Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Reviews

Movie Review: Abraham Lincoln, Vampire Hunter

By CosmicConservative
Went to see this with the Cosmic Wife on a rare day off yesterday. So we saw it in the early afternoon in an almost empty theater. The Cosmic Wife liked it. She thought some of the CGI stuff was wildly overdone, but found the film to be fun and campy. I enjoyed parts of the movie and don't regret having seen it, but I did find the movie strangely lacking in precisely the things that it is getting celebrated for doing. For example, the movie is getting lots of praise for treating Lincoln as a serious figure, commenting about how the movie slows down and highlights key speeches such as the Gettysburg Address. But I had more or less the opposite reaction. I found the juxtaposition of the private action hero Lincoln and the public tortured philosopher to be completely unrealistic and unbelievable. I too found the CGI to be badly overdone. Normally I enjoy a good full-screen 3D extravaganza, but there are limits to plausibility that the movie routinely blasted through without even slowing down. I realize that's part of the appeal of the movie, and perhaps I should just accept it as campiness, but the gore was too frequently absurdly gratuitous and the action scenes were more appropriate for a Marvel comic book hero. Then there was the acting... Or there was supposed to be acting. Who the heck was that playing Mary Todd Lincoln? I am pretty sure they could have replaced her with a wind up doll. And the main vampire villain? Glower for me! More! The scene needs more glower! There were just enough nice touches to the script and plot to keep me from just rolling my eyes throughout the movie. And it was somewhat diverting to try to spot the historical references ("there's more than one railroad") involved. But in the end it was just a momentary diversion. The money and effort that went into this movie could have been better spent.

Prometheus chained

By CosmicConservative
So... it's been a week now, or close to it, since "Prometheus" opened. I made some comments in my previous post about my problems with the movie's "plot". At that time I didn't want to spoil it for anyone who might want to go see the movie, but after a week I feel like I can post my thoughts more specifically. Especially since I really think this movie is one of the worst written "sci-fi" movies I've ever seen. So, WARNING! SPOILERS!! I have been particularly hard on the plot of the movie. Here are my specific reasons for feeling this movie was so poorly written. The entire concept of the movie is based on the fundamental premise that the "giants" or "engineers" who created humans on earth had spent time interacting with humans and helping them develop civilization all over the Earth, and in each case they had left a deliberate and highly specific "map" that would allow humans to one day locate their planet. The heroine of the movie and her boy toy interpreted this as a specific "invitation" from the engineers to visit their home world, presumably to get answers about the most profound and important questions in human history. "Why are we here?", "What is our purpose?", "What else can you teach us?" But later we learn that the planet the engineers "invited" us to, was actually some sort of military base that was specifically built as a means of creating and delivering weapons of mass destruction (in the form of alien creatures) to EARTH! Yes, the "engineers" apparently deliberately communicated to EARTHLINGS where they were building the genocidal weapons which they would use to destroy Earth itself. Why? What possible rationale would the engineers have for giving earthlings a map to the planet where they were building the weapons they would use to destroy Earth? The answer is that there is no such rationale. It beggars belief. It makes, quite literally, no sense whatsoever. It's like the Aemricans in WW2 provided the Nazis with a map of where they were developing the atomic bomb. It's not merely silly, it's incomprehensible. And