Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Hobbies

Geminids bust...

By CosmicConservative
So, I get up to walk my dog before dawn every morning. Stupid dog. But today I thought that would be great because of the Geminids meteor shower. 4:00 - 6:00 am was projected to be a top time to observe shooting stars. And it usually takes about ten minutes to walk the dog. Not. One. Meteor. Bummer.

Google Sky to add amateur astrophotos

By CosmicConservative

Alan Boyle writes: Google and the Slooh virtual-telescope company have announced a deal to integrate tens of thousands of pictures captured by Slooh's members automatically into Google Earth's astronomical database. The arrangement could bring scientific crowdsourcing to a whole new level.

Millions of Internet users have already been participating in space-themed projects such as SETI @ Home, Galaxy Zoo and Moon Zoo, but those projects mostly involve sifting through data collected by the professionals. The collaboration announced today immediately puts images of more than 35,000 celestial objects into a Google Sky layer within the free Google Earth standalone program. New Slooh pictures will be added as soon as they're taken.

via Cosmic Log - Sharing the Google Sky.

Very cool.

WoW 4.0.1 release notes

By CosmicConservative
I won't call this a "review" because I've only played my rogue since the release came out Tuesday, I haven't even logged onto my paladin, or my even rarer characters, the druid and the mage. I've been playing World of Warcraft for a little over two years I think. In that time there has been one MAJOR release (Wrath of the Lich King, which upped the level limit from 70 to 80) and several minor releases, some of which introduced new content, and some of which introduced new items or abilities. This Tuesday Blizzard released the "4.0.1" version of WoW. Of course we have highly motivated WoW players in our guild, and our guild website is pretty active, so I knew that there were some pretty big changes coming. I had read up on all the conversions of the old loot types into a greatly reduced number of loot types, and I knew that there was going to be some changes to the talent trees. But I frankly was not remotely prepared for what they did to my rogue. In fact the main reason I have not played my paladin is because I've been spending too much time trying to figure out how to rework my rogue to have something remotely comparable to my old damage per second. Before Tuesday the talent tree was, I think 71 talents. You could split them up any way you liked between one of three trees for each character. For rogues that meant you could choose talents from the "assassination", "subtlety" and "combat" trees. They are called "trees" because the talents have dependencies which means you can't choose some talents until you pick other talents, and you have to pick a certain number of lower level talents in one tree before you can pick higher level talents from that tree. Talents offer bonuses to existing abilities or entirely new abilities that are only possible if you choose that talent. Most of the trees include some super powerful ability that is at the very top of the tree which forces you to invest lots of talent points into lower level talents just to get that super powerful one. Most players picked one tree to focus on and dabble a bit in the other trees for specific needs. But you COULD build a character with more or less equal investment in all three trees. That's all gone. Now they have cut the number of talent points in half to 36 and you have to pick one tree as your main tree and spend all but a few of your talent points in that tree before it "unlocks" the other trees. Why Blizzard felt it was necessary to force all characters to be specialists is a mystery to me. Of course if you are a raider, you'll specialize in a raid tree. If you are a PvPer you'll specialize in a PvP tree. If you choose to be a jack of all trades you gain lots of flexibility, but at the expense of excelling in one thing. Now you don't have a choice, you have to pick one thing to excel at and throw a few remaining points at a couple of talents from the other trees. But that's not terribly bad for me since I am a raider. My main spec and off spec have always been raiding specs, so it's a little irritating that I am forced to fill in one tree before the other trees unlock, but I would likely have wound up with something similar anyway. It's just the lack of an option to generalize that irks me. What if I LIKED being a jack of all trades? What if I LIKED being an average DPS raider who could throw in some unusual talents for specialized situations? (For example, only one rogue tree used to have any significant multi-attack capability, and that is not on the main raid tree, but is sometimes very useful in a raid when you are fighting several mid-level monsters instead of a single boss.) But I figured, "oh well" and just redid my talents, wondering how the end result would work out after trying to figure out entirely new talents for my rogue. Well, so I raided Wed. and Thu. night. Ug. In most raids for the last several months my rogue has been one of the top DPSers in the guild. There is one other rogue who usually outdoes me, but in most boss fights the three rogues in the guild were usually 1,2 and 3 in damage. Which is as it should be, since rogues are by far the most fragile melee character and as such SHOULD do more damage since they are taking much higher risks than, for example, a paladin who wears plate armor, or a hunter who roams around the edge of the fight plinking their arrows at the enemy. So our first big boss fight, and I was number 11 in damage. Surely some sort of