Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Karma and science

By CosmicConservative
So I got involved in this discussion on a local community forum called "Pinecam". Somebody asked the question "Do you believe in Karma" and it took off from there. I am "PaperDragon" in the exchange, if you care to read it. This is the kind of thread I'd love to have had on CosmicConservative. Sigh.

Comments (1)

qwerty182764
I agree with your posts wholeheartedly. However, you're the guy with the bad news that it all won't work at a conceptual pep-rally. In a universe that was set up in such a way that it punished or rewarded us for our evil or good to others, that balanced everything out to achieve this state we call "fairness": Would we have invented jails? Would we have invented government? Would we even need to defend ourselves from barbarian hordes? (Wouldn't they run into trouble proportional to the trouble they cause, and hence dissolve?) Why, if the universe metes justice out for us, are we so keen on doing it for ourselves? Some problems internal to the concept: I'm assuming this hypothetical punishment takes place in a timely enough manner to matter. If you punish a dog a week after the negative behavior, then the dog only learns that you like to punish him, with no apparent pattern. A punishment at the end of a life of a bloodstained warlord is far too late to result in any sort of "fairness" to the lives destroyed and derailed, and it doesn't condition him not to like raising his neighbors to the ground. To put the punishment off to some reincarnated life doesn't make much sense to me either, for the same reason and others. It's pretty much as if you're punishing an entirely different person, for one. You've got new memories, a new family, a new upbringing, and you've made an entirely different set of choices than this tenuously connected "previous" life. In fact, the new set of choices that you make cannot be causally connected to your prior life experience, because the memories and experiences don't transfer. (If they did, I'd remember that time I ruled all of the Medeteranian - bwahahaha) Suddenly you're having extremely bad things happen to you for no apperent reason. What is that supposed to do, other than make the "new you" completely miserable? I'm not sure I would call it "justice". Empirical problems: Bad things happening to good people hasn't just been an occurence, throughout our history. In fact, it's been the norm. For thousands and thousands of years, the guys with the plows have lived in near-starving enslaved misery while the guys with the swords took their food and what little wealth they could wring from them. Tyrants ruled from posh (by the standards of the day, anyway: no high-speed internet access is definitely uncivilized :-P) fortresses, and the people who made their lives possible froze in straw huts. Justice has been talked about for thousands of years. But it's only been established to a reasonable degree in modern times (last 300-500 years or so). The golden rule is great, but people who follow it become slaves to people who don't if they can't defend themselves against their neighbors predation. If it were natural, we wouldn't have to be prepared to fight terrible wars to maintain it. Gaah. Turning into a paper, at the rate I'm going. Anyways, extremely long winded way to say I agree. If you want justice, you'll have to individually/collectively establish it yourself/ves. On of the things that I'm amazedly greatful for, living in the modern era, is that, looking back on our brutal history, we've managed to establish justice to the extent we have. It's literally made the modern world possible, and it rules.