Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Movie Review: Fatal Call

By CosmicConservative
This is an unusual situation. I write a lot of reviews of movies, books and even the occasional television show. But up until now, other than having a friend of my daughter work on some of the computer graphics for a movie, I've had no connection to the item being reviewed. This movie is the creation of one of the regular posters on this blog who goes by "Jack". And one of the very few liberals who hasn't been driven away by the anti-liberal commentary that is rather frequently expressed here. Or at least not yet permanently. So I don't feel quite the level of objectivity that I normally have when doing one of my reviews. With that caveat out of the way, here we go: First, the poster, reproduced here: fatal_call ... is a really egregious misrepresentation of the movie itself. Jack apologized for this up front indicating that he had no input into the cover. I find that very interesting and wonder how common it is for there to be that level of disconnect between the creator of a film and the marketing posters created. I suppose that would account for other posters I've seen that seem sort of off compared to the movie. In this case the poster seems to be deliberately exaggerating an action scene and the "femme fatale" nature of the movie. If I were Jack I would be quite incensed at the end result. OK, I've got that out of my system. On to the movie itself. My basic reaction to the movie is that it struck me as being fairly representative of the writing, acting and production qualities of a Hollywood movie. For what I suppose was a fairly low budget Indie movie, I was impressed with the final result. With a couple of exceptions, but then that's generally true of most movies I watch. The main character, Mitch, portrayed by Jason London, did a fair job overall, with some compelling moments. Amy, the femme fatale portrayed by Danielle Harris, was, I thought, the most compelling actor in the movie, even though her first scene in the bar was not her best. Kevin Sorbo, best known as the star of the "Hercules" TV show, showed moments of talent, but some scenes he seemed to be mailing it in. The two actors who portrayed Mitch's friends, Joel Lewis as Ted and Jimmy Chung as Simon were outclassed and sometimes painful to watch. The camera work and general cinematography were generally solid. Several scenes were well crafted, well framed, well lit and provided the proper tone for the scene. The editing itself was mostly unnoticeable, which is about the best thing you can say about editing. Which brings us to the story. Generally I judge how well a story is written according to at least the following things: 1. How easily I can predict the events. 2. How well the key plot elements are foreshadowed, woven into the story and, finally, revealed. 3. How plausible key events are. 4. How consistent the actions of characters are based on their personalities as portrayed. So here's how I react in each of these areas: 1. I'm afraid that I found the plot to be entirely predictable, and was not surprised by any of the "reveals". Not even the "big" reveal at the end. This was in part because the story had a fairly bad case of "wow, what a coincidence" going on pretty much all the time. That didn't ruin the story, I'm rarely surprised by the plots of Hollywood movies, so I can usually appreciate the story even when it seems to be clipping along the exact trail I expected. 2. This is probably the part of the writing that I think was done the best. It appeared to me that the writer (Jack, I assume) spent a lot of time working on exactly how to provide the clues that would eventually be used to justify the final reveals. For the most part I think this was done as well as, or even better than, many Hollywood movies, most of which resort to final second twists to justify their final reveals. At least that wasn't the case here. 3. Hmmm.... plausibility issues were unfortunately fairly common. Maybe no more common than most Hollywood movies, but I have a very poor opinion of most Hollywood writing, so that's not much to grab onto. The most bothersome issues to me from a plausibility perspective were the following: a) Mitch's reaction to the initial discussion to deal with an unwanted marriage were not consistent with the persona we had been presented with. This could have been managed better if this scene had been moved several minutes further into the movie, and we had seen Amy use her feminine wiles more deliberately to break down Mitch's supposed "good guy" tendencies. As it was, they went to bed and almost immediately Mitch was accepting the premise of Amy being willing to commit murder and even asking Mitch to do it. b) Virtually none of the detective, DA or police station scenes struck me as