fluke. In fact I did mess up and forget to trigger one of my new talents that provides a boost in haste. Aha! So the next big boss fight I remembered to trigger that talent.... and I moved up to #7. #7. This is just insulting. Well, in the course of two days we cleared out all but the final two bosses in Ice Crown Citadel. Usually we make much better progress than that, but many guild members were having problems re-learning their characters, and so we wiped probably about twice as often as we normally would. By the end of day 2 though we were all doing pretty well. But I never got higher than #6 in damage for a boss fight. This is an ego-crushing thing for me. To put some raw numbers on it, pre-4.0.1 on a typical boss fight, I would easily top 10,000 DPS. So would our other two rogues. In fact we had gotten to where we were typically in the upper 11,000 to mid 12,000 range, depending on how much the fight required the melee to run around in the fight. In straight standup fights where you could just slug it out and optimize your attack rotation, two of us were topping 13,000 DPS with regularity, and the third was topping 13,000 on occasion. Those are the fights I excel at, so I was routinely the top DPSer on those fights and all three top slots were pretty much always rogues. Now I only topped 10,000 on one fight. And that was one where you gain a damage buff during the fight. Most fights I was at 7,000 - 8,000 DPS. That means my average DPS dropped from the mid 11,000s to around 8,000. That's a drop of 3,000 DPS (to put it into perspective, there are quite a few raiders who find it hard to top 3,000 DPS on their own, so that's like losing an entire raid member's worth of DPS). Now, our most highly equipped rogue did manage to get into the 10,000 DPS range in a couple of fights, and was consistently doing about 1,500 DPS more than my rogue, so I have some hope of regaining some of my DPS leetness, but even so other classes were doing far more damage than us rogues. Warlocks, in particular, seem to have been buffed to an insane level. My DPS may have dropped by 3,000, but warlocks were reporting gains in DPS in the 5,000 DPS to 7,000 DPS range. They went from being one of the least effective raid DPSers to becoming the unquestioned champs of DPS. And this is doubly irritating since warlocks also have some of the best multiple attack options, meaning that they were leading DPS in EVERY fight, no matter what type of fight it was. Blizzard has some rogue-haters on their game design team is all I can figure. Every time they have messed around with fundamental build options, rogues absolutely suck for months afterward. Finally the withering barrage of complaints pointing out that rogues are uniquely vulnerable and must be played with a high degree of training and skill and as such SHOULD be the highest DPS class in the game, finally that argument seems to remind the game designers of simple common sense and rogues regain their role as the pinnacle of melee single-target DPS. But in the meantime rogues are virtually banned from raiding in pickup groups because if a rogue can't lead the damage, then a raid leader is taking a huge risk with very little reward when they choose to add a rogue to the raid. So rogues are back to being the last kid selected for the game, and if there are enough other classes looking to raid, rogues will be left out again. So yeah, I'm a little ticked off. It would have been one thing if they had nerfed rogues a bit to bring them back to the pack a little, but instead they beat the rogue black and blue with the nerf bat. I will say that I like what they did with the types of loot quite a bit. I had grown tired of all the different levels of emblems and marks and other means of keeping score. Now it's simple and tidy. They also reworked the "glyph" mechanic pretty significantly, but I haven't really looked into that in enough detail to know if I like it or not. All I know right now is that my rogue has three "prime" glyph slots, but I have only been able to find two prime glyphs that give her any benefit at all, so the third slot is basically worthless. I assume that there is some new glyph that is rare and hasn't yet made its way to the auction house or something. But that's still irritating for now. It is possible that my talent build is not optimal. I will be chatting with our rogue leader in the guild this weekend to see how his build was put together. Raiding or PvP players typically go to one of the WoW character forums (like "elitist jerks") to see what the "experts" are saying to use as a talent build. I'm stubborn and always do my own talent builds instead of following an "optimized" template. However, with such a dramatic decline in DPS effectiveness, I may just have to go sneak a peek at the new top talent builds to see if I've done something really stupid. One thing about the release is that it seems more unstable than usual. I've had several really unpleasant things happen to my character since the release, including having the game tell me I had been kicked out of the guild when I had not. I've also had many glitches where using a weapon ability triggers summoning my mount and other weirdness. It seems to have trouble placing characters into raid groups and we've had half the guild raid party on occasion wandering different instances of the same raid instead of being in the same instance. I am confident that Blizzard will quickly fix all those bugs. But for a limited minor release like this to have that many bugs doesn't bode well for the upcoming "Cataclysm" release. Hopefully by then rogues will be back firmly ensconced at the top of the DPS meters where they belong... So my take right now is that