that's the FUNDAMENTAL PLOT DEVICE of the movie. Now... throwing that aside... So a starship is built with ion engines that can cross 35 light years of space. (I think it was 35 light years, although this is unclear because the diagrams they show and other comments in the movie imply that the planet is halfway across the galaxy, or something on the order of 100,000 light years. Not that it matters. The engines the ship has could not possibly cover even 35 light years in anything less than generations. Clearly the writers simply have no clue what they are talking about in terms of space travel, propulsion or anything else. But... much more important than the complete ignorance of distance and time considerations is this. They flew the damn ship directly into the planet's atmosphere! This is more than bizarre. This violates pretty much every single precept of mission management, physics, logic and common sense. You don't fly your interstellar spaceship onto the planet! You have smaller shuttles that you send down to the planet for investigation! Even if you might EVENTUALLY land the main ship, you sure as hell don't fly across half the galaxy and then just nose down into the atmosphere and start flying around searching for things VISUALLY! I can't even begin to describe how totally and completely freaking insane this is. They literally were flying their whole spaceship MANUALLY through mountain ranges and canyons such that they DIDN'T EVEN SEE THE ENGINEER'S STRUCTURES until they were right on top of them. Look. You have a spaceship. You are coming into a stellar system where you suppose an exponentially superior technological race has their HOME PLANET. You don't even go into orbit around that planet at first. You park your ship somewhere and send probes in. Then, if you decide that it is safe to proceed, you might go into orbit around the planet, but you would dispatch some tiny mapping satellites which would not only map the entire planet in a few hours, locating any structures, for example, but would provide all of the navigational aids you might need when you actually send a scouting party down in a shuttle. But no. They just fly straight in, drop into the atmosphere and start FRIGGIN LOOKING AROUND WITH THEIR OWN DAMN EYEBALLS to see what they can see. Such complete and utter incompetence deserves to be eaten alive by aliens. I could go on. "Hey, let's take our helmets off!" No worries man. Just do it. "Joe and I are bored, we're heading back to the ship." Sure. Split the party. Nobody's really in charge anyway. This is a "scientific expedition" there's no need for discipline, logic or regard for physical safety while exploring the ruins of an advanced alien technology that appears to have been destroyed by mysterious attackers who might still be around. Joe and his buddy get lost. I mean really? They can map an entire underground structure to the sub-millimeter level and beam the holographic image back to the main ship, but two guys in spacesuits can't follow a breadcrumb trail back to their ship without getting lost? "Hey, look, I'm an engineer who has just been revived from hibernation, and I can see that all of my comrades are dead, our entire military infrastructure has been compromised by the very genocidal creatures we were creating, who now appear to be loose on the planet, but who cares about that? There's a friggin EARTHLING! KILL KILL KILLKILLLKILLKILLK!!!!!!" I was on the verge of outright hysterical laughter at that point. Just the high points. Oh, so why did they land their entire interstellar spaceship on the planet's surface anyway? Because the directer apparently thought a violent ship to ship ramming scene would be just the perfect visual climax for his movie. That's why. In fact pretty much every stupid, idiotic thing that happened in the movie (and there were truckloads of stupid, idiotic things) were clearly put in the movie to force the plot to happen the way the director wanted it to go. Not because it made any sense at all. It just had to provide the right impact to the viewer. That's all.

