the story. And the rest of the story may be the true test of a person's character, much more so than whether they can crawl up the face of a 29,000 foot mountain. In the show we have been watching an expedition leader named Russ (don't know his last name) is leading at least two expeditions simultaneously by radio from his position below the "death zone," which is what they call the area above about 28,000 feet or so where the oxygen is so rare and the air is so thin that nothing survives for more than a few days, and most things perish long before that. And one of the first things to go in that environment is good judgment, so part of the reason for the radio controlled expedition leading is so Russ can keep his mind sharp and give good advice to the climbers, who are led by Sherpas. Now I read the book "Into Thin Air" about the devastating 1996 Everest expeditions that left over a dozen climbers dead when a combination of too many climbers and sudden storms collided at the top of the mountain. Part of the story in that book was the change that was taking place from a mountain climbing experience to a financial enterprise. Many of the climbers documented in that 1996 expedition, including one TV personality, were more or less dragged to the summit by sherpas, or that's the implication. And in 1996 it was suggested, things were just getting worse every year. Climbing Mt. Everest is not a vacation activity. It takes months to pull an expedition together, weeks to get your body acclimatized to the altitude, additional weeks to make the actual climb up and down from base camp, and tens of thousands of dollars for equipment, travel, permits and guides. Maybe "tens of thousands" is a gross understatement. To put it simply, for most people, it is the biggest single expense of their lives outside of buying a house. So imagine that you have invested your retirement funds into this sort of endeavor, most likely over the objections of your family, or at best with the guarded approval of your "mid-life crisis" lark. You have effectively bet your future financial well-being on being able to come back with the story of your successful climb to the top of the world. Anything less and that investment might just as well have been thrown into the fireplace. Now imagine that you have spent all that money, and find yourself on a mountain slope, effectively living in a tent at an altitude greater than any mainland U.S. mountain for weeks as your body gets used to the thin air. During this period your anticipation builds to a fever pitch as you see several earlier expeditions mount their attempts to scale the mountain. Then you see the results come back down the mountain. Some exulting in their victory, others dejected by their failure, and still others in body bags, or simply left behind to lie eternally in the frigid cold because it is too much effort to bring the body back down. Now it's your turn. Finally all that money and time investment is coming to fruition. You carefully bundle all your equipment onto your back, and begin to ascend the mountain. This is done in stages and you essentially move from one camp to another on daily treks up the mountain. I believe you move through three camps on the way to the top, with the final camp just below the "death zone" where you have just enough time to hike to the top, spend a few minutes exulting and taking pictures to prove you were there, and then come back down, before your oxygen runs out. Each of these stages is probably the hardest physical thing you have ever done. Even now, well before you get to the final stage, people around you are giving up and turning back. Every time you see someone turn back, you feel a little thrill of superiority for having the will and the strength to go on. But also as you climb higher, you feel that strength draining away, even as you know that you need every last ounce of it. You fear that you too will be forced to turn back, and because you know that thrill of superiority, you know exactly what a crushing feeling of failure you will feel if you stop. Finally you are at the last camp, just below the "death zone." You know you will be starting your final ascent at midnight, but you find it hard to sleep, both because of the excitement of the moment, and because of the physical discomfort you are feeling. Your fingers and toes seem to never get warm, and your body is aching as it never has before. But you are almost there. The final part of the trip up Everest is about a 8 hour struggle to the top. There are famous landmarks like "mushroom rock" or "the first step" or "the second step" and you have researched this so you know exactly how much oxygen you need to have left as you pass each landmark. You know you are carrying as much oxygen as you can, and that if you run out of oxygen you can easily succumb to altitude sickness or worse. People die on Everest. You don't want to die. But you so very much want to get to the top. In fact this extravagantly expensive and incredibly time-consuming experience is just about to reach its ultimate climax. So at midnight you wake up. You are cold. Your fingers don't work well. You try to warm them over your high-altitude stove, but you don't have much time. You are not thinking clearly because even this "low" the air is thin and the oxygen is rare. You know that every minute you waste trying to get your socks smoothed out in your boot is a minute that you may desperately need in the climb back down. The Sherpas are insistently calling