Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

The NIE leak story grows...

By CosmicConservative
Squiggler is all over it. Here's the condensed version: The leading Democrat on the House Intelligence Committee is one Jane Harman. Ms. Harman hired a guy named Larry Hanauer who used to work in the Pentagon as a middle east analyst of some sort, specializing on Israel. He also was part of the team that worked on the Iraq war planning, but seems to have been one whose opinions were not followed. As a staff member of the ranking House Democrat on the House Intelligence Committee, he had high level security clearance. Shortly after he had requested access to the NIE report (3 days I think) the NY Times ran a story with excerpts from that report. Perhaps he is innocent. But it doesn't look good. Assuming he is the source of this information what that means is that he used his security clearance to find and leak damaging classified information to the NY Times specifically to damage the Republicans in the upcoming election. If true, this is a truly despicable act of partisanship. But also if true, one has to wonder what Jane Harman knew about this. This is a trail that Patrick Fitzgerald should truly be sniffing out. Violating security clearance in the House Intelligence Committee and leaking the information to damage a political opponent is a serious criminal act. And one the House should by rights take hard action on. If not then this sets a precedence for future staff members with clearance to leak information to damage their opponents in the future. This is a Pandora's box that needs the lid slammed hard and fast. Do the House Republicans have the stomach for it? Probably not. But we'll see. Of course this is all speculation since we don't know if he's guilty or not. But it's worth reading.

Comments (22)

fred
As I've said several times, I am glad the NIE conclusions became known before the election. And if the leaker ends up in jail, then so be it. Influencing the outcome of an important election can be as noble a cause as anything else. Exactly the same argument Beauprez is making for his guy: secrets need to be brought to light. Especially before an important vote. But I must say I admire Cosmo's rigid devotion to nonpartisanship and adherence to absolute moral principles! Wow!
Drax
Yes. Influencing the outcome of an election through the criminal dissemination of a lie is quit the noble pursuit. Glad we got that nailed down.
fred
Right. The NIE leaker is despicable scum but Linda Tripp is Mother Theresa. Well, there's only one man with enough true clear objective vision to put all of this into perspective: John O'Neill. I have such enormous respect for the man that I will certainly adopt his opinion on these matters as my own.
Drax
You equate the action of a person sworn NOT to dissiminate "secret" information who does so for his own personal agenda and a person drawn into the "Clinton Bimbo Eruptions" through NO action of her own taking rational precautions to protect herself? Especially when subsequent events established that, had she not done so, she would have simple joined the growing list of women that Clinton and his cronies smeared to protect Clinton from his inability to control his need to dominate women? That, again, helps clarify things.
CosmicConservative
fred, everything you say simply reinforces your fundamental contention that the ends justifies the means. Then you further expand that notion to say that the "ends" that are justifiable are purely partisan ones. I don't quite know how to say this fred, but if these opinions you are sharing with us here are truly indicative of liberal ideology, I am more proud than ever that I shed such ideas when I started reading the works of Winston Churchill, Thomas Jefferson, James Madison and the rest of the great defenders of liberty. If you think our founding fathers would find your dogmatic devotion to moral relativism and partisan law-breaking noble, you are quite naive.
CosmicConservative
fred: Can you explain to me what, if any, problem you had with the Republicans breaking into Democratic headquarters to find secret Democrat strategy papers to use to defeat them in 1972? Are Democratic National Party papers more sacrosanct in your mind than national security classified information? Do you think the Republicans did the right thing at Watergate? After all, they were only finding secret information to use to win a highly partisan election.
fred
Okay, all silliness aside for just a moment. I have a grudging admiration for people like Liddy and North who broke the law because they thought their causes were just. I have a grudging admiration for the lawbreaker Cindy Sheehan even though I don't support her cause. Heck, I can even show a little respect for Linda Tripp, although I'm not sure what her cause was other than Linda Tripp. If you can state the moral formula then please do so. Personally, I admit that our judgements are quite subjective when it comes declaring this illegal political act to be laudable, and that illegal political act to be despicable. Hopefully in the long run we will agree much more often than we disagree. We don't know yet who the NIE leaker is or what was the motive. I do know this, though. One person's partisan hack is another person's defender of a noble cause. Yes, please state the formula. And do yourself the favor of digging a little deeper for illegal political behavior you support. We know who is Drax's heroine on this score. Who is yours?