On bamboo fly rods and the apex of human civilization...

By CosmicConservative
When my father-in-law passed away one item from his garage collection of life's detritus fell into my hands. It was an old bamboo fly rod. Since I am the only fly fisherman in the immediate family, it was naturally assumed that the fly rod would find a home in my fishing collection. Of course I was happy to have it both as a potential additional fishing implement, and, more importantly, as a memento of the life of a hard-working, decent, caring and intelligent man. Alas, after taking it to a local fly rod shop which specializes in restoring old bamboo fly rods, the rod is essentially unusable due to years where it appears to have soaked up so much water that it has de-laminated to the point of structural failure. Still it remains valuable in non-fishing ways. But the whole episode exposes the atavistic side of my own personality, a side which is surprisingly strong for a person who is totally into technology in virtually all of its forms. I don't own a functioning bamboo fly rod. It turns out that you can buy one for about $100, which is quite comparable to modern graphite fly rods, of which I own several. So there is no reason, other than financial limitations, for my next fly rod purchase not to be a bamboo rod. Of course if you buy a bamboo rod, you really need to buy silk fly line to go with it if you truly want to complete the "traditional" picture of the compleat angler. And I admit, I have a strong desire to do exactly that. There is something very appealing to me in the idea of using a traditional bamboo fly rod along with flies I have tied myself using traditional patterns, materials and techniques. Doing so provides a sort of link back to generations of anglers and to a simpler, slower world that we've all but left behind, and which will likely disappear entirely within this century. To catch a fish, especially a spunky sixteen inch trout, with such gear would be a proud moment. Again, back to that quiet, contemplative, atavistic side of my personality, at such moments I can understand how some people view modern technology as dehumanizing and spiritually destructive. This is the side of me that makes me pick up a flint rock and try to make a functioning knife, arrowhead or spearhead. Or the side that wants to one day build a canoe out of traditional pre-technological materials and go fishing in it. Isaac Asimov once wrote a short story about human civilization which had forgotten simple arithmetic because technology had developed to the point that it was self-sustaining and humans no longer participated even in the production of technological devices, they simply used them. With ubiquitous calculators available from cradle to grave, humans had forgotten how to add, subtract, multiply and divide. In this world one man eventually became curious about how calculators worked, and essentially reverse-engineered simple mathematical rules. He attempted to educate others about his discovery but the common reaction was a deep aversion to his "parlor tricks". Calculators were, after all, free and made no errors. Sometimes I contemplate the far future and see a time when human civilization (perhaps with or without actual "humans" involved) has colonized a large portion of our galaxy. I wonder if there will remain even the tiniest fraction of historical knowledge about humanity's past and the long, arduous struggle from the muck and mud of pre-historical hunter-gatherer societies. At some point whatever beings have replaced the humans we know today may try to determine the point of human civilization that provided the most rewarding lifestyle which balanced the human's connection with nature against their utilization of technology. And I think the bamboo fly rod and hand-tied flies just might epitomize that perfect blend of the two sides of human nature. It seems to do it for me anyway. Yeah, I'll be getting a bamboo fly rod, and I'll be using it with silk line and hand-tied flies, and I will quietly revel in the contemplation of the simple fusion of nature and human ingenuity as I reel in a spunky cutthroat trout.

