Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Teaching a new generation of Lefties

By CosmicConservative
Teenage girl questioned by Secret Service for her "Kill Bush" Myspace page. Gee I wonder what her parents say about Bush at the dinner table?
On Friday, the teenager said the agents' questioning led her to tears. "I wasn't dangerous. I mean, look at what's (stenciled) on my backpack - it's a heart. I'm a very peace-loving person," said Wilson, an honor student who describes herself as politically passionate. "I'm against the war in Iraq. I'm not going to kill the president."
This is so typical. So tired. So lame. "OK, so I put a web page on the internet that said "Kill Bush!" drew knives stabbing him and typed hate-filled rants about how evil and horrible he is, but look at the heart on my backpack! Can't you tell I'm a sweetheart? How could you do this to poor, sweet little innocent me?" Her training is proceeding well. Next will be the lawsuit against the Secret Service.

Comments (30)

fred
There was no harmony around the dinner table back in the day when I was bad-mouthing LBJ and Nixon over Vietnam. So I wouldn't assume this girl is a clone of her parents. The knee-jerk mindset known as BDS (a coldly analytical term coined by which wingnut talkshow host?) is not entirely disconnected from reality. Sure, you have the juvenile manifestation which is nearly incapable of coherent rationalization. But there is also BDS based on the fact that an unpopular candidate was put into office by a court ruling and based on the fact that this president sold us a bill of goods and launched a war he doesn't know how to fight.
CosmicConservative
Fred: Please tell me you don't subscribe to the BS that Bush was "appointed" into office. You do realize that there were two SCOTUS rulings that applied to Bush v. Gore, right? One, a very narrow ruling about the need to recount the entire vote, was 5-4. The other, a more broad ruling about the need to protect votes from inconsistent counting means, was 7-2. Both were in Bush's favor. EITHER would have stopped the recounting and ended the fight in Florida. Now, please show me the official count of votes in Florida that showed Gore receiving more than Bush. I am so sick you you Lefties pretending that the Florida election was somehow "stolen" from Gore. The ONLY verified votes that should have been counted that were not counted were military votes that Gore attorneys got thrown out on technicalities, such as votes from the USS Cole that were not postmarked. So much for "count every vote", eh Fred?
fred
I didn't say it was stolen, unfair, or anything other than according to Hoyle. What I said was "an unpopular candidate was put into office by a court ruling." I accepted it the day it hapened because I realize "my" candidate may someday win by the same means. Also said "this president sold us a bill of goods and launched a war he doesn’t know how to fight." These, and other items account for a somewhat rational basis for BDS... some of which may or may not have filtered down to the unfortunate eigth-grader you seem to be so upset about.
CosmicConservative
Fred: Spin your comments however you like. Saying he was put into office by a court ruling implies that he did not win fairly. Actually "implies" may be far too weak a word for how strongly you are insinuating that he stole the election. Bush may be unpopular now, but he has had highs and lows, just like most Presidents. His highs have been higher than most and his lows have been lower than most. But that just means that things have been volatile. You may have "bought a bill of goods" Fred and been "sold" to by someone, but I made my own choices based on my own knowledge of what is going on in the world, and I don't feel like anyone "sold" or had to "sell" me anything. This is becoming one of the Democrat's key talking points, that somehow they were "sold a bill of goods" on the Iraq war they voted for. If you like that particular fantasy, there are lots more out there. If anything the rhetoric from the likes of Hillary Clinton and John Kerry about the need to depose Saddam was more extreme than Bush's own rhetoric. Yes, they now sing a different tune, but that only shows how feckless they are, not how wise. You can't have it both ways Fred. Either your Democrat leadership is stupid enough to have been fooled by Chimpy McHitler, the Moron-In-Chief, or else they voted for war in Iraq with the full knowledge of the consequences and have only changed their tune because they see it is now unppopular. There is a word for that Fred, the word is "feckless." Because I post on something doesn't mean I am "upset" about it Fred. Emoting in public is more of the stock-in-trade of the Left. I bring it up because I think it illustrates a point. It definitely illustrates the point of the hypocrisy of the Left ("I can say 'kill Bush' and draw pictures of knives and rant and rave about him, but I'm really such a sweet, innocent child.") This attitude is not just found in 14 year olds, although that is about the emotional level that you would expect to find it. It exists in many of the "spokespeople" of the Left, people such as Barbra Streisand and Rose O'Donnell. They make the most outrageous, viciously hateful statements imaginable, and then talk about the "intolerance" of the Right. I suppose it is possible that the parents of this 14 year old are stalwart Bush fans. What would you want to put the odds on them being registered Democrats Fred?
fred
Barbra Streisand, Rose O’Donnell and an eighth-grader are the standards by which you judge the Democratic party? And liberalism in general? Do yourself a favor and dig a little deeper into the issues of the day. Such stereotypes reflect you and your choice of targets, not me. I'm quite willing to accept that just before the 2002 midterm elections the Democratic leadership (in fact almost the entire party, the media and the populace in general) willingly allowed themselves to be fooled and cowed by the need to go with the flow: 9/11 fever. For myself as a private citizen, however, not having my job on the line or having any commercial need to stay attuned to the prevalent national mood, it was quite clear that there were plenty of holes in the story and questions to be asked and answered. I'm also quite willing to accept the proposition that if Gore had been president for 9/11 that we might be currently enjoying a Democratic boondoggle in Iraq rather than a GOP boondoggle. The difference being, of course, that a Gore administration would have been much more favorable to UNSCOM and European opinion than was Bush. Also wouldn't have had the "psychobabble" factor of Bush or a cadre predisposed to attack Iraq. But 9/11 fever might have tipped the scales anyway. But there is no way around the fact that in November 2000 Bush was the less popular candidate who achieved office via court fiat. That's fair enough for me: what am I going to do? Demand the scuttling of the Supreme Court? It was not a stolen election, and I am only slightly less perturbed than you by those who say it was.