Drax
Lol. Tripp is hardly my "heroine." However, neither is she the dispicable scum that the MSM made her out to be.
Drax
Oh. Before I forget. I cannot conceive of a single political "cause" in America (presently) which would justify breaking the law in order to promote it. I have enough faith in our political system's ability to accurately tally votes that all of the issues of the day can be resolved through voting, rather than through breaking the law to influence the vote. If, in this political system, you can't win "fairly, then your position doesn't deserve to win. Your notion of "the ends justifies the means" is the very reasoning that Enviromental wackos use to spike trees, abortion opponents use to kill abortion doctors, or whatever. What they cannot win at the ballot box in a country where, while there is corruption and vote fixing on a relatively small scale, everyone has the opportunity to vote, and everyone's vote is counted, they, instead attempt to change through criminal activity. I don't agree with Roe v. Wade. It was bad law when it was written and is bad law now, but, it IS the law. At some point the Supreme Court may revisit it as they did the segregation issue or other issues and make a ruling which at least resembles what is written in the Constitution. Until that day, however, I will OBEY that law, while attempting to persuade those who agree with the ruling to change their minds. That is how things are supposed to work, not through stealing records from Watergate or through leaking partial information you know that, in that form, to be a lie -- or by REPORTING that information knowing that you are being used to dissiminate a lie -- in hopes (by the leaker and the reporters) that the use of this lie will affect the outcome of an election. Cosmic is right. The ramifications of the depths of dispicability that the Democrats and liberals have sunk to over the past several years will reverbrate politically for many years.
CosmicConservative
fred: I don't think there's a "formula" but there's a "smell test." And here it is. When the actions are designed to further the ambitions of a particular party or a particular political ideology, then there is no justification for breaking the law. When the actions are designed to right a clear moral wrong, then there MAY be justification for breaking the law. The problem with the second part of this is that it is not clear to me that you can trust people's judgment about what is a "moral wrong" because they get their ideology so tied up in their morality that the two become inseparable. This is why Cindy Sheehan can say she wishes she could go back in time and kill the young GW Bush. She no longer has the ability to distinguish between morality and ideology. And frankly fred, I wonder about you. This twisting of morality and ideology is becoming, or has become, an alarming tendency of the left. In debate after debate with liberals, the accusation morphs from "I disagree with your position" into "you are on the side of evil!". Global Warming is an example. In Austria there is a politician who is seriously recommending that global warming skeptics be tried for "crimes against humanity." Why? Because global warming advocates have tried, convicted and sentenced their opponents already. Never mind that there are serious questions to be asked about both the methodology and the conclusions that are drawn in the global warming debate, to the Left if you disagree with them on Global Warming, you aren't just wrong, you are evil. The Iraq War is another example. There have been countless learned treatises written on the balancing of the current violence in Iraq against the systematic violence perpetrated for over two decades by Saddam Hussein, but to the Left it's decided. The Iraq War is evil and if you don't agree, you are evil too. Gay rights is another one. If you don't support the "right" to gay marriage, you aren't just supporting your cultural mores, followed for thousands of generations according to your deeply held religious convictions, no you are a homophobe and are evil. Abortion.... Affirmative action... Welfare reform... Wal-Mart... It has become the mantra of the left. We are the arbiters of human morality, if we believe it, then it is so. If you disagree with us, you must be silenced for you are evil and evil must be destroyed. It is this extreme interpretation of a once-reasonable liberal ideology that allows you to believe that it is OK to break the law to oppose Bush. Because you have decided that Bush is WRONG and that EVIL must be fought. You aren't the worst example, in fact there may be hope for you to avoid this, but it is becoming more and more the pattern of discourse with the Left. Recently the Minute Men, those folks who are patrolling the Mexico-US border, were scheduled to speak to a college gathering, a college who had sat quite reasonably while a Muslim radical preached Islamic supremacy. When the Minute Men tried to speak, a group of "liberal" (and I put that in scare quotes for a reason) activists rushed the stage and started what was effectively a brawl to stop the Minute Men from speaking. After the melee was over and the crowd had gone home, one of the leaders of the stage-rushing thugs stated that he was quite proud of what they had done since "the Minute Men have no legitimate voice in this debate." I worry about this tendency fred, and I see it in your argument that it is OK for you to decide which laws to break based on your ideology. That is a dangerous path you have set out on fred. History shows where it has led in the past.
