Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Sports

NFL Top 100

By CosmicConservative
The countdown is complete. Jerry Rice was the final player revealed in The Top 100: NFL's Greatest Players. NFL Network presented a 10-part series, with each one-hour show revealing 10 players in a countdown of the top 100 of all time as determined by a blue-ribbon panel. Each player is presented by a noteworthy individual in the world of sports and entertainment explaining what made that player one of the greats. via NFL.com | NFL Top 100 | Tracker.
Not sure if those of you who follow the NFL saw this. It's worth looking at. Of course there is no way any such list can satisfy everyone, or even most people. Questions like "How in the heck is Chris Carter, not on this list!?!" are perfectly legitimate questions. Is Jerry Rice truly the best player in the NFL ever? I'm a big Jerry Rice fan but is he really the best ever? Better than Jim Brown? Better than Joe Montana (you know, the guy who THREW all those passes for Jerry Rice to catch). Is Joe Montana the top quarterback ever, and does the top quarterback ever really fit as #4 overall? Lawrence Taylor is #3? My reaction to the list is both one of appreciation of the effort and a general sense of overall being a good list of the top 100 players (with a few notable exceptions, like Chris Carter) but at the same time I have major problems with almost every name on the list. I suppose the Peyton vs Brady debate is still underway, but is it even remotely reasonable that Peyton is #8 and Brady is #21? That alone indicates major problems with the entire list. Emmitt Smith, the top rusher in league history, is #28, and is #7 among running backs alone? What the heck is the point of running long enough and hard enough to set the overall record for yards, touchdowns and all-purpose yards if you end up being ranked below Gale Freaking Sayers!? I like Gale Sayers, but his career was marked by three amazing years and an injury plagued three more years where he was decidedly mortal. How does he get ranked above an Emmett Smith? Because he was pretty when he ran? Because Billy Dee Williams played him in a major motion picture? I call major BS on that. If Gale Sayers deserves that ranking, then so does Terrell Davis. For the same reason. One final comment. Brett Favre ranked above Tom Brady. That's just laughable.

ESPN: Brady vs P. Manning

By CosmicConservative
I thought this was an excellent story on the relative careers and accomplishments of Tom Brady vs. Peyton Manning.
Webster's defines a rivalry as "competition for the same objective or for superiority in the same field." That means Tom Brady and Peyton Manning have a rivalry. A phenomenal one, actually. And yet, it doesn't feel like one. via Bill Simmons: Tom Brady and Peyton Manning -- the rivalry - ESPN.
I guess I'm not sure where Bill Simmons gets the idea that "it doesn't feel like a rivalry." It sure feels like one to me, and has for years. I was the one saying Brady was an elite QB way back before the huge 2007 season where Brady and the Patriots redefined offensive dominance. You remember that season, it was the one where a poorly thrown ball into double coverage by a desperate Eli Manning (irony?) stuck implausibly to the receiver's helmet and cost Brady his fourth Super Bowl ring. Still, I think that much of what Simmons writes in his article is pretty good analysis and not bad writing either. I've been saying for almost a decade that my expectation is that in the end Brady will end up with more rings than Peyton, and that over time Brady's legend will grow while Peyton's will diminish. In ten years I expect Brady will be near the top of everyone's list of "greatest QBs ever" while Peyton will be near the top of everyone's list of "greatest individual performers ever." Brady will be remembered in the way Joe Montana is today while Peyton will have more of a Dan Marino vibe. Just sayin'

Denver Broncos...

By CosmicConservative
So, I've been looking at stats for the Broncos for the 2010 season so far. With one game to go, the Broncos are pretty much undeniably the worst team in the AFC. If not for Carolina, they'd be the worst team in the NFL. Their defense is the absolute worst, including Carolina. But their offense is only in the bottom third of the NFL, so there's some hope. This team gives up 30 points a game! Just as I didn't think Kyle Orton was the cause of the Broncos problems, even if Tim Tebow is "the next John Elway" he won't fix what's broken on this team. Until the Broncos deal with the worst defense in the NFL they won't be able to do anything but pray for mediocrity. There are rumors that John Elway is considering taking over football operations for the Broncos. I sort of doubt that since he has his own arena league team and is partners in other pro franchises, plus he has a ton of other things on his plate. But I suppose it's possible. The question is whether Elway is a Tebow supporter or not. He has had very little to say about the matter in public. Right now I'd say that things do not look good for a 2011 season for the Broncos. And as if things aren't bad enough, their one true defensive star player, Champ Bailey, is a free agent next year. Whooo boy.

Tebow watch...

