Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Another planetary curmudgeon

By CosmicConservative
CNN.com - Planet hunter: Definition 'takes magic out of solar system'
PRAGUE, Czech Republic (AP) -- Few planet hunters stand to gain as much as Michael Brown if our solar system balloons to 12 planets under a new definition. He's spotted more than a dozen objects that might qualify as planets. So why is he upset? "When I was a kid, planets were special," he said. "This definition takes the magic out of the solar system." It was Brown's discovery of an icy rock bigger than Pluto that helped lead astronomers to rethink their definition of what a planet is. But Brown doesn't think his discovery -- or even Pluto, which was spotted in 1930 -- should qualify as true planets.
Michael Brown is the guy who discovered the Kuiper belt objects that have led to the current desire to redefine planethood. I sort of like his attitude, although I disagree with his contention that the 8 traditional planets (forget Pluto) are "magical" and are the only true planets in the solar system. It's a good article to read though. Two in a row from CNN that I didn't gag when I read them. I hope that's a trend. Here's what I think about the whole thing: As far as I can tell there are really four types of big round objects in the solar system, and perhaps this also works for other solar systems: 1. "Small" rocky bodies that have a tiny gas envelope (compared to their size) or none at all, and which have differentiated their interiors due to the heat and pressure of formation. This includes the four "inner planets" (Mercury, Venus, Earth and Mars) and several large "moons" (our Moon, Titan, Ganymede, possibly Triton). This would not include large round objects which have not differentiated their interiors. In fact this differentiation is perhaps the most critical part of the definition. 2. "Large" gaseous bodies that have a tiny rocky core (compared to their size) or none at all, and which have strong enough gravity to have retained high concentrations of hydrogen, which bleeds into space too easily on smaller planets. This includes the four "gas giant" outer planets (Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus and Neptune). These "planets" are different enough in my mind to deserve a separate designation from rocky planets. If we call earth a "planet" perhaps we should call Jupiter and its peers "gibogs" ("giant balls of gas", ok I admit I'm not good at names.) 3. "Immense" gaseous bodies that have an internal nuclear fusion furnace and radiate copius amounts of energy. We call these "stars". Perhaps one day I'll tackle the stellar distinctions too (brown dwarf? white dwarf? neutron star? magnetron" are they all really close enough in physical attributes to all be called "stars?") 4. "Large" icy bodies made up almost entirely of water ice, carbon dioxide ice, methane and dust. These are currently called "Kuiper belt objects" because they are physically distinct from both the rocky planets and the gaseous planets. So let's give them a name too. We'll call them "Kubos" ("Kuiper Belt Objects"). Then there are small objects, some of which may be round, but if they do not fit any of the above definitions, they are just round planetesimals, or round asteroids, or whatever we want to call them. "Moon" then becomes more of a descriptive term of what something DOES rather than what it IS. We can then arbitrarily define moon like I did in a previous post, just so people are happy that our moon is still mooning us. (sorry, couldn't resist). This makes sense to me, but probably sounds like gibberish to everyone else.

Comments (2)

qwerty182764
"“Moon” then becomes more of a descriptive term of what something DOES rather than what it IS. " Actually, this is a pretty sensible definition. You don't just have a moon, floating out in space as an intrinsic property. It has to be a moon of something. Or a co-planet, if you have something like pluto/charon. My personal preference is to just call every natural astronomical object a planet and add descriptors from there. (You might run into trouble when we start building death-stars, but I don't anticipate a problem before-hand). I see two things that I consider silly being batted around in this whole debate. The first is that celestial objects neatly fall out in a class-heirarchy like animal kingdoms do. There's no reason for them to - they're just inanimate congregated matter. The second is that this whole thing is of paramount importance to science. Whatever we decide to name these objects doesn't have anything to do with science. We already know what they are. This whole issue is just over what we're going to call them, it won't increase or decrease our actual knowledge of the objects themselves and their characteristics.
CosmicConservative » It’s official, we’ve lost a planet
[...] Another Planetary Curmudgeon [...]