I don't know if a definitive timeline has been produced. Perhaps we'll get one after tomorrow's Congressional Hearing. But here's a high level timeline as I understand it now.
(Update: National Review has prepared an illuminating timeline with more details than my high level timeline below. It is here: Benghazi terrorist attack timeline.)
The situation in Libya has been dangerous for some time. Since Spring and into Summer there has been an increase in Al Queda activity with the Libyan government repeatedly warning the State Dept. of potential Al Queda attacks in Libya, both in Tripoli but more likely in Benghazi.
Months before the Sept. 11 attack there were other attempted attacks in Libya, in one case an attempted bombing. So these warnings appear to have been accompanied with actual terrorist activities in the area.
Nevertheless the State Department drew down security details in Libya, particularly in Benghazi. This in spite of repeated warnings from Chris Stevens and other security experts that the situation was growing more dangerous by the day.
By the beginning of September, as the critical date of Sept 11 was drawing near, the security detail in Benghazi was reduced to a few contracted security guards and some local Libyan security forces. A few days before the attack one of the embassy staff members reported to his online gaming guild that he was afraid for his life and that members of their Libyan security detail had been taking photos of the grounds. He feared for his life.
Additional requests by Chris Stevens for more security were denied. The local "quick response" team was reduced to a skeleton crew.
Then on Sept 11, after a quiet day where Stevens met with several dignitaries, a sudden attack of RPG and grenade wielding terrorists stormed the embassy and dragged the Americans to their deaths.
Within hours of the event Barack Obama made a statement about the events being a reaction to an internet Youtube video. For days thereafter Obama administration surrogates repeated the false claim that there had been a protest against the Youtube video that had gotten "out of hand" and had escalated into a violent attack.
Even when evidence to the contrary was provided, for almost two weeks Obama's surrogates continued to feed the false narrative to the public. Obama himself alluded to the attack at the United Nations using it as an opportunity to attack "those who would slander and insult Islam."
Think about this. Those four Americans, thousands of miles away from home, doing their best to represent American interests and believing they had the power and protection of the US Government behind them, were dragged physically from the embassy, their desperate hands leaving bloody trails across walls as their murderers hauled them to their deaths.
And our President repeatedly and deliberately lied to the American people about what happened and why.
Utterly shameless. There are no words to express my outrage.
This is a serious question. The feeling I get from watching Obama is something like this:
Obama wants his ideology to win. He knows his ideology is at major risk if he loses. So ideologically he wants to win.
Obama hates to lose. Most people do. In modern American politics a one-term President is generally considered a "loser". Our most recent one-term Presidents have been Gerald Ford, Jimmy Carter and George H. W. Bush. Obama certainly doesn't want to be remembered the way any of those are. So I think it's fair to say that Obama doesn't want to LOSE.
Obama hates the job. I mean he detests actually being President. He apparently thought he was being elected King or Emperor and the fact that there are actual limits to the power of the White House chaffes him horribly. I get the impression that Obama had a Jean-Luc Picard vision of the Presidency. You get to sit around looking noble and every now and then someone will come to you with something that needs to be done and Obama could then raise his noble chin, gaze into the distance with his noble eyes and intone "make it so" and the accolades and admiration of the masses would shortly follow.
Actually being President turned out to be work. And that's just not fun. It's "a drag" in fact. And Obama doesn't like being dragged down.
So I get the sense that Obama is wrestling with his own inner desire to be "above" all the petty details of politics that are just so burdensome. He knows that he can't just give up, but his heart isn't (or hasn't yet) really been into it. He doesn't like actually having to perform and being judged on his performance. He doesn't like being challenged by someone who doesn't just accept his awesomeness. And most of all a person like Mitt Romney is the very antithesis of all that Obama believes in. To have to even be in the same room and pretend to be polite to Mitt Romney is probably a huge strain on his system. And now he has to do it twice more.
If all of that above is accurate, then by now Obama must be absolutely seething from the beating he has been getting from a previously fawning and sycophantic press. In some ways he probably feels utterly and completely betrayed.
It will be interesting to see how he reacts to all of this.
Entire cities in the World of Warcraft have been reportedly destroyed with no one spared, not even the NPCs.
About 13:00 GMT, forums on WOW started getting the first comments from users regarding player and NPCs dying on the Ragnaros-EU realm in Orgrimmar. Users of the online game started reporting that Draenor had a similar sight to offer. Some of the other realms where this was reported include Tarren Mill, Twisting Nether and others.
