Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Comments (21)

Dadman
His demeanor was rude and condescending. I suspect that will work against him...to some degree.
CosmicConservative
He fired up his base. He gave them red meat. And Ryan walked right into it. It's not a "win" for Biden, I don't think it will do much to win back a lot of independents, but I do think it stopped the bleeding. And a draw for "Uncle Doofus" is a win.
Drax
A couple of things: A "draw" is, at this point, a "win" for Romney as he is currently in the lead. Biden isn't a "good debater." He is a good attack dog. In this format, with this moderator, and with Ryan's unwarranted deference, he was allowed to interrupt, laugh, and get in the last word often enough, that, if you read the debates, he would appear to be the "winner." But, on the split-screen, I think that it will be judged a narrow Ryan win simply because Biden came off as an asshole - Gore writ large. But, the style of his performance will, hopefully, warn Romney that Obama is gong to come out fighting and lying HARD in the next debate. So long as Mitt is willing to call him out on his lies (as Ryan, for some reason, appeared unwilling to do to Biden) - and is prepared for the "47%" barrage and "$5 trillion in new taxes" mantra as well as the "Medicare voucher" talking points - Romney can put the campaign to rest on Tuesday.
CosmicConservative
A couple rebuttals: Romney is not in the lead. Obama is. Even in the unlikely event that the recent poll bump for Romney lasts more than five days, I simply don't care about the national polling numbers. The polls I pay attention to are the individual electoral vote polls, and Obama still has the lead there. Biden's goal tonight wasn't to win over undecideds. It was to stop the bleeding and re-energize their base. He accomplished that. If I knew exactly what Biden was going to do, and I feel just as confident that I know exactly what Obama is going to do, how can this debate provide any more info to Romney about Obama's strategy than he already had? Worse, they had to know that Biden was going to be full-on attack dog, and they didn't prepare the sort of rebuttals necessary to deflect the worst attacks. Millions of women are right now thinking "hmmm... I guess my ladyparts are better protected by Obama/Biden".
Dadman
The meme that's developing is that Biden was a rude jackass who laughed his way through serious topics. At worst this debate was a draw, but some post-debate polls are indicating a Ryan victory. I'm going out on a limb and predicting Romney wins the election. Fingers crossed...
CosmicConservative
I hope you're right Dadman. I remain pessimistic. There is so much working against Romney. Not the least of which is a media so corrupt and partisan that scandals which would have destroyed any other President simply are ignored as if they are inconsequential. Ryan needed to knock Biden off his game, instead Ryan focused on staying on issues. I hate that our political system works the way it does today, but it works how it works. And winning on substance isn't winning. Ryan's strategy was to stay on message. That is not a winning strategy. That is playing for a draw and hoping the other guy makes a mistake. Ryan needed to go after Joe Biden directly, personally and forcefully. And that is such a target-rich environment. But the closest Ryan came to an attack on Biden was when he chided Biden for his constant interruptions. I don't want to knock Ryan too much here though. For his first major national debate he did OK. But that's all it was. OK.
Dadman
The polling is indicating viewers thought he won. Polling trends all seem to be moving in Romney's direction. I smell a Romney victory in just over 3 weeks...
Andy
Cosmic, you and I must have been watching two different debates...with all due respect. ;) Biden came off as the condescending jackass that he is. He seemed confused, flustered, and downright rude & arrogant. I don't think he did anything to stop the bleeding. As a qualifier, I only watched about the first 45 minutes before my eyes glazed over. But, all of the reviews I've read this morning (from the left and the right) seem to be pretty universal. The left is not AS disappointed with Biden as they were with ObozO, but he didn't give them any reason to hope for a shift, either.
Drax
CC: Latest RCP "poll of polls" has Romney in a 1 point lead. http://www.realclearpolitics.com/?state=nwa With around 5-8% undecided (which historically goes by a large margin to the challenger) this puts Romney in a fairly commanding position. The race is currently Romney's to LOSE. Second, Ryan WON with women, fairly big. Third, Ryan WON the likeability issue and he was considered, by many, the mean man who would throw Granny off a cliff. Fourth, Ryan didn't have to take Biden off his game, he had to appear Presidential so that he didn't hurt the ticket by appearing to be a bad choice. He did this both in substance and, especially in contrast to Biden, style. Ryan was able to maintain his cool in the face of all that arrogance and smirkiness - and actually answer substantively. He appeared to be the adult in the room. And, unlike most VP debates, this one will continue to be in the news and continue to hurt team Obama. Why? Quite a few reasons. 1) Biden's style. It was SO off-putting that it has ALREADY inspired a Republican ad http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PCtemaHgjyA&feature=youtu.be Further, clips from his extraordinary performance will be played on conservative blogs and discussed on liberal blogs for days, if not weeks. (And, of course, will be remembered FOREVER) 2) Substance. Biden blamed the intelligence community for the Administration telling us that the terrorist attacks in Libya and elsewhere were actually spontaneous mob attacks ignited by a YouTube video no one had heard of for nearly two weeks. This is not only false, but demonstrably so since members of the administration testified the day before the debate that the "intelligence community" knew that it was a terrorist attack within 24 hours of the attack. This will be a major substantive issue for at least through the weekend. 3) Biden said that the Administration inherited a big bill from the Iraq and Afghanistan wars, which Bush started but didn't pay for and BIDEN DIDN'T VOTE FOR. But...he did. This will be an issue as well. I expect that in the 3 day rolling polls (Tuesday or so) that Romney will pick up a percentage or so - from Independents and Democratic undecided women - as a result of this VP debate.
