Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

"Debating" the left

By CosmicConservative
I have been involved in a lot of debates with people on the left lately. Those debates have covered everything from the 2000 Florida election results to the Plame investigation indictments. In general my experience has been that the position on the left is not merely factually incorrect, it is usually deeply involved in the belief of many things that are simply untrue. For example, in the Florida debate my opponent did not know, and refused to believe until I provided the actual decison from the SCOTUS that the actual ruling on the Florida recount was a 7-2 decision that the process violated due process. They were absolutely certain it was a 5-4 decision that was purely politically motivated. The 5-4 decision that came down was on the relatively minor issue of whether Florida had time to do a proper recount, a recount that done according to the approved process would have gone to Bush anyway. But even with that knowledge the person still insisted that Bush "stole" the election and turned to the separate fantasy that Bush only won because so many Florida Democrats "accidentally" voted for Pat Buchanan. There was no way to break through the position with logic, the "truth" was that Bush stole the election and no mere fact would alter that. Another "debate" was on the subject of "Bush lied about WMD." After a solid week of providing unassailable evidence that Bush had been told by the CIA, with the support of at least six IDENTIFIED foreign intelligence agencies (Britain, Fance, Germany, Russia, Italy, Australia) all of whom were saying Hussein had such weapons, the entire argument on his side boiled down to these two statements: 1. Bush lied because he said there was "no doubt" that Saddam had WMD, when there was "some doubt." 2. Bush lied because he said he had "exhausted all options but war" when there were options left. So the entire argument boiled down to a sort of absurd rhetorical literalism. I provided multiple links from prominent Democrats, including Tom Daeschle, Joe Lieberman and Ted Kennedy who said exactly the same thing ("no doubt") but that didn't matter to him because only Bush's "no doubt" mattered. And since one option to avoid war is total capitulation, there is no way to win that argument either. It was an interesting experience for me. There is no opportunity for substantive debate, the people I debate with on these subjects are totally unable to accept facts that are opposed to their world view. It is scary. And it is widespread. When did people lose the capacity for reason and rationality? What do we do to get it back?

Comments (0)

No comments on this post.