Electric Cars Hurt the Environment
The U.S. and other countries have spent billions subsidizing electric cars, an environmentalist solution which has been met with only lukewarm enthusiasm from customers. And it turns out environmentalists are split over whether these things are in fact worse for the environment than what we’ve got. A new research paper from the Norwegian University of Science and Technology has this to say (via The Guardian):
The study highlights in particular the “toxicity” of the electric car’s manufacturing process compared to conventional petrol/diesel cars. It concludes that the “global warming potential” of the process used to make electric cars is twice that of conventional cars.
The study also says – as has been noted many times before – that electric cars do not make sense if the electricity they consume is produced predominately by coal-fired power stations. “It is counterproductive to promote [electric vehicles] EVs in regions where electricity is produced from oil, coal, and lignite combustion,” it concludes.
I have been pointing this out for years. I can't tell you how many times I have asked a smug electric car driving liberal "Where do you think the electricity you are using comes from? And how do you think your 40 lead-acid batteries were made, and what will happen to them when they wear out?"
But that doesn't fit the narrative...
Even the lefty blogs are now routinely suggesting that Obama's debate problems were due to the fact that Obama has never had to deal with an actual substantive challenge to his self-professed awesomeness before. Of course here on this blog and in much of the conservative blogosphere the "empty suit, affirmative action, do-nothing narcissist" meme has been pretty much accepted as a fair description of Barack Obama. But now I'm seeing similar statements from the left.
Let's say it's true. Let's say that Barack Obama, for the first time in his entire life, has suddenly been confronted with meaningful, hurtful, substantive criticism and ridicule from people whose opinion actually matters to him. Like Bill Maher or Snoop Dogg. What is Obama's likely reaction?
It is said that it is in adversity that we truly learn about ourselves. What is Obama learning right now?
If, as has been the preferred narrative on the right, Obama truly is an utter narcissist with delusions of grandeur, then he is likely to simply get angry and go into denial. That would mean that Obama will probably conclude that he simply needs to go after Romney with every gimmick and lie he can scrape together between now and the next debate. That would mean he will probably hurl "47%!" and "Bain!" and "$5 trillion tax cut!" at Romney repeatedly, waiting for the crushing weight of public opinion to reduce Romney to a puddle of goo. The goal would be to try to destroy Romney because the campaign would have become something personal to Obama.
If, however, Obama has more to him than being a purely ideological narcissist, then he might take the approach of trying to out-Romney Romney and actually prepare for the debate by learning what his administration actually has been doing and searching for actual substantive chinks in Romney's armor. If so then he will probably try to undercut Romney's criticisms by zeroing in on every possible detail of Romney's career as governor or any possible inconsistencies in Romney's promises from the primary campaign to now. He might focus on Romneycare, or statements Romney's made about social security or medicare. The goal then would be to try to undermine Romney's appeal to independents and restore Obama's slim lead in the polls.
I hope Romney's getting prepared for both of these scenarios. I think the first scenario is better for Romney because if he's gotten under Obama's skin deeply enough, he could conceivably goad Obama into some serious mistakes. If Obama takes the second route, it's going to be more difficult for Romney to repeat this week's performance, but if Romney is prepared enough and clever enough, he can, I hope, at least maintain his momentum.
I've always been of the opinion that Obama is not nearly as smart as people think he is, he's not nearly as good an orator as people think he is, and that he is truly a pretty textbook narcissist who simply can't endure mockery or ridicule. I suppose in this next debate we will find out once and for all exactly how accurate that analysis is.
... will be on, yep, foreign policy. And it happens in 12 days. Which may be just about enough time for the media to be forced to report some of the extremely disturbing news coming out of Libya. At the very least it should be plenty of time for the Romney campaign to load Romney up with facts and analysis of the Libya debacle, the damage done to the nation's credibility and prestige by Obama's obvious cover-up of his incompetence.
If I were Romney's campaign manager I would be sending a special invitation right now to Ambassador Stevens' wife and family to sit on the front row of the debate, where they can look Obama directly in the eye during the debate. And if I were Romney I would ask Obama to look directly at them and explain to them what happened that allowed their husband/father to die at the hands of terrorists. Maybe too harsh.... I'd probably do it though. At least I would invite them to the thing and make Obama squirm under their penetrating gaze.