Movie Review: Prometheus

By CosmicConservative
Well, I had low expectations going into this movie. I'm not a big fan of the "Alien" series of movies. I did like "Bladerunner", but I think that had better material to work with than Alien or Aliens. Still, I wanted to see the show, figuring this would be a special effects extravaganza. It was. That's all it was though. The plot was so utterly incomprehensible that I have to believe they started filming this movie before the story was written. There are plot holes so gaping they could swallow a galaxy-sized black hole. Heck... that's not fair. You can't put holes in what doesn't exist. This movie is more like a tattered collection of plot fragments scattered over a skeleton of gore, horror and cheesy background music. We saw it at the IMax in 3D. Please don't subject yourself to that expense. This would be a good movie to watch on your 52" home theater system on a rainy Saturday evening. Well... except the CGI is pretty good. How the heck they made Charlize Theron unsexy is a major mystery to me. That may be the most impressive achievement of the entire film.

Movie Review: "The Avengers"

By CosmicConservative
For a decade or so from the late 60s into the 70s I was a pretty avid comic book buyer and reader. I typically preferred Marvel comics to DC comics for a variety of reasons. My favorite Marvel comics were Spiderman, Dr. Strange, Warlock, Fantastic Four, X-Men and every now and then some Thor or maybe even a Captain America thrown in. On rare occasions I might purchase an "Avengers" comic. From the DC side of the equation I mostly liked Batman and the pre-Jack Kirby Superman. Somewhere in there was the really amazing and fantastic run of "Green Arrow" comics. But I never really cared for the "supergroup" comics from either Marvel or DC. The motley collection of superheroes always struck me as implausible and contrived. Superman fighting alongside Aquaman just made no sense and stretched my willing suspension of disbelief far beyond the breaking point. I couldn't help but imagine the super villains lining up to attack and one of them saying something like : "Oh no! We've been caught! You guys take the dude in blue and red tights who is invulnerable, can fly faster than light, can crush coal into diamond and whose eyes shoot laser beams. I'll handle this dude over here who can talk to fish!" The idea of Thor, the lightning-bolt-hurling, mountain-crushing, God of Thunder fighting alongside Hawkeye, the guy who shoots a bow really, really good, just doesn't really work. So I really didn't have high expectations for the movie going in. But Joss Wheedon. Am I right? I mean if anyone can make this work, it's gotta be Joss... And he actually really did. Let's be honest, the plot of these superhero stories is no more plausible today than they were when I rolled my eyes as a twelve year old kid, so you can't really analyze this sort of movie from any reasonable literary perspective. The scientific pseudobabble is so predictable and contrived that I'd honestly just prefer they stopped trying. Nobody really cares about the supposed technical rationale behind the acquisition of powers or the warped cosmology that allow Thor, Iron Man and the Hulk to slug it out as more or less equals while Captain America, the Black Widow and Hawkeye stand around looking all tough even though everyone knows if the Hulk sneezes on one of them, they'll just be a stain on a nearby wall... So the only real question for a movie like this is "how much fun was it?" Well, it was a lot of fun. There were plenty of things I could point out that made no sense, but what's the point? Here are the things I liked: 1. The movie had a sense of humor about itself. There was just the right hint of self-awareness, a sort of winking at the audience that allowed the watcher to realize the characters were in on the joke. 2. The CGI was amazingly well done in most cases. The fusion of live action and CGI was nearly flawless. 3. Some of the acting was surprisingly well done. Robert Downey Jr always rises to the occasion, but the toughest acting challenge in my mind had to be Thor. But Chris Hemsworth not only pulls it off, he injects the role with remarkable vulnerability and even some wisdom. His role in this movie faithfully carries forward the transformation from impetuous blood-thirsty warrior-king in the first "Thor" movie to the rightful heir to Odin's throne. He plays Thor straight, not campy nor overly serious. It's a surprisingly nuanced performance for such a seemingly one-dimensional role. 4. The humor. There are moments that I think only Joss Whedon could have conceived and brought to screen. I won't reveal any of them because they are some of the best moments in the movie. But they are reminiscent of some of the best moments from "Firefly" or "Buffy". There were some things I didn't like too: 1. Some of the acting. Mark Ruffalo strikes me as badly miscast as Bruce Banner. He also doesn't seem to be as attuned as the rest of the cast to Whedon's vision for the movie. He just doesn't work for me. Also, as much as I enjoy watching Scarlett Johanssen in leather tights... well, she's not really convincing as Black Widow either. 2. The whole S.H.I.E.L.D supersecret government entity thing with all the behind the scenes political machinations... I'm not watching movies like this to wonder if my government is the good guy or the bad guy. There's plenty of movies like that out there. Let S.H.I.E.L.D. be what it is supposed to be and focus the story on the action and the Avengers. Quit wasting my time with shadowy super-secret Tri-lateral commission skullduggery. 3. Complete disregard for plot holes so glaring that you just have to either say "OK, I'll just ignore that" or else spend most of the movie saying "what the hell?" I chose the former. 4. No Jane Foster (Natalie Portman). I mean come on! Thor is supposed to be madly in love with her! Anyway, it was a fun movie, the Cosmic clan greatly enjoyed it. Cosmic says, check it out.