The King is dead!

By CosmicConservative
Ding dong, the Lich King is dead! Heh. Epic battle does not even begin to describe it. My rogue survived the entire fight, which is pretty amazing considering all the various things that could have one-shotted her. She now has the title "Kingslayer" which is the highest title in the game. But, the king didn't drop any rogue loot. Which isn't a surprise, rogue loot is always the least frequently dropped in the game. It would have been nice to get one of the top daggers in the game though. But it's more than enough just to know that we took the king down. I think most non-gamers would be absolutely stunned by the level of planning, development, strategy, tactics and cooperation that is needed to be successful in such a battle. The "defile" spell that the LK drops several times in the fight is one that requires just one person making just one tiny mistake and the whole party will wipe. It's sort of interesting how the whole thing developed. For weeks and weeks we barely made any progress at all, the defile spell was just killing us. Then a few weeks ago we had our first success in dealing with the defile spell, and from that point we had rapid progress. Just last week was the first time we reached the final phase of the fight, and by this week we were reaching that phase almost every attempt. Each time we reached that phase we had lost about 1/3 of the raid to the various deadly spells or attacks, and we knew that if we could reach that last phase with all but a few raiders alive, we'd be in a great position to win the thing. And on our fourth try tonight, that's exactly what happened. Nobody screwed up the defile, we were able to take down all the valkyries and we navigated the various dances we had to perform and lost only four out of 25 raid members before the final phase. Yeah, it's only a game, but it's a danged difficult game, and yes, it does feel good to have accomplished the goal.

The virtual "drug" economy?

By CosmicConservative
The company behind Mafia Wars and Farmville doesn't like to talk about the sad addicts who fuel its profits. But it does quietly run a special store for them, where imaginary credits are bought with very real bank transfers. via The Secret Dealer for Farmville Addicts.
The article is about how Zynga, the company that produces Farmville, Frontierville, Mafia Wars and all those other annoying Facebook games has a near-secret store where you can exchange real dollars for virtual products or cash. The minimum purchase at this store is $500. Yes, you read that right. $500. And it only accepts direct bank-to-bank wire transfers. No credit cards, no PayPal... just direct bank-to-bank wire transfers. The author of this article, and the bulk of the commenters hammer the "drug addiction" meme. Of course the discussion ranges over a whole host of "virtual" products or services that people pay real money for, ranging from online games like World of Warcraft to watching a movie. As any regular reader here knows, I play World of Warcraft, and I played Everquest when it first came out. Long before either of those existed, I played (and still play) Dungeons and Dragons which is a paper and pencil game that is based around imaginary characters adventuring in imaginary worlds and gaining imaginary loot. I pay something like $150 a year for my WoW subscription. I probably play the game about ten hours a week, so easily 500 hours per year. I don't watch TV, and I'm sure most "normal" folks spend a lot more than ten hours watching TV. So I don't feel like my time is any less productive than most other folks. And I enjoy the game, and that's what I pay for. When you boil it down to the bottom line, I'm paying a bit less than thirty cents per hour for my entertainment. Throw in the original cost of the game and the two expansion sets, and that probably brings the cost up to a bit more than thirty cents per hour. A typical 2 hour movie is more than ten times that expensive. A round of golf is more than twenty times that expensive, and that's not counting clubs, bag, balls, tees, etc... I've said before on this blog that I try not to be judgmental about how people spend their time. I've endured more than enough scorn and ridicule for playing D&D. In fact WoW is probably much more socially acceptable than D&D, even though the cost of D&D is probably only pennies per hour overall. Heck, the cost of the gas I spend to go play D&D is probably orders of magnitude more than the money I've spent on the game itself. And let's not even start on fishing or my telescope hobbby.... In the end I guess if people can afford it and it gives them enjoyment that is worth the money to them, who am I to judge? But $500 minimum purchase fee for online Farmville junk? Seriously?