your name. Finally you are dressed, you go over your mental checklist and you are pretty sure you have everything you need, including that heavy bottle of oxygen that is your lifeline to the top and back. You leave the tent into -40 degree temperatures and darkness. And you start to climb. Two hours later you have descended into a numb routine of putting one foot in front of the other. Your radio link to your guide is your only real companion, except for the constant urging of the Sherpas to move faster. You are starting to hate those Sherpas. But you know you have to reach the first step on time, or you may be forced to turn back, and that is the one thing that you cannot do. So you trudge on, your fingers starting to lose their feeling, one foot turning into a lead weight that you barely recognize as a foot. And finally you reach the first step. And there's a traffic jam there. You find this hard to believe. How could there be a line of people milling around, stamping their feet to keep warm, here, on top of the highest mountain in the world? There must be twenty people! Where did they all come from. Now you are waiting in line, your oxygen is dwindling and it's getting late. And the line isn't moving. Finally your guide radios you that there is a problem. An expedition from Turkey is having trouble with some amateur climbers. They are having to bring one back down who is suffereing from altitude sickness. You must wait your turn. So you wait 30 minutes, as your fingers get more numb, and your left foot no longer feels like it is there. Finally someone makes their way down the ladder that gets you over the step, half dragging a frightened and incoherent woman who apparently cannot see. You avert your eyes as they go past, and sigh as the line starts to move up the ladder again. 30 minutes later you get your turn and you climb up the ladder. You know there's another ladder up ahead and you are desperately afraid that another traffic jam like that will force you to turn back and abandon your dream, and lose all that money and time, knowing that you will be seen as a failure by those who reached the top. Halfway to the second step, you are now half-blind yourself because the sun has come up and the snow is blowing in your face. It's warmer, but it's too late for your fingers and left foot. You know that you will be dealing with frostbite, you just don't know how bad it will be. You hope it will be OK, but you fear that you might lose fingers and toes. This doesn't seem so bad now though, in your present state of mind, because now you can see the second step and you know that's probably the biggest obstacle between you and your goal. As you trudge on, you see something on the side of the trail. At first you think it's just a pile of trash, or a discarded backpack. But then you realize that it's a man. That's not right, you think, nobody should be laying down here, all alone. You look ahead of you and the climbers in front of you are moving on. The man in the snow waves an arm weakly in your direction. You see that he has no oxygen mask on, and that his face is waxy and purplish, indicating frostbite and sunburn. You see also that his boots and gloves are not really suited for this environment, and wonder if that's why he's laying there. Suddenly your befuddled mind crystalizes into a sudden instant of clarity and you realize that this man is dying. Right there in the snow in front of you. You radio your guide and tell him what is happening. Your guide asks you to describe his condition, and you do. Your guide says "He's dead already, there's nothing you can do about it." You look at the dying man. Your Sherpa is telling you to hurry up. You see the line ahead of you leaving you behind, and feel more climbers bunching up behind you. You know with all the certainty that you have ever had in your life that if you stop to try to help the dying man, you will not reach the top of Everest that day, and you will never be able to afford coming back. Based on the actions of the climbers around you, you are equally certain that if you move on, this man will die. What do you do?
Update: This post was picked up by some larger blog sites so it's generating some traffic. Welcome to any non-readers! Look around, see if you like any other posts. ;)

Comments (19)

qwerty182764
People go to that much trouble to get to the top? If you're spending thousands of dollars on equipment already, how difficult could it be to create an actively heated suit/gloves (I mean, we're talking about resisting wires beneath the fabric here, nothing too difficult). You'd have to haul the battery as well, but you could try making the trip in stages. Bring an oxygen tank and a battery to camp 2 while using your own, climb back down for another, head back up to camp 2, then use the one at camp 2 to get to the top. We regularly send men into space without the environment mutilating them. It seems like they all need better equipment to me.
Brian Wohlgemuth
I never understood why you wouldn't want some sort of positive pressure suit up there. How hard would it be to have a sealed suit with heaters in the extremities and bottled oxygen? I also have to wonder about ropes and pulleys. I see these sherpas running ropes, why couldn't they are on the long sections run ropes that could pull the items up and over. I honestly would love to climb Everest, but I know that my pudgy body would never make it past base camp. I guess that's what I get for my proceeds of winning the genetic lottery....
