Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

On Time Travel

By CosmicConservative
For some reason my "On Patriotism" post went down a strange tangent in the comments where Pace asked me if I would use a time machine if had access to one. I asked him if the access was restricted in some way, or if I could use it at will. His reply:
Either way. Certainly you can use it to return to the current time, so you’d not be stranded in the future. It’s not a trick question, I was just wondering if you’d want to see what the future held, or if the practical risks or other considerations would dissuade you.
OK, so this is a serious question. And God knows, I love serious questions. It's the whimsical funny ones that I avoid like the plague. So, I'll respond with typical lugubrious bombast. Fair warning. So, if someone appeared from the future and proved to me that he or she was from the future (say, they appeared twice, once to give me the sports page from a week in the future, then came back after all the scores were in proving them right), and they then offered to give me the keys for "a while" (in quotes because, hey, if you have a time machine, you pretty much by definition have all the time in the world and can give it back whenever you want, and they'll never miss a moment of it) what would I do? Well, I suppose I would have to use it to prove or disprove once and for all the deterministic or non-deterministic nature of the universe. In other words, I'd want to know if the future is already set. So I'd want to change something in some way. In this way I could prove to myself that free will existed. Now this is a pretty profound thing to try to do, and attempting to do it might very well generate a paradox of some sort. But my logic would say that if I attempted to change the future, and doing so created some sort of catastrophic paradox, then the future was fixed already, or else the paradox wouldn't have occurred. And a universe with an immutable future isn't worth saving anyway, so if it were destroyed, well, c'est la vie. Since nothing mattered, nothing was "lost", just some old metaphorical videotape was destroyed. Now, there are paradoxes and there are paradoxes. If it turned out that the future was malleable, then I might be interested in attempting to set up a logically contradicting paradox just to see what happened. Like traveling to the future and destroying the time machine before the time travelers could come back and show it to me. Then I'd have a time machine that had been destroyed before I got it. What would happen? Assuming I survived that, I'd go get the stock market reports for a few months down the road and hock myself up to my eyeballs to buy and leverage as much stock as possible to make as much money as possible. Hey, a guy needs to eat too. Then what... Travel to the end of the universe to see if it really does end in entropic heat death? Travel to the beginning of the universe to see if it really was created by God? (There is a really good Cyril Kornbluth story using exactly that plot device). I dunno... I think what I did next would depend mostly on how long the thing would operate before I got stranded somewhere. See, I've read all those stories, so I know that all time travelers are ultimately overcome by ironic twists.

Comments (16)

qwerty182764
"But my logic would say that if I attempted to change the future, and doing so created some sort of catastrophic paradox, then the future was fixed already, or else the paradox wouldn’t have occurred. And a universe with an immutable future isn’t worth saving anyway, so if it were destroyed, well, c’est la vie. Since nothing mattered, nothing was “lost”, just some old metaphorical videotape was destroyed. " It is interesting to me why people insist on linking their ability to make decisions (free-will) with whether or not time is self consistent (determinism?) I'm a bit of a determinist myself. It only seems to make sense to me that if you make a decision when prompted with a situation, that there isn't any good reason why, if someone rewound time and re-prompted the exact same situation, you shouldn't give the same response. Whatever it is that you do to arrive at uncoerced decisions (free-will) should do the same thing again. You might protest about quantum effects, but the brain is a macroscopic device, and shouldn't be influenced much by quantum randomness. Furthermore, I find it strange that when people create a situation where they don't quite know what will end up happening, such as a time travel or logic paradox, they seem to think it is the universe that will be glitching up, not their idea of the situation! Besides, wasn't there some mathematician who set up some model of time travelling billiard balls and managed to show that the probability of all time-travel events that end up preventing themselves was identically zero?
