Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

CNN publishes videos of terrorist snipers killing US soldiers

By CosmicConservative
From their own story.
(CNN) -- Chilling scenes from a videotape made by insurgents show the work of snipers in Iraq, targeting and killing American troops, taking them down with a single bullet from a high-powered rifle. The graphic video of 10 sniper attacks was obtained by CNN -- through intermediaries -- from the Islamic Army of Iraq, one of the most active insurgent organizations in Iraq. In one scene, U.S. soldiers mingle among Iraqi civilians on a city street as a U.S. Humvee with a gunner in its turret stands guard nearby. From a distance, possibly hundreds of yards away, a sniper watches for his opportunity to strike as a fellow insurgent operates a camera to capture the video for propaganda purposes.
I added the emphasis. Looks like those "insurgents" know who their allies in the press are then, don't they? Gee, how did this manage to get to the American public two weeks before a critical election? I think I know what CNN means when they say they "believed this story had to be told." Indeed it did, just ask the terrorists. After all, those nasty Republicans just have to be defeated this year, don't they? Isn't this the same news organization that has steadfastly refused to air videos of 9/11 victims jumping to their deaths to escape the flames of the burning towers? Well, that's a story that needed NOT to be told, I guess.

Comments (14)

fred
Here now, what's all this then? Outrage over war footage used for propaganda purposes? And even greater outrage when it isn't? Personally I find it interesting in a chilling sort of way. And further into the story, Gunny Jack's analysis of the video oozes with respect for the sniper team. At the same time he makes it quite clear that he and his team are even better at shooting the enemy in the back from great distances. Although the video forces us to see our soldiers die, in the end we are left with the professional determination of one who knows and swears vengeance. I wouldn't say it's exactly a cut'n'run sort of message. But what propaganda will Fox put on the air in retaliation? The election may depend on it! Let me know because I don't have cable.
CosmicConservative
Fred: I am glad to see you are so cavalier about how CNN has become a propaganda arm of the enemy. Even if your snide allegations are correct, at least I am suggesting that if we are going to engage in propaganda, perhaps we ought to at least show BOTH sides. I am not even promoting the perfectly reasonable suggestion that we show OUR side, and NOT theirs. Glad to see you are so reasonable about how we represent our enemies. And so unconcerned about how we represent ourselves.
qwerty182764
I heard about a similar incident months ago on another blog. I was incredulous, and completely amazed that it wasn't being reported. CNN had embedded reporters with our enemies, were privy to hidden leaders and plans, and filmed them as they ambushed and shot our soldiers. CNN has committed treason. Period. There is no further room for interpretation. And as for liberals shrieking about our every publication targeting the Iraqi population is "propoganda", as if it is somehow wrong for us to present a decent image of ourselves or a moral defense for our actions, this is ridiculous. Why shouldn't we produce propoganda, if your definition of the term is so loose? "Gunny Jack’s analysis of the video oozes with respect for the sniper team. At the same time he makes it quite clear that he and his team are even better at shooting the enemy in the back from great distances. " As for the snipers, the morality of their actions has nothing whatsoever to do with how they fight, but what they fight for. We're fighting for a democracy, the enemy is fighting for a fascist state. Both the Germans and the US employed snipers in WWII. One set was fighting for an evil murderous cause, the other was not. This idea that we should fight "fair" (according to some chest-beating warrior code of formulaic ritual strategies that leaves us open and naked to the enemy's attack, for the sake of appeasing our guilt and convincing ourselves that we're holier) should have died with the medieval era. War isn't about rules, fairness, or how we conduct ourselves. When you engage in war, you've thrown the rulebook out the window. War happens when the ends are so conflicted and important, that any means are justified to achieve them (eliminating fascist enemies who would continue to murder us, preserving the union, ect).
CosmicConservative
Well said qwerty. I have one comment on the relative morality of reporters claiming some moral or ethical high-ground by saying "we are only observers." If a reporter knew that some lunatic was going to walk into a high school with a gun with the intent to molest and kill schoolgirls, would they claim that they had an obligation to simply "report" on the situation, or would they attempt to intervene? The moral question in our current conflict is no different. We fight for the side of freedom, personal liberty and tolerance. They fight for oppression, theocracy and bigotry. To put the two into moral equivalence is despicable. But CNN goes beyond that. They present the progaganda of the enemy as "we need to know" under the supposed premise that "we need to understand why the enemy is fighting" but they refuse to show videos that clearly help us to understand why WE are fighting. We are fighting to stop innocent men, women and children from having to choose between leaping off of an 80th floor window into certain death, or retreating into a burning inferno into certain death. That's reality. That's history. That's why we are fighting. Yet CNN will not show you that side. But they are quite happy to show the enemy killing our soldiers in cold blood and stating a moral equivalence between their snipers and our snipers. It is difficult to draw any positive conclusions from the situation. Something is deeply wrong with our society when this sort of reporting is considered "normal."