CosmicConservative
Fred: Don't lecture me on how I judge the Democratic party and then turn around and fire off an unending stream of Democrat talking points that are about as intellectually sophisticated and about as factually accurate as a blonde joke. George W. Bush won the 2000 election because of the Electoral College Fred, not because of some "court fiat". He may have lost the popular vote, but that's not how you win elections in this country Fred, in case you haven't been paying attention in Civics class. Your continued whining about "court fiats" just indicates how bereft of fact your argument is. A Gore administration may have been more favorable to UNSCOM and the European Union than Bush has been, but that's just your opinion. I might point out to you that when Clinton was President, the UN and European led and favored Kyoto Treaty failed in the U.S. Senate 98 - 0. So forgive me if I conclude that most of the rhetoric the Democrats use to talk about "Global Tests" is just what most such talk is, political rhetoric intended to win elections. When push comes to shove the U.S. usually acts in its own best interest. I love how you say "allowed themselves to be fooled." What a crock. That's just your way of keeping the Democrat Talking Point of "Bush Lied" on the table. The truth is that they believed the same intelligence the Bush administration and the Clinton administration believed because that was the best and only intelligence they had available. You can go back and rewrite history in your own mind all you want, I was there, I saw it happen. Now if you want to talk about how Clinton scuttled the U.S. Intelligence capacity during his administration, I'd be glad to do so.
fred
I might have to break down and buy "State of Denial" for the insight it may shed on the troubled emotional condition of you Bush apologists. Let's take a look at your rewriting of history and associated emoting: 1. Bush's election in 2000 was a simple matter of Electoral College votes. The Supreme Court played no role in the matter. 2. The final vote for the Joint Resolution of October was near unanimous because Congress, the Bush Administration, the Clinton Administration, the CIA and all intelligence services around the world had one set of intelligence, all were in agreement, all were fully informed. Midterm election politics, 9/11 fever and Administration predisposition played no role in the matter. 3. Conservative Republicans can't be bothered to go into any depth on issues which threaten their Bush/terrorism/Iraq paradigm but are more than willing slice and dice Clinton six ways to Sunday. 4. When speaking to any liberal Democrat you are essentially speaking to Barbara Streisand, Rose O’Donnell or an eighth-grade Bush-basher. 5. The US attacked Germany in retaliation for Pearl Harbor.
CosmicConservative
Fred: You can parse these any way you like. You obviously have your own ideological blinders well in place, and we are not likely to see eye-to-eye on them. The Florida election was thrown into the courts by Al Gore, not by George W. Bush. That's because all the official counts showed Al losing. The Florida Supreme Court committed the most partisan act I've ever seen by a supposed impartial set of jurists, which is what set up the need for the SCOTUS to rule on it. The SCOTUS ruling was one of the most severe smack-downs of a state supreme court I have ever seen. The joint resolution to approve war in Iraq was near unanimous for a lot of reasons. I will simply report history and let you "Kerry apologists" try to explain away the votes by invoking whatever the latest excuse you come up with. I am not in a position where I need to invoke excuses, real or imagined. My side has been resolute on this. As far as Republicans and depth are concerned, this is just simple partisan barking, it has no semantic or logical content to respond to. I am not responsible for those who claim to be the standard-bearers of the liberal movement in this country. When Jimmy Carter invites Michael Moore to sit in a seat of honor at his side at the Democratic National Convention, you can't blame me for reacting to that. You don't want Rosie O'Donnell and Michael Moore to be your standard bearers, do something about it. We have exhaustively discussed how Pearl Harbor was the actual historical event that led to the U.S. taking action against Hitler. Your inability to understand this is not my problem.
CosmicConservative
Fred: BTW, you left out my Air America fixation...
fred
Hang on, I'll check with my "standard bearers" and get back to you on that. But I am impressed by your resolute command of your own talking points. Especially the notion that it is me and Rosie O'Donnell who wear ideological blinders. Not you and Ann Coulter.
CosmicConservative
I don't think you are in the same camp as Rosie O'Donnell, and I hope you don't think I'm in the same camp as Ann Coulter. Frankly I find Ann Coulter to be despicable. If you think my take on the 2000 election is a "talking point" then go ahead and do so. I'll stick with history, so we can check back in 20 years and decide if History books call the election "stolen", or "court fiat" OK? I don't see how you can call my willingness to stick by the factual vote counts on the Iraq resolution a "talking point." It's in the Congressional record, and it's the only vote that counted. In both of these cases, my position is the one that is supported by actual, officially tallied votes. Yours is the position of ambiguity, supposition and psychoanalylsis of stranger's motives. I'll leave it as an exercise to the readers which of us is following partisan talking points. I notice you did not bother to respond to my point about Michael Moore being invited to sit in a position of honor in the DNC. Not to mention the despicable comments from top Democrats when his partisan rant Fahrenheit 9/11 came out. Like I said, I don't pick your standard-bearers, but I know them when I see them. And as far as I know, Ann Coulter has never been invited to sit on the podium at the RNC by George HW Bush. When she has, we'll continue to address your point as if it is equally valid.
fred
If you're going to stick me with Michael Moore then I'm afraid you're stuck with Ann Coulter. Yes, let's play the moral equivalence board game with those two as opposite pieces. And if official tallied votes are all there is to your sense of history... again, I'll have to check with my standard bearers for an adequate reply.
