Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Iraq, 9/11 and Pearl Harbor

By CosmicConservative
Next time a liberal friend pulls out the tired old argument that Iraq had nothing to do with 9/11, and therefore invading Iraq is immoral and illegal, remind them that in 1941 the Japanese bombed Pearl Harbor, and in response to that, the United States immediately attacked Germany.

Comments (18)

fred
Wrong. Germany had attacked and invaded our closest allies for over two years, had attacked our merchant shipping prior to 12/7/41, and declared war on us first. Only after all of this did we attack Germany. Next time you argue with your liberal friend I hope you get your facts straight.
CosmicConservative
If your premise is correct, why did we wait until attacked by Japan to respond to Germany? The reality is that pacifistic liberals and Nazi sympathizers in the US had opposed going to war in Europe for years and FDR knew that the Pearl Harbor attack was all that was needed to goad the US into war, and that fine distinctions between Japan and Germany would no longer matter to the public. Hitler, who had for months or years, been angry at the US for the Lend-Lease program and other outright support of Britain and other allies received word that a declaration of War on Germany from the US was imminent, and decided to pre-empt that and declare war on the US first. But the immediate war planning on the day after Pearl Harbor in the Pentagon was fully directed at the European theater, in line with war plans drawn up before the Pearl Harbor attack. So the declaration of war by Germany was pointless, FDR was going after Hitler first regardless. If Pearl Harbor was truly the spark that triggered an American response, with the US in a declared war with both Japan and Germany, and Japan being the only aggressor who had attaced us on our soil, the logic in use today by liberals on Iraq would compel you to say that Japan should have been our first target. But we chose Germany. Next time you argue with your conservative opponents, get your histry, your timeline and geopolitical motivations right.
fred
Wrong again. The timeline is correct and I stated no premise. Yes, 12/7/41 tipped the balance away from our isolationism, and war with Japan made war with Germany unavoidable. But no, we did not immediately attack Germany in response to Pearl Harbor, as you erroneously stated. We joined the war in Europe for quite different reasons.
CosmicConservative
I guess "immediately" is a relative term. If that's all you've got left, you've got very little left. In case you were unaware, FDR was criticized for attacking Germany for exactly the same reason, because Japan attacked us first. That's why the whole comparison is relevant.
fred
So, you're saying that after Pearl Harbor we attacked Germany in response to Pearl Harbor before attacking Japan? Which attack was that? What was the date? You're also saying that it was because of "pacifistic liberals and Nazi sympathizers" that we didn't enter the war in Europe sooner? Apparently you are not aware of the role played by conservative isolationists and anti-semites who hoped Hitler would destroy the USSR. Before you stretch your analogy too far, you might be wise to consider all of the profound differences and not just the rather superficial similarities.
CosmicConservative
Fred: If I recall correctly our first combat units to enter the war were units sent to Great Britain in January of 1942. American pilots and crews served alongside RAF crews on RAF flights throughout the first part of 1942 while US bases were set up and US equipment was staged. The first full-blown US only attacks were sometime in the summer of 1942, but actual bombing of Germany itself was several months later, maybe not until 1943. Our first active efforts in North Africa were in April or May of 1942 when US troops supported British actions in North Africa. The "invasion" of North Africa ("Operation Torch?") Occurred later in 1942, perhaps late autumn or winter I think. In the meantime US forces were being systematically clobbered by the Japanese in the Pacific, with perhaps the largest blow being in Bataan where several thousand US troops surrendered because the US was not able to supply or relieve them. Several naval engagements occurred in the Pacific, with most being Japanese victories until June 1942 when the US won the Battle of Midway, which finally stopped the Japanese advance. From that point on the US held the Japanese at bay, or forced them slowly back. But Europe was the priority for the Army although the Marines saw significant efforts in the Pacific. That's about as well as I can recall events without looking them up and publishing a timeline. You are absolutely correct about the role of conservative isolationists in the resistance to war in Europe. I should have been more fair on that point and listed both sides. Also it is fair to say that Nazi sympathizers were on both sides of the aisle. The analogy is apt, although the details are definitely debatable. Thanks for your posting.
fred
My pleasure. Several US attacks against Japanese forces and the Japanese mainlaind occured within a few months of Pearl Harbor which initiated the Battles of the Java Sea and the Coral Sea. Most notable was the Doolittle air attack on Tokyo. Yes, US troop deployment to Britain occurred early along with US participation in British commanded operations. Yes, there were disasterous naval losses early in the Pacific. But let's see how your analogy is holding up: "...remind them that in 1941 the Japanese bombed Pearl Harbor, and in response to that, the United States immediately attacked Germany." The fact is that there was never any attack on Germany in response to Pearl Harbor. And contrary to your implication, the US retaliated early and hard against Japan for starting the war in the Pacific.
