Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Hurricane Katrina vs. Paris Riots

By CosmicConservative
I have been thinking lately about the relative reaction of the governments of the US and France to two national crises. Now it may not be entirely fair to compare these two, but on the other hand, both are events that have widespread impact to their respective nations. Katrina was a natural disaster, but one that had been predicted for years. The general opinion of hurricane watchers was that it was a matter of "when" and not "if." The Paris riots are a completely man-made phenomenon but there is still that sense that the problems of non-integration, poverty and resentment were also a matter of "when" and not "if." In both cases it seems that the governments involved mostly took the approach of wishing the problem didn't exist. New Orleans was known to be vulnurable to a severe hurricane, but the money that should have been spent to build a stronger defense instead went to pork projects, or was sucked into domestic spending programs. After 9/11 France (and other countries in Europe) looked closely at their Muslim populations and realized they had a problem, and created programs to try to reduce the danger, but those programs lost funding as time and concern was pushed elsewhere. The end result in both cases was similar, at least from a political perspective. Eventually luck ran out and the feared event occurred. The result was not days but weeks of turmoil, with possible ramifications that are not yet understood. The reaction of both governments seemed to be limited and tentative at first, then growing as the situation's true nature became more clear. In both cases the immediately responsible government figure was publicly rebuked. That's about where the similarities end though. France has not yet seen a resignation or sacking, but that may yet come. But the major difference in the two is in how the press has covered the situation. In the Katrina story the mainstream media published every rumor they could find. They played up the racial angle with a vengeance. They reported stories as fact that have since been proven to be wild stories, and have yet to even acknowledge their irresponsible actions, much less apologize for them. In the Paris riots story the press has done exactly the opposite. They have downplayed the ethnicity to the point that it is difficult to even find references to it. They have downplayed the activities of the rioters even as the riots have grown in size and intensity. The restraint of the press has been phenomenal. What could possibly explain this phenomenal schizophrenia of the press?

Comments (0)

No comments on this post.