Hmm...
So three years ago the "Telegraph" ran a story supposedly sourced from the British Government about Obama returning a bust of Winston Churchill.
Now ABC is running a story saying that the original story was a bust.
The timing of the story is interesting, coming as it does at a time when Obama's campaign is still seeming a little shell-shocked by the public reaction to the Obama "You didn't build that" speech. Especially since the bust story has been repeated on almost every right-wing blog connected to the internet (including this one, I'm sure.)
So... did Obama insult the British in this fashion or not? And if not, why did the story not get rebutted years ago?
Hmm... interesting, I did a search on my blog's search engine and did not find a reference to the bust controversy. I suppose I may be the only right wing blog that didn't make hay out of that.
... has it been a major issue in the race so far?
As I recall there was a brief flare-up of anti-Mormon activity early in the primary campaign, but has there been much said or implied about it so far in the general campaign?
You know it's coming. We may as well get it started.
The Second Amendment, in its entirety, reads: "A well regulated militia being necessary to the security of a free state, the right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed."
There are two major areas where these words find vast disagreement among reasonable, intelligent people. First, of course, is the "well regulated militia" preface to the sentence. Many people who don't bother to investigate history think that "well regulated militia" is some sort of ambiguous phrase that might mean the Army, might mean the National Guard, or might even mean local police. The argument presented by gun control advocates is that the second amendment only means that the police or the armed military should have "arms".
The problem with this is that the concept of a "well regulated militia" is very clearly defined historically. In fact Congress in the earliest days of the union passed several laws about the "militia." The whole concept of the militia was a reaction to the new nation's desire to avoid having "standing armies" which the British Empire of the time utilized extensively. It was legal in the British Empire of the time for the military to simply appropriate homes or businesses for their purposes, and they did so. That was one of the things that built huge resentment in the early colonial patriots like Patrick Henry. So there was a strong desire to not have "standing armies". However, it was also clear that the nation had to have the ability to raise an army quickly. So the concept of the "well regulated militia" was actually codified in law and included every able bodied man of fighting age. Not only were they ALLOWED to own firearms, they were REQUIRED to own and be familiar with the use of firearms so that when the nation needed them, they could quickly react to hostile invasions or crises.
Now, that entire edifice collapsed by the War of 1812 and the "well regulated militia" was replaced with what is, in effect, a standing army ever since. However the principle of US citizens being expected to own and use firearms was by then deeply ingrained in the social fabric of society, and remained so until the social activism of the 60s, when gun control became yet another "social cause" for activists.
Since the militia system has been completely abandoned, it is actually a reasonable suggestion that the original intent of the second amendment cannot be realized. However, there have been multiple Supreme Court rulings since then that hold up the second part of the amendment even with the first part no longer applicable. So in terms of legal precedent, the "well regulated militia" part of the amendment can be considered to be completely irrelevant.
Which leaves the second important definitional part of the amendment. What exactly does "bear arms" mean?
This is a completely reasonable question too. Since laws banning the ownership of cannons or explosives go back to the dawn of the republic, the "arms" in the second amendment has long been recognized to mean "personal firearms" of the type used in hunting or self-defense. It has never been understood to mean cannons, nuclear weapons, artillery shells, etc.
But if the "arms" in the amendment means "personal firearms" we have to also acknowledge what that meant in the latter part of the 18th century. Although barrel rifling had been invented centuries earlier and was well known by gunsmiths and military experts, rifling a barrel was an extremely costly process and was virtually unheard of in both military and privately owned firearms. At the time of the ratification of the second amendment "arms" meant muskets and flintlock smooth-bore pistols that had to be muzzle-loaded by hand. Guns of this type were notoriously inaccurate and had a fire rate of roughly once or twice per minute, by a well-trained soldier or hunter.
The first "rifles" to enter the general public consciousness were the "Kentucky Rifles" of the Daniel Boone era. While these were far more accurate than the smooth bore muskets of the day, they were still muzzle-loaded and had a low rate of fire.
It wasn't until the Henry Rifle came out just before the Civil War that mass-produced, lever action, cartridge-based rifles that could shoot a round every second or so become commonplace. The Henry Rifle (and other similar rifles like the Spencer Carbine) were so much more lethal than the muzzle-loaded guns carried by most soldiers that a small company of Union soldiers using the lever-action rifles was able to defeat a much larger Confederate force using muzzle-loaders.