By CosmicConservative
So, after a mediocre but respectable first start as an NFL quarterback, Tim Tebow lifted the Broncos to a 4th quarter comeback victory, 24-23, over the struggling Houston Texans. Tebow's stats were again relatively pedestrian, but it was his first 300 yard passing game and he completed one TD pass and ran for another in bringing the Broncos back from a 17 point halftime deficit. I only watched the second half, so I missed the fans booing the Broncos play selection, but what I hear is that the Broncos called very few passing plays and the Texans were teeing off on Tebow and the running game just like Oakland had done the week before. After halftime the coaches finally decided to let Tebow be an actual quarterback and he lit the place up on a couple of high-pressure, high-drama drives, including the eventual winning score which he ran in on a broken play when his right side blocking broke down and he simply turned and sprinted about 30 yards to the left pylon for a 6 yard TD run. On that play he looked like the sort of QB who can turn a broken play into a big play using his feet. My initial impression of Tebow was more or less reinforced. He looked like a rookie on a few plays, and looks like he's still getting used to the speed and defensive reaction of NFL caliber defensive players. He has a very nice feel for the pocket when he wants to, and stepped up to deliver very well thrown balls on the few plays that the Broncos offensive line was able to actually create a pocket. When the pocket collapsed he ducked left and right with equal ease, on one play making a pass that would have done Jay Cutler, Dan Marino and Brett Favre proud, going back across the field probably 40 yards to an open receiver on the other end of the field. He managed the game well, as far as I could tell. He didn't screw up assignments, he identified the blitz and was able to find the man-on-man receiver, he was brilliant on the bubble screens that the Broncos called, turning several of them into critical first downs. But most importantly to me, he clearly won his teammates over. He reminded me of Brett Favre in his jubilant enthusiasm after every first down and especially after touchdowns. It was clear that the whole team fed off his energy. Even the defense, after making a critical stop, found Tebow on the sidelines grabbing the playmaker and high-fiving or chest bumping with them. I didn't see Tebow's first quarter interception, but he said it was a ball he shouldn't have thrown and he didn't seem overly upset with it. Drew Brees made two TERRIBLE throws on MNF so I'm not going to judge Tebow on one poor decision. In the main I would say that Tebow has shown some real promise with his skills, and has shown himself to be a leader that the team gets behind and feeds off his energy. Keeping my fingers crossed, but right now I think Tebow is doing fine.

Credit where credit is due

By CosmicConservative
Well, I have to give props to Jay Cutler. He made some downright awesome plays last night. He had a couple of moments where he resembled the Jay Cutler of the Denver era, but overall he looked sharp, effective and in command of the Chicago offense. Man that guy can hurl the pigskin... There were so many throws that Kyle Orton could not even remotely attempt that I lost count. Given time to plant his feet and let one fly, I believe he could throw that football 80 yards in the air. He chunked a couple of 60 yard throws without even trying hard. Plus he did most of this after taking a hard shot that split open his chin. Da Bears are now the NFC North division champions and could end up with a bye in the playoffs. Maybe we'll see Cutler in a Super Bowl after all.

Tebow to start next Sunday

By CosmicConservative
Well, this is interesting. According to KOA radio news, Tim Tebow will start next Sunday. I expect that we'll see more of the passing game from Tim this time. As much as I like Kyle Orton, I do think this is the right thing for the Broncos to do.

More thoughts on NFL weekend

By CosmicConservative
I wasn't able to see the Cowboys-Redskins game, but I did catch some of the Eagles-Giants game. The Eagles really stole one there. I'm not sure if I've ever seen a game won on a time-running-out punt return for a touchdown. Maybe so, but it's hard to imagine a bigger kick in the gut for the team on the losing end, especially when they were ahead by a touchdown just minutes earlier. What I read of the Cowboys game it looked like another 3/4 game for the 'Boys. At least this time they did enough in three quarters to hold off the Redskins fourth quarter comeback attempt. If that game had gone to O/T I have no doubt the Redskins would have won. This is the first game since Garrett took over that looks like his team quit on him in the fourth quarter. I hope that's a fluke, and not a return to the malaise that the Cowboys suffered under Wade Phillips. We'll find out next week, I suppose. Tony Romo may be back for their Christmas day game, but I suspect not. Reports are that he still looked pretty hurt while throwing on Sunday. Indianapolis saved their season for one more week. They have to win out to assure a playoff spot I think. Of course they are capable, but this has been a very poor year for Peyton Manning. His only bright spot is probably that his little brother is also having a poor year or else he'd be giving up bragging rights to Eli. Peyton Manning is currently not even in the top ten in QB ratings. Tony Romo is still rated higher than Manning. Know who's right behind Manning in the ratings? Jon Kitna! Speaking of all-time elite QBs, the Patriots keep rolling along. They made it interesting but in the end Brady chalked up yet another win at home to keep the streak going and keep Brady comfortably on top of the QB ratings list. 31 TDs vs 4 interceptions? That's inSANE! Very sad to see New Orleans lose. I had thought they were getting back to Super Bowl form, but they didn't look like world beaters yesterday. Oh, and look out for San Diego. Those guys have been playing lights out now for weeks. Right now I think they could beat anyone on the league. And they are hungry.

