Contemplations on gun design
By CosmicConservativeHaving shot my new 9mm pistol a couple of times and therefore cleaning it a couple of times, I can't help but evaluate and pontificate on the state of gun design and manufacture.
The crucial conclusion that I've reached is that modern guns are incredibly well designed. Almost absurdly well designed in fact. Watching a gun in action, knowing nothing about the internal functions, it would be reasonable to conclude that there must be a lot of complexity in the mechanisms invovled. After all a typical modern gun, rifle or pistol, has at least two separate safety mechanisms, has a means to feed bullets into the chamber automatically, can extract bullet casings and eject them out of the gun as fast as you can pull the trigger and is very hard to accidentally set off, even in the case of dropping the gun on a hard floor.
But the reality is that most of that is accomplished with just a few actual parts, parts which are designed so well that they have been relatively unchanged since 1911 when the first clip loaded semi-automatic guns were introduced.
Bolt action single-shot rifles are even simpler than clip-loaded guns.
For comparison my air rifle is a vastly more complex device than my powder guns.
Perhaps the most complex element of a modern gun is the trigger assembly. Triggers can be pretty complicated, especially multi-adjustable triggers designed for competition or combat.
But the remaining components of a gun are deceptively simple looking. My Bersa, for example, manages to handle all of the shell loading, case ejecting and safety functions with maybe ten separate parts. Maybe ten. The carriage which slides back and forth and contains the actual barrel is almost entirely one piece, with a couple of pins and levers which implement the safety features. The actual function of loading the shells, ejecting the shells and firing the gun are almost entirely performed by the interaction of five or six separate parts. Each part has been shaped specifically to engage the other parts, but each part itself has very few moving parts other than a spring or a slide here or there. The barrel itself, for example, is a single piece of metal which actually "floats" inside the carriage, held in place by the carriage and a spring-loaded rod which also manages the recoil and return of the carriage after each shot. The case extractor is similarly simple and mostly performs its functions as a consequence of its shape and the action of the carriage as it reacts to the recoil of the fired bullet. New shells are loaded the same way, when the carriage is returned to its set position, a simple prong slides the next bullet from the clip into the chamber, and the clip itself is essentially just a spring-loaded casing which shoves the next bullet up to be loaded on the next shot.
You can take the whole thing apart in just a few minutes. Taking it apart enough for cleaning takes just a few seconds. All you have to do is flip a lever which disengages the carriage and allows it to be slid off the front of the lower portion of the gun, and then pop out the retaining rod and spring holding the barrel in, and you're ready to clean.
I have always considered ten speed bicycles to be a marvel of engineering simplicity and robustness. I think I'll have to put guns in the same category. The level of cleverness involved in gun design is really impressive.
Comments (3)