By a decade after the Civil War the Winchester, Henry and Spencer rifles (as well as the Colt revolver) had almost completely replaced the earlier muzzle loaded or cap and ball designs which predated them.
It may not be clear to some non-shooters what a vast difference in lethality a Winchester model '94 and a Colt .45 is when compared to a muzzle-loaded flintlock smooth-bore musket and pistol. Just in rate of fire alone the Winchester and Colt could deliver up to 20 bullets in less than a minute before needing to reload, a number of bullets that would require half an hour or more with the firearms in existence at the time of the second amendment's ratification.
But that was only the start of the firearms revolution. By the end of the 19th century the lever action and revolver had become the state of the art in guns technology, but a new design was already beginning to appear in gun factory prototypes. The next advance in technology was the introduction of guns which used the recoil from fired bullets to mechanically advance a new shell into the breech and cock the weapon automatically so that it could be fired again. By the 1920s one of the first mass-produced "automatic weapons" was created in the "Thomas sub-machine gun". By holding the trigger down a Thomas could fire at a rate of several rounds per second until the magazine was empty or the shooter let off the trigger.
The same technology allowed for weapons to fire, but a catch stopped the next bullet from firing, forcing the shooter to pull the trigger again for another shot. This is known as "semi-automatic" firing and is how most modern military and self-defense handguns and rifles operate. Such weapons will shoot as fast as the shooter can pull the trigger, and if the owner knows a bit about gunsmithing, and is willing to break the law, many can be converted to full automatic fire simply by filing off the catch which forces the shooter to pull the trigger multiple times.
Fully automatic weapons were outlawed almost as soon as they appeared, and such rulings have been upheld by the Supreme Court as constitutional. So there is clearly some limit to the second amendment.
I am a gun enthusiast. I enjoy shooting guns. I don't happen to own any semi-automatic weapons at this time, but I have been considering purchasing one or more.
The shooter in the Aurora theater last week had three semi-automatic weapons, an AR-15 rifle, a Glock 40 pistol and a 12 gauge shotgun. In less than a minute he was able to kill 12 people and wound over fifty more. And his AR-15 appears to have jammed, which means he could have done even more damage.
I guess the question I have about the second amendment is whether people believe that the founding fathers would have supported the right of individuals to be able to unload that sort of firepower in that short of a time. The guns used in the attack are completely legal guns, anyone who passes a background check could buy them.
Is that too much? Should private ownership of guns have some constraint on the rate of fire the guns can deliver?
It is important to remember that a major factor in the drafting of the second amendment was that the government needed to fear the righteous anger of the people and if the people owned guns, that fear was realistic. But in the modern world with the army using tanks, airplanes, howitzers, artillery, etc. is it realistic that private citizens armed even with the sort of weaponry used in this shooting could present a credible threat to that army? Back in the late 18th century a force of citizens using weapons of the time WAS a legitimate threat. Is it still a threat today?
Would it be reasonable to have the second amendment define some rate-of-fire limitations to privately owned weapons such that it would not be possible for a privately owned gun to legally shoot 100 rounds per minute?
Just wonderin'...
... are they reasonable?
$60,000,000 fine, no bowl games for four years, loss of 10 scholarships, vacated all wins since 1998....
I'm fine with the fine, in fact I think it could have been more. That figure amounts to one year's worth of revenue that Penn State receives from their football program. I knew football was a college cash cow, but $60,000,000 a year? Geez!
No bowl games for four years is also potentially a light penalty, but I'm OK with it.
The loss of 10 scholarships sounds OK until you see that the NCAA is allowing football players to transfer out and compete immediately. I'm not sure how NCAA rules work, but to me that makes me wonder how that will "trickle down". Penn State is one of the nation's top recruiting schools, so those ten football players are very likely to find a home in another school. Does that mean ten other current athletes under scholarship will lose their scholarship at a different school because Penn State lost them, but the athletes can transfer? If so then I think this part of the ruling stinks.
Finally, the vacating of all the wins since 1998... What does that mean for the players involved? Does that mean players' records are also changed? I just don't know how that works. Does that mean that schools who played against Penn State suddenly have their wins increased? I don't think so, but I dunno. What I do know is that this is likely to be the part of the penalty that angers Penn State fans the most, especially those who still revere "Joe Pa" since this means he drops about 100 wins down the list of "winningest college coaches", which probably drops him off the radar. I think he may have been the winningest coach of all time before this.
