Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Some thoughts on Peyton Manning so far

By CosmicConservative
I made no secret of my disappointment in the Denver Broncos decision to kick Tim Tebow to the curb after Tebow virtually single-handedly rescued their season in 2011, ultimately winning the first playoff game he started and posting an 8-5 record overall for the year. But what's done is done and since I live in the Denver area and I do like to see my local teams win, I can't help but root for the Broncos in spite of my absolute disgust at the team's front office, especially John Elway. Plus I just always liked Peyton Manning, even though I think he is somewhat overrated from an NFL history perspective. The game is just so much different today that calling him the "best ever" due to his yardage and touchdowns just isn't a compelling argument to me. I can't help but wonder what sort of gaudy numbers Dan Fouts would have had if he had played QB under the current pass-happy rules in the NFL. Or even Dan Marino, whose career sort of spanned the period where the game changed into a pass-centric approach. But when Peyton Manning was brought to the Broncos, even forgetting the whole Tim Tebow angle, I had several concerns. And while two games isn't really enough to make a final determination on Peyton Manning's QB abilties, there is enough data there that it is worth looking at. I can guarantee you that opposing defensive coordinators are looking at it. So, these were my concerns: 1. Peyton Manning played in a dome for all of his home games and many of his away games. His numbers have always been better in domes than in open stadiums. Not only is Denver's stadium an open air stadium, Denver's weather is among the most fickle in the NFL. 2. There really is something to the "mile high" thing. And as athletes get older, dealing with the lower oxygen content truly does get harder. This affects stamina and even young athletes in Denver tend to wear down faster than athletes who play all year at sea level. 3. While the surgery Manning had done may well have "left his neck stronger than before" as all the pundits and experts like to say, there is no way that surgery of this sort did not have some impact on Peyton's body. What that impact is may be difficult to exactly determine but there is no way that sort of surgery did not affect his range of motion, his flexibility and/or his throwing mechanics. 4. While the aftermath of his condition and surgery may not have had a major impact on his bones or muscles, there is no doubt that it had some impact on his nerves. One common aftereffect of surgery that impacts major nerves is that those nerves frequently lose some of their effectiveness, which manifests itself most commonly as less efficiency in triggering muscle activity. The result of that is usually that even though the actual muscle may well be as strong or stronger after therapy, the actual process of triggering an action using that muscle may not engage as many muscle fibers, and the result is a weaker response. 5. The guy is 36 years old and missed more than a year of play time. 6. Even the best athletes tend to compensate for injuries unconsciously whether they want to or not. So, my fear was that some or all of the above things would mean that Peyton Manning would not be the same guy behind center, no matter how much the Broncos brass wished that not to be true. So... what are the numbers showing us so far this year? 1. Peyton's ball velocity is roughly 5-10% slower than it was before surgery on the same sorts of throws. 2. Peyton's timing is not as sharp as it was before the surgery. 3. Peyton's effectiveness on deep throws is significantly diminished in comparison to his pre-surgery days. Now does that mean Peyton is no longer an elite QB? I dunno. If Peyton can adjust to his throws being slightly less strong than they used to be so that he refines his timing, then timing patterns probably will not be affected. But I am really concerned about the deep balls. All three of Peyton's interceptions on Monday were on deep balls, and anyone who doesn't admit that those balls seemed to hang in the air just a tad too long is probably just not being honest. While it is true that arm strength is overrated in general for an NFL quarterback, the one area where arm strength really is important is in throws of 30 yards or more. The average "deep threat" throw in the NFL is about 35 yards in the air between the QB and the receiver. Most NFL QBs throw the ball around fifty miles an hour (Peyton was clocked at 46 mph on one such throw). That means the average QB puts the ball in the air for about 1.5 seconds. If Peyton has lost 5-10% of his throwing speed, that means his balls are staying in the air on those throws a bit more than a tenth of a second longer. That doesn't sound like much, but it's enough time for an average DB to make up an additional yard or so on coverage. Think about that. If Peyton's mind is still thinking he's throwing that ball 50mph when his body is really throwing at 45mph, then the DB has one yard more coverage than Peyton's mind thinks he does. That one yard is more than enough to be the difference between a completion and an interception. There are reports in the Denver sports press today that the Broncos were prepping Brock Osweiler, Peyton's backup, to go in and throw a hail mary pass if needed. What does that say about the Broncos own evaluation of Peyton's arm strength? Do you think that the Patriots would put in Brady's backup in that situation? I don't think so. It is concerning.