Season 4 of "Top Shot"

By CosmicConservative
I'm going to put this in the category of "reviews" just because it's sort of a review. But it's really more of a stream of consciousness reaction to the series. For those who may not know, "Top Shot" is one of those silly "reality shows" that have infected the television landscape like pustules on a plague victim. The host, named "Colby" something or other, is one of those deliberately-primped-to-be-rugged guys that irritate me to no end just by their preening, strutting affected hyper-masculinity. Everything about the guy annoys me, from the way he has a six-day growth of beard every day (the look initially made famous by Don Johnson in "Miami Vice" and I hated it just as much then), to the way he wears just slightly faded and worn jeans, to the way he stands to the way his blinding white teeth burst through his Clint Eastwood-esque squint when he spits his cliche phrases for the camera.... I've described the concept of the show before, so I'll just reiterate that it's based on the "Survivor" model except instead of voting someone off the island, there is a vote to determine two candidates in each show who have to face each other in an "elimination challenge" to see who goes and who stays. This gives Colby a chance to strut and preen as he says in his patented, clipped delivery, "you have fired your last shot" as he sends the hapless loser packing. But in spite of Colby's pervasive and irritating presence, the show itself has managed to do something that very few TV programs have done in the past decade. It has made me actually look forward to each episode. I do watch a couple of other shows right now ("Swamp People", "American Pickers", and "Pawn Stars") but I can take or leave those shows. I typically bring my laptop computer in and watch with the Cosmic Wife. They are engaging and I do enjoy them, particularly "American Pickers" but if I miss an episode or two, I don't sweat it. I make an effort to watch "Top Shot." Why? Because guns. So many guns. And bows, slingshots and atlatls. Not to mention rocket launchers, grenade launchers, sub-machine guns, gatling guns and twice now... Cannons. I mean, if you can't get a thrill out of watching a super slow-motion video of an artillery shell being fired directly at the camera... well, you might want to check your pulse. So anyway, this is the fourth season of the show. I've posted a couple of reactions to specific shows this year, including one where I was very disappointed with the overall accuracy that was demonstrated by these supposed "world-class shooters." But that was really an anomaly. In general the shooting is extremely good. But there is another dimension to the show, and that is the dimension that probably is intended to draw in viewers, although I admit that it doesn't really draw me in that much. Except in rare cases I almost never "root" for anyone. I have a few shooters that I like more than others, and I have to admit that I like seeing the hot chick shooters compete, even though they tend to get booted pretty early, but usually I don't get into the personalities of the shooters. I just like watching the shooting. This season though, I found myself getting drawn in. And as it happened the final two in the season finale who went up against each other were one of my favorites (Chris, the IT guy) vs one of my least favorites (Greg, the ex-soldier). From the start of the show it was clear that the military, police or competitive shooters were rather dismissive of Chris, who had never shot in any competition or been a member of any armed force. He was just a self-described IT geek who shot recreationally but who survived the auditions and ended up on the show. On I think the first episode, he and Greg both performed poorly on a specific team