Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Clinton vs. Foley

By CosmicConservative
I've heard a lot of conservatives compare the Foley scandal with the Monica Lewinsky scandal which overshadows much of Bill Clinton's "legacy". I've also heard a lot of conservatives say that the comparison is unfair since Lewinsky was an adult and the comparison makes conservatives look overly partisan. My take is that there are legitimate comparisons between the two situations, it is not completely partisan to make a comparison between the two. The comparisons that I think are legitimate are the following ones: 1. Both situations involved an extremely powerful figure who was using his power to gain sexual gratification from a person or persons who were in positions of responsibility under them and who could reasonably expect to gain career or professional benefits from the relationship if the powerful figure was satisfied, or to be hurt by the relationship if the powerful figure was unsatisfied. This has very little to do with age, it is mostly about abuse of a position of power. 2. Both situations involved an implied employer/employee relationship which brings in the entire issue of sexual harassment in the workplace. 3. Both situations involved a public figure in a position of trust who is working with idealistic young people sent to our nation's capital by parents and family members who believed they could trust the system and the people who run the system with their sons or daughters. The two significant differences in the two situations are these: 1. The one case is traditionally heterosexual in nature, while the other is not. 2. The one case clearly involves consenting adults, while the other case involves an adult engaged in activity with non-adults. I have seen some people try to say that the age of consent in Florida is 16. That is true only if the "adult" partner is under the age of 24, so does not apply here. Although I am sure that this is something Foley's attorneys are looking at. So I think it is completely reasonable to condemn Foley doubly for his actions, first for all of the same things Clinton did with Monica Lewinsky, but then to further condemn him for consorting with minors. So if you want to throw Clinton in the face of some of the liberal attack dogs who defended Clinton, be sure to tell them that 75% of the issue we have with Foley, applied equally to Clinton.

Comments (2)

Drax
A couple of things. 1. The age of consent is meaningless as there is no indication that there was any "sex" to consent to. 2. Washington D.C., as I understand it, does have an age of consent of 16. (Isn't Colorado's 15?) The above being considered, it would appear from what we have thus far seen, that no law has been broken. Even had he bedded the 16 year old page (in D.C.) no law would have been broken. So, it would follow that any E-mails or instant messages sent with the purpose to bed the 16 year old were legally harmless since the act itself was legally permissible. (One can assume that bedding a person entails some conversation leading towards that end...) It would seem to me that the ONLY question of importance here is whether or not he used his position of power to obtain sexual favors. If so, then this is sexual harassment. While I think that a man of his age using his position to attempt to bed 16 year olds is deplorable, I haven't seen anything which he has done which is ILLEGAL, or, apparently in the eyes of Washington D.C. legislators, immoral (else they would have a different age requirement for the age of consent.) I just am, as usual, aghast at the REPUBLICAN response to the Liberal hypocrisy. We should be on the attack on this matter, highlighting the Democrat response to Barny Frank's transgressions, to Clinton's pardons...etc. But, they continue to allow the liberal attack dogs to set the agenda, constantly being on the defensive.
CosmicConservative
Hmm... where is my head at? Of course it is Washington DC's age of consent that is at issue here, not Florida's... Excellent points all. The purpose of my post was to encourage conservatives to make Democratic comparisons to this case. I think they are apt and reveal the deep hypocrisy of the Left.