CosmicConservative
Fred: I consider an attack on German troops in Europe or North Africa to be an Attack on Germany. I'm sure you will agree that Germany held the same opinion. There was never any attack on Iraq because of the 9/11 attack either, there is just a perception that there was because the 9/11 attack changed the dynamic and galvanized the American public to make them more willing to accept a war than they would have otherwise, and yes I believe GW Bush took advantage of that just as FDR took advantage of US outrage over Pearl Harbor to initiate hostilities against Germany after Pearl Harbor. You and I can argue the fine details of this all you want. You make some good points and I give you credit for them. I haven't seen you respond in kind yet. You can parse "attack Germany" to mean only an attack on the German mainland if you like, I don't think you will find many people who agree with that perspective. You can also parse "immediately" to mean "the next day" if you like, in reality it takes a significant amount of time to mobilize the military. I'll back off the "immediately" and replace it with " as soon as was feasible" if you'll admit that attacking German troops is considered to be an attack on Germany itself. Deal?
fred
I have given credit to some of your points. See above. Here. I'll give you some more: Yes, an attack against German forces anywhere was an attack against Germany itself. And yes, it takes time to mount an attack: a few months is pretty quick. But you're not responding to my objection: the US did NOT attack Germany in response to Pearl Harbor.
CosmicConservative
Fred, you and I are going to have to disagree. FDR was looking for an excuse to go to war with Germany and Pearl Harbor gave him that excuse. Our initial attacks on Germany were the direct result of the Pearl Harbor attack. And FDR took some heat for focusing so much on Europe when Japan was the country that attacked us. In fact FDR was accused of allowing the Pearl Harbor attack to occur precisely so he could use that as an excuse to go to war with Germany, just as GW Bush has been accused of allowing the 9/11 attack to occur so he could go to war with Iraq to avenge "his daddy" as so many liberals like to write it. That is why this analogy is not just singly apt, but doubly apt. Yes it is likely, in fact it was inevitable that we would have gone to war with Germany anyway, but the single historical event that led to the actual military engagement occurring was Pearl Harbor, but if you don't agree with that, then you and I will just have to agree to amicably disagree. By the way, I always enjoy a discussion with a rational person, liberal or conservative, so I have enjoyed this exchange. I wish more folks of both sides of the aisle could read, fashion a reasonable and logical response, and put it on paper without resorting to name calling. I appreciate your posting here.
fred
I agree that immediately after 12/7/41 the dam burst and WWII went into full swing. I do not agree that any attack on Germany was in response to the attack on Pearl Harbor. It is only by "arguing fine details" that your statement makes any sense at all. “…remind them that in 1941 the Japanese bombed Pearl Harbor, and in response to that, the United States immediately attacked Germany.” It is much more accurate to say, "the Japanese bombed Pearl Harbor, and in response to that, the United States immediately attacked Japan." You have yet to aknowledge that the US attacked Japan first and in response to Pearl Harbor. You have yet to point to any attack on Germany in response to Pearl Harbor. Simply pointing out the obvious fact that the US entered the war in Europe immediately after Pearl Harbor isn't supporting your statement. I think you need to reformulate your analogy and think twice about using "tired old arguments" involving comparisons between Operation Iraqi Freedom and WWII.
fred
Would you say that our declaration of war on Germany was a response to the attack on Pearl Harbor?
