Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Peyton Manning vs Tom Brady

By CosmicConservative
Perhaps the single most common debate in the NFL, if not in all of sports, right now is whether Tom Brady or Peyton Manning is the greatest QB of their generation. Rarely have two such clearly superior athletes had careers that overlapped so long, and developed so drastically differently. image People who read this blog know that I am a Tom Brady fan. I acknowledge that Peyton Manning will likely retire with every single regular season passing record of any importance, and will be a total lock first ballot hall of famer. I also recognize that Peyton has demonstrated some of his best performances after being ignominiously dumped by the Indianapolis Colts in favor of the latest wunderkind, Andrew Luck, and I definitely get some satisfaction out of watching Indianapolis suffer Luck's growing pains while Peyton has simply transformed the Broncos from a mediocre team to an AFC powerhouse. So it's not as if I feel that Peyton Manning is a bum. Quite the opposite, Manning is perhaps the single best game manager and precision passer to have every suited up. So if that's true, how can I prefer Brady over Manning? The answer to that question can simply be found in two striking sets of statistics. In games where the two have gone head-to-head, Brady has won 10 while Peyton has won 4. In the post season Brady has 3 SB rings and one of the best playoff records in history while Peyton doesn't even have a winning record. This is beyond "Brady has 3 rings and Peyton only has 1." This is more "in big games, in bad weather, against good teams, with the season on the line, Brady is just head and shoulders better than Peyton Manning." And that's what I want in my QB. Win the big games in difficult circumstances no matter the weather. I think last night's game will probably cement the notion that Peyton Manning is the greatest indoor, good weather QB ever, but if you have to play a game in the cold, rain, snow or wind.... you better be able to run the ball.

Comments (17)

Drax
I'm not a Brady fan. However, I recognize that he is one of the Great Ones. However, unlike many of the talking heads (and you), I also recognize that Brady and Manning have NEVER gone "head to head." Brady (and the other TEN people on his offense, selected without his help by the GM and trained without his help by the coaching staff, using plays which he didn't design and, for the greatest part, doesn't call) plays against the DEFENSE of the team which Manning is on. Likewise Manning vs. Brady. New England was already on the rise when Brady took over. It had a good offense, a good defense, a good coach, and was (as time has established) a well-run organization. The Colts, when Manning took over was a perennial basement dweller. When Brady got hurt and sat out a season, the Patriots didn't lose a step. When Manning got hurt and sat out a season, the Colts went in the crapper. In the playoffs, Manning (until recently) hasn't done well. I believe that the reason for this is simple: For the most part, Manning WAS the offense and the Colts didn't have a decent defense. On the other hand, Brady, while the most important cog in the offense wasn't the offense - the SCHEME was the offense (as Cassel showed us). Without question, Brady ran that offense as only an all-time great QB can, but the offense was potent with ANY competent QB. And, in ALL the SB years, the Patriots had a top rated defense. For the most part, Brady had to do "just enough" to win (2 by field goals and several playoff games won by a field goal). So, I (as always) just look at what the two of them do which they have actual CONTROL over, i.e., how well they throw the ball. And, when it comes to that, it's Manning hands down. I will NEVER subscribe to the notion that, in a team game - ESPECIALLY one in which the player is only part of a THIRD of the team and has NO control over what the other 2/3rds DO - compare what a TEAM does to another TEAM when what is being compared is wha INDIVIDUALS do. Or, we could say that Bradshaw with 1 or 2 more touchdowns than interceptions for his CAREER is the best QB of all time. If we count championships, then how can we leave him out of the conversation? Who cares that he had somewhere along the lines of TEN Hall of Famers on those teams? (Manning will have - maybe - one on the Colts, Brady, perhaps four or five). Yeah, yeah, I know. Even though you can't defend comparing rings (or team performance) rather than individual performance when comparing individuals rather than teams, you'll continue to do so. It's the convention.
