Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Rangel adds to Kerry military insult

By CosmicConservative
Senior Democrat renews call for military draft | Politics News | Reuters.com Rangel, who opposed the 2003 invasion of Iraq, also said he did not think the United States would have invaded Iraq if the children of members of Congress were sent to fight. He has said the U.S. fighting force is comprised disproportionately of people from low-income families and minorities.
So, not only are the military folks dumb and lazy as Kerry pointed out, but they are also poor or minorities. Rangel's solution? draft rich people!!! Why? Because then their parents wouldn't start wars! It's crazy enough to work. I'm with Chuck on this one! ;) So, instead of being snarky on this, I should probably put a serious response to this, because this is a serious issue. Rangel is not the only one on the Left who believes that our military is made up of High School dropouts, and minorities who cannot find jobs in a nation with less than 4% unemployment, apparently because of entrenched and pervasive racism. This leads to our using the military because in their minds (minds like Rangel's) the powerful figures in Washington (I assume he includes Democrats who send troops into battle, although I suspect he really means only Republicans) view the military as expendable pawns in their self-glorification games. This sort of view is profoundly ignorant of the actual composition of today's military, profoundly insulting to the troops and deeply demonstrative of an inability to reconcile this view of the military as populated with ignorant, hapless children with the demonstrable fact that the U.S. Military is the most effective and most powerful on earth, which the Left then uses to claim that we are just big bullies. But cognitive dissonance is so deeply rooted in the mantras of the Left that I am beginning to think that without such logical contradictions, they could not formulate a position.

Comments (6)

Brian
A draftee army sure did wonders to keep us out of Vietnam, allrighty. The argument goes that if the rich are forced to serve then that a Vietnam won't happen. I find the logic questionable; if the conflict is unpopular the privileged classes will still find loopholes for dodging the draft - they always have. At the same time the best and the brightest from the privileged classes have always served. And to we're going to use the Army - the most effective way of winning the war is to have the best army we can. Evidence indicates that a professional force of volunteers is more effective than a draftee army can hope of being. It's not logical - and when your stated goal is not logical then the speaker is either an idiot (which Rangel is not) or it's self-serving politics.
qwerty182764
It's pretty obvious that the Democrats want the draft so that they have something to gin up anger about. The thing is, they probably won't even need it to end the war. All they have to do is cut funding to our soldiers.
CosmicConservative
If they cut funding to the soldiers, they will pretty much hand control to the Republicans in 2008.
Brian
If they cut funding to the soldiers, they will pretty much hand control to the Republicans in 2008. That brings to my mind images of troops going unpaid, regiments disbanding in foreign land ... reall 17th century stuff. Congress votes to defund operations and .. the troops come home is all. Dod plays finance games to charter ships to bring our gear home and that is that. Ah - shades of 1975. There is an upside - in about twenty years every city in America will have an Iraqi cuisine restaurant next to the Vietnamese place.
CosmicConservative
Brian: "the troops come home is all." Well, if you don't count the genocide that will occur throughout Iraq, the destabilization of the region leading to potential massive warfare and the greatly increased reach of global Islamist terrorists who will almost certainly redouble their efforts to strike targets in the U.S. By the way, that's why Iraq is different than Vietnam. In Vietnam when we left, they pretty much let us go. The terrorists we are fighting now will not do that, they will follow us home. But I think I count those things and so will the American public. If that happens and it is due to Democrats defunding the troops so that they simply "come home" than I stand by my assertion that the American public will throw the Democrats out en masse. Or at least I hope they will.
Brian
Well, if you don’t count th You're preaching to the choir. George McGovern - he's got a book out on how to solve the Iraq mess - was interviewed on our local WPR morning talk show. He was going on about how a huge deal was made if we withdrew from Vietnam then the domino effect would kick in ... and they became our trading partner. People go there on vacation! They golf! I'm paraphrasing, but not by much. Killing fields, boat people, Pol Pot .. basically a generation of wasted opportunity, dismissive wave. Not even worth mentioning. I was hoping the host would call him on it .. she didn't.