CosmicConservative
Official tallies aren't my "only" sense, but they are among the key events that are factual, as opposed to mere opinion. Actually I do think Michael Moore and Ann Coulter are roughly equivalent in tone, mental capacity and partisan mudslinging, although in opposite directions. However, I do not agree that the right has adopted Ann Coulter nearly as eagerly as the left has adopted Michael Moore. Jimmy Carter's example (which you still have not acknowledged) as the leading example of that.
Drax
Fred: "1. Bush’s election in 2000 was a simple matter of Electoral College votes. The Supreme Court played no role in the matter." If you cannot provide a link where a count showed that Gore actually won Florida, then this is an absolutely correct statement of fact. "2. The final vote for the Joint Resolution of October was near unanimous because Congress, the Bush Administration, the Clinton Administration, the CIA and all intelligence services around the world had one set of intelligence, all were in agreement, all were fully informed. Midterm election politics, 9/11 fever and Administration predisposition played no role in the matter." Um....yes? We and the rest of the world, including the U.N. were convinced that Saddam had WMD's. Why wouldn't we? He used them on the Kurds and the Iranians, didn't he? There were 17 U.N. Resolutions demanding that he stop producing them, right? Those were in place prior to 9/11, right? "3. Conservative Republicans can’t be bothered to go into any depth on issues which threaten their Bush/terrorism/Iraq paradigm but are more than willing slice and dice Clinton six ways to Sunday." Always willing to compare Clinton to Bush. How can anyone think that Bush would come off second to Clinton in this comparison, whether personally or as a foreign policy leader? We have the comparison of Clinton's response to terrorism to Bush's. Bush 1. Clinton - 0. We have Bush's response to N. Korea in comparison to Clinton's gift of billions and nuclear technology to N. Korea. Bush - 2, Clinton - 0. We have Monicagate, allegations of rape, Whitewater, several hundred FBI files in the wrong hands, disappearing files on 9/11 in comparison to .... well nothing comparable, eh? Bush - 3, Clinton - 0. Thus far, Cosmic has ripped your posts apart by appealing to actual, provable FACTS, while you resort to implication and rumors. "4. When speaking to any liberal Democrat you are essentially speaking to Barbara Streisand, Rose O’Donnell or an eighth-grade Bush-basher." More often than we would like, unfortunately. "5. The US attacked Germany in retaliation for Pearl Harbor. " Is this the part of World History you missed?
fred
1. The Supreme Court absolutely played a deciding role in the outcome of the election. Why pretend otherwise? 2. I wasn't convinced. Analysts within the CIA were cautious and skeptical. Elements within the State and Defense Departments were dubious. Similar doubts existed around the world. Conviction only existed in the minds of Curveball, Cheney and a horde of legislators playing follow the leader. 3. On ending al Qaeda terrorism: Clinton - 0, Bush - 0 4. Barak Obama was an infinitely more inspiring and influential standard-bearer at the 2004 DNC than any marginal character you might prefer to mention. 5. The US went to war with Japan in the Pacific in retaliation for Pearl Harbor. We went to war with Germany for entirely different reasons.
CosmicConservative
Fred: 1. Do you bother to read people's dissenting points? The Florida Supreme Court intervened in the election, and the SCOTUS corrected their error. The SCOTUS would not have had to get involved if the Florida Supreme Court had not committed such an act of supreme partisanship that their own Chief Justice said he was embarrassed and ashamed of his colleagues. Once the courts got involved, at Al Gore's request, it was inevitable that the SCOTUS would have to settle it. That is not the same as the SCOTUS unilaterally intervening, as you continue to imply. The deciding role in the outcome of the Florida election was the official count, recount, and recount of the votes the citizens of Florida cast. Why do you insist on pretending otherwise? 2. If you were not convinced of Saddam's WMD, please go explain to the Kurds and the Iranians that they must have been killed by granola flakes. 3. On attempting to do somthing about Al Qada's terrorism, Bush 3 Clinton 0.5. 4. If you think Barak Obama is inspiring and influential, much less a liberal standard bearer, that says more about the Democratic party than anything I could say. 5. You cannot accept reality. You don't understand cause and effect. You don't understand causal chains or how events are used to justify related activities. When you first started posting here, your points were clever, interesting and reasonably fair. Lately you have become just another bitter liberal. I am sad to see it.
fred
1. Yes I do read them. And what I hear you guys saying is that 2000 was just another election, nothing historic about it. I also hear you saying falsely that I claim the election was stolen. Fine. 2. Sure, I was convinced that Saddam used wmd against the Kurds and Iranians prior to his defeat in the Gulf War. What does that have to do with the Administration's rock-solid certainty that he had stockpiles and a reconstituted nuclear weapons program ten years later? 3. You are ignoring the latest NIE. The floundering effort in Iraq, the failure to destroy al Qaeda's leaders in Afghanistan/Pakistan, weak and misdirected efforts at home add up to a poor score for Bush. I'll concede him a point though just on the basis of my inherent optimism that every cloud has a silver lining. 4. First you insist that every boil on the butt of liberal politics must necessarily represent me. Then you reject Obama, someone who is clearly rational and able to compromise and forge bipartisan alliances. Tell me, is there anyone at all on the left with whom you disagree politically yet might have a grudging respect for? 5. Certainly I accept reality. You, however, cannot admit that your Pearl Harbor analogy was poorly formulated and simplistic to the extreme. Cause and effect, indeed. Why am I not surprised that you are now to the point of rank condescension and clucking with disapproval? I came here for a good argument in the weeks before the election. Please don't disappoint me.
