Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

CNN back to form on science writing

By CosmicConservative
Here's a quote from their story on today's possible "demotion" of Pluto from planet status:
PRAGUE, Czech Republic (AP) -- The ninth rock from the sun faces the prospect of being demoted to a "dwarf planet" on Thursday if the International Astronomical Union approves new planetary definitions. Some scientists say Pluto never deserved to be a planet in the first place. It's smaller than Earth's moon, has a funky way of orbiting the sun, and lurks so far out on the fringes of the solar system even the powerful Hubble Space Telescope has to squint to see it.
Sigh... "ninth rock" is so wrong in so many ways that it is painful just to see such nonsense. If it's a pop culture reference meant to evoke the "3rd Rock From The Sun" TV show's ludicrous view of science, then I guess it's apropos since the story is so filled with inanity, inaccuracy and downright stupidity. What is a "funky way of orbiting?" Does it do a little jig every so often? Does it do loop-the-loops? Does it smell funny? Again this shows the tendency in CNN published science stories to quite literally write like a middle-school student. And there's that "lurks" thing again. Another malevolent presence in the outer solar system sneaking around waiting to pounce on something. Sheesh... Of course Pluto is not on the "outer fringes" of the solar system, in fact it is not only on the inner limits of the Kuiper belt, its orbit actually takes it inside the orbit of Neptune for significant periods of time. There is a huge portion of the Kuiper belt left "lurking" beyond Pluto, not to mention the Oort cloud, which is furtively creeping around even more distantly yet, and finally the actual "edge of the solar system" is, of course, the heliopause, which is performing its own sinister skulk out yet further still. As far as Pluto is from earth, it is not remotely on the "edge of the solar system." More quotes from this travesty of reporting:
Pluto got an ego boost in 1978 when it was found to have a moon that was later named Charon.
Yes, we all know that our anthropomorphized planetary bodies spend most of their time reading the New York Times looking for ego boosts, and are so fragile in their psyche that they go out and "lurk" some more if they get snubbed.
New observations also showed that Pluto's orbit was oblong
Pluto's orbit was calculated accurately within a few years of its discovery, calculating planetary orbits takes only three solid position readings over a relatively short period of time, within a few years we had dozens of solid position readings and Pluto's orbit was well known. It is also of note that most planetary orbits are oblong (or have a degree of eccentricity, much like this article seems to have).
That prompted some galactic grumbling from astronomers who began openly attacking Pluto's planethood.
Ooooohhhh not mere "grumbling", not even "planetary-sized" grumbling, in fact this grumbling was so severe and profound that it went well beyond "stellar" and even "interstellar" in scope, and achieved actual "galactic" status! Whoah, that's some grumbling folks.
At one point, things looked so bad for Pluto, the international union said publicly in 1999 that rumors of Pluto's imminent demise were greatly exaggerated and there were no plans to kick it out of the cosmic club.
Well, that was probably another boost to poor Pluto's fragile ego, but this is the first time I have learned that the universe is much like a middle school recess and that there is even a "cosmic club" to belong to, much less that Pluto is about to get "kicked out", no doubt because of its tendency to "lurk" around, apparently trying to peek up Saturn's rings or something equally perverted. Sheesh. Welcome back to CNN science reporting.

Comments (5)

qwerty182764
Pluto, by any name whatsoever . . . is still what it is. I don't get it. Why is this even important to people? We're arguing about what to name something. However we arrange our naming conventions will not increase or decrease our actual knowledge of what Pluto is, it's characteristics, ect. Why does this so preoccupy the public mind?
Dadman
Incoming message from the Big Giant Head... Lighten up Cosmic. The author is just having a little fun with the language...
CosmicConservative
Dadman: I concur, but such "fun with the language" doesn't belong in a straight science news story. This sort of writing belongs in a middle-school update delivered by Disney News service. This was the lead news story on CNN.com when I went to their site this morning. I guess I think there's a place for "fun with the language" and a serious lead news story isn't one of them in my mind. It's not so much the "fun with the language" that bothers me as much as the outright inaccuracies. My concern is that this sort of writing sticks with people who are the most ignorant about the actual facts, and because it was "reported on CNN" it becomes the facts that they know. We have enough ignorance of science already without the supposed "global news leader" actively adding to that ignorance in an attempt to have a "fun" story.
CosmicConservative
qwerty: This fascination or obsession with classification is a big part of what makes us human, and in general it does greatly advance the field of knowledge for lots of reasons. What is hard to tell is when this need to classify crosses the line from "science" to "semantics." And as with all such lines, reasonable people definitely disagree with exactly where that line should be. Scientists have a reputation for being more obsessively anal retentive about such things, and in this case they are demonstrating that stereotype to have some ring of truth. Heck, I must have a fair share of that obsession myself or I wouldn't blog so much about it. I still maintain that objects should be classified by their actual physical characteristics, not by where they happen to be at a particular moment. "Moon" is not a "thing" it is a "relationship." Planets and moons are not mutually exclusive things, one is a description of an object, the other is a description of an object's specific relationship with another object.
CosmicConservative » It’s official, we’ve lost a planet
[...] Related posts: CNN back to form on science writing [...]