Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Privilege and Opportunity

By CosmicConservative
So, Madonna has adopted a Malawi "orphan" whose father is alive and well and farming his crops. I'm trying to figure out which I find more appalling, Madonna's actions in window-shopping a Malawi orphanage to find some child she can turn into a fund-raising tool for her Malawi project... Or the child's father, whose response to criticism was basically "shut up, I can't be bothered with raising the child, and look at the gig he's getting!" I did notice that the child arrived in London with a nanny, not with his "new mother." I think that he will see a lot of nannies as he ages. Not sure how much of Madonna he'll see though, but you know, she has a career and all that. And unlike the child's father, she can afford a nanny to handle those annoying child-rearing details like bringing a confused and terrified child across two continents into a strange household.

Comments (4)

Drax
As much as I detest Madonna and cannot put myself in the shoes of this dirt-poor farmer, I can only ask myself: If I could ill afford to raise my child, and, once raised the child would likely have little or no chance of being better off than I am, and a very rich person said that they would give my child a life of luxury and love....what the hell would I do? At this point, would keeping the child be selfish? The child won't "miss" me, won't know me. All the child will know is life of privilege and riches, and, hopefully have a good life? Dunno what I would do in a similar situation. (Throw in a couple of bucks to help raise my OTHER kids....and ....)
Brian
I've seen 3rd world poverty. Only for a month or so and in Asia not Africa ... but still. I'd rather grow up rich and privleged in the West than dirt poor in Malawi.
Drax
Yah. I've been to some of the cesspools of this world and seen some things that make me VERY happy to be an American.
CosmicConservative
I guess I can intellectually see that you could make a case that giving up a child in this situation could be described as a selfless act. I would find that characterization of the father more plausible had he not dumped the kid into a destitute orphanage in the first place. Based on the quality of life the child was experiencing in the orphanage, it doesn't seem like the father's initial goal was to make a better life for the child, when the mother died, he just dumped the kid on the orphanage. Or that's what the story seems to imply. I guess in that sense having the child reared by the nannies of a rich American celebrity is a step up and should be recognized as a step forward. Still, I can't help but think that there is another child in the orphanage worse off than the one Madonna picked, one without a father or mother perhaps.