Level 80 paladin

By CosmicConservative
After all the garage sale activity I stayed up late getting my paladin to level 80. So now he's level 80. Now if I intend to raid with him I need to gear him up. That costs gold or means running daily dungeons for a while. Which probably means, since time is not infinite, that I won't be playing my rogue that much. Sometimes even I'm not sure why I embark on certain goals. Why did I want a level 80 paladin?

WoW update...

By CosmicConservative
Yeah, so I'm now leveling up a paladin on the same server my rogue is on. He's level 77 now. He was level 55 about two weeks ago, so I've been power-leveling him pretty good. The funny thing is that the only reason I started leveling him was to have him mine titanium and saronite for my rogue to prospect or sell for cash. But that goal was achieved at roughly level 68 or so, and I've kept going... By this weekend he'll be level 80. Then he'll be competition for raiding with my rogue... Dunno what I think about that yet... One thing I do know is that paladins are insanely easy to level up and run dungeons with compared to a rogue. My rogue gets hit one time and she's down. My pally gets hit three or four times and says "hmm... perhaps I should heal myself" and continues fighting...

WoW note

By CosmicConservative
I know my last WoW post said it would be short and then rambled for several paragraphs. This will be shorter. When I was raiding last year in my old guild, my rogue was consistently in the top three of the raid for DPS on bosses. In standup fights where you could just rear back and focus almost entirely on damage, she was frequently the top DPS in the raid. When I decided to start raiding again, one of my main goals was to regain that form. Last night in our Ice Crown Citadel 25 man raid I was the top DPS in half of the raid boss fights, and in the top three in a couple more. So I'm now feeling that my rogue is back up to snuff, and can really only get better with better loot drops. Also of note, my paladin is now level 70 and can fly freely in all areas of the game where flying is permitted. That will make mining and level grinding much easier to do.

Short WoW update...