CosmicConservative
Fred: I think I've made my argument and leave it up to other readers to decide if I have made the case that the US used the Pearl Harbor attack to justify war in Europe as well as war in Japan. Since you seem enamored of fine parsing of words, let me point out to you that nothing in my initial post indicated what the US did or did not do regarding Japan. I furhter clarified it in response to your comments to say that attacks against Germany and Japan (not to mention Italy) were soon to follow. The point I was making still stands and is still completely valid. FDR was accused of allowing the Pearl Harbor attack to occur with full knowledge that it would cause thousands of U.S. fatalities. The supposed purpose of this dastardly accusation is that FDR was desperately worried about Europe in general and Great Britain in particular, and wanted an excuse to go to war with Germany. It should be obvious that an attack from Japan would initiate hostilities WITH Japan, it would not seem necessary to point out that the US declared war on Japan the next day, that goes in the category of "obvious." I would say that our declaration of war against Germany was a response to years of FDR's growing concerns about Hitler's global ambitions, the overruning of Europe and the imminent invasion of Great Britain. With the probably "official" cause being that Germany declared war first. But I hope you are not one of those who believe the "official" cause is the actual casus belli in the vast majority of declared war in the history of the world. However Fred, NONE of what happened prior to the attack on Pearl Harbor had been enough to convince the country to go to war on either front. Pearl Harbor was the trigger that allowed FDR to rally the country. So, yes, the Pearl Harbor attack did lead directly to the US going to war with Germany. I don't think there's much more we can dive into on this one, you and I are in deep disagreement. I think History is on my side though, not yours, and as with all debates on this blog, I never declare "win" or "loss" I simply allow the readers to draw their own conclusions. I maintain that the analogy is accurate, useful and works on two levels. In both cases the US went to war with an enemy that was not directly involved in the triggering event that allowed the war to occur, and in both cases the political enemies of the President accused the President of allowing US citizens to die as martyrs to a personal cause that they had not been able to pursue without the triggering event. Your mileage may vary. I'll let the readers choose for themselves who made the better case.
CosmicConservative
As far as my initial post not being detailed enough to satisfy you, it was not targeted at you and stands on its own merit without the exhaustive detail you demanded for those who know history well enough that they did not need the detailed explanation. Not that such detail was enough to convince you anyway. Like I said, I leave the evaluation of who is "right" as an exercise to the reader. On to other issues now.
fred
Sorry if this is a duplicate post. The first one didn't immediately appear the way most other posts have. ----------------------------------------------- If you will reread my remarks above you will see that I am in complete agreement that Pearl Harbor was a watershed event in the timeline of WWII and ushered in the US effort on the side of the Allies, even though conscription and mobilization had been well underway for over a year. But was Pearl Harbor the exclusive trigger to our declaration of war on Germany? I am mindful of the opinion reflected by the following extract: "The American public would have been quite content with dealing with Japan and leaving the European War to the Europeans. The treachery of the Japanese attack burned bright in the minds of most Americans, and they wanted revenge. If not for the declaration of war by Germany, Roosevelt would have had a hard time justifying declaring war on Germany until Japan was destroyed. But Germany did declare war, and the U-boats moved to the Eastern seaboard in January 1942." http://worldwar2database.com/html/us_war.htm I don't agree that we would have been "quite content" to let Europe burn. But I do think that FDR would have had a hard time getting a declaration against Germany on 12/11/41 without Hitler's declaration against us and his immediate attacks on shipping and threat to the mainland. FDR wanted war with Germany. Hitler handed it to him on a plate. That was quite a triggering event in itself, wouldn't you agree? All of which is ignored by your analogy. I think the first level of your analogy is suspect because the Joint Resolution to Use Force in Iraq mentions September 11, 2001 six times and attempts to link Iraq to 9/11. In contrast, FDR's request for and Congress' declaration of war against Germany doesn't refer to Japan's attack on Pearl Harbor or Germany's alliances. http://www.law.ou.edu/ushistory/germwar.shtml I think you would be hard pressed to document American sentiment for revenge on Germany for Pearl Harbor. This is quite different from American sentiment toward Iraq viz-a-viz 9/11. The second level of your analogy may have some merit if you think conspiracy theories from the fringe are "useful."
CosmicConservative
Fred: I've made my case, and I have no desire to continue to dig deeper and deeper into the psyche of the nation, the edges of history and to begin posting competing links to views expressed on other websites. You are welcome to the last word, I don't think it helps your case or weakens mine, so I remain content to let the readers decide.
fred
Readers? Hmmm. Thanks, Cosmo, for not yielding to the temptation to cut off debate by exercising editorial control. Believe me, some other blogoids wouldn't have let me get this far. It's been fun. I enjoy digging deep. Let's do it again sometime. Dangle the same kind of bait and I just might bite. Come, Tonto. Our work here is done. Hi-yo Silver, away!
CosmicConservative
Feel free to comment on any post you like, don't hesitate to send your friends here too. I do have readers, three our four anyway. Not sure why they've been so silent in this particular thread. I'll assume they thought that one or both of us was covering the issue adequately and needed no help and preferred to read and enjoy the exchange. Keep in mind that although I try to keep things "rational" (thus my tagline as a "Rational Conservative") it is nevertheless still a conservative blog and most of my readers lean towards the right. Or at least I think they do.