CosmicConservative
Heh, I agree that we'll never agree Drax. It's not Brady's fault he has a better coach than Manning had. Peyton and the Colts had one good year, Brady and the Patriots have been the dominant team of the past decade. I think there is great irony in the fact that the closest thing to a nemesis Brady has is Peyton's little brother. Do you consider the possibility that Peyton's impact on his team's inability to perform when he isn't behind center might have a lot to do with his absolute need to be the center of the offense? It is now considered a certainty that the Broncos would be a mediocre team without Peyton Manning. Every game they win is a Peyton win. Every loss is because Peyton didn't come to play. I suppose Peyton thrives on that sense of complete and utter responsibility. I personally think it creates a self-destructive atmosphere for the team if Peyton isn't behind center. Peyton has, through sheer force of will, created a situation in Denver where the backup QB cannot possibly succeed because the entire offense is based on Peyton's singular ability to read and react to defenses. That's exactly what happened with the Colts. Without Peyton the team is lost, because that's how Peyton defined the team. I actually hold him accountable for that, you give him kudos.
Drax
Well, Denver did a lot better with Manning than with Tebow and is likely Superbowl bound (would have gone there last year had the DEFENSE not let him down). I disagree that he by his "force of will" has made Denver's offense "dependent" on his singular skills. Rather, I suggest that his coaching staff RECOGNIZES that skill and EXPLOITS it. Just as they do in Green Bay. And New Orleans. And Seattle. And, for that matter, every other team where there IS a QB with "singular skills." The other teams can "plug and play" and hope that their QB doesn't LOSE games. The elite teams have offensive schemes which exploit their players' "singular skills." And, yes. Whoever comes after Manning will be a lesser QB than Manning. Just like those who followed all the great QB's, at least until THEY develop the skills to become one of the great ones themselves. And THAT is accomplished when the coaching staff is able to either find someone who fits perfectly with their scheme or develop a scheme which perfectly mirrors a QB of "singular skill." I take nothing away from Brady. We see what he can do when he HAS an elite receiver, i.e., sets the TD record. But, Billacheat doesn't invest that way. If he can get a Dillon for cheap or a Moss, then he rolls the dice. Sometimes he wins; sometimes he gets a Chad Ocho Cinco. No, he invests in his QB and his defense. He lets Welker go instead of paying him - and plugs in another just like him. All I'm saying is that when the two are compared as to their SKILL at the position, Manning is a superior QB. It's impossible to actually compare them with regard to the RESULT of their exercise of that skill because there simply is no comparison. They have different defenses, special teams, and offenses. Different coaches. Play different teams. In fact, other than their ability to read defenses and make adjustments and throw the ball - there is nothing to compare them TO. We USED to recognize this. For the longest time, Marino was considered the greatest QB of all time. It wasn't until the end of Marino's career that Montana was really considered the GOAT and Elway wasn't even in the conversation. It was only after Elway won 2 Super Bowls - CLEARLY due to, in greatest part, the effect of a Hall of Fame level running game - that Elway became considered to be in that conversation. And, to be fair, those two years in which he won those rings were mediocre at BEST and shouldn't have had any effect on how he is viewed historically. (He's got great numbers, but isn't even in my top TEN of all time QB's.) I still have Marino as my #1. No one could throw a ball as he could. Dunno who my #2 is. The rest pretty much come in a clump: Montana, Elway, Favre, Manning, Brady, Unitas, Starr, a few others. I look at Montana and recognize that he had the benefit of one of the few coaches who actually changed the game, along with a pretty good stable of Hall of Fame (and near HOF) players. Elway never got any help. Dunno if he EVER had a HOF player on his team. (TD would have been had he not got injured, I think.) Really can't compare pre-free agency QB's to modern day QB's (let alone doing so with the different rules.) But, Manning and Brady are contemporaries, playing with the same rule set. And, if he wins his FIFTH MVP this year (which is likely) - which is two more than anyone else, how can we say that any other QB is better? How many has Brady won? Zero? But, at least it's a legitimate argument - these two. Comparing QB's from different eras really isn't. But, I'd take Marino 1st pick every time if I'm looking for a pure pocket passer. Every time.
