Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Sane judge overturns insane moonbat judge

By CosmicConservative
The judgment to suspend the Bush Administration terrorist monitoring program by moonbat activist judge Anna Taylor has been overturned by a federal appeals court. Of course this is no surprise to anybody with a brain. Now perhaps we can get an actual legal ruling on this that is readable and rational. In the meantime, let's catch some more terrorists and stop some more attacks.

Comments (4)

George Ponder
SO IT IS YOUR THINKING THAT BY GIVING UP ALL OUR RIGHTS TO THE PRESIDENT WE CAN CATCH ALL THE TERRORISTS? Give us a break. If you knew anything about the so-called Patriots Act, you would know that now anyone, for no reason can be thrown into prison, with no one's knowledge, and treated like a terrorist simply because someone in Bush's government says the person is a terrorist. And can be held without any charges for as long as desired by the government. Furthermore, you talk exactly like most of the Bush people: you name call - in this instance your reference to a judge who rules as you desire is SANE, and the judge who sees it another way as INSANE. This is exactly how you and I both will end in a prison when you wake from your sleep and begin to understand what Bush is doing to the freedoms of this country with his "rubber stamp" congress. He has done absolute nothing but lie since September 11: about everything, such as terrorists in Iraq when Saddam would not allow terrorists in his country. Bush lied to the public to get them to believe all he said about Iraq. And how about Plame. No need to go over that lie again. Good luck after your numbered days as the American public is sick of the perverse republicans, unless of course the paperless voting puts republicans back in the same seats. Probably even Foley would get re elected with those machines.
CosmicConservative
George: I want to sincerely thank you for posting on my site. It is important for both sides to be able to hear and respond to the other. On the internet it is all too frequent that each side stays with their ideological peers and simply reinforce each others beliefs. This is how groupthink happens. So you posting here is a step towards breaking that groupthink. Now, to address your concerns:
"SO IT IS YOUR THINKING THAT BY GIVING UP ALL OUR RIGHTS TO THE PRESIDENT WE CAN CATCH ALL THE TERRORISTS?"
What rights have you given up George? You are aware, I hope, that the program the Bush administration is following to intercept phone calls from overseas to this country from suspected terrorists is very similar to the "echelon" system that has been in use for over a decade, and which Clinton defended himself. Clinton claimed to have exactly the same executive powers that Bush is exercising now, and Clinton used them not only to "spy" on overseas phone calls, but on internal truly domestic calls. So if you are giving up rights with this decision, you gave them up long before GW Bush came into office.
If you knew anything about the so-called Patriots Act, you would know that now anyone, for no reason can be thrown into prison, with no one’s knowledge, and treated like a terrorist simply because someone in Bush’s government says the person is a terrorist."
You realize, I assume, that the Patriot Act itself is modeled after the RICO laws that have been in effect for over a decade to combat organized crime and drug peddling, right? I hope you realize that. The vast majority of the Patriot Act was designed to give the government the same capability in fighting terrorism that they had in fighting organized crime. The rest of it is mostly allowing the CIA, FBI and other Law enforcement agencies to share information, something the Clinton administration specifically enacted laws to separate those agencies and make it illegal for them to share information. Your assertion that Bush is using the Patriot Act to throw innocent people into jail on trumped up terrorism charges is no more valid than my assertion that Clinton used RICO to throw innocent people into jail on trumped up drug or organized crime charges. The number of lives that have been ruined in the "War on Drugs" vastly outnumbers the number of lives that have been ruined by the Patriot Act. Since you aren't screaming about Clinton's use of the existing laws to go after people in Waco or Ruby Ridge, I have to assume that you are OK with the giving up of rights if those giving up their rights are somehow the people you think SHOULD give up their rights.
Furthermore, you talk exactly like most of the Bush people: you name call - in this instance your reference to a judge who rules as you desire is SANE, and the judge who sees it another way as INSANE. This is exactly how you and I both will end in a prison when you wake from your sleep and begin to understand
I said her ruling was insane because it was insane. If you don't like the word "insane" I'll replace it with "incompetent". Read the overuling decision George, and read some analysis even from Left leaning legal scholars. The initial ruling was batty. It was poorly reasoned and poorly written. That's what I said when it was handed down, and that's basically what the appeals court said today. I think it was an insane ruling. Your hysterical paranoia about ending up in prison when I wake up is a testable hypothesis George. Check with me in 1, 5, 10, 20 and 40 years. I'll bet you a thousand dollars per year that I don't end up in prison on trumped up patriot act charges. Each year I stay out of prison, you pay up. Or shut up. How's that for putting your money where your mouth is?
what Bush is doing to the freedoms of this country with his “rubber stamp” congress. He has done absolute nothing but lie since September 11: about everything, such as terrorists in Iraq when Saddam would not allow terrorists in his country. Bush lied to the public to get them to believe all he said about Iraq.