fred
Treason. Period. No further room for interpretation. Right. Whether the insurgent sniper team in the video is pursuing a political ideology that combines elements of corporatism, authoritarianism, nationalism, militarism, anti-anarchism, anti-communism and anti-liberalism (i.e. fascism) or not... ...I think that the CNN story serves our own propaganda purpose as much as the enemy's insofar as Gunny Jack's perspective is inspirational to our side, no? Doesn't the death of our soldiers make you want to get right in there and fight back even harder? Was CNN a propaganda arm of the enemy when it heartbreakingly reported on 9/11? (Cosmo claims CNN refused to show victims jumping to their deaths: forgive me if I take Cosmo's reportage with a pinch of salt.) Was CNN a propaganda arm of the enemy when it breathlessly trumpeted "Shock and Awe"? It is amusing that some conservatives like to take such a simple view of CNN, which I suspect is a beast with many arms. When you engage in war, you’ve thrown the rulebook out the window. Right.
CosmicConservative
So Fred, you are on record saying that the U.S. is no better than the theocratic goals of the terrorists then. At least we know where you stand. I think you and I both know that CNN's purpose in airing this is to reinforce the Cindy Sheehan side of things. "Look how our soldiers are being killed for no reason!" CNN has refused to air the video of the people jumping out of broken windows. Repeatedly. Nothing is absolute Fred. Because CNN has aired some pro-US propaganda does not mean it does not show anti-US propaganda. The question is which side does their bias support. I contend that they are biased against the U.S. position and that they are more willing to show propaganda that undermines our goals than to show propaganda that supports it. I point it out when I see it. I don't claim to be infallible. If you want to see the other side, spend more time on Daily KOS. This is "Cosmic Conservative" Fred. CNN may be a beast with many arms. Let's say it has 100. My contention is that 50 of them are not engaged in this issue, 35 of them are on the side of the enemy and 15 are on the side of the U.S. That's my perspective. I take the opportunity on my blog to point out when I can document things that support my contention. That's what I do here. Your sniping and apologia for the left is welcome here, I have not done anything to shut you down and I and my regular readers have done our best to engage you in rational discourse. But here the issue is clear. CNN has a compelling "need" to show videos of our soldiers being killed by snipers even when those videos are labeled "propaganda efforts" by our enemies. But they will not show videos that demonstrate why our soldiers are over there. I contend that is proof of bias. I think I made the point well and clearly. I can't be held responsible for how you perceive things. I am only responsible for how I present them. I notice you completely avoided my question about a school shooter. Wanna take a crack at that one?
fred
You claim I am "on record saying that the U.S. is no better than the theocratic goals of the terrorists then." I reject that unfounded statement and seriously doubt your perspective on CNN and the media in general. If the purpose of CNN's story was to echo Cindy Sheehan then why did they include Gunny Jack? Did you watch the video with his commentary? What do you think of Gunny Jack's comments and inclusion in this story? Yes, if a local news reporter had known what Duane Morrison was going to do and failed to intervene so as to get a scoop on the aftermath, then I think that reporter should be charged with criminal negligence, aiding and abetting. What does that have to do with this story of CNN's receipt of a video they decided to post? What does that have to do with Gunny Jack's analysis and determination?
CosmicConservative
The media's general "we only observe" "ethic" as stated by Mike Wallace was that a reporter has a duty to report, not to intervene, and if that meant that US soldiers were walking into an ambush he knew about, he would be ethically obligated to not tell the US soldiers and allow them to be killed. That's the relevence Fred. This is more of that same mentality that somehow reporters have no moral obligation to 'take sides'. I reject that notion. But beyond that, as I said before, I believe that the discrepancy between CNN's willingness to show this video and their unwillingness to show the dying innocent US citizens on 9/11 reveals that they are NOT following even Mike Wallace's despicable notion that reporters "take no sides" but this goes beyond that and is quite literally providing "aid and comfort" to the enemy. That's my contention Fred, and I have repeatedly stated it. You can call it jingoistic, ignorant, or whatever you like. I try not to characterize your opinons so negatively, but that is fine if that is what you believe. I believe otherwise. I believe that CNN is unconscionably providing aid and comfort to the enemy. Would I prosecute them for this? Probably not, but I reserve the right to comment on it. If you truly cannot see that this video is clearly propaganda for the enemy, then you are more ignorant than the enemy themselves, who have already admitted that this is their propaganda.
fred
You try not to characterize my opinions so negatively? But you claim I am “ON RECORD saying that the U.S. is no better than the theocratic goals of the terrorists?" Tell me, do you see a problem there at all? Again, if the purpose of CNN’s story was to echo Cindy Sheehan then why did they include Gunny Jack? Did you watch the video with his commentary? What do you think of Gunny Jack’s comments and inclusion in this story? If you want to take the focus away from the story you posted and say it's simply an example of something larger, can't we at least take a close look at the example first?