fred
I don't know where you guys get the idea that the "ends justifiy the means" encapsulates how I might judge illegal political acts. What I said was that the only way I might be able to approach a formula is to judge the consequences of the act. But I will take up that slogan and try to turn it around and see if it doesn't apply to you just as superficially. Therefore, if a political group breaks the law and destroys property in pursuit of crass personal motives, do you not judge that more harshly than a political group breaks the law and destroys property in pursuit of throwing off the yoke of tyranny to establish a free nation? Same means, but different ends. If an individual coordinates the illegal sale of weapons to an enemy for personal or corporate profit, do you not judge that individual more harshly than one who coordinates the illegal sale of weapons to an enemy in order to channel funds to freedom fighters? Same means, but different ends. If a leak of classified information leads to endangered lives and the neutralization of a US intelligence front company, do you not judge that more harshly than a leak of classified information which leads to a wide dissemination of information which was being held back for no real security reason. Same means, but different ends. Since we all agree on MLK, do you not judge civil disobediance for trivial reasons more harshly than civil disobedience which leads to important legislation? Same means, but different ends. I don't like the slogan "the ends justifiy the means" but since you insist on foisting it upon me, I ask you to take an example of your own choosing, some illegal political act that you would support, and then put it up against a similar example you detest. Tell me then that it is not the consequence of the act which determines your judgement, but the act itself. And I have to tell you, Cosmo, your tendency to paint liberal Democrats with your chosen extremes says much more about you and your style of debate than it does about my side of the electorate. Your pet peeves don't represent me on Iraq, global climate change, Islam or illegal immigration.
CosmicConservative
fred: Um... "consequences" is a synonym for "ends." So when you say the morality of an act depends on the "consequences" that is synonymous with "ends justifies the means". Your latest straw man argument, comparing destroying property for "crass personal gain" vs. "throwing off the yoke of tyranny" is a bit broad, don't you think? I guess I would respond that it depends a lot on what your definition of "tyranny" is. My definition of "tyranny" might be a theocratic rule that does not allow me to speak freely or criticize the authorities. Osama Bin Laden's definition of "tyranny" might be a state which forces him to endure seeing the naked faces of women and see the religious symbols of other gods hanging from the necks of passers by. So your analogy is not sufficient. I need to know which tyranny you are referring to. Surely you realize that Osama Bin Laden considers himself to be "throwing off tyranny" right? Similarly, I would need to know who you were calling "freedom fighters" and what sort of weapons. Again, I have heard Democrats in elected office refer to Al Qada as "freedom fighters" so I'm not prepared to make a blanket statement on this. Tell me WHICH freedom fighters. Going on, I don't consider you to be capable of judging which national security leaks put lives at risk. I believe all of the leaks have put lives at risk for a variety of reasons. ONE reason is because it is now virtually impossible for us to work with other intelligence agencies because they are convinced the US can't keep a secret. That has real-world impact fred. It is precisely because it is virtually impossible to determine which "leaks" are "good leaks" and which are "bad leaks" that it is not legal to leak ANYTHING that has been declared classified. Tell me what you like fred, but the examples of "liberals behaving badly" are real examples, I didn't make them up. As a liberal I am sure that you don't judge your peers as harshly as I do. But show me the last time a group of college republicans rushed the stage to beat the shit out of Cindy Sheehan. I don't make this stuff up. You are on the side of those who quite literally beat their opposition into submission, you defend them.
