Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Civilization is BAD!

By CosmicConservative
Research indicates that the development of civilization was forced because of (wait for it...) GLOBAL WARMING!!! (you knew it was coming). And it was bad. You knew it all the time. The money quote:
As the climate became steadily drier formerly nomadic people were forced to come together for mutual support and to eke out the dwindling natural resources. But not all of the consequences of this merging movement were beneficial -- social inequality arose as did organized violence, there was no increase in life expectancy and autocratic governments emerged, Brooks said.
Apparently they found fossilized neoconservatives at the site. And a copy of the Patriot Act chiseled into stone tablets.

Comments (5)

Brian
I'm having a hard time picturing a bunch of nomand having a society of equals. But I'm biased tword agriculture and bathing.
CosmicConservative
Romanticizing the nomadic lifestyle is a class attribute of the hard-core liberal. I have never understood why. I think they associate it with a lack of personal property. But that's only because nomads could only "own" what they could carry. It wasn't a philosophical thing by any means. But they seem to think it was. My attitude remains: "If you like that so much, go live like that yourself." That just leaves more time for dental appointments for me.
qwerty182764
I've encountered this attitude all over the place. It's an amazingly ungreatful one, considering what civilization regularly does for us. On one level, I can see their point - at the time (the early copper age), people were probably indifferent to being able to range, and ekeing out a living; and being someone's agrarian slave, barely eating, but being protected from the neighboring tribes by a professional gang of thugs. These days, with any modern (non-communist) civilization the choice is clear - civilization wins hands down. The only reason I qualify the statement is because people actually do flee communist countries for the wilderness!
CosmicConservative
My problem is the blatant ignoring of civilizations benefits and the focus on the problems it introduced. This idea that "organized violence" only began with civilization is in direct contradiction to Jane Goodall's work with chimpanzees in Africa who actually organized tribal warfare. If chimps do it, I am dang sure that humans did it too. So organized violence is not a trait of civilization, it is a basic primate trait. The benefits of civilization are obvious to anyone who cares to view reality straight, instead of through their left eye only.
Drax
I love the "social inequality arose" part. Someone actually said this with a straight face. Oh my. I'm still laughing.