Drax
Oh, and ... 4) Most of the time which will be spent by the talking heads (on both sides) will be spent on Biden's offensive STYLE (attacking it, describing it, or defending it) and/or his misstatements as noted above (again, attacking them or defending them). This can ONLY inure to the benefit of team Romney.
CosmicConservative
I guess I am too willing to accept the role of curmudgeonly pessimist. But that's what I am. The one thing I was holding some mild hope out for was that Biden's performance was particularly off-putting to women. Based on the CNN 48-44 split of response though, I concluded that it couldn't have been that off-putting to that many women. Maybe it will be one of those things that builds over time. The RealClearPolitics overall state-by-state analysis has shifted towards Romney, but it's not yet shifted enough to give Romney an edge. Until I see Ohio, Colorado and Florida firmly in the Romney camp, I just don't see any way for Romney to get the Electoral votes he needs to win. He has a VERY slight edge right now in Florida and Colorado. But neither is statistically anything but a tie. Ohio is still statistically in Obama's camp. I didn't see anything last night that convinces me that Ohio will move to a tie, or that Florida and Colorado will move into a statistical advantage for Romney. The reason I am pessimistic today is that I had almost convinced myself that the enthusiasm gap would be enough to overcome Obama's edge. I do think the only way Romney wins is if the right votes en masse and the left is de-motivated and demoralized. Biden did two things last night that helped Obama. First, he stopped the bleeding. The true believers are back on board. Second, he pulled some people back onto the reservation.
jussayin'
CC, if a CNN poll has Ryan winning, when that station leans so heavily liberal, as does their audience, doesn't it seem at least possible that Ryan won by bigger numbers? It seems you are falling for exactly what these polls are designed to do. The polls are continually pushing that the democrat registration and turn out will be higher than 2008. Even though republican registration is up, self identification to being republican and independent is up. My biggest concern is not that Romney is going to win as much as it is that voter fraud will sway this election to Obama, and is the real reason behind the fight to stop voter ID laws. The polls can give cover for the fraud.
CosmicConservative
jussayin', I'm not reacting to the polls of the debate at all. I am focused entirely on the daily polls of the key swing states. Those have been moving towards Romney, but they are not moving fast enough. If the election were held today and the RCP poll averages end up reflecting the actual vote, Obama wins by 20 electoral votes. Romney is still losing. That's just the fact. The only reason I mentioned the debate poll at all is because I had some hope from Biden's jerk-ass pompous arrogance that women might find that off-putting. But the near even split of the CNN poll made me think that was probably not the case. Again, I am only looking at the individual state polls. That's all that matters. Most of the rest of the talking head material spewed out of the TV is meaningless. All that matters is who wins electoral votes. And right now Obama still has the edge.
Dadman
But the electoral map is shifting in Romney's direction and there's good reason to doubt some of these swing state polls. Almost all of the movement is toward Romney right now and that's a very good thing just over 3 weeks out from an election. I am hopeful...
CosmicConservative
Yes, the momentum was (maybe still is) with Romney. That's why I think a knockout by Ryan (which is what virtually all the right-wing blogs, except me, were predicting) would have been devastating. The results of last night's debate have turned what was a rout into a holding action. Romney will have to win the next debate to close the deal. If Obama manages to reassert his image as a "great debater" it may be all over. My main technique for looking at the election is to look at states Bush won where Obama is leading vs states Obama won where Romney is leading. That is not very encouraging. Obama has the edge in about twice as many of those states. And all of this is a mystery to me. How Obama is anything but a disgraced failure by now is beyond my comprehension. How he could win a single state is mind-blowing. As I said on FB a week or so ago, I think this nation can survive an Obama, even an Obama re-election. What I fear this nation CANNOT survive is an electorate that would knowing VOTE for Obama.