Drax
"1. Yes I do read them. And what I hear you guys saying is that 2000 was just another election, nothing historic about it. I also hear you saying falsely that I claim the election was stolen. Fine." You state that the "Courts played a deciding role." What other implication is there than the courts RATHER THAN THE VOTES decided the outcome. If you intend to say that the courts (at Gore's urging) decided that, yes, Bush had more votes than Gore in Flordia, and, yes, the votes were properly certified....then say that. Your purposeful implication is that the courts OVERRODE the vote of the people rather than RATIFIED it. It is disingenuous at best, and a bald faced lie at worst. "2. Sure, I was convinced that Saddam used wmd against the Kurds and Iranians prior to his defeat in the Gulf War. What does that have to do with the Administration’s rock-solid certainty that he had stockpiles and a reconstituted nuclear weapons program ten years later?" You ignore the 17 UN resolutions. You ignore France, Germany, the UK, Russia, and just about every country on the face of the earth's conclusions that: 1) He had WMD's, 2) He was attempting to get nuclear weapons, and 3) That these WMD's in the hands of a dictator who had USED THEM TWICE, had attacked his neighbors for CONQUEST and had USED WMD's in the process of one of those excursions, were a threat the mid-east stability. Beyond this, you choose to ignore that we have statements from drivers who say they drove WMD's to Syria. You choose to ignore reports that we actually found some WMD's there. You choose to ignore the reports of those who say that they were tracking Saddam's efforts to obtain nuclear tech. Instead, you choose to believe that this dictator, who attacked his neighbors and own citizens, had rape and torture as routine as we have court cases, who certainly had WMD's at one time, just decided to give it up and destroy his existing WMD's and WMD programs WITHOUT TELLING ANYONE. Why you choose to believe this, I can't fathom. Oh, nevermind. I do. It is because it is BUSH that is saying this. "3. You are ignoring the latest NIE. The floundering effort in Iraq, the failure to destroy al Qaeda’s leaders in Afghanistan/Pakistan, weak and misdirected efforts at home add up to a poor score for Bush. I’ll concede him a point though just on the basis of my inherent optimism that every cloud has a silver lining." Yah. Those women in Afghanistan who are actually allowed to read now are a failure. The millions of people in that country who can now at least attempt to be self-determining are a failure. The millions in Iraq who are now attempting to gain control of their own destiny rather than have it imposed on them by a dictator is a failure. You and those like you think that, because we haven't WON, that we have LOST. Because you think we have ALREADY lost, we should leave. Those who think otherwise think that, although we have not yet WON, neither have we LOST, and we should keep fighting UNTIL WE WIN, rather than leave and LOSE. It's easy to lose. It's easy to cut and run. It's hard work to stay the course (how many decades in Japan and Germany before they were anything resembling our "allies?") We may have to wait until the current leaders die off (or fall out of power) as we had to in Japan and Germany before we see the full fruits of our efforts. I'm okay with that. One less country on the face of the earth which is dedicated to the destruction of the U.S. is worth a large amount of national treasure. "4. First you insist that every boil on the butt of liberal politics must necessarily represent me. Then you reject Obama, someone who is clearly rational and able to compromise and forge bipartisan alliances. Tell me, is there anyone at all on the left with whom you disagree politically yet might have a grudging respect for?" Leiberman, for sure. He's about as leftist as they come, but he doesn't let his social leftism blind him to the realities of the world. Further, it depends on how you defing "leftist," doesn't it? There are VERY FEW positions the left holds which I can find ANY intellectual support for, which can be rationally argued for, which don't, in the end, boil down to some emotional foundation rather than a rational one. I have no INTELLECTUAL respect for people who choose to accept positions which cannot be rationally supported. So, the list of those on the left WHO WE ACTUALLY GET TO HEAR that have even my "grudging respect" is small indeed. Your arguments in this thread are similarly bereft of any actual factual support and boil down essentially to "I hate Bush; he stole the election, therefore, anything Bush has done is bad.
fred
1. I made no implication, simply stated facts. It was an extremely close and messy election. The Supreme Court ended it. For the final time, I don't feel the election was "stolen". It was historic both because of the popular vs. electoral vote count (has happened 3 times in something like 55 presidential elections) and because of the Court's intervention (this was the first time for that). In the end, the Peoples' choice was ratified by virtue of their faith in the Electoral College and in the Court. I share that faith and apologise for my simplistic statement, "an unpopular candidate was put into office by a court ruling". 2. I'm not ignoring anything. It was clear to me at the time that the Administration's undeniable demagoguery and propagandistic marketing of the danger of Saddam was overblown and not supported by fact. We are finding that the bold public statements by government insiders and intelligence chiefs were politically motivated and did not reflect the substantial doubt and uncertainty of what was known. 3. This election will be in part a referendum on Iraq. I predict "stay the course" will morph into "course correction", meaning partition and redeployment. You won't like it, but I think it's inevitable. I supported the invasion of Afghanistan and think that much of the Iraq redeployment should be to that country. 4. I like Joe too, though disagree with him on Iraq. What will the voters of Connecticut do? 5. You forgot number 5. Your claim to the intellectual high ground is undermined by your emotional assumptions as to my beliefs and insistence on a simplistic view of all who oppose Bush. "Cut and run". How lame is that?
