So this weekend I did some catching up on the state of electric car technology due to all the hoopla over the Chevy Volt. In doing so I noticed a few assumptions about electric cars that are blatantly untrue in some cases and are cynical spinning of the facts in others.
The first thing that leaped out at me was the near universal comparison of electric cars to gas cars which get 25mpg. On the surface this appears to be reasonable because that's about the average gas mileage of a new car these days. But that presupposes that people buying an electric car would have purchased a gas car of that mileage when every study done shows that electric car buyers disproportionately purchase higher mpg cars. In other words, the Chevy Volt competes directly with the Mini Cooper and the Toyota Prius, not the Ford F100 pickup truck. To be more realistic, the mpg value electric should be compared to is more like 35mpg than 25 mpg. Using those more realistic numbers the supposed CO2 advantage pretty much disappears entirely.
The next assumption is that the cost of electricity won't rise when the demand caused by electric cars hits the grid. In fact the comparisons typically use laughable government goals which somehow defy the laws of physics in projecting energy costs declining to about 20% of current values. To call these projections "optimistic" is a serious understatement.
The next assumption is that electric cars will pull their power according to the overall energy production distribution that exists today. That means for countries like Canada or France which have a high % of power generated from nuclear or hydro, the CO2 output is much less than in a country like the USA which uses coal and natural gas for the bulk of energy demand. What this sort of analysis overlooks is that electric car recharging is a net new power request and even in countries like France and Canada, additional demand is usually met with coal or natural gas. Especially in America where hydro and nuclear have been stalled indefinitely by the wacko environmentalist lobby. In other words all of that additional demand is likely to be met by burning more coal and natural gas.
Finally, none of the analyses I saw factored in the cost and environmental impact of the battery pack production, yet all of them factored in the cost of refining and transporting gasoline. Even with all these assumptions electric cars are barely beating gas cars on CO2 and energy costs. If the comparisons were honest the outlook for electric would be quite a bit less rosy. And that's not even looking at how much work has to be done on the grid infrastructure to support a couple million cars sucking up electricity like sponges all night long...