CosmicConservative
Qwerty: There are a couple of levels to approach this issue. First let's apply pure logic. Let's say you are on a casual hike in the woods of a small park. You know that all paths are equally safe and equally long. You have no predisposition to go one way or another. After a few minutes you come to a path that forks to the right or left. If the future has already been determined, then your choice has already been made. That choice was made when the universe was formed. You are going left. You can rewind it and rerun it a billion times, but you will always go left. What happens if you choose to go right instead? If your description is correct, you cannot go right. No matter how much you think you can "choose" you cannot actually choose because all the variables are set. At every level of the universe every variable has been set. Your choice can be affected by your mood, but your mood itself is immutable. No matter how many times you rerun it, your mood will be the same. From a pure logical perspective you have no choice. If you have no choice, you cannot "choose" if you cannot "choose" you have no free will. I would call this "QED". If we look at it from a Religious perspective, say God knows all outcomes and God "knows" you will turn left. What if you turn right instead? Well, obviously you cannot because God cannot be wrong. Again, "choice" is an illusion, you are going left, and you were predestined to go left when the universe was born. Unfortunately there is no way to look at this from an experimental perspective because we don't know how to rewind and rerun the universe. But if you look at it from a quantum mechanics perspective, there is no way to predict if you will go left or right. Quantum mechanics says such events are probabilistic. You might be 99.99% certain to go left, but if you rewind and rerun the situation enough, you will eventually go right. Now, you can argue that this probabilistic approach is no more free will than the deterministic one, that the final decision of turning right or left boils down to the cumulative effects of every quantum event in the history of the universe, and the "choice" you make is really just the direction you werre bumped, but at least you can say that the universe is not deterministic. Now lets look at this philosophically. If your path in life is set from the day you are conceived, if the future is fixed and deterministic, and if you rewind and rerun the event a billion times with the identical outcome, then what is "will?" This, to me, is the most profound and fundamental question in the universe. What is "will?" Most people would say that "will" is the exercise of an individual choice, and that "free will" means that the individual has the ultimate control over that choice. It also means that the choice itself is an act of creation. By "choosing" to do one thing instead of another, an individual has fundamentally affected the fabric of the universe, because by turning right instead of left, every possible future of the universe that involved me turning left disappears forever, and every possible future of the universe that involved me turning right is opened up. I find it interesting, both scientficially and philosophically, that quantum mechanics gives us a means to describe a non-deterministic universe. I am fond of saying that "will" exists in the quantum foam of the universe. That's where it lives. We haven't found it, and may never find it, but it is deeply woven into the actual fabric of the fundamental elements of the universe. There is no deterministic universe that I find philosophically appealing. In fact I would say I find all of them philosophically appalling. And I repeat my assertion that such universes are no more than metaphorical videotapes. Insofar as I have any actual will to choose, I choose to believe that the universe is not deterministic, and that my choices actually are undetermined until I make them. And that by making them I am affecting the universe, and that I am responsible for the end result of those choices. I look at it like this. The past is rigid and set, unchangeable. The future is fuzzy and undetermined, but certain futures are far more likely to occur than others. The cumulative quantum probabilistic effects that occur every single instant effectively weave the unformed and undetermined future into a rigid and set past. This moment of weaving is what we percieve as "now". And in that moment, at the most basic level of the universe, in the quantum foam of it, innumerable acts of creation occur as living beings exercise their free will. And that is why free will is what it is all about. One more note. Quantum effects are not invisible at the macro, human scale. In fact computers run on quantum effects. The circuits that reside in your computer depend on a principle called "quantum tunneling" that drives the circuits themselves. Also, recent experiments and theory indicate that "quantum effects" can be arbitrarily large. How large they can be depends on the boundaries of the situation. Our understanding of what those actual boundaries are is far from complete. But for quantum effects to influence the decision of whether you have biscuits or sweetrolls for breakfast, the actual quantum fluctuations could be sub-atomic in scale, but effect the circuitry of your brain so that you choose one package instead of another when you reach into the fridge.
qwerty182764
"I look at it like this. The past is rigid and set, unchangeable. The future is fuzzy and undetermined," That there should be a difference between the two bugs me. Why should one be less well defined than the other? "From a pure logical perspective you have no choice. If you have no choice, you cannot “choose” if you cannot “choose” you have no free will. I would call this “QED”." Well, if we are neglecting the details of what constitutes your will and looking only at your physical ability, then you can go right, you just will not go right. Well, you can choose, but choosing is a well defined process within your head, right? It seems that for nondeterministic-will to work, "you" have to remain undefined. To define what constitutes your will is to define what will eventually result from it's interaction with your immediate circumstance. Since you exist, and I assume you have a well defined set of attributes and manner in which you exist, shouldn't the process of your choice be deterministic? if(conditional(you, your environment)) then { A } else { B } To demand that your will be non-deterministic is to demand the un-definability of either yourself or your circumstances. I suppose you could include some element of randomness to the whole deal. if(conditional(you, your environment, random variable)) then { A } else { B } But I still can't quite see how that improves matters. It succeeds in making your decision non-deterministic, but why is the latter philosophically preferable to the former?
qwerty182764
It also just seems to be a bit anthropocentric to attempt to hang something dealing with human-scale philosophy on quantum randomness. "But for quantum effects to influence the decision of whether you have biscuits or sweetrolls for breakfast, the actual quantum fluctuations could be sub-atomic in scale, but effect the circuitry of your brain so that you choose one package instead of another when you reach into the fridge." The stars aren't in the sky for the purpose of guiding our sailing ships, I doubt that quantum physics is as it is for the sake of randomizing our wills.
qwerty182764
"That there should be a difference between the two bugs me. Why should one be less well defined than the other?" Especially if you're talking about hypothetical time travel! If you have the time vehicle travelling backwards in time, then the way it is relatively oriented, the universe's past is it's future. Would the past then be fuzzy and undefined on the time-machine? In any situation that permits time travel, it seems to me to only be consistent if either both the past and the future are fuzzy, or both are well defined, but not with any sort of directional bias.