CosmicConservative
As I watched the show I also wondered about the relatively common equipment the people were using. At one point in the show they were talking about the "severe cold" and said something like "at -20 degrees Fahrenheit skin freezed within 20 seconds of exposure to the air." I looked at my wife and said "remember that year I went ice fishing on Lake Granby and it was 27 degrees below zero? Well, because I was fishing, I not only had to take my gloves off, I had to pull wet, flopping fish out of the water, pull the hook out of their mouth put them in a bucket and then re-rig my line, all of which took probably five minutes where my hands were not only exposed to the 27 below temperatures for the entire time, but they were actually WET most of the time. In fact, by the time I got done with the rerigging, the water on my hands was usually turning to ice." So -20 doesn't impress me that much. -40, that's another thing. But back to the gear. I am sure that they all have state-of-the-art climbing gear, meaning they probably have kevlar lined parkas and coveralls, with the highest insulative type of synthetic filling and all that. But at one point on the show, one of the climbers was having trouble with his foot, and his Sherpa reached into the climbers backpack and pulled out one of those chemical hand-warmers to put in his boot, and I swear it was the same kind you buy at Wal-mart. I used them even while ice-fishing. I wonder if there's a market for high-altitude climbing suits that are designed the way Brian suggests? Would there be enough of a market for them? I know that astronaut spacesuits are hand-made and cost a fortune to make. Or at least they were the last time I saw a documentary on them. Doing that would probably be cost-prohibitive, but perhaps there is new technology and new materials that could be used to simplify and reduce the cost. I think I'll do some googling on the subject.
CosmicConservative » Everest isn’t the only killer mountain…
This is a trackback from another CosmicConservative post... [...] Some relevence to my Everest post… Rescuers search for climbers in wind, chilling rain - CNN.com COOPER SPUR, Oregon (AP) — Cold rain lashed the base of Mount Hood on Wednesday as search parties headed back up the treacherous slopes to look for three climbers missing since the weekend. [...]
Drax
I'll never understand the compulsion that drives these folk. Hell, I don't even want to WATCH something like this.
CosmicConservative
I watched it at my wife's urging, and now I'm hooked. It's basically a reality show, and I am learning a lot. But I'm learning a lot more about human nature than about Everest.
pace
Ok.. my interest is piqued. I just set the PVR to record this.
CosmicConservative
I hope it makes sense coming in at the end like that. In the previous episodes they set up at base camp, made their way progressively up to the higher camps, split into two groups of four climbers, and the first group already summitted (is that a word?) the day before (May 14, 2006 to be exact). On that day, undocumented in the filming, a man named David Sharp attempted to summit solo. Unknown to the climbers now being filmed, he did not make it back down to camp, and spent the night under a rock overhang just off the trail, and has been slowly freezing to death without oxygen now for about 20 hours. The climbers in the film went past him on the way up, but this was not shown in the documentary, for various reasons, including that the family of David Sharp asked for certain parts of the film not to be shown. The group of four being filmed in the upcoming episode split into two smaller groups of two each, one group, including the double-amputee, has already summitted and is on the way back down, the other group, a frenchman who had a cancerous kidney removed just a few weeks earlier and an ex Hell's Angels biker whose spine and leg are held together with wire and steel rods, has not yet summitted and the expedition leader has been begging them to come back down the mountain because they are too weak to make it to the top and survive the trip back down. The two groups were just passing each other as the last episode ended, and the two who summitted already are heading down where David Sharp is still dying. So that's where it's starting when you join in.
pace
I found this rather damning indictment of the documentary and it's star guide: http://www.mounteverest.net/news.php?news=15288 After reading that, and several commentaries from experienced Everest climbers, I don't think I'd want to put my life in Brice's hands.
Buddy
Well mounteverest.net has an ongoing beef with most of the commercial efforts on Everest. here is another angle of Brice that might clarify some of his 'bluntness.'