challenge, and Chris ended up being voted to do an elimination challenge, which he survived. The challenge involved using a pistol to shoot a series of plates where you had to shoot six plates in a row without a miss to move to the next row. Both Greg and Chris failed to complete a row of plates in that challenge. But after that, Chris steadily and quietly performed well in challenge after challenge. He showed a specific skill in being able to pick up a weapon he had never seen before and master it quickly. For example, using the atlatl, he nailed a perfect bullseye at the farthest distance, shutting out his opponent in the elimination challenge by scoring 9 points on one throw. Nobody else even got close to the bullseye on the farthest target. Greg, in the meantime, continued to spectacularly fail in challenge after challenge. Plus he demonstrated extremely poor interpersonal skills, repeatedly frustrating and angering both his teammates and the other team. He formed an early clique with three other shooters and they voted to protect each other instead of voting to send the worst performers to the elimination challenges. Even so Greg was sent to three elimination challenges during the season. And I have to give him credit. For whatever reason, while working as part of a team, Greg repeatedly choked badly in competition. in one competition he seemed to completely freeze up for an agonizingly long time trying to make difficult shots. In one case he took forever to make a shot, only to realize he still had the safety on, and then went through the whole agonizing process again, taking forever and missing his shot to boot. But in the elimination challenges, with him one on one vs another shooter, he was a totally different person. He survived all three elimination challenges, sending home shooters that I personally believed were far superior to him. So, in the end, both Chris and Greg survived the team challenges and entered the individual rounds. Both were considered to be the weakest remaining challengers, even though Chris had been perhaps the strongest shooter overall since that first episode. By now I was rooting for Chris and rooting against Greg. Well, in the end they ended up being the final two. And the final challenge was a series of seven individual shooting tests consisting of a flintlock pistol, an ancient British pistol, a Colt pistol, a crossbow, two different rifles and ending with a six-shot grenade launcher. Oh, did I mention that Greg's main credential for appearing on the show was that he was the military's champion grenade launcher in 2003? The second pistol challenge was a repeat of the "perfect series" test that both Chris and Greg had failed so spectacularly back in episode 1. Well... of the four season finales, this one was by far the closest. Chris took a small but significant early lead over Greg until they got to the crossbow, where Greg caught up. Both nailed the perfect series test shooting 12 plates in a row with a Colt revolver without a single miss. Good for them. Greg took the lead in the rifle challenges, ending up on the final challenge a good six seconds ahead of Chris. And the final challenge was the grenade launcher. They had to hit two targets with grenades one at 25 yards and one at 50 yards I think. Anyway, Greg hit his first target before Chris even got his grenade launcher loaded and into firing position. It looked very bad for Chris. When Chris missed his first shot, it looked like all was over, but Greg missed his shot at the farthest target. Then Chris nailed both targets with two successive shots in a stunning example of his uncanny ability to master unfamiliar weapons. His winning shot not only hit the target, it nailed the exact center of the bullseye, while Greg's final shot went just wide. I actually cheered.