CosmicConservative
qwerty: It is this statement of yours that is at the core of the matter:
It seems that for nondeterministic-will to work, “you” have to remain undefined. To define what constitutes your will is to define what will eventually result from it’s interaction with your immediate circumstance. Since you exist, and I assume you have a well defined set of attributes and manner in which you exist, shouldn’t the process of your choice be deterministic?
This is a fundamental refutation of both "will" and "probability." This is a bare assertion that if you cannot predict the outcome of something, then you cannot define the entity. I would say this is exactly where science was in the mid 1800s, when a famous physicist said "Everything we can know is known, the rest is just filling in the details" or words to that effect. That statement was based on Newtonian, deterministic, billiard-ball dynamics. That is why quantum mechanics was such a revolutionary breakthrough in physics. Quantum mechanics says we can know everything that is knowable about a system, and yet we cannot predict what it will do. This inability to predict the outcome is not due to some limitation of the human mind to comprehend, nor of the tools we have to measure, the initial state of the system. The system itself is fundamentally probablistic in nature. That's what quantum theory says. Most experts describe quantum theory as the most successful physical theory ever conceived, it is the foundation for everything from nuclear physics to information processing systems. You are asserting that quantum mechanics is wrong. That the underlying nature of the universe is deterministic, not probabilistic. As I said, I find that philosophically appalling and our current theories and experiments run counter to that idea. That's not to say that you aren't right. Maybe you are. But if you are, I assert again, the universe is nothing more than a metaphorical videotape, you are nothing more than the result of your initial conditions and "will" itself is merely an illusion, much less "free will." Such a universe is unworthy of consideration as a means for individuals to learn, grow and affect their own futures. Maybe that's the way it is. I don't think it is, and if it is that way, then I would argue that there is fundamentally no point to the whole thing.
CosmicConservative
qwerty:
“That there should be a difference between the two bugs me. Why should one be less well defined than the other?” Especially if you’re talking about hypothetical time travel! If you have the time vehicle travelling backwards in time, then the way it is relatively oriented, the universe’s past is it’s future. Would the past then be fuzzy and undefined on the time-machine? In any situation that permits time travel, it seems to me to only be consistent if either both the past and the future are fuzzy, or both are well defined, but not with any sort of directional bias.
So you have nailed exactly why I find time travel to be unlikely. And why time travel introduces so many logical paradoxes that most scientists find it to be unlikely. I have not come up with a reasonable model of time travel that would not force us to completely redefine what the "universe" itself is. Not that we haven't redefined what the universe is hundreds of times already, but I will admit that this is a limitation of my own mind. I can't figure out how time travel could exist without fundamentally violating everything I think I know about causality.
CosmicConservative
Oh, and qwerty, back to pace's question. That's the reason if I had a time machine I would investigate exactly the issue you and I are discussing. To prove it one way or the other.
qwerty182764
Well, don't let me sour your mood. I only think of the world in deterministic terms because all of the physics I know and understand to date is deterministic in nature. (d/dt(something) = function of (a,b,c,something,time)) (along with every other derivative, and with no particular bias towards past or future) Furthermore, I can't wrap my head around any function that is at best more than pseudo-random. r = random_function(takes no inputs??) - I mean, how in the world would something like that work? But if quantum physics does give rise to actual randomness, then I can't argue with the way the universe behaves. I just don't understand it yet. Hanging deep questions of whether or not life has meaning on the minutia of how the universe operates on a subatomic level seems odd to me. Whether or not life has meaning should derive from what we already know about life (and we should have a good body of experience with that already), regardless of what we discover about how the substructure, or macroscopic structure of the universe runs, what it's ultimate fate is, ect. It should be relatively self-sufficient. "the universe is nothing more than a metaphorical videotape," :-P Hey! I'm still watching that tape!
qwerty182764
[quote]Oh, and qwerty, back to pace’s question. That’s the reason if I had a time machine I would investigate exactly the issue you and I are discussing. To prove it one way or the other. [/quote] I would go forward in time and buy a history book. :-P. If the universe turns out to be non-deterministic, then I would repeat the process as often as needed. Then I would ensure that America/democracy continues to kick butt and rule the world!
