Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Science & Technology

Denial of tickets attack

By CosmicConservative
Rockies ticket sales were down due to an external "malicious attack."
FOXNews.com - World Series Ticket Sales Suspended After 'Malicious Attack' Crashes Computers - Local News | News Articles | National News | US News DENVER — Colorado Rockies officials said Monday their computer system for online-only World Series ticket sales was the target of an "external malicious attack," but online ticket sales to resume at noon Tuesday.
The story sort of implies a "denial of service" attack. For a company that provides online commerce for selling sporting event tickets, I would expect them to have firewalls that shut down traffic on any ports not needed for their legitimate traffic, load balancers and scalable web server infrastructure, with additional load balancers at the app server level and, if they use them, even at the database server. Such an infrastructure should be able to handle most amateur denial of service attacks simply by restricting traffic to the narrow band that is legitimate, and then essentially out-muscling the requests. To defeat a truly enterprise level internet architecture requires some serious muscle. Usually that muscle is assembled by the denial of service attacker recruiting hundreds or even thousands of external PCs to flood the site with page requests. This is usually done by utilizing home PCs infected by worms which listen for a broadcast command and then send page requests to the target in the background without the user even knowing it is happening. Some worms have infected tens of thousands of computers and the IP addresses of those infected computers are made available to "hackers" for this purpose, sometimes at a price. So if that was what happened, it should be easy to show that such a technique was used. That technique is virtually impossible to attempt without using computers across many states (and countries). So since this is an e-commerce site, and the attack would have crossed state boundaries, if this is true, then such a denial of service attack is a federal crime. And such attacks frequently leave traces. I'd love to know more about this.... Just call it professional curiosity....

On Cloning and Artificial Intelligence

By CosmicConservative
I have been reading Ray Kurzweil's book "The Singularity is Near" and it has gotten me thinking more about the future than I normally do, and I normally do that quite a bit. One of the things that it is making me think about is the difference in public acceptance of cloning and of artificial intelligence research. Cloning is generally viewed with deep suspicion, and in fact laws have been drawn up to outlaw any cloning research based on the premise that it is morally wrong to mess around with the fundamental properties of human life. Artificial Intelligence is generally viewed with puzzlement or cynicism, in fact many deeply religious people consider the research to be a fool's errand since they view human intelligence as the sole province of divine intervention. But it is probably true that Artificial Intelligence research is nearly as far down the road to practical reality as cloning is. In fact an artificial intelligence comparable to a human brain is now considered to be likely to be created within a decade or two, probably closer to a single decade. There are many roads on the map to get to a working AI system, but many of them essentially are reverse engineering the human brain and applying the patterns and techniques used by the brain to create electronic versions of the brain. In essence this is "cloning" the human brain's information processing capabilities. I haven't voiced an opinion on cloning here because I am conflicted on the subject, but up until now I have been highly supportive of AI research. I'm now wondering if these are fundamentally inconsistent positions. It might be helpful to describe "cloning" as mass producing the hardware of the human body, while "AI" is mass producing the software of the human mind. I think that history has taught us that the human mind is the more important of those two systems. So if I have some fundamental issue with recreating human life in a lab, then logic compels me to say that I should be more opposed to AI research than to cloning. Or at least equally. But I can't do it. I still find myself fully supportive of AI research. And if anything, that is making me rethink my position on cellular cloning.

