Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

More on "The Singularity is Near"

By CosmicConservative
So, I'm getting to the end of the book. This isn't a book review, if it were I would say something like "Great Idea, not so great book." It's a hard read. I am usually an aggressive and voracious reader. But the writing in this book is to reading like speed bumps are to the Indianapolis 500. But the ideas themselves are fascinating. I've just finished the part where he contemplates a universe where 99% of the matter in the universe is intelligent. He sort of casually says "that's about as close to God as I can imagine" to which I say, you've got pretty hard limit on your imagination. I can certainly imagine more than that. (Slight aside here, a human body is considered "intelligent" even though well more than 90% of the body is not associated with thought, even the brain is not 100% cognitive tissue, yet we consider the body to be "conscious" - there is no reason the universe cannot be considered "alive" and "conscious" with a similarly small percentage of its matter actually being cognitive...) But he left it at that (so far) and moved on to discuss consciousness itself, or, as he puts it: YRUU (Why Are You You?). Or to be more accurate, Why Am I Me? What are the connections of consciousness over time that allow me to view my life history as an uninterrupted continuum? That's an interesting question, but I think it is essentially tautological. There is a more compelling (to me, that is, if there is a "me") question that he seems to be missing so far, which is "What is will?" Yes, I know I sort of harp on the issue of "will" but that's because I think that is the only compelling question in the universe. It is debatable that "will" even exists. Carl Jung didn't really believe in it, he sort of views "will" as the brain's rationalizations of why we take the actions our life experiences force us to make. This view of "will" as an illusion created by the subjective experience in our brains to explain our stimulus driven actions is actually pretty common in some of the more self-congratulatory ivory towers in academia. Such a view explains a lot, by the way, and I believe that to be the primary reason I am a conservative, because I believe in will which means I believe in personal responsibility and the value of personal liberty. As I said, "will" is the ONLY meaningful property in the universe. Everything else comes from that. Without "will" everything else is pointless. Of course we have not yet explained what "will" is, but it is pretty commonly believed that "will" exists only in living things. In fact some believe that "life" and "will" are interchangeable concepts. It is the expression of "will" that separates living things from insensate matter. Even bacteria move about because they WANT to. That's also why you hear about how the "will to live" is the most powerful instinct in living things, because life IS will. But what if you connect a bunch of silicon circuitry together and write a really clever program and hit the "run" button? It is clear that programs are getting more and more "intelligent" all the time, and I agree with Kurzweil that they are almost certainly going to pass the Turing Test in the next few decades and may even one day be indistinguishble from human intelligences, or even surpass them. But will they have "will"? Or will they only be doing what they must do because of their programming? If we conclusively prove that they always do exactly the same thing in exactly the same circumstances, even though they are clearly "intelligent" what does that tell us? Does that tell us that there is something truly special about "biological life" or does that instead prove that Jung was right and our "free will" is only rationalizing our own rote actions? Well, if Kurzweil is right, and if this blog makes me filthy rich (ha!) then I may actually live long enough to find out that answer to that question. It's a puzzle to be sure.

Comments (6)

qwerty182764
I'm going to post more on this subject when I have some time. It is something that interests me. My previous argument for determinism is not so much that I believe the universe has to be deterministic (quantum physics seems to suggest some sort of randomness in play). However, attempting to hide some fundamental aspect of the meaning of life in that randomness seemed contrived to me, and I wanted to explore the implications of "so what if the universe isn't random? Shouldn't life's meaning derive from the more immediate, less mundane aspects of life?" "As I said, “will” is the ONLY meaningful property in the universe. Everything else comes from that. Without “will” everything else is pointless." I think this is the statement that bugs me the most. To me "without X, everything is pointless" type arguments seem to sell life, the universe, and everything short. Especially when X is insisted to be undefinable or hidden in some gap in our knowledge that we aren't expected to fill. It ties back in to my previous quip about mystery. Anyway, got to go.
CosmicConservative
qwerty: Would it be fair to say "without life the universe is pointless?" I will assume that the vast majority of people would agree that if life did not exist, the universe would not matter. Which is pretty much the same as calling it pointless. So for that particular "X" it seems pretty compelling to say that "without X everything is pointless." So then the question should be asked, what would make life pointless? And I think "determinism" is the best answer to that. If life is purely deterministic, then it is pointless. The single thing that challenges "determinism" is "choice" meaning that the end result of an event is unpredictable. So it is fair then, in my mind, to say that "without choice, life is pointless, without life the universe is pointless, ergo, without choice, the universe is pointless." But choice in and of itself is pointless if it is purely a manifestation of random events, which make it unpredictable, but ultimately pointless. It is "will" that makes "choice" meaningul. Without "will" choices are simply random acts. So I think it is fair to say that without will, choice is pointless, without choice, life is pointless, without life the universe is pointless, ergo, without will, the universe is pointless.
qwerty182764
To the extent that will is reacting to information about the world, isn't that the extent to which it is deterministic? I agree about the randomness part. Random source terms add no information, only noise. So if will were completely random, the choices it makes would indeed be pointless. But if it were in part random, the choices it makes would be in part random themselves. Wouldn't the meaningfulness of the choices be somewhat inversely proportional to the amount of randomness you fuzz the system with? Would there be a maximum somewhere, an optimal amount of randomness?
CosmicConservative
It is precisely because will is affected by the universe, but also affects the universe that it is so critical. The basic expression of will is for us to learn from our experiences and use that learning to change our futures. If we can't do that, then there's no point to learning life lessons that change our outlook and are expressed as choices that we make through the application of our will. That's a large part of why will is important. And that's why we are more responsible for choices we make when we have the proper knowledge about what we SHOULD do, then for those that we make mostly in ignorance. This is a pretty standard concept in moral, ethical and legal analysis. "Common sense" understands that it is because of our free choices that we must be held responsible for them. Your question about an optimal amount of randomness is interesting, but I don't think I have an answer for it. My fundamental assertion is that the meaningful non-determinism in the universe is NOT random, but will-driven.
Rick Larson
There is a whole mind full of ideas in that post. Not sure if this author is following some Eastern Philosophy, or is an avid reader of Azimov. mypointissupposetobefunny Ha!
CosmicConservative
Heh, if the "author" you speak of is me, then there is a little of both Eastern philosophy and Asimov in my background. But most of this comes from contemplating the meaning of life itself, I don't think I could point to any one source for my thoughts. The whole concept of "will" being the central aspect of the universe is not one I hear a lot, but I am convinced it is the only meaningful issue there is. Without will, nothing matters. Period.