Sort of review: Hatsan Mod 125 .25 caliber pellet gun

By CosmicConservative
Just can't stop myself... Even though I'm not ready to weigh in on the accuracy of the gun... I'm stuck on an endless conference call and need to stay awake... Here are the things I like so far: 1. The gun is solid as a tank. It weighs as much as a tank, but it's built like one too. All the parts seem to be meshing together well, there don't seem to be any problems with any seals, the stock fits the metal breech and barrel cleanly, it all feels solid and secure when you pick it up. 2. The barrel sights are much better than I expected. I've been seeing lots of ads for guns with "fiber optic sights" for a while. Pretty much every pellet gun over $125 comes with them. I thought they were pretty gimmicky sounding until I actually saw how they work. During daylight anyway, they work very nicely. The rear sight has two green fibers making up the framing, and the front sight is orange. Lining it up on the target gives a sort of LED look and feel. It's quite nice actually. I'm looking forward to sighting them in tomorrow. The back sight has a nice adjustment screw for both windage and elevation too. 3. The trigger. Very nice trigger. Very very nice. And adjustable as well. I may play with the trigger pull weight at some point, but right now it seems to be set just about how I like it, so I haven't messed with it. You can adjust both the weight of the trigger and the length of the draw on the trigger. 4. The noise level. It's not "quiet" but it's not nearly as loud as other similar guns. If I'm shooting it off the deck in my back yard, you can't hear it if you are sitting in the living room with the TV on. I doubt if any of my neighbors can even hear it unless they are out in the yard. Considering the violence of the actual firing, it's very surprising how quiet it is. There is no "ringing" sound that most break-barrel pellet guns are infamous for. The damping mechanisms inside the gun to reduce vibration and reduce sound seem to work. 5. The power. I'm not kidding about this thing being comparable to a .22. I suppose it's not really near the actual power, but compared to the pump style pellet guns I'm used to, this thing is a monster. The pellets I'm pulling out of the bullet trap are literally just flattened. There's no "pellet" left, just a thin smear of lead about the size of the tip of my thumb. I have no doubt this thing could take down a deer. Seriously. 6. The safety. It automatically sets the safety when you cock it, and you can't turn the safety off until it is fully cocked, so it is supposedly impossible to misfire while cocking. The safety "switch" is a simple thumb-operated lever on the very back of the barrel behind the breech. It's handy and easily manipulated with your thumb. I typically leave the safety engaged until I sight in the target, and then turn it off just before firing the gun. 7. The stock. OK, it's plastic, not wood. But I am more about function than form, and the camo stock with the adjustable cheek rest and the rubber shoulder pad with rubberized grip enhancers feels very comfortable, with the nitpicky detail of having to deal with the split front end of the stock so that the barrel can lever downwards through the stock to cock the gun. Unlike most "plastic" stocks, this one does not feel slippery, doesn't feel fragile, doesn't feel hollow or ring when tapped... it is quite sturdy, functional and is easy to grip. 8. The look and feel. The gun does not look or feel like a pellet gun. It looks and feels like a "real" gun. And it looks like a pretty cool gun. Things I am sorta "meh" about: 1. The sling. It is nice that it comes with a sling and the sling connectors are already installed on the gun. I've had to install slings on guns without sling connectors before and it's pretty touchy to figure out the best place to put the connectors so that they carry the gun comfortably but don't put so much stress on the stock that you end up splintering the stock. But the sling itself is lame and is only adjustable on one side of the shoulder pad. It seems to work OK, but it's nothing great. 2. The loading. To load the gun you have to break the barrel and insert the pellet directly into the front barrel, then fully cock the gun so that it is ready to fire. It feels sort of clunky and puts dirty, perhaps wet, fingers way too close to the compression tube for my taste. I put this in the "meh" category instead of "don't like" because I don't really have a good alternative to suggest. It's sort of built into the fundamental break-barrel design. But it's funky and awkward and you need to be mindful of the proximity of the compression tube, which can be damaged if you manage to get dirt into it. 3. The scope rail. It's better than lots of pellet gun rails. At least it has one, my pellet pistol doesn't and I had to buy special mount gizmos to even mount a scope on it. And it also has a screw in "adjustable" stop so that the scope won't just slide off. Plus it is the new design (I forget the name, maybe "Weaver") which allows scopes with built-in stops to latch firmly onto the rails (of course the scope that came with it doesn't have that feature...). I suppose one day I might put this feature on my "things I like" list if I buy a better scope, but for now it just seems odd that the gun has such a well thought out scope rail system, and such a crappy scope. It almost seems like a deliberate design to encourage the buyer to buy a better scope. Things I don't like: 1. The scope. 2. Did I mention that the scope sucks? 3. The recoil/backlash. It's more than I expected, and I expected a lot. 4. The weight. It's actually pretty heavy. 5. The cocking. Cocking this thing is like doing chest buildup exercises. It's a serious effort. Probably 35 pounds worth of effort every time you cock it. And there's no perfect orientation that I've been able to find that makes it simple, easy and fast. I suppose over time I'll figure the best compromise between those things, but right now it's just work. I will do a separate post on the gun's accuracy when I believe I have finally convinced myself of whether it shoots straight or not.