plausible. Pretty much every character in any role of law enforcement was not fleshed out enough to be believable as anything but a means to advance the plot. The actors in the detective roles attempted to inject personalities into their portrayals, but ended up mostly just providing personality quirks that were sometimes incongruous and even unprofessional. Considering what their role was in the plot, they should have been more menacing, gritty, hard-bitten, even bitter or resentful, but the most important aspect of their role in order to be meaningful to the plot is that they should have been competent and they were not. c) The entire sub-plot with the ruffians pursuing Mitch was unnecessary and distracting. If I were editing the work I would have suggested cutting that entire bit out of the script. It added nothing important to the story and demonstrated nothing new about Mitch's character. d) Mitch spent much of the first half of the movie running around in public with obvious and potentially serious wounds, and interacted with people in a strange and disturbing manner, and it never seemed to occur to anyone to call the police. 4. I already touched on this with Mitch implausibly accepting the idea that Amy was a murderous bitch and being OK with it after nothing more than an evening of rather tame and conventional sex. I know from my own experience that writing sex scenes is quite difficult, especially if there is any deviation from what people consider "normal." But Amy needed to be more forceful and unconventional in her approach to sex for Mitch to have fallen so quickly to her wiles. Amy needed to be a beast in bed, a vixen with a mission. She should have left Mitch exhausted, astonished and overwhelmed by this sudden realization of his wildest fantasies. Then I would have believed that Mitch could have fallen prey to the temptations of his repressed sexual urges. Amy was too tame and conventional and Mitch was too decent for me to believe that the story would have developed the way it did. I know this probably all sounds harsh, but as I said above, the movie struck me as being pretty well in line with the quality and standards of Hollywood movies, which is probably quite an achievement on the budget and with the resources the movie was made with. Overall it hung together and there was a story to watch with some interesting characters, some surprisingly good production qualities (particularly the film editing) and a couple of acting performances that would have stood out in many big-budget Hollywood films. I give it three lanyard-flash drives out of five. You could do worse than check this out.

Comments (16)

CosmicConservative
In re-reading this I feel like I should have put more up front "friendly" chat to perhaps blunt some of what might feel like harsh criticism. Jack, I took the approach of reviewing this the same way I would have reviewed any other movie, which is, I believe, what you wanted me to do. Looking at this as the effort of someone I have talked to and have a lot of respect for, I feel I should have made the following things clear: 1. This is really a significant accomplishment for anyone to have done. I tried to make it clear in my review that I thought the movie would stack up reasonably well against a lot of major movies produced by big-name Hollywood production machines. 2. While there are some things in the movie that I think represent opportunities for growth and experience as a director/producer/writer. But the level of writing, producing and directing that has been done is quite extensive. I can only express my admiration for having been able to complete such a monumental undertaking. 3. I don't know what sort of movie-making infrastructure you had to work with, but if you only had a skeleton crew of camera men, a few cameras and no significant budget for special effects, I think the end result does a good job of not giving that feeling to the viewer. The camera work in doing dialog felt natural and flowed well, which usually requires multiple cameras to allow the viewers point of view to switch context as the conversation occurs. In many low-budget movies this is one of the main areas that the lack of movie-making infrastructure becomes glaringly obvious, and that was not the case here. Whether that was due to the ability to raise enough money to have all the angles covered, or due to directing the action more carefully with fewer resources, either way you deserve credit for that. Anyway, I would be proud to have produced something this extensive and bringing it to fruition and having a final version that was suitable for public view. I hope it is clear that I am impressed with the result and I think that if some of the criticisms I offered are taken to heart, you've got a great potential writing/directing career in front of you Jack.