In terms of the severity of the punishment, I certainly don't think it's TOO severe. Is it severe enough? Well, it's hard to say. I suspect there will be massive civil lawsuits against Penn State that will likely take years to settle. As far as I'm concerned the penalties should not be restricted to the football program. This thing was covered up all the way to the top. Penn State allowed a man to continue to prey on young boys for over a decade because they didn't want a public "stain" on their precious football program. That's pretty close to pure evil in my book.
I don't think it's a coincidence that this is the same university whose "investigation" of Michael Mann's obvious scientific fraud in the "hockey stick" fabrication was also a whitewash. My only question is how many major universities would have done (or are currently doing) the same thing Penn State did.
Sick, sad world...
This is a photo from a major international news organization that accompanied yet another breathless article on the Aurora movie theater shooting.
The "arsenal" of a psycopath.
One semi-automatic rifle used throughout the world as a hunting rifle.
Two semi-automatic pistols considered among the most common self-defense weapons on the planet.
One standard 12 gauge shotgun.
Let's see how that compares to my own "arsenal".
I don't have a semi-automatic rifle, but I have TWO rifles, one a lever-action Winchester, the other a single-shot bolt-action Remington .22. While a semi-automatic AR-15 can certainly shoot faster than a lever action, you can fire a lever action pretty dang fast too.
I only have one pistol though, it's a six-shot Ruger .22 revolver, but it does shoot magnum loads.
I also have a 12 gauge shotgun.
But wait! There's more!
I also have a high-powered pellet rifle that would easily deliver a fatal wound to a human. And I have a pump action pellet pistol that might not kill a person easily, but I wouldn't want to get hit by one of its pellets either.
And then I have a wrist-rocket slingshot that is probably more lethal than the pellet pistol. I've punched steel ball-bearings through foam core and cardboard signs on the side of the road.
"Arsenal". I know a dozen people who have more and more powerful guns than this guy.
For the third time since I moved to Colorado our state is in the national news due to a lunatic (or lunatics) with guns and captive targets. First was the Columbine shooting, then the Platte Canyon shooting (which my son was in school just a short distance from the shooting) and now this.
There will be political grandstanding, exploitation of the event for campaign purposes and renewed screeching for gun control.
I don't remember if I've ever been in that theater, but since we used to live in Aurora and it's just right next to the Aurora Mall where we shopped regularly, I would bet I have been in that theater before, unless it was built after we moved. Anyway I've spent a good bit of time in that area and lived just a few miles south of the mall and theater for about five years before moving into the mountains.
In this case the shooter surrendered and is in custody. Maybe that will allow us to shed some light on what was going on in his twisted mind.
But I doubt it. In the end I can't help but think that crazy is just crazy.
So, I haven't commented on one of my favorite examples of pseudo-scientific nonsense in a while. That would be "Peak Oil" or the concept that the world is approaching a crisis because we are running out of oil.
The concept goes back to the early 80s (or at least that's when I first encountered it) during the OPEC oil embargo when people first started really looking hard at fossil fuel reserves. At that time it was frequently stated that "Peak Oil" would hit hard before the turn of the century. The theory seems to make sense. As we use more and more fossil fuels and become more and more dependent on them, we MUST be using them up because there is only a finite amount of oil we can drill for. The "Peak" in "Peak Oil" describes the point where world oil production reaches the point of maximum production and from then on can only decline more and more rapidly as we use up dwindling supplies.
Even way back then I didn't buy the notion. At that time I used to explain to people that technologies we had in place to explore for and discover oil was pretty limited. Besides that, it had mostly only been used in the USA and the Middle East. Virtually all of Africa, much of Asia and both the north and south poles had been virtually untouched, not to mention the 75% of earth covered in water.
Since then huge reservoirs of oil have been discovered in South America, the North Sea, Alaska, Asia and (ironically perhaps) Israel. And exploration of those areas has really only just begun. But even those massive discoveries pale into near insignificance when compared to the reserves of oil present in oil shale and oil sands, where trillions and trillions of barrels of oil can be economically extracted using today's technology, and that technology is only getting better.