CosmicConservative
qwerty: Hmm.... You havent' soured my mood, I enjoy this sort of discussion. I am curious to know why you say that all the physics you know is deterministic in nature. That is fundamentally opposed to modern quantum mechanics which is probabilistic in nature. This is the central debate that led Einstein to say "God does not play dice with the unvierse" and which Heisenberg (I think, perhaps it was Neils Bohr) responded "God not only plays dice, he throws them where we can't see them." In fact Heisenberg's "Uncertainty Principle" was once called "Heisenberg's indeterminancy principle" precisely because it described the universe in nondeterministic terms. The conflict between Newtonian determinism and the "Copenhagen Interpretation" of the universe was the spark that founded the science of quantum mechanics. This is why I have said on other posts that the current theory of quantum mechanics is purely descriptive. It gives no reason that the universe is fundamentally non-deterministic and probabilistic, it simply describes how the universe acts in that manner. Nobody knows why it would be that way, but philosophically nobody has ever described why the universe should be deterministic either. You mentioned anthropomorphism earlier, it could well be nothing but anthropomorphic predispositions that lead us to expect the unviverse to react in cause and effect terms. I disagree with you fundamentally about life, purpose and meaning. It is impossible for me to conceive of any meaning of a life which was pre-ordained when the universe formed. My consciousness is either an illusion, or else is merely along for the ride, alternately railing against the deterministic events that I cannot control, or rationalizing them to give the the comfortable illusion that I have some measure of control over my life. As I said, I find deterministic interpretations of the universe appalling. And the reason I turn to the quantum foam as a potential place for will to exist is because that's where the universe appears to be non-deterministic in nature. This is a 100 year old debate. Einstein and Heisenberg never settled it. It is unlikely that you and I will. But I enjoy discussing it regardless. However, in this case, I side with Heisenberg. I will also make one slight foray into theism here. It is not inconsequential that Einstein's deterministic argument invoked "God." Most do.
qwerty182764
"I am curious to know why you say that all the physics you know is deterministic in nature." Well, like I said, all the physics I know and understand. (I'm still on the 1st chapter of that quantum physics book btw). I don't understand quantum physics, so I can't visualize how it works yet.
CosmicConservative
qwerty: All kidding aside, if you ever "understand" quantum mechanics, you will be sitting in a chair in stockholm some day, wating for your name to be called. I completed an undergraduate degree in modern physics and passed all the required tests to do so, which included years of calculating probability functions to describe physical events such as the decay of radiaoactive nuclei. But I don't think I can claim that I ever "understood" it. Quantum mechanics is deeply, profoundly, almost incomprehensibly... weird. Relativity theory, on the other hand, is deeply beautiful and elegant. This is one reason the two have been so difficult to reconcile. One is entirely deterministic, the other is fundamentally indeterministic. It's a problem.
Dadman
Cosmic said: 'Insofar as I have any actual will to choose, I choose to believe that the universe is not deterministic, and that my choices actually are undetermined until I make them. And that by making them I am affecting the universe, and that I am responsible for the end result of those choices.' I have to say that I am completely behind Cosmic on this one... Cosmic also said: It is impossible for me to conceive of any meaning of a life which was pre-ordained when the universe formed. My consciousness is either an illusion, or else is merely along for the ride, alternately railing against the deterministic events that I cannot control, or rationalizing them to give the the comfortable illusion that I have some measure of control over my life. Again, this is an excellent articulation of what I personally believe. I believe free will is the most important principle of the universe and I do believe, as Cosmic does, that it can be found in the 'quantum foam'.
CosmicConservative
Oh, one more thing. In several posts I meant to address the relative philosophical appeal of "deterministic" "random" and "will-driven" universes. I find deterministic explanations to be completely uninteresting. They are nothing more than the initial conditions. The entire universe's history, events, growth, life and death are all completely and immutably described in the initial conditions. Such universes are essentially meaningless. I find the introduction of randomness to improve matters somewhat, at least in the sense that you can not predict the outcome so it might be fun to watch. But in the end the universe is nothing more than the initial conditions and the randomness. The mechanics might be more interesting, but they have no more meaning. It is only when you introduce "will" into the picture that I find a universe to be philosophically meaningful. And that is really, I think, profound. I have tried to explain this to people many times over the years. Life, love, meaning, purpose, everything that matters, fundamentally depend on will. If there is nothing that drives the course of the universe based on choices that have consequences, then there is nothing but a pretty picture. Some people might call that same concept the "soul" I don't like to use such words. But there is no denying that my concept of "will" is fundamentally outside of our current ability to scientifically define. And in that sense it might even be described as "supernatural" Or even... ... divine. It is this sort of contemplation that keeps me up late at night.
pace
Awesome discussion. I would of course agree with Cosmic's assertion, that in a probablistic universe time travel would seem to present irreconcilable paradoxes. Not to mention that if we really have 'free-will', not the deterministic illusion of will, then there are an infinite set of possible, even likely futures. Which one are we visiting?