With the stunning dismissal of Bill Polian, the architect of the Colts' 11 playoff appearances, uncertainties remain over Peyton Manning's health and Jim Caldwell's future as coach, but sources say one thing is certain: Colts owner Jim Irsay plans to take Andrew Luck with the draft's first-round pick.
So, in a moment of unbridled optimism I three weeks ago declared that Tim Tebow was bigger than the Cosmic Conservative sports curse which afflicts all teams and sports figures I root for.
Since that day Tim Tebow and the Denver Broncos have not won a game, nor played a decent game. Tebow himself has demonstrated all of the attributes his detractors have accused him of having.
I take it back. The CC curse is all-knowing and all-powerful after all. Tim Tebow is not only not above the CC curse, he has just been slammed by it.
Yeah, I thought the game would be over by now, so turned on the radio in just the right moment to cause Tebow's last pass to be intercepted, giving KC the victory.
So, take me off the Tebow bandwagon...
Every. Single. Game.
If I was interested in a game, it went the wrong way.
Tebow erased most of a year's excellent play in one game.
Even the Cowboys lost and Romo probably broke his hand.
Merry Christmas from the NFL...
:)
This is a tough game for me. I've been a Brady fan for years. I've probably stated here on this blog several times that I think Brady is the best QB in the game and has been for almost a decade. I know I've debated Brady vs. Peyton Manning with Drax here multiple times. When I saw the schedule come out earlier this year and saw the Broncos had a game with the Patriots on my birthday, I thought "cool, a birthday present" because I sure as heck didn't think the game would have any playoff implications for the Broncos.
But now it does. And more than that, this game has become the latest game that will "prove once and for all" that Tim Tebow is not an NFL QB. The cries from around the league and around the world for Bellichek and Brady to stop the Tebow Train are becoming a chorus of "Stop the madness!!" on pretty much every sports venue on the planet.
As far as I'm concerned the Broncos have already far outperformed my expectations. When Tebow took over I said that a six win season would be all the proof needed that Tebow was a perfectly acceptable NFL QB, and said that I had my doubts that they would reach six wins. Now they have eight. If they win this weekend, they'll have nine and be leading the AFC West by one game with two games to play IF the Raiders can get past Detroit.
So, what do I think the Broncos chances are this weekend?
On the surface it seems that the chances are not good. New England is one of the few recognized "elite" teams in the league after all. Besides certain Hall of Fame QB Tom Brady they also have the leading WR in the league in Wes Welker and the record-setting tight end in Rob Gronkowski. Brady is on track to break Dan Marino's yearly yardage record and New England is, I believe, currently the #1 seed in the playoffs if the playoffs started today.
But it's not quite that simple.
For all the cries of the anti-Tebow nation about how Denver has not beaten a decent team this season, the truth is that Denver's wins have come against teams with a combined 41% winning percentage while New England's wins have come against teams with a combined 39% winning percentage. The "best" team each has beaten (according to current win-loss record) is the same team, the New York Jets (at 8-5). Denver has the lowest rated passing game in the league, but New England has the lowest rated passing defense in the league. In fact New England has the lowest rated defense overall (but is above average against the run).
The "conventional wisdom" is that Denver Defense will not be able to stop Brady/Welker/Gronk and that the Denver Offense can't possibly keep up with the Pats offense, so that it is ridiculous to suggest that "Tebow time" will be meaningful since the Patriots will likely be up by 30 points by then.
And frankly that's about how I see it too. But I can't help but think that the single most obvious thing about the Broncos since Tebow took over is that "conventional wisdom" has been wrong every time.
Could be a good game. I probably won't have the intestinal fortitude to be able to listen to it on the radio...
So, I've been intrigued enough by the Tebow phenomenon to have entered half a dozen Tebow posts here on CC in the past month or so. And I think my general appreciation for Tebow has been clear, even though I have pointed out that I share some of the concern of all the "experts" about his seemingly poor performance through the first three quarters of the games he's played.