Jack
Hi Cosmic! I thought your review was very good and fair! I didn't respond last night because I had a long day and just fell asleep. :-) All your movie reviews are very detailed and you delve into every aspect of the production so I appreciate and am honored that you took the time to do the same on my film. The points you brought up are valid and some have been brought up by others. My producer, and others, had similar comments about the ruffians that Mitch encounters. I put them in there for two reasons. One, to illustrate that Mitch can rise to a physical confrontation if he has to (so the climatic fight doesn't seem too far out of whack) and also I feared the first half of the film would be too boring and I would lose my audience. (I had complaints that my first film, Ghost Image, was too slow and boring and that weighed heavy on my mind as I was making Fatal Call. It would appear my solution had it's own problems though as pointed out by you and others). I added humor with the detectives because the film seemed to lack humor or comedic relief. Again, there were those who felt that was a mistake. And there are those who thought it was fine. But you bring up good points about that. You are correct about writing sex scenes. Very difficult. And actually filming a sex scene makes writing them a walk in the park! Ironically, the scene was written with the intensity that you describe (so I think you have a good sense of "what should've been" when it comes to the scene). My producer and I had long discussions over it. Do we want a 'PG-13' rating or an 'R'? Hmmmm. The problem with the ratings is there is no clear-cut distinction between PG-13 and R except in one area. F-bombs. You can do one F-bomb in a PG-13 but if you do two then, PING, you now have an R rated film. You may or may not have noticed, but there is no real foul language in the movie. So we have our bases covered for a PG-13 film if we want to go that route. A PG-13 rating will open us up to a wider audience which means more revenue. But what about the sex? Will that give us an R? There's no telling because it's a fuzzy line when it comes to visual content. For better or for worse, we decided to err on the side of caution and go for something milder to insure a PG-13. As it turns out, it was a moot point. The film is NR (non-rated) because it wasn't necessary. Ghost Image was picked up by 20th Century Fox which required a rating but Fatal Call has not been picked up by a studio (yet) so it remains unrated at this time. Some clarification on how films are made. All feature films and dramatic television shows only use one camera. Only sit-coms, soap operas, talk shows, and reality shows use a multi-camera set-up. The only exception in feature films or dramatic television shows is when shooting something you can't easily reproduce such as a car crash, an explosion, a collapsing building, etc. When only used one camera except when the stunt guy fell off the industrial complex at the end. We used two on that. And still had him do the fall four times. Some background on the film. I wrote it several years ago between two work-for-hire screenwriting jobs. That's sort of my day job. Besides being a university instructor, I am a hired gun on screenwriting. I took a break between two jobs and banged out Fatal Call (titled Call Me on Tuesday at the time) in 21 days. I tossed it to my producer and he liked it but wanted changes (which is normal). I did several more drafts and we shot it in 15 days in September, 2011. A few weeks after principal photography, we did 2 days of pickups with stunt-people, helicopter shots, the car chase, establishing shots, sunrise, etc. I edited a rough cut in about 2 weeks, my producer requested changes, I made those, he requested a few more, I made those, and the editing was done. That process was about 6 weeks working sort of part-time on it. Score and final sound mix took a few more months, then it was done. A writer/director at my level has no input in the marketing once a sales agent/distributor is contracted. Same with my producer, he has no (or very little) input. Redbox called the shots on the artwork; we were not happy but at the end of the day, it is what it is. My goal as a filmmaker is to eventually make studio-level films. So I strive to make my indie films look and feel as close to a Hollywood studio film as possible. I try this with very limited resources. You noticed that! And to me, that's what counts the most! Thank you so much for your review! :-)
CosmicConservative
Jack, I almost commented on the two detectives providing comic relief. I didn't because I was afraid that wasn't the intent and it would be taken more as an unfair criticism of the writing. I probably should have included that note because I did think that might have been your intent. If I had been involved in the review and editing of this movie here are some very specific things I would have suggested: 1. If you really wanted to have the ruffians scene to demonstrate Mitch's potential combat prowess, you could also have used that for comedic effect at the same time, which would have accomplished two things for you and avoided the temptation to turn the detectives into Mutt and Jeff. 2. I feel that I have not been clear about the sexual stuff. I am not suggesting that the sex scenes should have been more explicit. I am suggesting that they should have been more evocative and the nature of the encounter should have been more indicative of Amy being in control and explicitly satisfying some deep cravings that Mitch had never had fulfilled. As it was the scenes were filmed as if Mitch was the actual sexual aggressor, and in all the scenes I can recall, Amy was the passive recipient of the attentions. I think there are ways that the filming could have actually been less explicit but still advanced the notion that Amy was (perhaps literally) blowing Mitch's ever-loving mind. Scenes with him laying in bed, closup on his face as Amy is doing SOMETHING to him off-scene may have even been more evocative because they let the viewer's imagination run wild. In some ways this could have even been done post-coital, with Mitch literally exhausted on the bed saying things like "I've never done anything like that!" With Amy cooing "You like it? I'll do anything you want Mitch. ANYTHING you want." Then, a short scene with Mitch and Ted or Simon walking to lunch the next day. "How was it you dog you?" "Oh my god Simon, you cannot imagine what that woman can do to a man..." I think the movie would have been more believable if the ruffian scene had ended with the punch to the face and Mitch getting away, with the additional time you had devoted to really exploring what a deep craving need Amy was fulfilling in Mitch. Add a scene with Amy showing up at Mitch's workplace and savagely seducing him there for example. I think you were trying to make a movie that was more mental than physical, and one reason I think the ruffians were a bad fit is because the time you spent on them could have been better spent reinforcing the mind games Amy was playing and Mitch's fall into "I'll do just about anything you want, if you'll just keep on fulfilling my innermost desires." "Oh, what about murder?" "Murder!? I can't do that..... can I?"