CosmicConservative
I'm not going to argue against Marino. I pretty much agree with you on that one. However, as you know, I am a Montana fan and I do consider Montana and Brady to be very comparable. I think Favre was a loose cannon who relied as much on luck as skill. And that hurt him. Although I admit that I am inconsistent in this regard because I look at Favre and the closest QB I can think of to Favre is Romo, and I find myself rooting for Romo when I rooted against Favre. Is my Cowboy fandom that strong? Apparently it is. If you were to line up Brady and Peyton and put them through QB drills, I agree Peyton would make Brady look pedestrian. Unless it was outside. In the wind. Raining. Or snowing. And a big game was on the line. Then I'd take Brady. :)
Drax
Heh. You really have to look at the numbers on Favre. You don't win THREE MVP's by being a "loose cannon." You don't own every QB record by being a loose cannon. In every statistical category of any significance, he is heads and tails above all but a few HOF QB's, INCLUDING TD/INT ratio and INT/ATT ratio. In other words, he didn't throw as many interceptions as he is perceived to have thrown RELATIVE to the number of ATTEMPTS. Of course, he made some high-profile attempts which were intercepted. But, what QB hasn't who's actually been in that position? And, by "that position" I mean, a high-profile game where the game was on the line and he either made a play or they lost. Oh, yeah. Manning. Montana. Elway. Warner. On the other hand, sometimes they MAKE those throws. To say that "luck" had ANYTHING to do with Favre's awe inspiring numbers is really pathetic "Favre hate." He was one of the best QB's in the history of the game. And, that ain't "luck." Manning has done well in playoff games in the latter part of his career - in bad weather, on the road, whatever. You want talk about a Manning and "luck," then you really gotta talk about Eli.
CosmicConservative
Heh, I did mention Eli and how ironic it is that he has two of Brady's rings. Including the 16-0 ring. Whatever arguments you want to make, I'd still take Brady over Manning, especially outdoors, in the wind, rain, snow and nuclear holocaust. I'd probably go for Manning for the zombie apocalypse though.
CosmicConservative
By the way, they had a huge debate on the Manning vs Brady subject on ESPN radio a few weeks ago. The expert analysts were split on overall "greatness" but there was almost unanimous agreement that Brady was the better mudder.
Drax
I'd have to look at the actual statistics. But, Manning's doing okay in Denver in the weather. He only had a decent running game combined with a decent defense while with the Colts for a couple of years and won the SB one of those years. In Denver, he has a pretty good defense and a solid running game. (Brady's running game has always been those line of scrimmage "passes" which, for reasons known only to the coordinators, Manning hasn't ever really incorporated into his game.) Brady is a better passer, I think. Marginally. Tighter spiral. Maybe even a stronger arm. But, Manning can read a defense better. Billacheat can read his half-time "scouting reports" better and Brady, who FREQUENTLY has horrible first halves, becomes awesome in the second half. I'd take either one. It's pretty much of a coin-flip. Manning's career isn't over. I think Brady won't win another one. (As I have said since Spy Gate. Moss almost made a liar out of me.) I think Manning might run off two in a row like Elway.
CosmicConservative
It's a common misconception that Denver has bad weather in football season. Actually that's not true. As far as I can remember Peyton's only played one game in tough weather conditions in Denver and that was the Baltimore playoff loss last year. And that wasn't even that bad, just a little cold and windy. Generally speaking Denver might get a blast of snow and cold but it usually only lasts a few days and we're back in the 40s and 50s, even in late December or January. This week and next is a major exception. I don't remember the last time we had ten days in a row below freezing. Long long time. I will tell you that in Denver, which is 100% Peyton country, even Peyton fanatics dread bad weather days. In fact that's pretty much all the radio shows are talking about right now, temperatures for this Sunday's game are expected to be well below freezing and there may be snow. Denver is more or less panicked about it. I heard fans on the callin show today asking if we should start our backup QB. Seriously. My take on Peyton's throwing right now is that he's not able to power the ball with a tight spiral through a crosswind. Just can't do it. The ball flutters and sails when he tries. The last time he was in that situation, in the Patriots loss, he was throwing almost nothing longer than 15 yards. If I had to compare the game management of Brady and Manning I'd say that Manning is better at reading defenses and reacting to blitzes, but not by much, and Brady is better at checking down to his third or fourth option, but not by much. My main reason I rate Brady higher is I honestly think he's got more killer instinct and a bigger chip on his shoulder. Even now.