But in spite of all of those concerns I find myself really rooting for the guy. And this weekend I realized that's what I was really doing. Sure I'm rooting for the Broncos to win, they are my "home team" after all, but I'm really rooting for Tim Tebow.
And as I drove into work and was listening to Chris Carter and Merril Hoge on ESPN radio eat a little crow (and both did so with some class, frankly) I realized that they were struggling with the same thing I've been struggling with. And Hoge, at least, came the closest to sharing my own perspective on the Tebow thing.
Tebow is bigger than football. I don't mean that in a Tebow-hype way, I mean that what Tebow represents as a sports figure is more about SPORTS than it is about FOOTBALL. Tebow calls himself a "football player playing quarterback" but that's not quite right. What Tebow has managed to become is a personification of the essence of sports as it used to be in this country. It's not about the player, it's about the team. It's not about individual statistics, it's about being part of something bigger than that. It's not about style, it's about competing. It's not about winning or losing, it's about never giving up. It's not about beating the other guy, it's about having faith in yourself.
I have come to appreciate Tim Tebow because Tim Tebow has reminded me what I always thought sports was supposed to be all about. It's about learning lessons, having faith in your teammates, doing the best you can with the skills YOU have, and never, ever, EVER giving up.
That's what Tim Tebow is showing America. And there could not be a better time for the kids of this country to see someone do that.
Now that I've realized that, I suppose that I have to say I've become a Tebow fan. Not because I want him to win football games for the Denver Broncos (although I do) but because I want him to continue to show the kids of this nation that you CAN be a team player, you CAN be a "baller", you CAN do it your own way and be successful, and you CAN be at the top of the game and not be a selfish, self-important ass.
So go for it Tim. Just keep ballin. Just keep doing your thing and working your butt off and never giving up. Do it for the kids who look up to you.
So last night I couldn't help myself. I spent about two hours while listening to the MNF game on the radio perusing all the ESPN, Sports Illustrated, Fox News and other sports "news" sites to see what the latest take on Tim Tebow is.
This is actually relatively new to me. I've never cared to read through all the opinions of a bunch of has-been or never-was football players about a player. Normally I just see the headline stories and I sort of assume that those stories reflect the overall opinion of the sports talking heads about a guy. And usually I think that's right. Certainly the NFL analysts have been pretty consistent in their analysis of Jay Cutler (he's the perennial "almost superstar" who never quite gets over the hump) or Tony Romo (he's an erratic conundrum who sometimes seems like he could outplay Brady or Manning, but then lays the most monstrous eggs imaginable at the worst possible times) or Aaron Rodgers (he's going to make Green Bay completely forget about a guy named Brett Fa.... uh.. what's his name?)...
So I wanted to see if that was true of Tebow.
And it is. The headline stories are all about how Tebow is winning in spite of his awful QB skills. In general the only positive Tebow sports stories are the fluff human interest pieces. All the "hard analysis" stories, even those that are seemingly pro-Tebow, still say that Tebow can't throw, can't operate out of the pocket, won't be a long-term QB and can't take a team deep into the playoffs. Not a single story I've read predicts Tebow will be successful, or even a starting QB next year.
The blogs are the worst. The venom dripping from the comments about Tebow is palpable. The guy is HATED with a passion that I don't think I've ever seen. He's hated so much that the hate bleeds over to anyone who supports Tebow. Besides Tebow the most vilified sports figure on the blogs seems to be Skip Bayless, who has been a vocal Tebow supporter on some ESPN talking head shows. If anything the hate for Skip is even MORE than the hate for Tebow. It's really sort of stunning.
Every now and then you'll see someone grudgingly give Tebow some credit, but for the most part, no matter what Tebow does, the narrative seems firmly established. He can't throw. He is too slow. His mechanics are unfixable. His accuracy will never improve. He has nothing to do with Denver winning games (the credit is given mostly to Von Miller).
If anyone attempts to defend Tebow the sneering condescension heaped upon them is like an avalanche of vitriol. Only an idiot would suggest that Tebow can play in the NFL. Just to say "give the kid a chance" turns you into a "Teblow fan" or worse.