Jack
Those are all great points, CC! Oh well... 20/20 hindsight and all. Since you're working on a novel (I assume you're still working on it) you know how difficult it can be to structure a story. So many decisions, so many possible directions. With movies, there's a saying. It states, "There's the film you write, the film you shoot, and the film you end up with. And all three are different." No matter how big your budget or how long your shooting, your finished film is never what is actually on the page. There's various reasons for this. Some are creative (director, writer, producer, or principle actor has some new ideas) and some are due to things beyond your control such as the weather, loss of location, main cast or crew falling ill. We only had a 3 hour window on a specific day to shoot the final scene in Fatal Call, the exterior scene with the emergency vehicles. And guess what, it was raining. So what did we do? We threw a tent over the camera and sound gear and shot it in the rain. Emergencies in the real world happen in the rain and the personnel have to just deal with it, so we just had to deal with it too. That we suggested it was planned by adding a little thunder on the soundtrack to the previous scene. The showdown scene at the industrial complex was originally supposed to be an abandoned house at night. Then it became the industrial complex at night. But that was deemed to expensive to light, so we just moved it to daytime. There are many stories I could tell about changes to both my films. I have to say: Filmmaking can give you a neverending headache sometimes but I absolutely love it! And I can't imagine doing anything else.
Jack
Some great unscripted, improvised moments in film: The Empire Strikes Back. Leia: "I love you!" Han: "I know." He was supposed to say "I love you too" but Irving Kirschner, the director, felt it was flat and predictable so he just told Ford to something else, anything else, on the next take. Indiana Jones and The Temple of Doom. Indie pulls out his gun and shoots the swordman. In the script, he's supposed to fight him. Taxi Driver. De Niro to himself in the mirror: "you talking to me!" He was just rehearsing. The Warriors. Luthor with the beer bottles on his fingers: "Warriors... come out to plaaaayaaaa!" Thought up on the spot to replace what was written because it just wasn't working. And many many more...
CosmicConservative
Jack, I hear you about the end result not always matching the original vision. That is even true with writing books. As you note, as you produce the material that your vision demands, viewing the material exposes flaws and opportunities that the original vision did not anticipate. Which either have to be worked to conform to the original vision, or the original vision shifts if the opportunities discovered provide a more compelling narrative than the original vision. I have experienced that in spades man. In spades. I have twice "finished" my book, in terms of "completing the story" and even now, after a "final final draft" I have decided I missed some opportunities and have some flaws that need to be fixed. At some point you almost have to just say "this is not exactly what I envisioned, but I have to get SOMETHING done." This is a healthy discussion for me though, I need to get back to my book's latest version of its vision. :) By the way, I mostly tried to address things in the movie that I thought could be take-aways for your future efforts as opposed to nit-picking things. My final evaluation of the movie is that I think it demonstrates that you have mastered the fundamental skills of movie-making, and have even managed to go beyond the mechanical aspects to focus on presenting a vision of your own. I would say that in this case you didn't fully accomplish that goal, but I am confident that your next movie will be tighter, more internally consistent and have a more dramatic narrative. I look forward to it. Keep me informed. :)
CosmicConservative
Oh, and if you are willing, I'd be more than happy to help with edits or just provide feedback if you want.