By CosmicConservative
I blogged here how I had retooled my main World of Warcraft character, Rhlyssa, a level 80 raiding rogue, to focus her professions on those that gave her the best buffs for raiding, and how that had sort of dried up her cash flow because jewel crafting and engineering may give the best buffs to a DPS character, but both of them are high-expense professions and both are best serviced by a profession that provides raw materials so that the character doesn't have to buy those materials at a high markup from the auction house. So, since the bulk of Rhlyssa's cash used to come from mining, I decided to level up my paladin, a character that up until now has served mostly as a tool to convert Rhlyssa's unusable loot items into magical components which can be sold on the auction house. Leveling up a character in WoW is also known as "the grind". So I've been grinding it out with "Soulcleanser" and have managed to bring him right to the brink of level 70. That's high enough to get his mining skill maxed and allows him to travel around the bulk of Northrend, the highest level continent in the game. But doing the level grind has been an education in itself. It's been over a year since Rhlyssa did the level grind from about level 60 to level 80, but I have very clear memories of many of the quests and activities that Rhlyssa had to do, and so it is fairly easy to compare leveling up Rhlyssa and leveling up Soulcleanser. And the difference is striking. When I was leveling up Rhlyssa I was a pretty decent power-leveler. Going from level 70 to level 80 was a mad dash to get access to the highest level content, and Rhlyssa managed to complete that effort as the first level 80 rogue in her guild and one of the first 20 in the guild overall to reach that level. That's actually how Rhlyssa got into the raiding party in the first place, because she hit level 80 well before most of the guild's DPS candidates. So I felt like leveling up a rogue was a pretty easy task. But compared to leveling up a paladin, leveling a rogue is like pulling teeth. Soulcleanser is virtually unkillable in the level grind. Rhlyssa would die fairly commonly, all it took was for a fight to veer a little bit into another critter's "pull zone" and Rhlyssa would suddenly find herself battling three or four critters at once, and with four parties attacking her leather armor class, she would usually die easily in those situations. Plus there are a lot of quests which end up their tree as "group quests" which recommend 2 - 5 players to complete to get the best loot. Rhlyssa could only rarely go one-on-one vs an end of tree quest boss. Soulcleanser, by comparison, can easily take on three or four opponents, even if they are a level or two above him. And only the very hardest of the elite end-of-tree quest bosses give him any serious trouble. This weekend I was wrapping up the quests in one of the high level areas of the Outland, and I happened to come across a pair of players who were doing the same quest tree I was. They happened to be a bit ahead of me, but I managed to catch up to them just as they engaged the quest tree boss, a particularly large, nasty and brutish ogre. They were both level 68 while I was level 67 and the boss was an elite level 68 ogre. The pair was a rogue and a warrior. The boss kicked their butts. Twice. Finally they agreed to allow me to join their group so we could all get credit for the boss, and with Soulcleanser added to the party, we took down the boss easily. After they went on their way, I camped the boss and easily defeated him single-handedly. At the end of the fight Soulcleanser had 70% health and 80% mana. I didn't have to use any potions and didn't even trigger my two trinket cooldowns which boost my spellpower and attack power. At level 68 I was taking on multiple opponents of up to level 71 and not even working up a sweat. And Soulcleanser is not remotely optimized, in fact many of the key slot items he has were not even enchanted or gemmed, just because it costs a lot to do that and he's been replacing gear so fast that it doesn't make sense to invest in buffing the gear. So if I realyl buffed him up, he'd be even better. In WoW monsters of four levels higher than your character gain a powerful ability that does massive damage. This is to keep characters from playing too far up-level and is just part of the game designers' attempts to keep twinked characters from dominating the game. But even four or five levels above Soulcleanser is not too far for him to reach sometimes. In fact I was tackling level 70 monsters at level 65 and as a result was getting loot drops that Soulcleanser couldn't even use because they were too high level. However, that sort of fight takes a long time, and since the loot is unusable, it's not the most efficent way to level up a character. So for the most part I am keeping Soulcleanser in areas where the bulk of the monsters are two to three levels above him. My whole goal in leveling Soulcleanser up was to maximize his mining and enchanting skills so that he can provide Rhlyssa with a steady supply of ores which she can use to prospect for raw gems. But the more I play him, the more I realize just how difficult it really is to play a rogue. Rhlyssa is a true "glass cannon." She's got awesome damage output capability, but she can't take a punch. Her only hope to stay alive in a major battle is to manage to avoid getting hit. Soulcleanser can take half a dozen hits that would put Rhlyssa down, and smile while he self-heals in the middle of a battle. And from what I understand, Death Knights are even more overpowered than paladins. Now I'm wondering if I should bring Soulcleanser up to level 80 and go raiding with him. It would almost certainly be less stressful to do so since the main stress with Rhlyssa is the one-shot kill problem. When playing Rhlyssa I have to keep a constant eye on her threat since her DPS output can easily put her threat above that of the tank. In most dungeon or raid battles, if Rhlyssa ever gains threat, even for an instant, she's dead. Soulcleanser could take a couple of punches and stay alive long enough for the tank to regain threat. Plus paladins can perform any part of the raid and do so quite well. Paladins can tank, heal or be damage output characters. Since I expect to hit level 70 tonight, this is no longer an academic question. Soulcleanser could easily be running level 80 dungeons and building raid level equipment by next week if I keep leveling him. But I'm afraid two level 80 characters will just be too high-maintenance for me, and that in the end I'll end up only playing one anyway, and as difficult as I find the rogue to be in comparison to the paladin, there is a certain amount of satisfaction gained from topping the raid damage charts with a character that has to be played virtually flawlessly to avoid being crushed routinely in combat. Paladins can be played much more sloppily and still survive those same battles. This is making me wonder if I'd ever have leveled Rhlyssa up if I had started with the paladin...