CosmicConservative
fred... Did you know that both the House of Representatives and the Senate Intelligence committees have "whistle-blower" rules that allow any government employee to bring issues to their attention with guaranteed anonymity? I am fine with that process, I think that gives these "leakers" the legitimate, legal means to address their concerns. It isn't a difference between total ignorance and the front page of the NY Times. There are other options that are legal, ethical and effective. Why do you suppose these leakers have not gone to those committees?
fred
Before address some of the points you raised... You are saying that I defend thugs who beat the shit out of people trying to exercise their free speech?
CosmicConservative
I'm saying that once you start saying the ends justifies the means, beating the shit out of your opposition starts to look like an effective means to an end.
fred
No, you said "You are on the side of those who quite literally beat their opposition into submission, you defend them." You think I am in support of beating people into submission, that i defend them?
CosmicConservative
No, I was asking you to defend them, if you can. I think it's indefensible. But I also think it is the logical outcome of an environment where you have people like you arguing that the ends justifies the means. YOU probably wouldn't beat up someone to shut them up, but you have said you do support breaking the law to advance an ideological goal. Assault is just another law fred.
Drax
Fred: I get your stance from your words. Even in your denial of the stance, you continue to use the words, "judge the consequences of the act" which IS the "ends." As I said, I do not dismiss out of hand the notion that some ends justify just about any means, as certainly there are. In fact, there is a good argument to be made that just about all actions must be judged the ends against the means, weighing and measuring one against the other to arrive at an outcome which one can live with, comfortably or not. And, as I indicated, in THIS case, there is no real argument that knowing release of a lie in order to attempt to affect the political outcome of an election -- was an acceptable "ends." And, this is what Cosmic is alluding to. This person or persons who knowingly released this lie decided that the "end" in this case justified the means, setting himself/herself up as the final arbiter of what is "wrong" and "right," rather than allow the ballots to flow in the normal course of things--unpolluted by this particular lie. Most of the big questions, such as "Whether or not to invade Iraq," are such that those charged with answering that question must evaluate the "ends justifying the means" equation. That, of course, is what we pay THEM for. We do not, and should not, entrust this decision on unelected and unanswerable INDIVIDUALS who think they know the "right" answer. This is the road to anarchy. The person(s) who released this information took it upon HIMSELF to attempt to sway public opinion in the direction he desired, solely based on his own world view. He did this because it was becoming apparent that, unless he did something like this, the Republicans would retain control of Congress. (Much the same reason that those who knew about the Foley matter waited until the day it was no longer possible to put anyone else on the ballot to reveal what they knew and, in my opinion, the same reason that the MSM beat the story (such as it is...) to death) So, he decided that he would, through lies and deceit, to SUBSTITUTE his will for the will of the people.
CosmicConservative
Well, I guess the kitchen is getting a little hot now.
CosmicConservative
If you do come back, please address the issue I've raised about the environment your liberal leaders have created which leads to thugs attacking conservatives in college auditoriums. Believe me fred, they think they are doing "the right thing" because they've been told repeatedly, for years, how evil conservatives are. It is not unreasonable for them to conclude that such evil can be combatted by any means necessary, including beating the shit out of their opponents. Yes, fred, I do hold you and your peers accountable for this state of "debate". Every time liberals uttered "Bush lied and people died" or "if you oppose gay marriage, you are a homophobe" or any similar over-the-top rhetoric, you were moving the bar just a little bit further down the road, and now that bar is set where disagreement with the left is openly discussed as hate crimes, crimes against humanity, and illegtimate debate, and "liberal" thugs feel justified in kicking their opponents in the teeth to shut them up. These are the pigeons coming home to roost, fred. And I'm afraid its going to get worse before it gets better.