Drax
Fred: "1. I made no implication, simply stated facts. It was an extremely close and messy election. The Supreme Court ended it. For the final time, I don’t feel the election was “stolen”. It was historic both because of the popular vs. electoral vote count (has happened 3 times in something like 55 presidential elections) and because of the Court’s intervention (this was the first time for that). In the end, the Peoples’ choice was ratified by virtue of their faith in the Electoral College and in the Court. I share that faith and apologise for my simplistic statement, “an unpopular candidate was put into office by a court ruling”." You did not state facts. The Supreme Court did not CHANGE a single vote. All counts of Florida Voters show that Bush won. It is not "faith" that I have in the Electoral College, it is the Constitutional Method that we in this Republic determine our Presidency -- NOT by "popular vote." "2. I’m not ignoring anything. It was clear to me at the time that the Administration’s undeniable demagoguery and propagandistic marketing of the danger of Saddam was overblown and not supported by fact. We are finding that the bold public statements by government insiders and intelligence chiefs were politically motivated and did not reflect the substantial doubt and uncertainty of what was known." Why is that clear to you? You state your emotional conclusion, ignoring the FACTS. You say that we are "finding that the bold public statements....were politically motivated." Where is there something which even RESEMBLES proof of that this statement? There is none. We could argue whether or not Bush was WRONG to invade Iraq on an intellectual level, but your side constantly imputes to Bush some base motivation for doing so instead of simply making a wrong choice, and never can support these base charges. Bush did it, so it must have not only have been wrong, it must have been for a wrong REASON. "3. This election will be in part a referendum on Iraq. I predict “stay the course” will morph into “course correction”, meaning partition and redeployment. You won’t like it, but I think it’s inevitable. I supported the invasion of Afghanistan and think that much of the Iraq redeployment should be to that country." You may be right in that that is the way that the Iraq question is decided--by partition. It may even be the best solution. I didn't say "stay the course" in some set plan or objective OTHER than not leaving until Iraq is self-governing in a democratic fashion rather than by a dictator. "4. I like Joe too, though disagree with him on Iraq. What will the voters of Connecticut do?" Elect Joe. "5. You forgot number 5." I didn't forget. That's not my argument. "Your claim to the intellectual high ground is undermined by your emotional assumptions as to my beliefs and insistence on a simplistic view of all who oppose Bush. “Cut and run”. How lame is that? " Leaving Iraq before Iraq is able to protect itself from the Islamic Radicals who would turn it into another pre-Invasion Afghanistan but with oil is "cut and run." Parse it however you wish, that is what it is.
fred
1. For all I know, if there had been a statewide re-count, Bush might have increased his margin from 0.01% to 0.05%. That's not my point. I don't see why you can't understand the significance of these facts: the Supreme Court ended it and Bush lost the popular vote. Both facts are historically important. By the way, I don't advocate amending the Constitution to abolish the Electoral College. 2. No, I'm not ignoring facts. The administration conjured mushroom clouds, anthrax armed drones and collusion between Saddam and al Qaeda while selectively ignoring contrary intelligence. They sent Powell out to make a fool of himself and then blamed the whole mess on Tenet. Bush is correct to say, "The world is better off without Saddam Hussein in power." But I don't believe him when he says, "Knowing what I know today we still would have gone on into Iraq." Without the fear of the alleged grave threat of Saddam and the constant linking of Saddam to terrorism and 9/11, there would have been no way we would have invaded Iraq in March 2003. 3. I certainly don't advocate letting Iraq "turn it into another pre-Invasion Afghanistan but with oil" and I'd like to know who does advocate that. In many ways, Bush has set us on an irrevocable course: we cannot let Iraq become even worse than it was. Unfortunately the invasion was ill-timed and unnecessary, the occupation has been a disaster, and Bush's course is... what? Stay loyal to Rumsfeld and the slow, grinding decay of the Iraqi people. The best solution may be a timetable for partition, separate governments under a federal umbrella, a fair sharing of oil revenues, and coalition redepoyment to Kurdistan, Kuwait and Afghanistan.
Drax
Fred: "1. For all I know, if there had been a statewide re-count, Bush might have increased his margin from 0.01% to 0.05%. That’s not my point. I don’t see why you can’t understand the significance of these facts: the Supreme Court ended it and Bush lost the popular vote. Both facts are historically important. By the way, I don’t advocate amending the Constitution to abolish the Electoral College." I understand the historical significance of winning the Presidency while losing the popular vote as I understand the historical significance of the Supreme Court being forced into deciding what everyone already knew, i.e., that Bush won Florida. But, that is HISTORICAL significance. It has no meaning other than being something to put on a history test. Bush won fair and square in the manner prescribed by our Constitution. You and others keep bringing the results of the election up for no other reason than to de-legitimize Bush. There was NO other reason than that to bring it up in this thread to begin with. "2. No, I’m not ignoring facts. The administration conjured mushroom clouds, anthrax armed drones and collusion between Saddam and al Qaeda while selectively ignoring contrary intelligence. They sent Powell out to make a fool of himself and then blamed the whole mess on Tenet. Bush is correct to say, “The world is better off without Saddam Hussein in power.” But I don’t believe him when he says, “Knowing what I know today we still would have gone on into Iraq.” Without the fear of the alleged grave threat of Saddam and the constant linking of Saddam to terrorism and 9/11, there would have been no way we would have invaded Iraq in March 2003." Again, you impute to Bush and the Bush administration base motivation, saying that they "selectively ignored contrary intelligence," rather than that they, like just about every other nation on the face of the Earth, like the U.N., believed exactly what they SAID they believed: He had WMD's and was seeking to obtain Nuclear Weapons. That is a CHOICE. It is ENTIRELY unsupported by any FACT. It is a FACT that he HAD WMD's. It is a FACT that the UN thought he had them and was attempting to get nuclear weapons. It is a FACT that he had the means to deliver those weapons, if he obtained them, to any place in the Middle East. It is a FACT that he used WMD's both on his people and in an aggressive war on his neighbor. It is a FACT that he invaded Kuwait with no provocation. With these facts in mind, how you come to the conclusion that Bush was making all this stuff up befuddles me. "3. I certainly don’t advocate letting Iraq “turn it into another pre-Invasion Afghanistan but with oil” and I’d like to know who does advocate that. In many ways, Bush has set us on an irrevocable course: we cannot let Iraq become even worse than it was. Unfortunately the invasion was ill-timed and unnecessary, the occupation has been a disaster, and Bush’s course is… what? Stay loyal to Rumsfeld and the slow, grinding decay of the Iraqi people. " So, you're saying, unlike the Democratic LEADERSHIP, unlike the vast majority of the Elected Democrats, that we should "stay the course," meaning stay there until we actually WIN? If not, I don't know what the hell you're saying now. "The best solution may be a timetable for partition, separate governments under a federal umbrella, a fair sharing of oil revenues, and coalition redepoyment to Kurdistan, Kuwait and Afghanistan" Over time, this may be the case. It is unfortunate, and quite telling about how the various Islamic sects cannot live together without killing each other.
