Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

John Kerry on Trent Lott

By CosmicConservative
So, when Trent Lott made a gaffe at Strom Thurmond's birthday party, a gaffe Lott immediately apologized for and claimed to have been a misguided effort to show respect for Thurmond's long public service, here is what John Kerry said:
Earlier Wednesday, Sen. John Kerry, a Massachusetts Democrat and 2004 presidential contender, became the first member of the Senate to suggest Lott was now unfit to lead the upper chamber. "It saddens me greatly to suggest this, but in the interests of the Senate, his party, and the nation, I believe Trent Lott should step aside as majority leader," Kerry said. "I simply do not believe the country can today afford to have someone who has made these statements again and again be the leader of the United States Senate."
Now, that was after Lott repeatedly apologized. Not once did Lott attack his Democrat accusers as "liars" or worse. Not once did he defend the remarks as a "bad joke." And Lott lost his position as Senate Majority Leader. If Kerry expects Lott to pay for his gaffe, how can he now act aggrieved and unfairly attacked for his own? In both cases the gaffe was claimed to be a misstatement, but in both cases the comment that was made was consistent with a history of previous offensive comments on the same subject. I wish Lott would come out and essentially repeat Kerry's quote verbatum in a press conference, just to see if the press is smart enough to pick up on it. Kerry has a Lott of explaining to do. OK, last post on Kerry unless something else interesting breaks on it.

Comments (7)

pace
John Kerry is an idiot. I think his comments have only the most abstract relevance to the Democratic midterm campaign, but Republicans will view this as a gift and will likely milk it for all it's worth. And who can blame them? The Democrats would do the same.
CosmicConservative
Pace: I disagree. I think the view of the military as a bunch of redneck idiots who see themselves as graduates of "Soldier of Fortune" magazine is rampant on the Left, particularly in our universities and our media. Mark Halperin, the ABC political news director, was on Hugh Hewitt yesterday and he admitted that the Left is profoundly anti-military, and that the media was profoundly Left (he said roughly 90 - 95% of reporters and editors are hard-core liberals). For this reason I think Kerry's comment was a clear indication of how Democrats will govern this country, just as they have governed the country since JFK and LBJ, the last two Democrat Presidents that I would call remotely patriotic. It isn't merely political opportunism for Republicans to make an issue of Kerry's remarks, although I support even that aspect of it because, as you say, the Democrats would do the same (look at Trent Lott). It is also a clear differentiation between parties that are harder and harder to differentiate. That's the reason this is such a major gaffe. It reinforces what everyone knows about the Democratic party and the Left. They really do hate the military. Maybe not every single one of them (maybe not you) but the Scoop Jackson wing of the Democratic party has one member left, and he's running as an Independent this year because the Leftist 'netroots' who have taken ownership of the soul of the Democratic party ran him out of the party, and celebrated for having done so.
Drax
The democrats missed two news cycles (thus far) trying to explain, run from, or decry Kerry's remarks, cycles the MSM would have loved to have used to promote Democrats. The longer this stays alive, the better for the Republicans. And, yes. Kerry's an idiot. An idiot who stood somewhat of a chance of being elected in 2008, and that speaks more of our voting populace than anything I can think of.
pace
CC: I think your response highlights the fundamental difference in how Republicans and Democrats view the notion of 'patriotism' and what makes one a Patriot. In other discussions with you, it is clear that your and my politics are more aligned than they are divergent, so it is curious how the so-called 'Left' and 'Right' can be so profoundly divided on this particular subject. Even folks like you and me that do not occupy the extremes of the political spectrum. Of course, I grew up in a country that is now largely devoid of the notion of patriotism, and you grew up on military bases, so certainly that would account for some profound differences in perspective I think. Well, I digress.. My view of how the Democrats perceive the military of course differs from your analysis. I think it has more to do with their view of how and when it is appropriate to deploy them, and Democrats are certainly more nuanced in that regard. With that said, I will be honest and say that I do not by any means share a view that the military represent our intellectual elite (if that is what you hold), but I do not view them as being largely comprised of high-school dropouts either. I'm trying to be honest here, and hopefully did not just Kerryize myself.
CosmicConservative
Drax: I can't agree that Kerry is an "idiot", even if in the heat of passion I may have said words to that effect myself. He's an intelligent individual who has ideological blinders. My personal opinion is that this whole episode came about because Kerry feels as if he is "among friends" when he is speaking at colleges and so let his guard down and let slip some of his true beliefs. Once that ignited a firestorm he decided he had to address the problem. He believes that he was not forceful enough in his defence of the Swift Boat claims, and so he made a conscious decision to go on the attack in this case. That's bad politics, and was unwise, but I can't really say it demonstrates that he is intellectually deficient. At least not any more than Bush who has made similarly unwise political choices. However, I do believe that the Republicans need not worry about Kerry's motivations or possible errors in this, they just need to ride this particular horse as far as it can take them. Pace: I think you are reading more into my comments about patriotism than I have explicitly stated. I do not believe that it is unpatriotic to be nuanced. And in fact I now regret having used the term "patriotic" in my above post because I can't really question the Left's "patriotism" as much as I question their "judgment." I am not a "my country, right or wrong" ideologue. I have repeatedly stated that there is a legitimate and defensible argument that the war on Iraq was a mistake. I don't question someone's patriotism for attacking the war on Iraq. I do, however, question the patriotism of anyone who routinely assumes the worst about the United States, and specifically about the United States military. I think John Kerry routinely assumes the worst about the United States military at least, if not the United States itself. His record is clear, public and indefensible. He has leveled some of the most egregious charges conceivable against our military men and women, and I think it is about time that he paid for it. Even if in this case he did "botch a joke" Kerry doesn't even realize that the reason he has ignited a firestorm is because he has advanced such opinions routinely over his career, and now that is coming home to roost. I think the latest actual analysis of performance on standardized tests such as IQ tests has demonstrated that the US military is slightly above the national average. I don't think that the military has any more or less of our intellectual "elite" than the general population, I think that the military is very representative of the general population. There are people with all degrees of education, all levels of capability and all spectrums of ideology. I will try to post on what I consider "patriotism" to be. That will give you a chance to weigh in on how much you and I might diverge in that definition.
pace
Just to clarify, I termed Kerry an 'idiot' to mean that his making this statement this close to an election is extremely careless, and grossly ill-advised if it was in fact scripted. I do not think he is notably more or less intelligent than George Bush for example, whom I've likely termed an idiot before and likely will again. How we like to abuse the english language, huh? I would agree with your observation of the military demographic likely being representative of our general population.
CosmicConservative
OK, I posted a "definition" of patriotism for your review.