Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

In the "duh" files

By CosmicConservative

Stanford University scientists have weighed in on the “maybe not” side of the debate after an extensive examination of four decades of research comparing organic and conventional foods.

They concluded that fruits and vegetables labeled organic were, on average, no more nutritious than their conventional counterparts, which tend to be far less expensive. Nor were they any less likely to be contaminated by dangerous bacteria like E. coli.

via Study Questions Advantages of Organic Meat and Produce - NYTimes.com.

The value of organic foods has always been to make people feel better ABOUT themselves, not to actually feel better. It probably has some placebo effect that makes people think it's better for them, but I've pointed out for years that food bought at unholy "big box stores" is just as healthy as the stuff you get for twice the cost and twice the bugs in the local "I'm so much better than you" market.

Comments (8)

Drax
I had always thought that the advantage of organic food was that fewer pesticides were used in growing them - giving advantage both to the consumer and to the land itself. I will say that homegrown vegetables taste about a zillion times better than anything I buy at Krogers...
CosmicConservative
Drax, I have looked into this quite a bit actually. Not that I'm an expert, but it is one of the subjects I find myself interested in. The one thing that the study hedged on was the level of pesticides used in organic vs. "Kroger" veggies. As it turns out, both have pesticide residue, but "organic" has about 1/3 to 1/2 as much. However, "organic" has 2 to 3 times as much pest damage. So it's a trade-off. What's better to eat? A small amount of pesticide residue or a small amount of bug crap? Hard to say. As far as taste, the latest studies I've seen on taste of veggies is all about how they are bred, picked and shipped. There is no real difference in the "taste" of organic vs Kroger veggies when they are picked and shipped at the same time and are the same breed of veggies. But stores like Krogers sometimes have to ship the veggies further and because of that, they pick them earlier and that affects the development of sugars in the veggies. That's all tied to ripening on the vine vs in the truck. Anyway, gotta go. This is a far more interesting subject than one might think, and investigating it will teach a person an amazing amount about our food distribution system, which is where most of the differences exist.
mtnlurker
To Drax's point. I think heirloom tomatoes taste much better than the hot house or vine tomatoes sold in most stores. Something about the breeding to make them redder. I never buy orgainic. Too expensive and not enough advantage.
CosmicConservative
mtnlurker, the tomatoes that are bred to be red are less tasty than "normal" tomatoes. But that's a breeding thing, not a quality thing. They literally produce fewer sugars when they ripen.
Andy
Drax is right. Stuff right out of the garden is WAY better than what you get off the cooler at Kroger. But...that is if you grow it yourself, and cook/eat it soon after harvesting it. Trust me. I know. I honestly don't have a lot of experience with "organic" food that is sold commercially, so I'll call "monor" on that whole subject. But, I do know from personal experience a good bit about vegetables ;), and honestly the whole "organic" deal at thrice the price is pretty lame to me. But, God bless the folks that have figured a way to snooker morons with plenty of money. There's one born every minute.
CosmicConservative
Vegetables that are grown and picked at the height of their ripeness and cooked immediately will always taste better than vegetables that are picked before they are fully ripe (to reduce spoilage in transport and on the shelf) or vegetables that are frozen. That's just how it goes. If we could grow a garden here, we would for that reason.
Andy
Yeah, I know what you mean, Cosmic. We grew a garden when we lived in CO at 6500 ft. One year, we lost ALL of it on a 28 degree morning...on July 4. Really.
CosmicConservative
We live nearly half a mile higher than that...