This is actually the real reason behind the focus on "anthropomorphic global warming" in the past two decades. Once it was clear that Mother Nature wasn't going to stop the industrial juggernaut of development, for those who oppose progress (who ironically call themselves "progressives") it became critical to convince the world that burning fossil fuels ALONE was destroying the world.
In the past few years two major events have happened which have the potential to dramatically restructure the world economy. Those two things are the discovery of vast reservoirs of natural gas and the development of exploitation techniques for oil shale and oil sands. Putting both of these together, according to our current knowledge about fossil fuel reserves, North America has suddenly become the world's largest source of fossil fuel energy reserves. Recoverable oil and natural gas in the USA and Canada dwarfs the reserves in the Middle East.
Right now the Left is doing all they can to stop development of these resources. But in this case I can't help but think the sheer momentum of the world's industrial infrastructure is going to eventually steamroll over Obama's objections and the next 100 years could well see the USA and Canada benefiting from a renaissance of energy development.
The big loser here would be the Middle East. Which makes me wonder, if the Arab countries lose the leverage they have with oil today, does that make the Middle East more or less volatile?
So, a few days after the Obamacare decision came down, after I had read through the decision, slept on it a few nights and had contemplated what could possibly have led to the outcome I saw, I published this blog post describing what I thought of the decision, how I thought it had happened, why I thought it had happened and what the likely outcome of it would be. I was surprised by the reaction from a couple of my readers who expressed serious reservations about my reasoning capacity.
Since that time my take has become more or less the accepted wisdom of those who follow the court closely. In fact it is pretty much considered to be accurate by virtually every media commentator on the subject. In fact I heard an interview with a Supreme Court expert on a talk show yesterday who said that Roberts' decision had created a palpable and potentially permanent schism in the "conservative wing" of the court. And last night Antonin Scalia took the almost unheard-of step of doing an interview where he answered questions about several decisions (including Bush v Gore) made while he was sitting on the court. I believe Scalia did that in large part to allow him to give the conservative case for the Supreme Court since he no longer trusts Roberts to do so.
I am 100% convinced that everything I said in that post was not merely accurate, but was quite frankly ahead of the curve. Well, not quite everything. I had predicted a "double digit" swing in Obama's favor. The day before the decision came down Romney had a five point lead in the daily Rasmussen Presidential Tracking poll. At one point he dropped to a -2 in that poll, which would have been a 7 point swing (not quite double digits) and today he has a 1 point lead, so it is currently a four point swing.
Plus in the comments I had further said that I expected Obamacare to gain in the polls as well. Which it has, but not nearly as much as I had expected.
So although I believe that I absolutely nailed the political and social motivations and impact of Roberts' betrayal, it appears that I overestimated the impact on Obamacare itself, and Obama has not risen as much as I expected him to.
Now, I personally believe that the polls are now reacting to a series of incredible political blunders by Obama, the most critical of which is the "You didn't build that" speech, and had he been able to keep his actual beliefs hidden, as he usually tries to do, he would be higher in the polls, but that's merely speculation.
I will concede that I misjudged the impact of the decision on the American voting public and that I should probably have a little more faith in the public (at least 3% more faith anyway).
So... it turns out that the "native Americans" that European settlers drove from their "ancestral homes" in coordinated "genocidal attacks" essentially stole North and South America from the previous "native Americans" who appear to have been more or less entirely wiped out by the invading noble savages.
The ancient people who have long been thought to be the first humans to colonise North America were actually johnny-come-latelies, according to scientists who have comprehesively analysed the ancient fossilised poo of their predecessor Americans.
The new revelations come to us courtesy of Copenhagen university, where some of the investigating boffins are based. The scientists say that their results demonstrate conclusively their somewhat controversial thesis: that the "Clovis" culture dating from around 13,000 years ago - which has long been thought to be the earliest human society in the Americas - was actually preceded by human habitation at the Paisley caves in Oregon.
This is what the Clinton administration was actively trying to hide when they aggressively shut down access to archaeological sites in Oregon almost twenty years ago. This doesn't surprise me, of course, and I fully expect that the pre-Clovis natives who were wiped out by the Clovis culture had no doubt done the same to the humans who preceded them.
That's sort of what humans did all around the world right up through the renaissance. That's the "normal" human behavior that has driven human culture for the past million years.
People don't like to hear that, but that's the way it was.
If you want to know what the world was like ten thousand years ago, watch "Conan the Barbarian". That's pretty accurate actually.