fred
1. If you understand "the historical significance of winning the Presidency while losing the popular vote" and "the historical significance of the Supreme Court being forced" to decide the outcome, then you must understand why these events are historically significant. Care to share you thoughts on this? Hint: these event are not mere procedural oddities. 2. More FACTS for your consideration: FACT: The Rendon Group, a Washington, DC based public relations firm, was employed by the administration to help develop a marketing strategy in the run-up to war. (Cosmo can reach into his supply of WWII analogies for a relevant parallel.) FACT: In late 2001, Rumsfeld's Office of Strategic Influence was formed. This office was created with a propaganda mandate. In February 2002, Rumsfeld was forced to close it down claiming he lacked any knowledge of the program. FACT: Prior to the invasion of Iraq, Cheney stated flatly that "Iraq is the geographic base of the terrorists who had us under assault now for many years, but most especially on 9-11." FACT: George Tenet said prior to the invasion that "the jury was out on whether Iraq had been involved in the 9/11 attacks on New York and Washington. FACT: Prior to the invasion, Condi Rice said, "We know that when the inspectors assessed this after the Gulf War, he was far, far closer to a crude nuclear device than anybody thought -- maybe six months from a crude nuclear device. The problem here is that there will always be some uncertainty about how quickly he can acquire nuclear weapons. But we don't want the smoking gun to be a mushroom cloud." In fact, "after the Gulf War" did not accurately portray nuclear capacity ten years later. There was no evidence at the time of the quote, and no evidence subsequently emerged supporting the allegation that Saddam was "six months" away from a nuclear weapons capacity. FACT: Bush claimed "We have also discovered through intelligence that Iraq has a growing fleet of manned and unmanned aerial vehicles that could be used to disperse chemical or biological weapons across broad areas. We are concerned that Iraq is exploring ways of using these UAVs for missions targeting the United States." No evidence has ever been produced. Maximum flight of a UAV is 300 miles. FACT: Bush claimed, "We have seen intelligence over many months that they have chemical and biological weapons, and that they have dispersed them and that they're weaponized and that, in one case at least, the command and control arrangements have been established." Easy to make the claim for public support of the invasion. Apparently no supporting evidence was necessary. FACT" Bush claimed, "Our conservative estimate is that Iraq today has a stockpile of between 100 and 500 tons of chemical weapons agent. That is enough to fill 16,000 battlefield rockets." And that was just a conservative estimate. FACT: Prior to the invasion, Bush pronounced, "The evidence indicates that Iraq is reconstituting its nuclear weapons program. Iraq has attempted to purchase high-strength aluminum tubes and other equipment needed for gas centrifuges, which are used to enrich uranium for nuclear weapons." It was known at the time by the Administration that these tubes were likely destined for an entirely different purpose. FACT: The now infamous "The British government has learned that Saddam Hussein recently sought significant quantities of uranium from Africa." Bush was unpersuasive about aluminum tubes so he added this to make his case more strongly. FACT: Rumsfeld jokingly asserted, "We know where Iraq's WMD are. They're in the area around Tikrit and Baghdad and east, west, south, and north somewhat." The fact is he didn;t know anything of the sort. FACT: Bush said prior to the invasion, "We've learned that Iraq has trained al-Qaeda members in bomb-making and poisons and deadly gases. Alliance with terrorists could allow the Iraqi regime to attack America without leaving any fingerprints." No evidence to this effect was ever produced. Ever. FACT: Cheney claimed prior to the invasion, "We know he's been absolutely devoted to trying to acquire nuclear weapons, and we believe he has, in fact, reconstituted nuclear weapons." This claim has been shown to have been baseless when it was uttered. FACT: Bush claimed, "We gave him a chance to allow the inspectors in, and he wouldn't let them in" when in fact the inspectors were inside and gaining increasing access when Bush launched the war and prevented further inspections. FACT: After the invasion, Bush declared, "Yes, we found a biological laboratory in Iraq which the UN prohibited." A refeerence to two modified truck trailers which served as facilities to fill weather balloons, sold to them by the British. "FACT: After the invasion, declaring that major combat operation in Iraq had ended, Bush typically muddled the two different issues, "The battle of Iraq is one victory in a war on terror that began on September the 11, 2001." FACT: More recently Rick Santorum declared, “we have found weapons of mass destruction in Iraq.” His allegations were based on the U.S. government's Iraq Survey Group report. The very same report convinced President Bush, accurately and finally, that Iraq did not have WMD. 3. On the one hand you play the "cut and run" card so flippantly against Democrats. On the other hand, you say "over time, this may be the case" and then pass off the blame to Islamic sects who like to kill each other. So tell me, in your most objective, rational, intellectual non-emotive manner so typical of right-thinking conservatives... ...how does the US government disengage, withdraw, and re-deploy away from the occupation of Iraq, disolving that country into separate partitions under some as-yet-to-be-determined loose federal authority... ...without falling prey to the dreaded "cut and run" epithet and an overall verdict of FAILURE?
