Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

The ethics of 3D printing...

By CosmicConservative
Now, I'm not going to pretend all of this is new, but 3D printers take the convenience of making a real-world copy of an item to a new level. With the release of the new Makerbot Replicator (models 1 & 2) the legal and political world is suddenly taking notice of this newfangled technology. And the result has been fairly predictable. It's all about copy protection. There have even been calls by some lobbying firms to outlaw 3D printers. Especially toy companies, many of which make the majority of their profits on mass produced plastic trinkets with limited or no mechanical functionality. But before we get into the legality of 3D printing, which will assuredly end up in a morass of rhetorical argument and counter-argument, I would first just like to discuss the ethics involved. First let's abstract this thing out so that it is not tied to current or near-future functionality. Let's say, for the sake of argument, that you could purchase, at a reasonable cost, a machine that could to a 3D scan of an existing object, create a computer model of the object, then recreate the object at any scale within a reasonable range (say from less than an inch to several feet across) out of the same materials as the original, and paint it exactly as the original was painted. All at the touch of a button. What should or shouldn't you do with such a device? Should you replicate the Mona Lisa? Well, it's not likely that you would HAVE the original Mona Lisa, so let's be more realistic. Let's say you are redecorating your house and you find an exquisite light switch plate, hand-made, hand-painted and just exactly what you want. You can either buy a couple dozen of them for all of your rooms, or you can buy one and then print out copies of the rest. Should you print copies? Let's say you have a set of legos, and you want more blocks. Print them or buy them? Your daughter wants a pair of earrings just like her friend's earrings. Scan and print? You have a new birdfeeder and your neighbor wants one exactly like it, but they don't have the money, nor do they have a 3D printer of their own. Do you just print one up and give it to them, or just charge them a nominal fee to cover materials and maintenance? What are the limits of the use of the thing?

Comments (8)

Drax
The way to deal with this (in large part) is for there to be a manufacturer sponsored site through which one could download the plans for their products - for a small fee which would resemble the PROFIT which they would have made if they had sold it themselves. (Perhaps slave the home 3D printer to the site so that the plans couldn't be copied and sold...) Shut down the pirate websites (such as was done to Napster and whatnot).
CosmicConservative
Drax, that's actually already started. Makerbot industries sponsors a website which allows the sale and distribution of replicator files, some of which are copyrighted, some of which are public domain. In the future (far future? not so far?) "Manufacturing" may be an obsolete concept for many things that are mass produced today, and your model here will potentially replace it. However, as long as there are still people without access to 3D printers, there will still be some need for mass production. Although I suspect the long-term solution for mass production of many things WILL end up being massive industrial strength 3D printers.
Boyd
If you can reproduce the exact same item in your 3D printer for less than the manufacturer can produce it, including the various markups, then that's the manufacturer's problem, pure and simple. If it can be done cheaper on the printer, then the manufacturer is using the wrong process to make his wares.
CosmicConservative
Boyd, this has been true of digital music and video files for decades. And the result has been a bewildering patchwork of laws to try to protect the industries who can't produce things cheaper than they can be copied. As small as it might be, there are always research, development and testing issues for new products, which will always have to be amortized somehow through the sell of mass produced copies. So theoretically, in a "level playing field" where everyone has the same technology, it will ALWAYS be cheaper to make a copy than to make the original. Your comment would assert that it is simply not economically viable to make ANYTHING.
CosmicConservative
So, another question. If you download a replicator file and "print out" a product, and that product fails catastrophically, resulting in serious bodily injury or death, who do you sue?
TheEvilShane
All great comments. I agree with all those predictions/recommendations. Perhaps this will inadvertently solve the crazy "lawsuit era" we ended up in.
Stoof
While it might not be very obvious, tTprinter and making copies of an MP3 on your computer. While it might not be completely obvious all the time due to the fact that both start with a digital file, the final states are much different. Bits are free, massless, and practically infinite. Can you place a price on a bit? When it comes to physical objects, there is no "one size fits all" when it comes to manufacturing processes. Until the day 3D printers are converting energy into mass, pirating physibles will not be an issue.