Tebow's first start...

By CosmicConservative
Well, his QB rating was 100.5, 8/16 for 138 yards, one TD and no interceptions. And I saw at least three perfectly thrown balls dropped, one a sure touchdown. Without those drops he'd have been 11/16 for close to 200 yards and two touchdowns. Add in his 78 yards rushing (and one touchdown) and that's a pretty good day for Michael Vick. Considering that he spent the whole day with the Oakland front line in his face, I thought he did pretty darn well. Also it was a rainy day and the ball was slick enough that Oakland's QB, Jason Campbell, was having a tough time finding his own receivers. Based on his results in throwing the ball, I think the Denver game plan was seriously flawed by calling twice as many running plays as passing plays. Since the Raiders were teeing off on the running plays on first and second down, Tebow was in 3rd and long on most of his passing plays, with at least a couple Raiders in his backfield. Yet I didn't see him make a throw that I would call a bad throw. And after all the talk about his awkward throwing motion, I have to say he either improved it dramatically, or else people are just full of BS. He doesn't have the quickest release in the game, but he's at least as quick getting rid of the ball as Kyle Orton, who also isn't known as a quick-release QB, and yet was leading the league in passing until two games ago. I'd say it was a good start. It's not Tebow's fault that the Denver defense gives up 80 yard plays like candy to the opposition. For all the talk about Tebow vs. Orton, the real problem with these Broncos is a defense that is incapable of stopping the run, and gives up huge passing plays at least three or four times per game. It will be interesting to see who starts next week.

Shanahan circus continues in D.C.

By CosmicConservative
Donovan McNabb to second-string. Then to third-string. Then no guarantee that he'll be back next season. Maybe he's no John Elway after all. The ever-dramatic Washington Redskins upset the NFL apple cart once again Friday when coach Mike Shanahan announced Rex Grossman as his starter for the rest of the season, beginning with Sunday's game at Dallas. McNabb will be the No. 2 quarterback against the Cowboys, then drop to No. 3 behind Grossman and John Beck for the final two games of the season. And after that? "I also told him," Shanahan said, "that I cannot guarantee him that he will be back next year." via Washington Redskins to bench Donovan McNabb for Rex Grossman vs. Dallas Cowboys - ESPN.
I really am glad that Mike Shanahan is playing his bizarre player personnel games in Washington now instead of Denver. Of course I admit that Denver didn't necessarily get the better end of that deal with the sorry state of the Broncos organization, but still, this sort of thing used to drive me crazy in Denver. Now I don't really fault Shanahan for deciding that since their playoff hopes are gone, he should see what his other quarterbacks can do for the team. I fault Shanahan for the never-ending circus that has surrounded Donovan McKnabb and Albert Haynsworth, and to a lesser extent, before his injury, Clinton Portis. When Mike Shanahan likes you, you are an awesome football playing machine. I like how he was comparing McKnabb to John Elway earlier in the season. But when Mike Shanahan doesn't like you, you are a worthless sack of bull excrement. McKnabb is getting the bull excrement treatment now. I think it's fair to say that I predicted Shanahan would take his locker-room destroying style to Washington. And I also think I said I was glad for it. At least the Cowboys have a chance now to climb out of sole possession of last place in the NFC East.

Tim Tebow must play

By CosmicConservative
Of all the bone-headed, ignorant, foolish, unaware, un-coachly things that the Broncos did yesterday, the most bone-headed, ignorant, foolish, unaware and un-coachly thing of all was not putting Tim Tebow in when Kyle Orton took a rib injury. Putting Orton back in when the game was lost, lost, lost, and Orton had already thrown three interceptions and been the cause of at least one fumble... Well, it tells me that these coaches are either just plain stupid, or else they have something against Tebow. I know there are a lot of people who are knee-jerk anti-Tebow people because Tebow has had the gall to speak out against abortion. I have no doubt that some of those people are NFL coaches. I'd put the odds at about 50/50 that Tebow's current coaches are among those NFL coaches. But regardless, Tebow must play. I can't think of any team in the past fifty years who would not have put a first round draft pick in under those circumstances. Kyle Orton is a known commodity. I like Kyle Orton. But it is quite literally true that there will never be a better time to put Tebow in a game than when the Broncos were down 3+ touchdowns in the 4th quarter and their starting QB after throwing three interceptions and fumbling the ball had received a rib injury. I mean it simply doesn't get any more "no-brainer" than that. This does not bode well for the Broncos current coaching competence.