Trilogy Review: The Hunger Games

By CosmicConservative
So, I had reviewed the first book here, then gone to see the movie while still reading the second book, ("Catching Fire") and then yesterday I finished the final book of the trilogy ("Mockingjay"). In the past few days I've had a number of conversations about the books, plus I've read a bunch of reviews. After discussing this with the Cosmic Daughter this morning on the way to work, she suggested that I post my thoughts about the book, since apparently my thoughts are somewhat unusual compared to what I am seeing on the web and she has seen in discussions with her friends. Here's the deal. I think these books are incredibly well written and have a much deeper political purpose than most people seem to be getting. I see a lot of discussion, for example, about how the book is a fairly typical "teenage love triangle" between Katniss, Gale and Peeta, much like Twilight is a love story between whoever the three main characters of that book are. In fact I see a lot of fan discussion about how Katniss should choose Gale, or should choose Peeta, or neither, or whatever. These sorts of things seem, to me, to be badly missing the point of the book. And here's why. This book appears to me to be deliberately constructed as allegory, with the characters each symbolizing an aspect of human culture or ideology. And how they interact is a metaphor for how cultures act, react and evolve. And it's all pretty brilliantly done. Here are my interpretations of the symbology involved in the book: Katniss - represents human society as a whole. This, to me, is so blindingly obvious and so deliberately presented, that I find it almost incomprehensible that people don't immediately get it. Viewing Katniss as an individual is completely missing the point. Katniss represents all of us. Peeta - represents morality, altruism, loyalty and everything that is good and noble about humans. He is Sam to Katniss's Frodo. He is the conscience of the story. He provides Katniss with her moral compass and her aspirations to be good, aspirations she frequently falls short of. Gale - represents rebellion against authority. Gale is Thomas Paine and Che Guevera rolled into one person. His entire purpose revolves around fighting against what he sees as oppression, and he has no visible limits to the lengths he will go to oppose his enemies. Prim - represents hope. Not much more to say here, Prim is the center of Katniss's life, and the entire story revolves around Katniss's desire to keep Prim (hope) alive. That is, I believe, very deliberate. President Snow - represents absolute authority. But NOT, as some have supposed, absolute evil. Snow is not Sauron, nor is he the Sith emperor. This book is far more subtle and complex than that. Snow is brutal, remorseless, inexorable and violent. But Snow is not the source of the evil in the book, he is merely its face. The evil is buried deeper in the soul of society, and is revealed through Katniss's own actions. President Coin - well... I can't reveal what Coin represents in case some of my readers have not yet finished all the books. What Coin represents is almost the core of the final true climax of the book. So to reveal that would be to essentially spoil the books. Haymitch - perhaps the most enigmatic figure in the book. I believe Haymitch represents the author's proxy, much as Farimir represents Tokien's proxy in Lord of the Rings. Haymitch is the one who pulls the strings from behind the scenes. He is Katniss's soulmate, but he is badly damaged. He provides a way for the author to telegraph her intentions to the reader. Even many of the "bit part" characters are clearly archetypes as well. Madge, Johanna, Finnik, even Katniss's mother have specific roles they play to weave the cultural actions, reactions and evolution outlined in the books. When Katniss is kissing Gale, that is an allegory for cultures flirting with rebellion. That, I believe, is entirely deliberate. The fact that the story works as a character study is simply a demonstration of the author's skill in wrapping the layers of the story in a vehicle that allows it to be delivered to readers in an entertaining, gripping manner. But it's done so well that I believe the deeper purpose may well escape some readers. This has definitely gotten onto my list of best stories ever. I believe this story will grow in reputation over the years, as more and more people realize what Collins actually accomplished here. I am totally humbled by this book. This is a tour de force of writing. A masterpiece. It is so brilliantly done that it may well be too brilliantly done. I hope not. The message in this book is a powerful indictment of authoritarian central government and a full-throated scream for the freedom and empowerment of individuals. I love Katniss. I love these books.

Movie Review: The Hunger Games

By CosmicConservative
Heh.. this has to be some sort of record between reviewing a book and then reviewing the movie made from the book. So, we saw the movie Saturday. Like fools we went to the IMax viewing, figuring that the movie would be real crowded but the IMax early afternoon viewing would be the least crowded. We ended up sitting in the next to last row in the theater. But that's the beauty of IMax I guess, we ended up with a view comparable to sitting in our normal spot in a non-IMax theater.... it just cost us four dollars more per ticket. I have to add my raves for the performance of Jennifer Lawrence. I also thought the other cast members were excellent. If I were a fan of the books on the level that I am a fan of the LOTR books, there is plenty I could pick apart. Haymitch being a casual drunk vs the book version of Haymitch being a falling-down vomit-stained drunk for example. But they did stick with the story much better than most movies do. Probably because Suzanne Collins was a co-writer of the movie script. The one thing that I have to point out for those who have seen the movie but not read the book is that the violence in the movie is downright tame compared to the book. Too tame, really. The movie just doesn't give the same emotional impact as the book from a pure graphic violence perspective. I suppose that was necessary to maintain a PG-13 rating, and I don't know how much it really matters except that gut-wrenching response was one of the main strengths of the book. None of the injuries sustained by Katniss or Peeta seemed remotely as serious or life-threatening as they did in the book. The notes in the parachuted items was probably a necessary movie device which avoided some of the problems Dune had with the internal dialog issues. In the book Katniss had to figure out Haymitch's strategies by inferring them from the timing and content of his sponsor deliveries. In the movie there's an actual note included. It diminishes Katniss's cunning and resourcefulness. But frankly don't know how else to have done it, so that's probably the best compromise. Not enough time setting up the Gale or Prim relationship. Too much reliance on a few longing glances or brooding stares. But again, the movie was long enough already, so it's hard to be too critical. In the end I think they did about as well as they could have with a book that had to be a real challenge to turn into a movie. For the most part I think they did an excellent job.

