Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

What about, you know, those "other" races?

By CosmicConservative
Yeah, I've more or less ignored the state of the House, Senate and possible gubernatorial elections on the ballot tomorrow. As well as other things like amendments and referendums. Here's the deal. I think that all boils down to how the Presidential election goes. I see it as four possibilities: 1. An Obama blowout. In this case we will probably see the Democrats pick up a few more Senate seats and probably five or six House seats. Really they should pick up more, but the Democrat House Re-election Committee has badly screwed up these elections by trying to demonize the Romney/Ryan budget. That attempt fell flatter than a pancake, and as a result Republican candidates have been able to run positive campaigns which will get a lot of them re-elected. 2. An Obama squeaker. In this case I expect the Senate to remain about where it is now, maybe a shift of a couple of seats towards the Democrats. House Republicans will probably end up about where they are now too. 3. A Romney squeaker. Since Romney did not campaign heavily in any House or Senate races, I don't expect him to have any significant impact on those races if he just manages to win. I would expect the same results here as an Obama squeaker. 4. A Romney blowout. This would be huge and would shock the punditry, not only because it would show how badly they have read the minds of the electorate, but because such a result would mean very heavy Republican turnout in swing states, and that would tip several House and Senate races to the Republican side just through the sheer number of Republican tickets being voted. As such I would expect Republicans to pick up 2 - 4 Senate seats and probably an equal number of House seats. There are some key initiatives on the ballot in states like Michigan which might fail if Romney wins those states. If Michigan votes against the Union sponsored bill to mandate union membership, that will be the biggest story outside of the Presidential race itself. But I don't expect it to fail. I do not think there is any realistic chance for the Democrats to take the House, nor do I think there is any realistic chance for the Republicans to take the Senate, regardless of the outcome of the Presidential race.

Comments (22)