Jack
I strive to make each film better (in some way) than my previous films. I keep learning from my experiences (at least try to) and keep moving forward. You brought up something that is very important! Something I tell other filmmakers, writers, and students, over and over. There comes a point when you have to say, "I need to just finish this, in whatever shape it's in, and move on!" An artist can always look back on their work and find areas of improvement. Always. Since there will always be room for improvement no matter how long you work on anything, you must pick a point ("after this draft I'm done!) and stick with it. Otherwise, you'll just go crazy! There is another saying in film that I'm sure applies to every artistic endeavor. And that is, "A film is never finished, it is just abandoned." I do not strive for perfection when making a film (life is too short). What I do instead is to try to make the best film I can at that moment in my life, with what life experiences I have, and writing/directing experience I have, and resources available at that time, and how much time I have to do it. And that's basically it. A pretty simple formula. And then try to learn from that and channel that experience into my next film. And so on and so on. Wash, dry, repeat. In my opinion, you should do one last draft of your novel and address the points that you feel you need to (as long as it doesn't lead to an entire rewrite which I believe would be counter-productive) and then declare it done! Then try to go through whatever channels you need to get it published. And if it's rejected for publication, look into self-publication even if it's just a digital download through Amazon and other online sources. I made a feature-film in the 80s, a horror film. And it was indeed horrid! In all the wrong ways! LOL! It cost me 40K. Troma (the people who did The Toxic Avenger) offered me 10K. I made the mistake of not taking it. I should've just accepted I was going to lose money on it and get it out there and be done with it. At least with Troma it would've gotten some kind of nationwide release. As it was, I ended up selling VHS copies to local video stores and made a couple hundred dollars. It was a 40K lesson but I got it out there locally then moved on. Lesson learned. You need to finish and take the plunge. And however it ends up is how it ends up. Then move on to your next novel. :-) I will definitely keep you informed of my filmmaking endeavors. As for as feedback, I'll think about it. I have to say, I have plenty of people lined up for that :-D but I will certainly think about it. Thanks!
CosmicConservative
Excellent advice. I do have one final change I am making in my story. I had set up a massive battle throughout most of the book, but the narrative was focused on the protagonist learning how to master his own abilities and fulfill his own destiny. I had previously thought that I would have him come into his birthright as the final climax of the first book, with the battle being resolved as the first part of the second book. I now realize that a book with the epic scope of this one NEEDS a resolution like the final battle, and that the realization and mastery of his abilities is what allows the protagonist to lead the "good guys" to defeat and rout the invaders, setting up the second book to be the larger battle for the entire continent as I had already intended. Moving the battle's finale into the first book provides a suitably dramatic climax, while at the same time allowing me to separate the protagonist from his past since the revelation of his abilities turns his own people against him. I probably have a couple days worth of dedicated writing to make these revisions. Now it's just making myself take that time.
Dadman
One of the unique attributes of a profession in the creative arts is the fact that EVERYONE seems to have an opinion, sometimes very strong ones, regarding the quality of your work. Artists must have thick skins. :) I haven't seen your new film yet, Jack, but will check it out as soon as possible.
Jack
CC, having a final resolution of a major story for the first book is a good, and necessary move. You're readers must feel some closure even if you have some loose ends. This is just in case you never write the second book. Hopefully that won't happen but we never know what tomorrow will bring. Dadman, yeah, I have a pretty think skin! :-D I try to learn from honest critiques of my work. Hope you get a chance to check out the film soon. Sorry I've been slow to respond, guys. I got married a few months ago and my wife, her son, and I just moved to LA and we're still getting settled in. That was an 1800 mile move! Whoa! But it's great!
Jack
CC, I meant "final resolution of a major story arc". Forgot the word 'arc'.
Jack
I just read through my comments and noticed how sloppy my writing has been. Sorry, just exhausted and distracted.
Dadman
Where did you move from, Jack? For some reason I thought you were already living in SoCal.
CosmicConservative
I buckled down yesterday and churned out 2,500 words revising the ending to include the final battle. I have to weave it into the existing book and make sure I didn't create any loose ends of contradictions, but I think it came out OK. I'll have to let it sit for a day or two and reread it to be sure. But getting that into the book properly will finally make the book feel like it is truly complete, and has the sort of climactic ending that an epic story needs, even as it opens up a larger conflict for the next book.
Jack
Dadman: I'm from St. Louis. Have traveled to LA on a regular basis for filmmaking reasons. My wife and I thought it was time I take the plunge. And it's normal that you would've thought I lived in SoCal. For the last several years in St. Louis I would routinely run into friends I hadn't seen in a while and they also thought I had moved to LA. CC: That's great! Keep chugging away at it and get it done! For me the feeling of accomplishment is beyond satisfying; I can only assume it's the same for everyone.