The future of telescopes

By CosmicConservative
Telescopes will one day be virtually useless if based on earth. The combination of light pollution, atmospheric interference, and political turmoil over their placement and use will eventually turn earth telescopes into museums. There will also be a limit placed on how large you can build one, and with telescopes, size is everything, so that alone will eventually make earth-based telescopes obsolete. Astronomy, even optical astronomy will move into space. The Hubble Space telescope is a relatively small telescope by modern astronomical standards, roughly one-third the diameter of the Keck telescopes. Its amazing photos are more a result of the lack of atmosphere and the ability to keep the telescope pointed at the same spot in the sky for hours, even days. There is already talk of trying to put a larger telescope into space, but what we need to be doing is not thinking about how we get telescopes designed on earth into space, but instead we need to start thinking about how we design a space telescope to be MADE in space. I've had some really bizarre notions about how to build telescopes in space. One idea I've had is to blow a really, really big bubble in space. Now I'm not sure how you do that, but for the sake of argument, let's say that you can build a giant beach ball in space, say something on the order of ten kilometers in diameter. Then you spray the entire outside of the ball with a hard-setting resin that makes it a solid shell. Once it cures, you cut out circular pieces of the shell and paint the inside with reflective aluminum or something else. Do it right and you end up with several huge spherical mirrors. Spherical mirrors are not perfect telescopes, but if you build a much smaller (say something the size of the Hubble telescope) hyperbolid mirror as a secondary mirror, you can correct the spherical aberrations of the main mirror. One big beach ball in space could give you six or more giant reflecting telescopes in orbit. Arrange them properly and use interferometry, and bingo you have telescopes with resolution capable of spotting a planet like earth orbiting millions of stars in our galaxy. But say you want something truly gargantuan. A telescope the size the earth. Let's shoot for a 15,000 kilometer mirror. How would you build something like that? It's pretty clear you can't use the beach ball approach (or could you.... hmmm...) still, it seems unlikely. So what can you do? Well, you could build a lot of little mirrors and have them laser-ranged and self-adjusting in relation to a central platform. So, as with many of my far-future space-based schemes, let's say you start with an asteroid, one with a high silicon content. Then you build a self-replicating robot that builds two copies of itself, and then builds a small (say 1m diameter) mirror. For the sake of argument let's copy the Keck idea and have them make hexagonal mirrors. For the sake of simplicity, make the mirrors spherical with a focal radius of say, 15,000 kilometers. Then the mirror-robots launch themselves from the asteroid, and arrange themselves in the shape of a telescope. It would start small, but would grow rapidly. As each new mirror was completed and put in place, the final telescope would be just a bit bigger and better. Perhaps it would take a hundred years to complete the mirror, but I'm betting on the exponential nature of the robots making two copies of themselves getting the full mirror built pretty fast. Now, what if you wanted to build a telescope the size of earth's orbit?

Global Warming debate branches

By CosmicConservative
So for years I have watched climate study turn from a scientific inquiry into a political one. From my perspective the Global Warming debate has a lot in common with the Intelligent Design debate. In both cases there are very real and verifiable phenomena that are supported as much by faith as by actual data. I posted quite a while ago about a group of scientists who were investigating Global Warming and had decided to plant GPS devices on the top of Greenland's glaciers. Their hypothesis was that due to global warming, over the course of a few years we would see the GPS devices drop in altitude as the glaciers melted out from underneath them. After a few years of measuring the glacier's height though, they discovered that the glaciers had in fact grown in height, not dropped. The conclusion they reached when confronted with evidence that directly contradicted their hypothesis was that the glaciers were getting thicker because of more snowfall caused by more cloudcover caused by .... global warming. Now I am not using that as any sort of evidence that global warming is not happening. I have been a skeptic on this issue for years, but more of a skeptic of the alarmism than a skeptic of Global Warming itself. Global warming may indeed be occurring, but I do not yet believe that the evidence is conclusive that the warming is caused by humans. I also have seen no reason to believe the "end of the world" doom and gloom prognostications that are commonly blasted across the screens of CNN or the New York Times. In fact, as I have pointed out before, Time magazine once ran a sensational cover story about the coming ice age complete with a picture of New York City covered in ice. So I pay little attention to the yammering of the mainstream press on this subject. As any competent climatologist will tell you, we have had periods of sustained warming in the historical past, and the world did not end. In fact the most recent period of warmer temperatures (called the "Medieval Warming Epoch") coincided with a huge growth in human population and human wealth, including a surge in exploration and technological advances. In a nutshell, the last time the earth warmed up a bit, those were "good times" for the human race. I see no reason to assume the same situation will somehow be catastrophic if it happens again. Also there is significant evidence that the earth's temperature has not significantly increased in the last decade, in spite of greatly increased sensitivity and breadth of climate tracking. So for the most part I consider the entire global warming catastrophe industry to be indistinguishable from the "Great California Earthquake" industry or the "Yellowstone SuperVolcano" Industry or any other of the industries that grow up around predictions of doom and devastation. I'm more of an "end with a whimper" sort of person when it comes to the end of the world, not an "end with a bang." But there is one area of the whole global warming debate that does worry me more and more. And that is the violent reaction in the science community towards anyone who questions the now commonly accepted maxim that humans are hell-bent on destroying the earth through SUV driving. The viciousness that is expressed in these "debates" is almost always from those who support global warming against those who question either the proof of its existence, or the certainty of its detrimental effects. There are increasingly stories appearing in the press about dissenting views being shut down, even to the point of jobs being lost over the issue. This is not good for science. It is not good for our society either. The very same people who claim to sanctify the "skeptical examination" of things taken on faith will pull no punches when their own beliefs on global warming are met with skepticism. There is also a tangential issue to touch here, which is that we have lost sight of what it means to be an "environmentalist" in this country. What we have today in the political spectrum are not environmentalists, or people who are concerned about the environment and want to be sure that humans are not having an overly negative effect on the environment, no what we have are "preservationists" who are demanding that humans have NO impact on the environment except to insure that the current state of things on earth remain in stasis. Any change to the environment is met with alarm because it might impact some local species variation of slug. My environmental philosophy might best be described as "managed environmentalism" by which I mean we should be good stewards of the earth and its resources, but we should not wall humanity off from the natural world, even if the goal is to "protect" the natural world. My experience has been that those who best care for the environment are those who have a vested interest in interacting with it. Not those for whom it is some sort of fairy tale that they only partly believe in.

