Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Quarterback stories

By CosmicConservative
So the improbable rise to prominence of perennial backup quarterback Tony Romo continued with a shockingly good performance against Tampa Bay today. Romo's 306 yards and 5 touchdowns was more like Payton Manning than Drew Bledsoe. It was made all the more significant by the fact that Tampa Bay had clearly come into the game with the intention of stopping the Dallas running game to force Romo to beat them. This is a common tactic with new quarterbacks, and I was worried it would work, but Romo repeatedly avoided the rush, picked up the blitz, found the open receiver or threw precise passes exactly where they needed to be. Based on this game Romo could find himself atop the league's quarterback ratings next week, unless Payton has a similarly remarkable game himself. Of course as a Cowboys fan, I'm glad to see Romo emerge as he has this past month, but I still find myself questioning how long his run can go on. He has been playing at a level that I just don't think anyone can sustain for as long as Dallas needs it to go on to make the playoffs or win the division. Dallas's next game is against the New York Giants in the Meadowlands, where the Giants will try to sweep the Cowboys. I would say that's the biggest game of the season for the Cowboys, but they've all been the biggest game of the season since the Arizona game three weeks ago. So instead I'll just say that it's another big game in a string of big games for the Cowboys. Gotta root for Romo though, he's such a great story. And that takes us to Jake Plummer. Jake's game today was decidedly mediocre. It would have been disastrous except for a very fortuitous penalty called on the Chiefs afer what looked like a game-breaking interception Jake had thrown. But that was called back and Denver went on to score their only touchdown. But I have no doubt that Mike Shananhan remembers that errant throw, even if it was wiped off of the stat sheets. The raging rumor here in the Denver area is that Jake Plummer will be replaced by Jay Cutler. Cutler is a rising star because of his play in the preseason and his reputation for a big arm and a big heart. I would guess a majority of Denver fans would say to start Cutler for the next game, not Plummer. I have not been a big fan of Jake Plummer since he came to Denver, and I have been one of those who has said that Jake's one of those quarterbacks who can look awesome, and look awful on consecutive weeks, but that no matter how awesome he looks in the regular season, he's never managed to handle the pressure of the big games where he tends to fall back on desperation heaves downfield, or ill-advised scrambles where he loses the football. That's been his history as long as I've watched him, and that goes all the way back to his Arizona Cardinals days. He reminds me of Randall Cunningham or Michael Vick in that way. He has his moments when he looks like he can beat the whole world, but he just can't seem to get over the big hump of getting to, and winning, the big game. It will be interesting to see if Shanahan benches him. Doing so would more or less be an admission from Shanahan that the brain trust in Dove Valley (Denver's training facility and administrative offices) has lost faith in Plummer's ability to win the big game, and that they are playing for 2007 now by giving Cutler real game experience so that he is ready for the big time next year. It's sort of sad in a way, Jake Plummer's not a bad guy as far as I know (although rumors of his behavior towards fans is generally negative) and he definitely has a lack of supporting players of the caliber Denver has had in the past (does Denver even suit up tight ends?) but that's the nature of the game, and the same crowd who four years ago was clamoring for Jake Plummer to be the savior of the Brian Griese led Broncos, are now calling for Jay Cutler to be the savior of the Jake Plummer Broncos. The reality is that unless Denver develops some other offensive talent, it's not going to matter much who is playing quarterback. And the longer the season goes on, the more injury and fatigue is wearing down what looked like a mighty defense. I don't envy Mike Shanahan or Jake Plummer their flight back to Denver tonight. Both of them are going to be doing some heavy thinking.

Comments (1)

buckblog
I heard the Cutler rumor also. It didn't make sense to me but since KC destroyed Denver last night maybe it will happen. Jake is a decent quarterback who may or may not be able to get them far in the playoffs but I don't think his supporting cast is as good this year. I'd think they would play out the string with him this year and maybe go with Cutler next. Just seems too early to go to an unproven rookie. Now in the case of Dallas that season was going nowhere with Bledsoe and Romo was obviously the qb of the future there from Parcell's view. That switch made sense. I've seen all of Romo's starts. He looks like the real thing. He's making good decisions, is mobile, has a good arm and seems to have the confidence of his teammates. I'm betting on more of a Troy Aikman career than Clint Longley for Romo.