Book review: The Hunger Games

By CosmicConservative
Just wrapped up this book on my break. Yeah, I took it to work to read on my breaks. That's actually a first for a work of fiction. I mean I've brought lots of technical books, and even "Why We Get Fat" to work, but not to read, just to have handy if I had a question or wanted to look something up. This time I actually took a book to work so I could read it on a break. So... this is a book that in my opinion gets every big thing right about story telling. I do think it's got some issues with some of the small things, but I've rarely read a book that hits so many right notes on the most basic, and usually missed, things about story telling. Unbelievably great characters. Riveting action. Multiple layers of complex and sometimes shifting conflict. There were moments in this book that I teared up, and I don't tear up easily. Katniss, the protagonist, is one of the more compelling fictional characters I've encountered in a long, long time. Her life story is heartbreaking even before she gets thrown into a murderous last-child-standing-wins arena. The book reminds me of many other books for different reasons. Many people are comparing it to "Harry Potter" but I don't see any resemblance whatsoever to that bloated mass of incomprehensible magic and incompetent battle tactics. (Full disclosure, I liked Harry Potter, but the story in those encyclopedic tomes could have been told better and been more compelling at less than half the number of words). No, what Hunger Games reminds me of are the following works: "The Lottery" by Shirley Jackson "Anthem" by Ayn Rand "Ender's Game" by Orson Scott Card "The Giver" by Lois Lowry You might notice that all of those books are acknowledged to be deeply and deliberately political satires or exposes. Which is how I would characterize "Hunger Games." I hope that most readers understand that Katniss's story is not about Katniss. Katniss is used as a window into the dark nature of human political and social dysfunction. Katniss and Peeta provide a way to explore that dark dysfunction in a raw and visceral way. The clash of cultures between the Capital and the districts is a deliberate and merciless expose of the capability of human indifference to suffering, acceptance of defeat and imposition of power. I suppose some will consider it to be heavy-handed, but I found it to be very deftly done. This is a book that will get a whole lot of people thinking about the danger inherent in allowing overwhelming power to exist in the hands of a privileged few. Which is where this country is headed right now. I hope it helps to wake some people up.

Movie Review: John Carter of Mars

By CosmicConservative
Haven't done a movie review in a while. Haven't really been watching many movies lately, it's gotten too expensive even for my profligate spending habits. But, we had been planning to see JC of Mars when the first previews came out so we finally managed to see it (two weeks after it premiered, I think). It was OK. The graphics were awesome of course, but it's getting to the point that stunning 3D computer graphics are only worth mentioning when they suck. It's become a commodity almost. And it's likely to just get easier and cheaper to do it in the future. In some ways I liked the "prologue" of the movie better than the Mars scenes. The movie starts with John Carter in the Arizona territory where he's been summoned by a local military leader to try to get him to sign up and help fight the Apache. He refuses. Several times. It's a pretty funny sequence and does a good job of setting the character of John Carter for the movie. Once he gets to Mars though, things get a little.... strange. Which is to be expected I suppose. The martian landscapes alternate between stunningly artistic vistas pulled from NASA's orbiters to obvious shots of Lake Powell or the Arizona desert. The dichotomy is startling for those of us who have spent any time in Arizona. And I haven't spent that much time there. The Tharks are presented almost as a schizophrenic race. My memories from the book of the Tharks is that they were brutally savage, but respectful of strength and courage. Sort of like four-armed Apaches in fact... It was sort of strange how Carter was super strong enough to leap about like 1940s Superman, but was overmatched in hand to hand wrestling with both Tharks and martian humans. I suppose it was that way in the book too, although I don't really remember it well enough to be sure. The story was entertaining enough, both the love story and the save the world story. I liked Dejah Thoris, although she came off as a little too buff in some scenes. She was much softer in the original story. But these days female leads in action/adventure movies have to be badass swordfighters or it's sexist. OK, I get that. We all enjoyed it. The fight scenes were well choreographed if a little over the top. The flying ships were really cool, and came across as downright steampunkish. All in all it was probably worth the destruction of a cool C-Note to see the movie, get some snacks and eat out for the evening. But it wouldn't be terrible to wait for the DVD either.