Drax
I really, really, really try not to compare such intangibles as "killer instinct" and whatnot. Impossible to quantify. Circumstances frequently are significantly different for each player such that one has the more opportunity to exhibit such intangibles as does another. (For me, the classic example of people trying to get into the heads of a player are the LeBron haters who opined over and over how he didn't have a "killer instinct" as did Jordan or wasn't a "closer" as is Kobe. I'm sorry. You don't GET to that level - even as a role player - without having those attributes. LeBron simply has a different play STYLE than do those players and would rather make the best BASKETBALL decision at a given time than simply jack up a shot and shrug - whether or not it goes in. In other words, he's a better basketball player - a better team player - than EITHER of those because HE DOESN'T CARE WHO GETS THE CREDIT, he just wants to try to give his TEAM the best opportunity to win by putting the ball into the hands of the person who has the highest percentage shot at any given time - even if it's the last shot of the game - and even if it isn't him.) The Baltimore game in the playoffs Payton played quite well. It wasn't his fault that his defense did the ONE THING they couldn't do at that stage of the game and let a WR get behind them. He certainly did enough to win the game. But, I tend to agree with your assessment of his arm strength, but the reality is that very, very few QB's HAVE that arm strength. Brady sure doesn't. But, Brady has always had Welker to dump it off for a 5 yard pass across the middle, tight ends he could dump it off to, and a decent running game. For the most part, Manning (as a Colt) had two burners and a competent tight end. No one who made his living going across the middle as does Welker. (For example, this year, Welker is 3rd in receiving yards on Denver (28th in the league), but is 1st in receptions (12th in the league.)) I believe that the "can't play in adverse conditions" charge against Manning is overstated. He throws the ball a LOT (moreso while a Colt) Currently 3rd in the league. But, he throws the ball, generally, deeper than does Brady (Close to 2 yards more per pass - basically, Manning throws the ball once more a game, but gets almost 70 yards more per game (currently 1st in the league in YPG by a wide margin). The more you throw, the deeper you throw, the more likely it is that you'll make an errant throw. (Although, Manning only has 1 more interception than Brady while more than double his TD's (41 to 19). This is pretty much the story of their two careers (with the exception of the Moss years). Manning throws more, throws deeper, gets a lot more TD's and a few more Interceptions. They have different play styles under different coaching schemes. (It's kinda like the Favre thing. You, as a coach, have someone with a cannon for an arm, the ability to make every throw, is utterly fearless - what, you're going to go all short-pass Brady with your play calling? No, you'll have some high risk/high reward packages. And, with Favre, the reward HEAVILY outweighed the risk as it got the coaches winning season after winning season, deep into the playoffs, a Super Bowl - and job security...)
CosmicConservative
There are other considerations to take into account. Brady plays in the most weather adverse division in the NFL. He plays in Buffalo at least once every year, in New Jersey at least once every year and in Boston at least 8 times a year. That's ten games in outdoor stadiums in generally the worst weather outside of maybe Seattle, which plays indoors. That, I believe, has a lot to do with Brady's and Belicheck's game tactics. I've seen a lot of those games, many of them are frigid, icy, snowy, miserable conditions. That HAS to impact the passing game. The fact that Brady is one throw fewer and 70 yards less per game than Peyton is actually pretty impressive to me considering the relative conditions the two play in. And have played in their entire careers. I also think that factors into the "Peyton throws more long passes" situation too. The Patriots play a ball control game and build their team around ball control and defense. Peyton has always played on teams that are focused on offense and passing. I think that's as big a reason as any that the Patriots have a much better playoff and Super Bowl record than Peyton's teams. That's the style of playing that wins Super Bowls, and is, I think, also the reason that Favre only won one and played in two. All of this factors in. And as far as killer instinct is concerned, or other intangibles, I believe I am an excellent reader of body language and mood. Here is what I see between Peyton and Brady. Peyton is generally an excellent on-field commander. He is demanding and specific with his offense. He exudes confidence most of the time and his offense rallies around him. He almost NEVER interacts with his defense. When it is cold, he hunches up with his hands in his hand warmer and paces moodily on the sidelines. Brady is also an excellent on-field commander. He is demanding and specific with his offense. He does not exude confidence in the same way that Peyton does, instead he exudes a sort of determination that sometimes intimidates his own players. Where Peyton is calm and patient with his offensive teammates, Brady is fiery and critical. Brady interacts frequently with his defense. Brady almost never stands around isolated and hunched over no matter the weather conditions. He is always moving around the sidelines and seems to never shut up between series. Both of them are great leaders. But I give Brady the edge because he engages the entire team, his energy and fire is infectious and he seems oblivious to the elements. This weekend's game will be one to watch I think. If Peyton closes up and shivers on the sideline like he did in the Baltimore game last year, I think the team will react to that. His body language in bad weather is atrocious. He just looks like he doesn't want to be on the field. That is infectious too. He has to consciously force himself to act as if the cold doesn't bother him. It is in part because he has become the entire focus of the Broncos that his body language is so important. I know you probably think this is not a big deal, but I totally disagree. This stuff matters a lot, and it matters a lot more when the situation gets more difficult and meaningful.