You tell me that I sound like one of the Bushies, and then you go off on this hysterical paranoid moonbat rant. You say Bush lied. Prove it. So far every investigation that has been performed has vindicated him. If you can't prove he lied, then you're just a ranting partisan hack. I love this argument anyway. All but a handful of Democrats voted to go to war in Iraq, including Hillary Clinton, John Kerry and John Edwards. So you tell me George, are they just stupid gullible idiots who are easily fooled by a moron like George Bush? If so, what level of intelligence does that mean they have? Or if they aren't gullible fools who were led down the lily path by a moron, are they simply feckless boobs following the fickle finger of public opinion? It must be one or the other George, so take your pick. At least George W. Bush and I have stated our principles, charted our path and stuck to it.
And how about Plame. No need to go over that lie again.
What lie George? Joe Wilson's lie about what he told the CIA about yellow-cake uranium? The 9/11 commission said that Joe Wilson's actual report to the CIA supported the yellow cake uranium story, go read it yourself. Or Joe Wilson's lie about his wif'es "covert" status? Or Joe Wilson's lie about who "outed" his wife in the first place? If you are still playing the Bush conspiracy game on the Plame game, then you are beyond help and living in a fantasy world. That ship has sailed George, and apparently it left you on moonbat island.
Good luck after your numbered days as the American public is sick of the perverse republicans, unless of course the paperless voting puts republicans back in the same seats. Probably even Foley would get re elected with those machines.
I guess we'll see. Every actual case of voter fraud that was documented in the 2000 and 2004 elections were committed by Democrats, not Republicans. If it makes you feel better to think that you are getting beat at the polls because the other side cheats, then I will only say that one thing I have noticed in life is that people tend to accuse others of that which they are predisposed to do themselves. Come back soon.
CosmicConservative
One other point. I don't disagree with your statement that America is sick of the Republicans in Congress. I certainly am. They have been monumentally inept in running this country. They have allowed a minority of Democrats to drive their agenda, they have undermined the Bush administration by courting favorable public opinion, they have spent money like drunken sailors, they have apparently had a surgical spine-ectomy, I could go on for a long time. Perhaps it is time for the Democrats to come back into power. Unlike you George, I don't attack the entire Democratic party, or even the entire population of liberals. I don't think Democrats are evil. I don't think liberals are stupid. I think Democrats by and large are good, decent people who are trying to do the right thing. I think exactly the same thing about Republicans. I will be disappointed if Democrats win the house and senate for obvious reasons, but I can very definitely promise you this. Seeing Democrats in power will not unhinge me to the point that your post shows you are unhinged by Republicans. I have a lot more important things in my life to worry about than whether Hillary Clinton is secretly trying to sneak into my house and plant bugs in my underwear so she can spirit me away some dark night on trumped up charges of being a neocon. See, that's why I call myself a "rational" conservative. I don't get all hysterical and start throwing around unfounded charges of conspiracy when I don't get my way at the polls. You do, obviously. But I don't. Let the Democrats run things. I lived through Clinton and Carter. One thing I have learned is that all things change. You'll get your turn, and I'll get mine. That's how it works. That's WHY it works. That's why it will continue to work long after GW Bush is building his Presidential Library and you have moved your wild hysteria to some other neocon target so you can maintain your manufactured outrage as long as you possibly can. I'll just watch, wait and hope for the best. In the meantime, if President Hillary Clinton comes to Colorado and I meet her in a bookstore, I will be polite, respectful and will truly be wishing her the best in her pursuit of her duties to the best of her ability. Goodnight George.
Drax
The initial ruling was done by a person who was either insane or handed down knowingly as against every applicable principle. In Judges, this is not "incompetence," it is malfeasence. This particular judge was shopped for, chosen for her partisan political hack opinions. The moonbats knew what her ruling would be before they filed the petition. Her opinion was more akin to George's rant than an actual learned judicial opinion, and was treated with as much respect by almost every legal scholar as would George's. George is living in his own Michael Moore of a world. Facts do not inform him. Plame? We don't need to know no steenking facts! Iraq? Subsequently finding WMD's -- of no importance. Previous use of WMD's -- niggling details. Seventeen UN resolutions to stop making WMD's, the intelligence services of just about every Western country convinced of the presence of WMD's and continued WMD production -- don't bother me with these things! George apparently did not read your description of yourself as a "rational conservative." Rational discourse, even with the most liberal of people, has the possibility of persuasion. Facts, in these discussions, are supposed to actually inform our decisions. Poor George, however, simply cannot bother himself with either finding the facts or paying attention to them when others bring those facts to his attention.