Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Natural intelligence?

By CosmicConservative
In conversations I have with people there is a clear belief that "modern man" is somehow naturally more intelligent than the "caveman" of, say, 15,000 years ago. This is one reason I'd love to get a working time machine. Let's do a thought experiment, let's take a typical 25 year old man from 2006, take him back to 15,000 years ago in North America, pick up a 25 year old man from that same time, and bring him to 2006. Which of the two do you think will survive longer? Which do you think will have a more profound impact on the existing culture?

Comments (4)

Drax
From then to now, it might be the luck of the draw in whether they could survive in today's society. From now to then, however, it would depend on who you took. Me? Dead in a day, probably. My older brother? Might start his own tribe.
qwerty182764
One could make the point that absolutely anyone can survive in today's (western) society, which is one of the reason there are no starving people on our streets. It wouldn't matter if you were a natural genius of a leader, a rugged survivalist, or a bumbling idiot muttering darkly about conspiracies ruining your life. You wouldn't even have to speak the language to vote!
qwerty182764
Of course, I could see how a caveman would get in trouble in short order for attempting to set up shop (finding a good clearing, making an axe, beginning to clear trees and build a cabin, hauling off and doing things without asking anyone's permission, ect). The living blasphemy against modern man's bambified pastoral utopian illusion of pre-industrial life would not be tolerated for long by the high priests of that religion.
CosmicConservative
I personally think that the modern man would find it far more difficult to adjust and learn the skills needed than the prehistoric one. Mostly because of what qwerty said. To live in the stone age, you had to have skills. Today you don't need skills. And the skills you needed to learn in the stone age were not trivial. I've actually tried flint-knapping. It's hard, injury prone and time-consuming. It takes a true craftsman to make a good arrow or knife.