Space Elevator update

By CosmicConservative
Via Instapundit: An interview with Dr. Bradley Edwards. Space elevators are the ultimate in space exploration, much like fusion energy is the ultimate in power generation. I once wrote a short story that did not get published that was a takeoff on space elevators, so I have had an interest in the technology for over 20 years. Back then it was considered to be a pipe dream (pun intended) to pursue a space elevator. Now NASA is actually looking at the technology. Consider a planet earth that has a series of space elevators spaced around the equator and which also has active asteroid mining under way. Refined materials (iron, aluminum, gold, etc.) would come down the elevator, which by converting gravity to electricity would provide the power to bring people, manufactured goods and trash (yes, trash) up the elevator. What kind of trash? Nuclear waste is one example of a good thing to get off the planet... This sort of scenario describes self-sustaining space habitation, exploration and exploitation that does not require dangerous, polluting and wasteful rockets to launch stuff into orbit. One thing that is frequently overlooked by proponents of space elevators is that one thing that is required for such a scenario to be successful is for the space elevators to be moored in places where the political environment is stable. If I had three wishes from a magic genie, I could do far worse than to wish for cheap sustainable fusion power generation, space elevators around the globe, and a thriving industry in space. It is hard to over-estimate the long-term beneficial consequences of those three things coming to pass. Ah, but would it cure world hunger? Perhaps not...

Iran crazy about the stars

By CosmicConservative
As an avid amateur astronomer myself, I have to say I am pleased by this CNN story. I have cloudy skies tonight, so I am stuck inside, sigh... Last night was a clear night but I had to work late and decided to chance it and planned to set up tonight instead. Then the weather changed. Oh well, the moon is nearly full anyway, so it would have been tough to see most of my favorites anyway...

The gravity of the situation

By CosmicConservative
I love to read stories about science in the press. Remember, this is the same press that repeatedly lambasts Bush and conservatives as "anti-science" and then reporters and editors combine for a story like this. Some of the choicer quotes:
Shenzhou VI, which has two astronauts on board, is in a low enough orbit to be affected by the Earth's gravitational pull
So let's see, how high do you have to go to get above gravity? I think I missed that day in astrophysics class.
Gravity has drawn Shenzhou VI too close to earth, the agency said.
So, did this "gravity" suddenly appear out of nowhere? Why didn't those engineers plan for such a thing as "gravity" in space anyway? Sigh... I'm not sure if the orbital problems are due to inaccurate calculations or to unexpected friction with the high atmosphere, but I'm pretty sure the gravity has always been there and that even if the orbit were higher there would still be gravity. Still, kudos and congratulations to China. A world with three space-faring countries is a better world than one with two in my opinion. Now to do something about science education for reporters...

Asteroid hopping

By CosmicConservative
Man, I love living today. Look at this story. When I was a kid the idea of sending a spaceship to investigate asteroids was pure science fiction. The detail of the pictures coming back from Hayabusa is stunning. This mission plans to land a probe on the surface of the asteroid and return a sample to earth. I live for this sort of thing.