So I've taken another look at the rest of Denver's schedule and compared that to the Oakland Raiders schedule.
It's almost impossible to believe, but on paper I would say that Denver actually has a slightly better chance to win the division than the Raiders do. Of course the Broncos could lay an egg in every remaining game, but realistically I think the Broncos have a shot to win two or three games, while realistically I think the same is true of the Raiders, and the Broncos have most of the tie-breaker edges over the Raiders. In most scenarios Denver actually wins the tie-breaker.
And if Denver wins the division, then they get at least one playoff game at home. And right now I think it looks like if that happens, they would play Cincinnatti in the first round.
Could Denver beat Cincinnatti?
I believe they actually could.
Which would mean that Tebow might actually win a playoff game this year.
And if he does, I can't imagine what that level of cognitive dissonance will do to the Tebow-hating population, but more importantly... what does that do to Elway?
Can Elway possibly bench Tebow if Tebow takes a 1-4 team and wins an actual playoff game? I don't see how. I think the Denver fan base would turn on Elway in a huge way.
Right now I think it mostly hinges on this Sunday. I think Denver HAS to beat Chicago to actually have a chance to win the division. The Raiders still have Green Bay to play, and I doubt they can win that game (but of course... "any given Sunday" caveats apply). Denver has New England. Can Denver beat New England? I dunno...
Tebow passed for a season-best 202 yards and two third-quarter touchdowns to help the unflappable Broncos win their fifth straight game, 35-32 over the Minnesota Vikings Sunday on Matt Prater's 23-yard field goal as time expired.
via Denver Broncos vs. Minnesota Vikings - Recap - December 04, 2011 - ESPN.
The Tebow narrative is going to find it difficult to explain this one. The Denver defense was awful, apart from winning the turnover battle 3 to 2. Rookie QB Christian Ponder ripped the Denver D apart.
The most common sneering comment made by Tebow haters in the last seven weeks of the Broncos amazing resurgence has been "Yeah, as long as the defense keeps the Broncos in games, Tebow's miserable offensive performance can be just enough to scrape out a lucky victory, but when a team puts up more than 20 points, Tebow will be exposed."
Well, Tebow went toe to toe with Christian Ponder trading scores all through the second half, tying the game with 96 seconds left, and then winning it on the last play of the game.
Tebow went 10 for 15 for 202 yards, with a QB rating of 149.
How many games do you think John Elway hit a QB rating of 149 in his first ten games?
If you answered "John Elway was lucky to hit a QB rating of 75 in his first ten games" you would be correct.
So, let's say you are a GM of a NFL team and someone offers you one of the two following QBs based on statistics alone, after starting at least 9 NFL games, sight unseen...
Which one do you take? (all stats normalized to a "per game" standard)
QB #1
Total yards from scrimmage per game: 164 (combined passing and rushing)
Touchdowns: 0.73 (combined passing and rushing)
Turnovers: 1.3 per game (combined passing and rushing)
Win % 27%
QB Rating: 50
QB #2
Total yards from scrimmage: 243
Touchdowns: 2.4
Turnovers: 0.63
Win %: 67%
QB rating: 80
Is this even a hard choice?
SAN DIEGO -- Tim Tebow wasn't watching as San Diego's Nick Novak lined up to attempt a 53-yard field goal that would have given the Chargers an overtime victory over the Denver Broncos.
He was praying, of course.
Did Tebow ask for a miss?
"I might have said that. Or maybe a block. Maybe all of it," the Denver quarterback said with a laugh.
Whatever, it worked.
Novak missed wide right. Tebow moved the Broncos down the field and Matt Prater kicked a 37-yard field goal with 29 seconds left in overtime to lift the Broncos to a 16-13 victory Sunday over the Chargers, who've lost six straight games for the first time in 10 years.
I was certain that the Broncos would lay an egg today. When I checked the score in the fourth quarter and the Broncos were down a field goal, I said "No way. Not again. This is not possible."