Drax
Dunno why you think Obama's ahead. Even the RCP average on the swing states has Romney ahead in Florida (at the edges of the MOE) and North Carolina (outside the MOE). Every other state is within the MOE. Rasmussen puts Romney ahead in Virginia by 2. (Rest of swing states not already mentioned are pay-to-view at this point). But, they're calling Missouri a tossup. Not likely. Colorado isn't a tossup either. At worst, it's "likely Romney." And, many of the swing state polls don't even take into consideration the 1st Presidential debate. Updated Rasmussen polls will be out today sometime. Romney is ahead nationally and, if the election were held today, he would win.
CosmicConservative
Drax, you were the one who referenced RCP, and RCP currently lists Obama as 20 ahead if the election were held today.
Drax
Yeah. I referenced the "poll of polls," but not because it's accurate, but because it's NOT. It has many polls which are WILDLY skewed towards Democrats, but is moderated by Rasmussen (and once in a while an "outlier" of some other pollster). What this means is that, if the "poll of polls" has Romney ahead by 1%, then he's actually ahead by more (closer to Rasmussen). Additionally, this close to the election, the "undecided" invariably vote by a huge margin for the challenger when it's time to actually vote. This puts most (if not all) of those "swing states" well into Romney's camp. Further, there is a 13% "enthusiasm" gap in favor of Republicans. This will make many "leaning Obama" states actually "toss ups." As I've stated before, this election will either be a narrow, narrow win by Obama (who will have won through voter fraud) or it will be a landslide by Romney. It's looking more and more like a landslide for Romney. If he doesn't screw up the next two debates, that is. (And, frankly, I don't think he will. He's too battle tested to do so.) Get excited, but, as the good professor quotes: "Don't get cocky, kid."
CosmicConservative
I think that enthusiasm gap just tightened significantly. I hear you on the possibility of skewed polls. I also hear you on the enthusiasm gap. However, I am not as sure as many on the right are that the polls are as skewed as some people think. I could allow myself to "adjust" the polls by factoring in a skew factor and an enthusiasm factor. Let's say that the two of those result in an across the board 1 point bump for Romney. What happens? Obama still wins Ohio and wins the election. In fact it would require a 1.5% "enthusiasm" and "poll skew" effect to get Romney to win Ohio. I'm sure there will be a 1% fraud factor in the key swing states to overcome, so that means Romney needs to have a 2.5% gain in votes due to enthusiasm and poll skewing to win. Are the polls skewed that much? Is there that much enthusiasm? Two days ago maybe. Today? Probably not.
Andy
Guys, I will KNOW about the "Enthusiasm Gap" when I go to vote in November at my mixed-race polling place (Central Park Elementary School). In 2008, I showed up to vote early in the morning (as usual). The line was at least 50 deep. I was SHOCKED! Even in Presidential elections, there would be no more than 7 or 8 people in line ahead of me. In that 2008 line were young-ish black folks that I had never seen before. Almost all of them had to be instructed by the poll workers once they got behind the curtain, as to how to cast a vote. I knew McCain was in trouble...I mean, here in a State where McCain won 60%+ of the vote, the turnout of first timers for ObozO (first-timers I've not seen since on election days) was pretty impressive. I knew it was a lost election for The Republicans. I knew that in swing States, McCain was gonna get killed. I would say that it was a lost election for "sanity," but I was always lukewarm about McCain, and in the broad scope of things, it may have even been for the best (long thought train there that I don't have time to ride). Maybe. Maybe not. Who knows? Regardless, I'll know about that "Enthusiasm Gap" deal when I show up at the polls.
Drax
Got some new polling. The RCP "poll of polls" has Electoral College at 201 Obama 181 Romney. But. It also has Florida (29) as a toss-up. It isn't. It's Romney and outside the MOE (10/11 Rasmussen at +4%). Virginia (13) isn't a "toss-up," it's leaning Romney. (Rasmussen 10/11 +2) North Carolina (15) isn't. It's, at worst, "Leaning Romney" at +3%. (Rasmussen 10/9). Missouri (10) isn't a "toss-up." It's Romney with Rasmussen (10/2) at +3% and every poll with Romney ahead - before the debate. On the other hand, Pennsylvania (20) and Michigan (16) are certainly "leaning Obama" at least as of 10/9. That gives Obama an additional 36 for 237 and Romney an additional 67 for 248. Colorado, Wisconsin, and New Hampshire would put him over the top and I think he'll win those. (And a lot more, but at least those.) Cheer up. Soak up the goodness while it exists!