CosmicConservative
Fred: Your comment:
Whether the insurgent sniper team in the video is pursuing a political ideology that combines elements of corporatism, authoritarianism, nationalism, militarism, anti-anarchism, anti-communism and anti-liberalism (i.e. fascism) or not…
.. reads to me as classic moral equivalence. I read that as implying that the snipers on both sides are pursuing essentially the same sort of goals, just differently applied. If that wasn't your intention, perhaps you can clarify what you meant by that. Fred, why does the ACLU sometimes take cases from the right? Because that gives them plausible deniability. That's the same technique as CNN uses. CBS just ran a story on the CBS evening news where they interviewed several people who claimed that lower gas prices were due to some GW Bush conspiracy to improve Republican election results. After interviewing several people who said they believed this was so, they interviewed one person who said "that's preposterous" from the right. This is fairly typical of the mainstream media. A talk show panel will have three liberals and one conservative. Etc. etc. etc... For the fourth time, I think I stated the issue clearly and provided the relevant example to state my case. You disagree. Fine, as always, I leave it to the reader to draw their own conclusions.
fred
I think the ACLU lawyers sometimes take cases from the right because they are interested in protecting civil liberties. Conservatives get their rights trampled too. There is no central authority within the ACLU which directs individual lawyers and tells them which cases to take. Defending NAMBLA and the KKK were not decisions made by the ACLU Central Committee. Why? Because there is no Central Committee. My comment, "Whether the insurgent sniper team in the video is pursuing a political ideology that combines elements of corporatism, authoritarianism, nationalism, militarism, anti-anarchism, anti-communism and anti-liberalism (i.e. fascism) or not…" was directed to qwerty who defined the insurgents as fascists. Poor use of the term "fascist", in my opinion. I was merely including a definition in that part of the remark. The rest od it, "…I think that the CNN story serves our own propaganda purpose as much as the enemy’s insofar as Gunny Jack’s perspective is inspirational to our side, no? Doesn’t the death of our soldiers make you want to get right in there and fight back even harder?" Personally, I read the inclusion of Gunny Jack, his analysis and video voice-over to be exactly that: inspirational. For the last time, For the final time, if the purpose of CNN’s story was to echo Cindy Sheehan then why did they include Gunny Jack? Did you watch the video with his commentary? What do you think of Gunny Jack’s comments and inclusion in this story? If you refuse to address these questions then I will let the reader draw his own conclusion.
CosmicConservative
I have already stated that the inclusion of Gunny Jack's perspective and commentary was done to provide an appearance of balance, just as CBS included the single "that's preposterous" statement for the same reason. To deflect criticism of overt bias. And it is working for that purpose as you so clearly demonstrate. That's my opinion Fred. I have formed that opinion from numerous examples of bias from CNN, CBS and other major media outlets. You have a different opinion. That's what makes this country great. You and I can disagree and neither of us has to be looking over our shoulder for the thought-police to come and drag us to the stoning. As far as Gunny Jack's actual commentary, I don't know what was edited out but what was left in was pretty coldly analytical and mostly a discussion of tactics and effectiveness. Quite frankly I couldn't think of a more effective way to suggest moral equivalence than the final comment of his they ended with. "The worst enemy of a sniper is another sniper." Overall I would call this a skillfully produced piece of propaganda that not only shows Americans being killed, but suggests that it's all just part of a mutually clinical set of military tactics. As far as being an effective bit of political propaganda, I give it four stars, two to the original terrorists who filmed it, and two more for the CNN moral equivalence reinforcement, speaking through a U.S. military sniper to make the point as clear as possible.
Ron
Someone Earlier compared the current battle earlier to World War II citing that the United States is fighting facism today, and that the Evil Germans had snipers, and so did we. Well The U.S. Had Probably as much Propaganda as the Third Reich did in the 40's. I'm sure there were combat films on both sides trying to give themselves an upper hand. This is certainly the case today, although I will be the first to say that the U.S. is much less "shielded" about the current status of the war due to news compainies like CNN. Someone also compared this video to footage of people jumping from the world trade center. This is not a fair comparison due to the fact that this footage takes place in an area that could be considered a battlefield. Watching a innocent victim leap from a high rise building is a bit different from watching soldiers in combat. Yes, its just as tragic, and I grieve for ever soldier lost in this war, however, every U.S. citizen should have an accurate depiction of whats happening in our war, and Propaganda or not, This shocking video is an account of what our soldiers have to go through on an everyday basis.
CosmicConservative
Ron: I don't buy either of your arguments. Propaganda is just a tool, and like all tools it can be used to server noble or base purposes. The question isn't whether both sides use propaganda, the question is what each side is fighting for. Secondly, the unwillingness to show victims leaping to their deaths from the WTC was justified by saying that the images were "too disturbing" and that it might cause emotional harm to some of the victims families. I guess we don't care about the families of military folks.