Drax
Everything you said about the offensive scheme translates into: "Brady is a good game manager." Not that this is a bad thing, but, it is also supportive of my assertion that it is the scheme as much as the QB which translates into offensive success. I believe that, with the same team/coaching staff, just about any 2nd tier QB could get Brady just as far - or nearly as far - as they've gotten every year since Bellacheat got caught. We cannot simply discard from historical consideration their lack of Superbowl success since Spy Gate. On the other hand, we KNOW just how far a 2nd tier QB got the Colts and have a pretty good comparison as to what Manning would do on a team he takes over which had a 2nd tier (or worse) QB. We don't have that on Brady and never will. I try to look not only at what a QB has done relative to his contemporaries, but what he has done relative to himself under varying circumstances where possible. How did Brady do before/after Moss? Before/after Dillon? Before/after he loses the two potential HOF defense players (Brewski/McGuinnes) Before/after Welker? With/without the Gronk? We SEE, with Brady, HUGE swings in performance when he has these high octane players. On the other hand, with Manning, what we SEE is the opposite. HE continues to rack up HUGE numbers (and wins) while making players like Eric Decker Pro Bowl players. Brady loses the Gronk and the Patriots go on a losing streak until he comes back. (And Brady has his worst year.) Brady gets Moss and has an historically great year. And, I'm not as much of a believer in that whole "leadership" thing as quantified by such things as "intensity," or "body language" or whatnot. These are pros. They want someone who can help them WIN and, for the most part, could care less whether or not their QB is a "silent leader" (Aikman) or whatever. They get paid to play and to win. I can pretty much guarantee you that, unlike Aaron Rodgers, you won't be hearing anyone from the Colts or, later, from the Broncos, EVERY say anything negative about Peyton's negative "body language," or his isolating himself on the bench. (Which I generally don't see as you do. He sometimes does get warm - but mostly I see him studying photos with his receivers and offensive line during the times he isn't on the field.) Ah, well, back and forth.
CosmicConservative
Perhaps... I don't see it quite like you do. I saw Peyton struggle for the first four games last year before he finally started clicking with some receivers that were previously considered either very good (Erick Decker) or a likely pro-bowl prospect (Demarius Thomas). It seems Peyton has gotten a whole lot better since they added Wes Walker too. What did Brady have to work with? A bunch of unknown rookies that weren't even considered prospects. And what has he done with them? He's made Edelman look like Welker and he's steadily making those no-name rookies look better and better. I remember at the start of the season all the "experts" were predicting that New England probably wouldn't even have a winning season, much less make the playoffs, much much less, win the AFC East and have a playoff bye. And if Denver stumbles this weekend, well, we'll see. I personally think Brady is actually proving exactly what I am saying about his leadership this year. Just as Peyton proved what both of us say about Peyton last year. Both of them are elevating teams with less talent at other positions. You bother to count how many drops Brady's receivers have had this year? New England struggled early, but still managed to win several close games. They are now jelling as a solid playoff contender. If I were John Elway, the one thing I would not want to do is travel to New England for the AFC championship game. And I bet that's exactly what he's telling his team. Really, the main difference I see between the two of them remains what I pointed out in my original post. Brady owns one of the best playoff records in NFL history, and is renowned for his bad weather play. Peyton has a losing playoff record and whether you think it is warranted or not, it has become pretty common to hear even Denver fans question Peyton's bad weather and big game performance. Let's see what happens this week and this season. Let's have this conversation again in February.
CosmicConservative
Oh, one last thing. I totally agree with you that Peyton at his best is better than Brady at his best, and by a significant margin. But Peyton has too many times been at his worst when it matters most, and that is when Brady has usually been at his best. And that's why I would rather have Brady in the long run.
CosmicConservative
Sigh, I guess I should have hedged with a "as long as Gronk stays healthy".
Drax
Yeah, and Peyton seemed to be really bothered by the cold...
CosmicConservative
Heh, yep, I'll give you that. Today Peyton looked sharp. In fact I'd say that he was better than his stats, and his stats are pretty stellar. He had at least three or four balls dropped that hit his receivers right in his hands. He was throwing a pretty tight spiral too, the times I made a point to check. So, yeah, for today I'd say he beat back the demons.