Drax
Much better. Cites to the quotes would have been nice, but I can do the research. As to your question: Hell, I don't know how or when we disengage anymore than I know the answer to how and when we disengage from South Korea or Afghanistan. However, I do know that we can't disengage before Iraq has a government which is capable and willing to control activities within its own borders, to quell the murder of its citizens by its own citizens and foreign agitators at least to the degree that they are actually able to protect themselves from within and without. This must be accomplished while Iraq has a government which is representative of the people and answerable to the people. Is that possible given the intense hatred the various sects display towards one another without some sort of partition? Again, I don't know. I think it's possible. I hope it's possible. But, if it's not, then partition may be the ultimate answer (which, of course, creates even more problems down the line). Am I convinced that Iraq was the place to go? Not really. Not totally. But, I AM convinced that the Middle East paradigm has to be fundamentally changed and NOW. There are too many countries which hate the United States and everything we stand for. There are too many countries which support financially and otherwise terrorist organizations which have the stated goal of destroying Israel and the "Great Satan." Even our so-called "allies" in the area teach hatred of Israel and any non-Mulsim, breeding many terrorists in the process. It is, right now, an endless cycle of bred violence directed against us and our allies. This has to stop. We have a relatively small window in time in which to provoke change. More and more countries are obtaining nuclear technology. Terrorist organizations are becoming larger, better financed, more organized, with bolder and more violent goals against us and our allies. The violence around the world is growing at an alarming rate. Those who profess their hatred of the U.S. and its allies have shown NO regard for murdering civilians, indeeds, TARGETS them, and targets the largest number of them possible. Had al-Queda the ability to drop a nuke in NYC rather than two airliners, I have no doubt that it would have done so. So, in this small window of time, before our enemies have nuclear capability and the means to deliver them, before they have the means to give this capability to terrorist groups, we must provoke fundamental change in the Middle East. Iraq had made clear that it wanted to be the head of a larger "Arab State" and had attempted twice to make that desire a reality. Iraq had attempted to acquire nuclear technology, supposedly for non-WMD purposes, but, we're supposed to trust this guy? Nukes, with the ability to deliver them in the hands of Saddam would mean that we would have to fight him at some later point in time when he had nuclear capability when he has already established his willingness to use WMDs. I choose fighting now when HE isn't ready, rather than later when he IS. It is exactly the position that Clinton put us in with North Korea. Because of his policies, we now face a nuclear threat from a country with a tyrant at the helm. It is only a matter of time before Syria or Hamas or al-Queda gets nuclear weapons or other WMD's and the means to deliver them. I believe that when that time comes, they will be used, and they will be used against us or against our allies. If we don't change the fundamental Middle Eastern Paradigm before then, it will be too late to do it later.
Dadman
That's a good question, Fred, and the crux of the dilemma we face in Iraq. I would ask the question a little differently...how do we achieve U.S. and freedom-loving Iraqi objectives in Iraq? Disengagement might be part of the solution, but I'm not convinced it is at this point. I know that the 'cut and run' epithet is largely applied for the purpose of scoring political points. But I also know that setting a date certain for drawing down our force strength (or re-deploying entirely) plays into the hands of the insurgents - they will immediately know precisely how long it will take to wait us out. I don't view that as a responsible position to take. I also know we have to succeed in Iraq somehow, someway. Many liberals don't seem to share that vision. They just want the U.S. out of Iraq irrespective of terrible fate that might thereafter befall the vast majority of Iraqi's who desire (and voted for) liberty and self-determination. You liberals also spend a great deal of time wringing your hands over how Bush and his administration lied us into the Iraq War (Bush Lied, People Died). While that might be an historically relevant or politically relevant discussion in an election cycle, in my view it is not in any way germaine to the problem of how we can achieve success in Iraq today and tomorrow. I'm still waiting for a liberal to offer a viable solution that is significantly different than what Bush is already doing...
fred
I guess you've never heard of Peter Galbraith, a liberal who has for a couple of years propsed a plan to extricate ourselves from Iraq and leave behind a three-state solution. There's a definite element of pie-in-the-sky and a host of dubious uncertainties, but skip past the litany of US failures in Iraq, if you like, to the secind half of the article for the meat of his solution: http://www.thinkingpeace.com/pages/arts2/arts185.html This is, by the way, a liberal who supported the invasion in march 2003. Variations on this approach have been taken up by Joe Biden, Leslie Gelb and others. I predict that this will be seen as the only workable endgame by both conservatives and liberals by the end of the Bush presidency. Setting a timetable plays into the insurgents hands? How much more does an endless unfocused occupation play not only into the hands of the insurgents but also jihadists intent on as much broad destruction within what remains of Iraq as possible? But what do I know? It seems to me that channeling the constituencies into their own territories and letting them have their own governments and militaries would achieve a lot of what we are trying to accomplish. The biggest problems, of course, would be the major cities which are traditionally multi-ethnic. But at least is seems to be a formula to contain civil war as much as possible. Was there a GOP conservative plan offered somewhere on this page? I seem to have missed it.
Dadman
The GOP, conservative plan is a strong, unity, self-sufficient government capable of sustaining itself. That's what we've been trying to achieve. I concede it may not be working... Please try to resist the sarcasm, Fred. It makes you sound like a pompous jerk...and I doubt that in real life (as opposed to cyberlife) that is what you are...
