Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Taking the Oath of Office on the Koran

By CosmicConservative
OK, I just don't get this. I keep hearing that there is some sort of controversy because newly elected Congressman Keith Ellison, a Muslim, plans to take the oath of office on a Koran. And people have a problem with that? Why? If he's truly a Muslim, he better damn well take the oath on the Koran. As for me, being agnostic, I would have to take the oath on a copy of "Skeptic" magazine.

Comments (12)

qwerty182764
Do what you say. Keep your word. The rest of it is just ceremonial posturing. Valuing the truth is so fundamental to civilization that without it, every social contract degrades to the status of toilet paper, and every promise to that of a drunken tall-tale. We should expect the same degree of honesty from people whether they are swearing complicated oaths in full public view, or just setting an agreement to provide an everyday service. I suppose the only issue with taking an oath on the Koran is that radical muslims hold that it is perfectly acceptable to lie to infidels whenever convenient. Another issue is that taking an oath to support and defend the Constitution of the United States entails upholding religious liberty. I suppose it all comes down to exactly what kind of Muslim the man is, and whether he believes his religious duties contradict his oath or not.
Dadman
It's a significant break from tradition. I think that is what people have an issue with. Dennis Prager has been the most vocal against taking the oath on anything other than the Bible. He argues that taking the oath on the Bible honors the Judeo-Christian heritage of our laws and institutions and honors what most Americans value (i.e. our Judeo-Christian traditions). Taking the oath on something other than the Bible, he argues, will only lead to more divisiveness. I think he is being more reactionary than rational. As long as the oath is the same, it doesn't really matter on which document one swears that oath on as long as it is genuinely meaningful to the one doing the swearing. I'd probably request to swear my oath on The Lord of the Rings...
CosmicConservative
If the purpose of using the Bible has any foundation whatsoever in the idea that breaking an oath taken on it would be difficult because it was tied to an oath given to God, then any person elected should take the oath on their specific religious text, whether that be the Koran, the Torah, the Bagavad Vita or the Egyptian Book of the Dead, otherwise the oath would hold no religious meaning. If it's purely ceremonial, then get rid of the archaic and inappropriate trappings of Judeo-Christian ritual. The Constitution says that there shall be no religious test for serving in office. I'm good with that. Take the oath and violate it, and we'll send your butt up the river for perjury or treason. I'm good with that too. Make it purely secular, as a secular Government office should be.
CosmicConservative
qwerty: If the issue is that some people believe that Muslims hold to no oath taken when dealing with infidels, then what does it matter if he's taking the oath on the Koran or a copy of Mad magazine? How would making him use the Bible make any difference?
qwerty182764
It wouldn't. And he should probably take the oath on the Koran anyways. I just thought that maybe that was what people were reacting to.
CosmicConservative
I guess you and Dadman are right, but that's what makes me so weird I think. I just don't get it. No matter how I look at it, swearing the oath on the Bible makes no sense to me for a Muslim. And getting worked up about it just seems to be ridiculous. I'll go ahead and say it, this is the sort of reaction that gives "conservatives" a bad reputation.
Ed Minchau
How about swearing the oath on the Constitution? Wouldn't that make more sense? Either that, or eliminate the whole oath of office thing altogether.
CosmicConservative
No, we need the oath, it's what gives teeth to impeachment charges, perjury or treason convictions. It's just the religious trappings that I find archaic and inappropriate.
Drax
Meh. We don't need no steenkin' oath to bring malfeasence or corruption charges; the oath is no law in itself. There should be an oath to mark and highlight the solemnity of the occasion and the high purpose of the office. However, I'm with Conservative on this one though. I don't care if it's on the Bible, the Koran, Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance or whatever floats the particular boat of the office holder in question. By the same token, taking an oath while placing my hand on something which represents a religion I reject makes absolutely no sense to me, and, would offend me if I practiced any religion other than the one upon which I rest my and on its material representation.
Drax
Heh. Almost forgot this part. The taking of the oath isn't for the oath taker, but for those who observe. It has long been known that, for an oath-breaker, it doesn't matter upon what he lays his hand; it doesn't matter which God he swears to; it doesn't matter if he ends the oath with the phrase: "Upon pain of my immortal soul." The oath-breaker breaks his oath, thus, the GIVING of the oath has little meaning, while the ACCEPTING of it has much.
qwerty182764
Ah. Now that I've actually read Prager's comments, I can see how he got it pretty completely wrong. There are plenty of reasons to be leery of Muslims these days, but the bible being a "foundation of American civilization" isn't one of them.
CosmicConservative
One of the things I find most difficult to deal with as a conservative is the assumption by both conservatives and non-conservatives that conservatism itself is tied to religion and tradition. Particularly religion. That's why I bill myself as a "rational conservative" my brand of conservatism has nothing to do with religion and tradition and everything to do with practical reality, logic and pragmatism. So when I say "a strong offense is the best defense" I'm not relying on holy writ nor on blind tradition, I am relying on common sense and historical evidence. It should be clear to any student of history that the best way to avoid being attacked by a foreign power is to be strong enough for that foreign power to seriously doubt they can easily defeat you. Similarly my views on human life are based on the fundamental assumption that there is something special about human life, and that in the absence of clear definitions of when it begins or ends, our respect for that sanctity of human life should have us err on the side of life whenever there is a chance that we are erring in any direction. This is why I am so ambivalent on issues such as gay marriage. I simply don't see why there is any big deal here one way or the other. I don't buy the "immoral lifestyle" argument, and I don't buy the "we never did it that way" argument. If you could show me a compelling economic or social reason that gay marriage was harmful to society, then I'd listen, but frankly I haven't seen an argument on that subject that I've bought yet. When "conservatives" like Prager go out and start invoking "judeo-christian tradition" as a rationale for a "conservative point of view" I feel a lot like a rational liberal would feel if someone were to advance a position on an issue based on atheistic dogma. Not all conservatives are Christian, and not all liberals are atheists.