Comments (14)

Drax
He'll learn and adapt to his physical circumstances. His teammates will learn his system as best they can in the time they have. But, unlike Montana, he doesn't have Rice (or, for that matter, Craig - or Lott when Montana is on the bench - nor for that matter a genius for a coach) So, lessened arm. Lesser personnel. Much lesser defense. I'm still on 8-8 this year, maybe make the playoffs next season. (Although KC and Oakland are playing like crap right now, so, Denver might make the playoffs at 8-8...) As to one of the best of all time, I really don't think there's a question. As always, on these questions, I compare him to his contemporaries. I think that he is FAR AND AWAY the best QB of his generation. No close second. (And, yeah, I don't think Brady is even in the DISCUSSION for "best of all time.")
CosmicConservative
LOL, the Peyton Manning vs Tom Brady debate for "best of his generation" is rapidly becoming a Tom Brady vs ELI Manning debate... Let Eli win another Super Bowl and see what happens. For that matter, let Brady win another Super Bowl and see what happens. My guess is that in the end you'll see a John Elway vs Joe Montana result. John Elway had the more impressive arm, more wins, more yards, more of everything statistical. Yet Joe had four Super Bowl wins and zero losses, while Elway had two wins and three losses. Game. Set. Match. Let Brady win another Super Bowl and fifteen years from now Peyton Manning will be a long way behind Tom. And maybe even behind Eli.
Drax
I'll never get it. You're so rational in so many other areas, but in this area, you continue to rank QB's based on how the TEAM performs in the Superbowl - how the TEAM does when the QB is actually SITTING ON THE BENCH for 1/2 of the game. Brady "won" 3. He played well enough to "win" 3. He ALSO played well enough to have LOST two of them. Whether or not he won or lost those two was ENTIRELY out of his hands. Warner "won" 1. He played well enough to have "won" 2 more. One he "lost" because a defensive player missed an assignment and wasn't where he was supposed to be and intercepted a pass and ran it back for a TD. The other he "lost" while he was sitting on the bench. Eli has "won" two. But, if anyone thinks that he is an historical great because of that apparently doesn't watch him the rest of the season - where he, for 1/2 of his career, was always on the verge of GETTING CUT. Big Ben "won" 2. One utterly DESPITE his horrid play. The other he played well enough to win, and thankfully, so did his receiver. Elway "won" 2 - AFTER he got TD. He "lost" 3 (horribly) when he had to try to win it without a running game. Favre "won" one, and couldn't win another without Reggie. (Sure helps to have HOF'ers on the team...) I'll never understand it. I judge the QB's on HOW THEY PLAY - not how the TEAM performs or whether or not they get lucky and win because of the errors of another or the stellar play of someone else. I look at the WHOLE BODY OF WORK. Jim Kelly never won one. He got there 4 times in a row. I'd take him over Eli EVERY TIME. Or Big Ben. Brady? A product of his system, almost entirely. Put another QB in his place and there's no drop-off in TEAM performance. Take Peyton out ... well, we know what happens then. Same with Favre. They've been looking for a Marino since Marino. Sigh.
CosmicConservative
I'm not saying that I would rate Brady higher than Peyton Drax, I'm saying that is how the sports world will end up with them ranked twenty years from now. That's just how it works.
Drax
Yeah, I know that it works like that for most of the talking heads. Their "reasoning" inasmuch as it qualifies as such, is that - when you get to ranking the "best of the best" the number of rings seems to be the tie-breaker. Or so they say. And, it makes SOME sense in basketball where a single transcendent player - who plays both offense and defense and is in the game the vast majority of the game - can and does make a huge difference in the performance of the team. It makes almost NO sense in football. I would take Tarkenton over Bradshaw EVERY TIME and twice on Sundays. I would take Manning over everyone of his generation, Marino over everyone in HIS (including Elway). My contention is that a QB is the most important member of 1/5th of a football team. The most important part of the team. But, the number or rings a QB has is almost MEANINGLESS to me in terms of my ranking them against one another. (I also happen to look at the quality of the members of his team (both offense and defense) because it MATTERS as well as the quality of the coaching staff...silly me.)
CosmicConservative
Heh, you would think after a couple billion words back and forth on this debate one of us would have budged a millimeter just due to the crushing weight of all that rhetoric... My problem with Peyton Manning is that he's boring. Just plain boring. I want excitement in my QB. I want to see a QB run around and make things happen. Peyton just looks around and fires the ball to the perfectly open reciever. Boring. Of course I don't like it when an exciting QB overdoes it and becomes a loose cannon gunslinger like Brett Favre. No, the perfect QB is somewhere in the middle, able to move and think on the run and make the play nobody thought could be made, but he has to make the plays, not throw the ball away or get sacked thirty yards behind the line of scrimmage. Interestingly Eli is more exciting than Peyton. Heck just about any QB is more exciting than Peyton Manning. Oh well, I may as well just say it. White bread with mayonnaise is more exciting than Peyton Manning.