CosmicConservative
I am sorry I was not part of this discussion, I was clobbered by a massive snowstorm and was stuck on the highway for four hours last night, then was stuck shoveling a foot of snow until 10:30, so I didn't even turn on the computer. Fred made a lot of good points this time. This is much more like the Fred I was hoping to have here on CosmicConservative. Thanks for rationally addressing the issue instead of resorting to strawmen arguments and sarcasm. Well, not as much stramen and sarcasm anyway. I am not going to be able to address Fred's points one-by-one, I unfortunately have a job. But I will make some general comments and then deal with individual items that I think do need some response. First, if you want to get a list of comments from Bush administration officials that are questionable in retrospect, I can certainly provide a list of wonderful quotes from Hillary Clinton, Bill Clinton, John Kerry, Ted Kennedy, etc. I've done it many times in other contexts. There is very little that Bush administrtation officials said on this subject that liberal icons did not also say, or even say more damning things about Hussein. Should I post the numerous comments from liberal leadership about how the Bush adminstration was dragging their feet in dealing with Iraq? Both sides said indefensible things. To say that Bush's rhetoric was somehow worse or more extreme than Clinton's, Kerry's or Kennedy's is just plain ignorant. As far as whether the White House engaged a PR firm to help them shape their message about Iraq, please tell me you are not so naive to think that government officials do not use propaganda to advance their goals. Should I research all the liberal think tanks and PR firms that have been engaged by the Left? This is just politics in the modern world Fred. There have been proven links between Iraq and Al Qada. They have been well documented. If you don't believe them, fine, I'm sure I'm not going to convince you here. That ship has sailed. I have my interpretation of historical facts, and you have yours. Mine includes the certainty that Iraq had communication with Al Qada leaders and shared a hatred of the US. Does that mean Iraq was involved in 9/11? To me that is a question of what you mean by "involved in." Did Saddam have direct knowledge of the plan of attack and provide logicical support for carrying it out? Probably not. Did Iraq know that Al Qada was plotting attacks on the US, and did Al Qada have at least a blind eye from Saddam for activiites that Al Qada performed in Iraq or in areas Iraq had influence and knowledge? Almost certainly. Does that mean Iraq was involved in 9/11? Draw your own conclusions. Iraq was certainly not working to stop Al Qada. Iraq is known to have financially and logistically supported Hamas and the PLA, and is suspected to have supported other terrorist organizations, so in the sense that this is a war against "Terrorism" then Iraq certainly is documented as being a terrorist supporting state, and so falls under the Bush Doctrine of being a country that was siding with terrorists. Perhaps not Al Qada, but frankly I think supporting two terrorist organizations is enough to qualify as a terrorist state. Your mileage may vary. Most of your "Bush claimed" "facts" are well documented as U.N. claims and Clinton administration claims, so unless you are willing to assert that Bush's claims were extensions of other administration claims and the claims of other governments, then you demonstrate a bias against Bush on the subject. A few specific ones. The drone aircraft claim is one that I think is worth mention. There is evidence that Iran was doing this, but I haven't seen proof that Iraq was. By the way, in the recent Hamas-Israel conflict, Hamas actually used one of those things on an Israeli ship. So they do exist. Did Iraq have them or was Iraq working on them? Maybe not. But since Iran was, I think it was not much of an extension for the administration to think Iraq was too, especially since Iran and Iraq had been in a mutually escalating arms race for decades. So factually, I'll give you this one, but I still think it is defensible. The aluminum tubes thing is, in my opinion, the closest thing to a "smoking gun" that anyone has found that the Bush administration "genned up" some evidence for enriching uranium. I have some knowledge of the process of enriching uranium and when those aluminum tubes were mentioned, I felt like the administration had overplayed their hand. They did not look to me like what the administration claimed they were. So this one I give to you completely and unreservedly. I think you are right on this one. You can disbelieve the WMD finds in Iraq all you like. The evidence is clear that not only did Iraq have chemical weapons, and that they were prepared for delivery. You can deny it all you like. You can say "well, there were only a few dozen found, and they were old" or whatever your excuse is to ignore them. But they were factually there, were factually WMD and were factually weaponized. UN inspectors had been systematically misled, denied access and expelled from Iraq for years. At the particular moment that Bush launched the attack they were "back in" Iraq, but only a fool would think that they were likely to have any more success, more access and more cooperation from Iraq that time than any other time. The fact is that Iraq was in violation of 17 UN resolutions. How many resolutions do you need Fred?
fred
Remember when Bush said he wanted a final vote and resolution from the Security Council, he wanted them to show their cards? Then he folded his hand when he realized how that vote would go? Bush was intent on invading and didn't want to do so in violation of a UN resolution. So the prudent thing was to avoid the resolution altogether. If that final vote had taken place and gone against Bush, would you have supported the invasion in violation of a UN resolution? Of course you would have. So don't hold up UN resolutions as criteria for taking such a huge step as launching a pre-emptive invasion, particularly considering the attitude on the part of GOP conservatives and hawks toward the UN. It's bad enough that Bush scuttled the renewed inspections when they were starting to break through resistance and yield results. Invoking UN resolutions on one hand while completely dissing UNSCOM and the UN in general is quite hypocritical. Fools rush in where angels fear to tread. "The GOP, conservative plan is a strong, unity, self-sufficient government capable of sustaining itself. That’s what we’ve been trying to achieve." I've benn thinking, Dadman, and will make an additional or alternative prediction that after the election Bush will continue to redeploy within Iraq and also send in a massive infusion of troops, perhaps enough to win the "Battle of Baghdad." I seriously doubt he will ever embrace e three-state solution.
CosmicConservative
I would agree that Bush has always been dogmatic on the issue of what the Iraqi nation should look like. I personally have no problem with a three-state solution. The current boundaries of Iraq are completely arbitrary anyway. I don't think it's going to happen though.