Dadman
Perhaps I've lost my mind, but I think #4 is the most likely outcome. If I must eat crow please ensure it is fresh with a side of green beans and new potatoes. Thanks...
Drax
It's looking more and more like a 320-341 EC victory. Should be a 5 seat gain in the Senate. Maybe a 4-8 gain in the House. Go team!
CosmicConservative
Drax, I think you mean 320-218 EC victory?
Drax
Heh. No meant that Romney will get somewhere between 320 and 341 electoral votes.
CosmicConservative
Oh... Well. I don't see that. To get even to 320 Romney would have to run the table on all current "toss-up" states AND pick up a couple of "leans Obama". I just don't see that. In fact I think it is more likely that Romney will squeak by after losing Ohio by picking up Wisconsin, Minnesota, Iowa and the single Maine vote. And I think that's nigh impossible.
Dadman
So CC, you believe an Obama victory is a lock? Maybe. But I remember what happened in 2010 and I don't think the electoral dynamics have changed much since then...
CosmicConservative
Dadman, no I still have hope that the polls are oversampling Democrats and the enthusiasm gap will pull out a win for Romney. I just don't think the odds are really high of that. My best guess right now is that Obama ekes out a very close victory with Ohio going his way by less than a percent. I would put the odds of a Romney win in the 40 - 45% range at best. Possible, but I wouldn't bet the mortgage on it. I hope I'm wrong. I was wrong about Bush v Gore, I had predicted a Gore win.
CosmicConservative
By the way, I've hinted at this before, but in my mind this race boils down really to one question. Will Democrats vote for Obama like they did in 2008, or will enough of them refuse to vote for Obama to allow Romney to steal the election? I've said all along that I think this election is entirely about whether Barack Obama is fired, not about whether anyone else is hired. Democrats hired him. They will have to fire him.
Drax
Dunno, of course. But, as I've been stating all along - it will either be an Obama "squaker" or it will be a Mitt landslide. Looking at the internals of the polls, what I get is the following: 1) The majority of the polls have a model of +6 or better Democrat party identification. That's wrong. Gallup had a 6000+ poll showing that party identification nationwide is +1 or +2 REPUBLICAN. This means that any poll which has a +6 Democrat advantage is 8 points WRONG. 2) Early voting in most of the swing states shows that Obama's early voting advantage has either been muted or absolutely demolished. Much less Democrat early voting. Much more Republican early voting. Republicans tend to turn out in larger numbers on election day. (Dunno how this will be affected by the foregoing... but, Republicans are getting a larger percentage of marginal voters to vote early while Democrats are "cannibalizing" solid voters) 3) Enthusiasm is on Republican's side. 4) Romney has a huge advantage in independents. (Around 10 points.) So, with all that in mind, the way I see it is as follows: Romney wins Florida, NC, VA. That puts him at 248. He wins NH and Pennsylvania. That puts him over the top. The election will be over before it even gets to Ohio. But, he'll win Ohio, Wisconsin, Iowa, Colorado. Minnesota and Michigan put him at 341. (These are closer, but I think he'll win one or both of them.) Go team!
CosmicConservative
Drax, that would be an incredibly pleasant night of election returns to watch. I just don't see it. Pennsylvania, I believe, was a diversion by the Romney camp to try to keep Obama from effectively defending Wisconsin, which Romney hopes to win due to Paul Ryan being on the ticket. Wisconsin is part of his plan to route around Ohio. Romney is betting his election on keeping his current "leans Romney" states and adding to them Iowa, Wisconsin, Virginia, Florida, Colorado and New Hampshire. That would take him to 277 electoral votes. Watching his campaign and where he has sent his big guns, that's what I think he believes is in play. Winning Ohio would be a huge win for him. But he's trying not to need Ohio.
Dadman
Interesting article: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2228359/Romney-campaign-internal-polling-puts-Republican-nominee-point-ahead-Ohio.html?ito=feeds-newsxml CC: Will you be eating crow IF your doom and gloom proves to be wrong?
Dadman
Yeah, I know they're internal polls and may serve an ulterior motive...
CosmicConservative
So, a lesson in how my mind works. Why in the world would Romney leak this if it were true?
CosmicConservative
That story, in fact, may be the single most discouraging thing I've seen in weeks. That just reeks of desperation.
Dadman
Wow...such a negative way of looking at it. Perhaps you're right, but this internal poll has been corroborated by some independent polls. Rove is also predicting Romney wins Ohio. Again, he might have ulterior motives (probably does), but his analysis seems sound to me. Do you really think the conservative base is LESS energized than they were in 2010 when Republicans/conservatives were swept into office all over America? Do you think Obama gets more or fewer votes than he got in 2008? I'm thinking fewer. Obama won independents in 2008 by a large margin. Romney is polling quite strong with independents going into election day. I expect him to win the majority of independent votes this time. Do you think Obama will get more or fewer white voters this time? Veterans? Catholics? Jewish? Business owners? I hear the huge evangelical voting block is lining up nicely behind Romney (praise the Lord) when many of them failed to vote for McCain. I dunno. Maybe you're right. I just sense an unexpectedly comfortable margin of victory is on tap for Romney. My fingers, toes, elbows, legs, eyes, arms, feet, and a few other body parts are all crossed for a Romney win. ;)
CosmicConservative
Dadman, I think Ohio is a special case. Obama spent hundreds of millions of dollars on endless ads painting Romney as a man who puts babies into blenders and drinks them raw. Romney has done an amazing job of overcoming that, but that image has been ground heavily into the Ohio population's mindset. There are a lot of people who simply won't change that view now. I think Romney's strategy is to bypass Ohio. I think it has a shot at working. But it's a tough row to hoe. That's why I think he put Pennsylvania "into play". He did that to suck resources away from Wisconsin, Iowa and Colorado.
Drax
I hope (as I generally do) that CC is wrong here. But, unlike the norm, CC ALSO hopes he's wrong here. I concede that it's "tea leaf" reading at this point - perhaps colored by hope/bias. But, I just can't get past the internals of EVERY poll. Republican early voting is significantly up; Democrat early voting is significantly down. Republican enthusiasm is up; Democrat enthusiasm is down. Obama doesn't get to 50% in ANY of the swing states. Self-identified Republicans outnumber self-identified Democrats. Independents tilting heavily towards Romney. If all or most of these are true, then, frankly, the polls are simply WRONG. (I know, I know...citing polls to say polls are wrong...) But, ALL of the polls reflect these factors whereas the "predictive" polls go both ways. And, if the polls are wrong - then this is going to be much more like 1980 than 2004.
CosmicConservative
Drax, actually Obama is at or above 50% in a few swing states. We just don't think of them as "swing states" anymore just as most people don't think of Florida or Virginia as "swing states" although they technically are. I guess a lot of my "tea leaf" reading here is based on my early conviction that Ohio was the critical state to win. I have as a result watched Ohio closely and I have simply not yet seen anything to convince me that Romney has taken the lead there.
Drax
Yeah. I've pretty well locked into Rasmussen. He's closer to the actual Dem/Rep divide than any other, although Gallup is close.
CosmicConservative
Yeah, well, Rasmussen's most recent polls don't give Romney any more chance than Gallup's or anyone else. Obama still has the lead there too.