Drax
You're gonna LOVE RGIII and Luck. Luck more, over time, I think. He's almost the "athlete" that RGIII is and a much better pocket passer. And, you ought to absolutely LOVE Cam Newton and Michael Vick.
CosmicConservative
Just some thoughts... Vick is, to me, sort of like a more mobile version of Bret Favre. Vick is a Jekyl/Hyde QB. He can be awesome or he can stink up the place. So not really my kind of QB since I think one interception is much worse than completing one touchdown. Cam Newton... I haven't actually seen him play. I don't watch that much football and the Panthers aren't commonly shown in my area. I was planning on watching the game tonight mostly to see Cam in action. My guess is that if he were the Denver or Dallas QB I'd already be a big fan, but I have read some stories that indicate Cam is still maturing as an NFL QB. Everything I've read and heard about RG3 would indicate that I would be a huge fan. Except he's on the Redskins. Crap. And finally from what I've read, Luck may have that athletic skills and ability, but so far he's mostly played like a traditional pocket passer. If I had to pick my prototypical exciting NFL QB who did all the things I'm talking about here, I'd have to go with Roger Staubach or John Elway in his prime. Steve Young had his moments. Randall Cunningham was just a paleolithic version of Michael Vick, but he also could be very exciting. And I suppose I should recognize Roethlesberger even though I have essentially concluded that the guy is a narcissistic predatory bastard and as such I really don't care to root for him. I do think Romo is just on the verge of satisfying me in this regard. He's just a bit too quick to make bad decisions still, but otherwise he is far more athletic than he gets credit for.
Drax
Luck is a 4.6 40. Yeah. He's THAT fast. RGIII was a 4.4. (Faster than Vick who is faster than Luck.) I've never been a fan of Vick. He's as smart as a brick. RGIII seems more intelligent, but, as a runner, he's only got straight away speed and, unlike Luck, isn't a true runner when he tucks it and runs. (Or Tebow, for that matter.) Newton is awesome but an utter ass and completely self-centered. I don't think he'll ever be able to put his team on his back - mostly because many won't want to climb on.
CosmicConservative
So... another week, another sub-par performance by Peyton Manning. Sure he had some guys drop passes, but Tebow was having 6-7 passes per game dropped too. Of course then the dropped passes were Tebow's fault, now the receivers are to blame. It's funny listening to the radio talking heads try to revise their history to explain how the Broncos with Peyton shouldn't really be expected to be any better than the Broncos with Tebow, in complete blatant disregard to their incessant yapping for the past 8 months about how a "real" QB is all the Broncos needed to get to that next level. If the Broncos lose to Oakland this weekend, I think the floodgates of fan criticism are going to open. And I think there is a real chance that Oakland might just pull off the victory.
kblast
I mostly agree with Drax. Super Bowls can be one on defense and special teams alone. I also agree a qb who can get to the show repeatedly is more of a barometer OF QB greatness than actually winning unless the choke and blow an otherwise winning team effort. I disa gree that Brady is a product of the Patriots system and therefore interchangable. The man can't move but I'll bet on his accuracy vs. Peyton's any day over 30 yards even before the surgery. Maniing has frequently thrown back foot ducks on the long ball over his career. Brady has a stronger and more accurate long ball. Neither of them are as strong or accurate when pressured as when they have a clean pocket. Manning has always been about timing. Teaching his recievers when and where he will put the ball. He does not throw to them he throws to a spot they are supposed to get to. Bret Farve and Marino threw to their recievers. even their late throws MOSTLY were complete. Farve was a narcasistic cowboy. He made the same bad throws over and over. He simply could not believe he could fail. I see peyton's arm getting worse not better. The nerves in his neck and shoulder will get inflamed if he gets roughed up a whole half. I f you plant him on his back enough the nerves will cause him to tighten up and become inaccurate. His passes already flutter at 25 yards.
kblast
I wanna see how Peyton takes a shot like Farve took. See if he can get it up after that kind of hit.
CosmicConservative
I gotta give Peyton credit for getting his team back in the game last night. While I really think Denver should give the game ball for the game to Phillip Rivers, Peyton apparently gave a pretty good halftime motivational speech based on the attitude of the team going into, and then coming out of, the locker room. Last night Peyton earned his pay for the week.