Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Bad science in the news

By CosmicConservative
CNN.com - Phone telepathy: You knew it was true - Sep 5, 2006 NORWICH, England (Reuters) -- Many people have experienced the phenomenon of receiving a telephone call from someone shortly after thinking about them -- now a scientist says he has proof of what he calls telephone telepathy.
OK, so what's wrong with this story? Where do I start... Perhaps this bit of info is relevant:
However, his sample was small on both trials -- just 63 people for the controlled telephone experiment and 50 for the email -- and only four subjects were actually filmed in the phone study and five in the email, prompting some skepticism. Undeterred, Sheldrake -- who believes in the interconnectedness of all minds within a social grouping -- said that he was extending his experiments to see if the phenomenon also worked for mobile phone text messages.
OK, so the first thing you do is you check to see if your experiment has some sort of bias. Having the lead researcher admit to "believing in the interconnectedness of all minds" is a hint that perhaps there was some bias here. Then you set up a statistically valid sample rate, which for something like this would be on the order of a couple thousand subjects being tested, not 63. Reporting results on an experiment with statistically invalid results is not just bad science, it's downright unethical science. Then you repeat the experiment and offer it for peer review. Then you announce your results. Not only is this guy not following the fundamental means of validating his experiment to prove it, he's "extending the experiment to see if the same results can be achieved with text messaging." Sheesh... can anyone say "Cold Fusion?"

Comments (4)

qwerty182764
Speaking of ESP, what is it with people and ESP anyways? It seems we have some sort of instinctive attraction towards odd ideas like this. I wonder what makes us consider the possibility, much less make every other random nut base his epistemology on "mind over matter"? (Never mind the fact that ESP itself is an oxymoron and an incoherent idea...)
CosmicConservative
Mankind's fascination with "psychic phenomena" is purely and simply about basic superstition. We think we are sophisticated and educated as a race, but fundamentally there is very little difference in the way an average person on this planet in 2006 views the universe, and the way an average person on this planet in 2006 BC views the universe. For the most part, it's all just magic. And since it's all just magic, well anything is possible right?
Drax
I get a kick out of myths like these. Have they even considered the most plausible reason why people sometimes think of a person just before getting a call, letter, or e-mail? Hmmm. 1. We start with the most obvious, i.e., that we think of other people all the time, but only remember the times we happen to be thinking about someone just before they call. With only a select and small group of people that would actually call us, it's just a matter of time before the "thinking about" coincides with the "just received a call from." 2. Why were they thinking about the person in the first place? Was it their birthday? Did we forget to call them after a party? Perhaps the same reason we "happened" to be thinking about the person calling was the very reason they called? I'm sure others can think of other, obvious reasons why someone just "happens" to call at around the same time we're thinking about them...