CosmicConservative
I am actually trying hard not to pass moral judgment too much on this. I see so much contradictory information that it is virtually impossible for me to make a judgment that I consider to be informed and not biased by people with agendas. What I think I am coming to conclude on this is that the mountain climbing community is actually pretty small. It is also in tremendous flux. Up until a few decades ago, the only people trying to climb 8,000 meter mountains were true adventurers and technically skilled climbers. And most of them knew each other very well. So a sort of "ethic" grew up around the shared experiences of these elite few. But things have been changing rapidly, and the new Everest climber is not usually an elite climber, but is instead what can be called either an amateur climber or even worse, a tourist climber. Some from the old elite community have embraced this and have decided to profit from it. Russ Price is in that category. Others have rejected it and have decided to lobby against it. Most of the elite climbers are in that camp. However, even though there are more in the elite camp, the Russ Price camp has far more effective public relations efforts, and interacts with far more reporters, videographers and rich clients who have influence of their own. Because there is such an obvious schism in the community, I find it hard to accept the pronouncement from either side as being "true". I suspect the truth is somewhere in-between the extremes. From what I have seen, no matter what I think of Russ Price as a person, I have no doubt that given the chance, he is the guide I would hire. He may be ruthless, but he does protect his clients. I've read quite a bit about other, far less scrupulous individuals who steal oxygen at altitude, squat in tents they did not buy, and do not secure ropes or ladders as securely as Russ Price's team does. So if you want to get to Everest and back I would say hire Russ.
Buddy
I see russell having done this so long and getting tired of getting essentially robbed blind (he doesn't mind giving when asked, it seems, it's when you just take it without asking) by the 'tourist climber' types that he is perhaps 'overbearing' at times. Personally I think he's somewhat earned the right to be (this is from the 2000 season):
Russell Brice showed to be the "Rongbuck major". He was involved in all the rope fixing. The Russian police team did the initial rope fixing of the North Col. The second part of their route was in a rather Russian way (steep!) Russell arranged a new route, which ascended more gradually. Russell was also involved, in fact or in comments afterwards, in all the rescues. And he was involved in building a new route along the road blocking lake on the East Rongbuk Glacier. This is all very understandable because Russell was the most experienced person on the mountain and he had the best support team (guides and sherpas). But then you see other expeditions gratefully use all of the things accomplished by or via Russell and they don't contribute at all. This actually produced some friction between the teams. Climbers ought to practice "gentleman's behavior", but one must not ignore the many national cultural differences between the teams.
I mean the guy seems to have his hand in most of the northcol operations, including most of the rescues. Many of the 'elite' climbers resent that, but the fact of the matter is, if he were to not do what he does, I think the situation on the mountain would be much worse than it is. Also, It seems from what I can gather there were at least 3 emergency situations going on, one, or maybe even two involving the turkish team, possibly two including his own team, etc. I think this guy was simply overlooked because he had no support system and nobody knew who he was, and when it was realized how bad of a shape he was in, he was already frozen nearly rigid. Just seems like an agonizing chain of events that is quite easy to second guess by us sitting in our offices at the computer. I really just don't get the people who wanna be up there in the first place, quite honestly. I've been at 6500 feet in 10 degree weather with a wind, and that was rediculous. I can't imaging 5x that height -- you're essentially in the jet stream, and in the lower reaches of the Stratosphere.
CosmicConservative
I haven't seen the next episode yet, but I can't help but feel the "crisis" in Russel's team was a little over-dramatized for the purposes of making the documentary "watchable." So far I've seen several examples of what looked to me like clear hamming for the cameras in the Russel expeditions. But when push has come to shove so far, there have been very few crises. But as I said, I haven't seen next week's episode yet, perhaps a real crisis does develop.
Buddy
There certainly was at least ONE other crisis, and that was with the turkish team (and I believe they had two people who were having major issues, one similar to the indian climber we saw earlier in the season, and another climber lost consciousness). It wouldn't surprise me at all if the guy with the kidney issue had major problems getting down, either. He appears on the brink of losing it, although it could be dramatized. The link I posted to a comment on one of the TV message boards from a person who claims to be the website manager for the Everest show says there were three ongoing rescues at that point (I'm not quite sure what that means/how severe, etc) I guess my point is, I'd rather hope for the best in these situations, but on the roof of the world, when the guy can't stand up because his legs are 'wooden' (as several of the sherpa descriptions put it) then he doesn't have any real of chance of getting down the first step. Should somebody have tried? Well I think they did, but the sherpas weren't available to get the job done at the time, as it appears they were tied up in other situations. We know from the turkish team's statement that they attempted to help, couldn't found the guy was frozen to the knees, and that he had ice in his nose and throat. We have a similar response from the Himax sherpas with descriptions of 'wooden legs' and 'extremely cold chest temperature' Dawa, the sherpa from the Turk team abandoned his summit attempt and tried to tend to the guy, and got nowhere. Best timeline I've been able to establish (there are many overlapping times and reports): He'd left camp 2 on may *13* at 6pm and by 1am on the 14th he was spotted moving up the pass near 'green boots'. It was during this time that the Himax team was almost getting blown off the mountain due to wind, and Inglis had his ascent delayed a day. It was during this same period that the NYPD guy and the guy with athsma guy turned back due to the whiteout. 10 (May 14, 11am) hours later he is spotted near the third step, resting but still attached to the line. At 1:30PM on the 14th he is spotted about 100 meters past the 3rd step. Inglis and crew are still hunkered down pending weather wind reports. Nearly 24 hours later (May 15, 12:30am), Inglis group sees him at green boots the cameraman with the team yells at him to get moving, he doesn't respond, and thinking him dead (evidently he was sleeping), they move on. 1 Hr later (May 15 1am), the turk team passes him, they urge him to get moving, (he is awake and evidently concious at this point) but he waves them off, and they go on. 20 minutes later, (1:20am) more of the turk team passes him. At this point he is evidently unclipped from the line and laying down again because this person assumes he is 'green boots' and moves on "They all thought he was a dead body just like Indian, none of them knew the exact number of the bodies on the route." 8 Hours later, plus or minus (9:30am, 39.5 hours after David left camp 2) one of the turk members starts having issues. They short rope her down with 4 sherpas and as the pass green boots they notice Davids arm move. The troubled turk is doing better, so two sherpas start down wit her and two others work with david for a while. Max and his sherpa are on the way down, see the commotion, and stay (the timeline is a little fuzzy as to whether max or the turk team arrived first). The group of (4 I think, 3 sherpas and Max) work with him for about an hour administering O2, trying to get him to drink warm tea trying to get him to respond. "His nose was completely frozen deep inside. His hand was frozen as a rock also. He was able to open his eyes but couldn't say anything." At this point, the turk lady started having worse problems, so he radioed up to the rest of his team which were not far behind, and went down to help with her. From the Turks report: "When rest of the team arrived to cave David was still laying down. Soner, Lakhpa and one sherpa from Russel Brice expedition tried to make David move. Russell Brice's sherpa had an extra oxygen they used it to make him awake. But those also didn't help to make him walk. When Soner informed me over radio. I realised that they have nothing to do more. And I called him down." Thinking him beyond help, and very low on O2 they head down the mountain. (Max is very, very distraught almost a day later at having to leave him, but says he did all he could do) 2 hours and 45 minutes later (42 hours after David left camp 2) we get the camera recording of David stating ''My name is David Sharp, I'm with Asian Trekking, and I just want to sleep" to Phurba Tashi Sherpa. He and another Sherpa work with him for an undetermined period of time, administering O2 medication, and attempted to get him to his feet. His legs are stiff (wooden is the term used) and they pull him out in the sun a bit, and leave him (this could overlap with some of the work of the above team, too). Bottom line, it looks like multiple groups and many different people tried to help him. Did they try hard enough? Heck I dunno, that environment is crazy and he'd been out in -30 -40 weather for going on 40 hours. May 13-14 Inglis and the rest of the Himax bunch were locked down due to wind, and david had been out through that, too.
CosmicConservative
Buddy: I have tried to avoid passing judgment on this. But I am sure my true feelings are evident. I think they should have done more. I think more of them should have done more. I like to think that I would have done more. But maybe I'm overestimating my own resolve.
pace
Reading the account Buddy posted, it does sound as though the oxygen administered by the Turks revived him somewhat, given that he was subsequently talking to the film crew with Phurba Sherpa and by all accounts alert. It is too bad they were unable to give further oxygen and meds and physically force him down off the mountain as happened with Lincoln Hall from a significantly higher elevation.
pace
Watched it last night. I'm hooked. I set the PVR to record the omnibus showing this Sunday.
CosmicConservative » Nepalese woman saved on Mt. Everest
[...] of you may remember my post last year about David Sharp, who was left to die just a few yards off the main trail up to Mt. Everest, [...]