If they allowed props in the debate I would bring a globe and walk over to Obama's podium and say "Mr. President. Can you point to ANY NATION on this globe where the USA is better regarded and has more influence TODAY than when you took the oath of office? Take your time. I'll give you Venezuala even. But can you pick another?"
I would hammer, HAMMER Obama's "smart diplomacy" promises, and point out how incredibly stupid Obama's policies have been. I would point out example after example of how Obama's foreign policy has been driven entirely by ideology and has not dealt with political realities. I would say "Mr. President, how can you explain to the American people why you told the Israili Prime Minister, who is living under threat of imminent nuclear annihilation, that you had no time to meet with him, yet you had more than enough free time to appear on 'The View' and 'David Letterman?' Is it your view that the President of the United States views campaigning and posing as a celebrity as more important than the rise of a known nuclear threat to one of our most valuable and trusted allies?"
I would ask him "Mr. President, what exactly did you mean when you told Russia's President Putin that you would have "more flexibility" in your negotiations with him after you 'won' re-election?"
And "Mr. President, one of the crowning triumphs of US foreign policy was the liberation of Eastern European states from the umbrella of Russian hegemony. Why have you acquiesced to Putin's requests to withdraw US strategic support of those same states, which will surely push them again into Russian dependency?"
Just simple stuff like that.
No, I didn't watch a split second of it. Based on my experience with my observations of professional sports, if I had accidentally switched over to the debate for a nano-second, Mitt Romney would have projectile vomited all over the audience.
I'll read the transcripts and watch some Youtube videos.
But what say those of you who did watch?
Barack Obama is politically immortal because our mainstream media is hopelessly immoral. Also, corrupt down to its miserable, rotten core. But should there be one member of the mainstream media who still cares about truth, should there be a single member of the mainstream media who actually cares about reporting these things called “facts,” should there be Woodward or Bernstein out there who just wants to make a name for themselves, I have put a little guide together outlining the five scandals that ought to sink Barack Obama’s political career.
PJ Tattler - Bryan Preston
So, Bryan gets some of this right, but narrowing down Obama's "scandals" to a top five is actually quite difficult because of the quantity and scope of the non-scandal scandals this administration has committed(courtesy of the sycophantic media's complete unwillingness to report on them).
Bryan's list:
Scandal 1: Fast and Furious
Scandal 2: Kathleen Sebelius breaks federal law, keeps her job
Scandal 3. Obama administration leaks sensitive national security information for political purposes
Scandal 4. Obama administration tells defense contractors to violate federal law. Bonus: Obama administration says it will use taxpayer dollars to pay any government fines incurred
Scandal 5: Libya
Here is a short list of some other scandals that Bryan missed:
Solylndra and the rest of the "green energy" crony capitalism loan debacles. Billions and billions of dollars thrown away on silly unicorn-fart fantasies pursued by Obama campaign contributors.
Iran/Israel - "I'm too busy campaigning to deal with an imminent nuclear threat in the Middle East. Call back after the election, if you're still alive."
Obamacare - Remember that? Remember the "Cornhusker Kickback?" How about the "Louisiana Purchase?" How about blatant violation of House and Senate bill-passing laws? Open bribery of elected officials?
Obama's regal Presidency - More than ten times as many politically motivated "Executive Orders" than any previous President. Many, if not most, blatantly illegal. Appointment of unaccountable "czars" to run federal agencies that are nominally under Congress's control, not the President's. Nationalizing entire industries and screwing investors in favor of political cronies. On and on and on...
Using the IRS as a harassment vehicle to intimidate political opposition. There are many cases of prominent Republican donors being audited for what appear to be political purposes. This use of the IRS goes beyond investigating individuals and has even led to businesses which don't play ball with Obama being audited and levied fines and penalties.
I'm sure I am missing many, many more. I'm not even listing the minor little things like telling Putin "I'll have more flexibility" to appease him "after the election", or throwing East Europe under the bus and potentially back under the umbrella of Mother Russia.
What a depressing list...
It has become increasingly difficult to contact potential respondents and to persuade them to participate. The percentage of households in a sample that are successfully interviewed – the response rate – has fallen dramatically. At Pew Research, the response rate of a typical telephone survey was 36% in 1997 and is just 9% today.
I don't participate in polls, but then I never had. My typical poll phone call goes like this:
Me: "Hello?"
Pollster: "Hello, this is XXXX and we are taking a poll ...."
Me: (interrupting) "Who are you?"
Pollster: "... This is XXXX and..."
Me: (interrupting) "I heard that the first time. I don't know what that is. Who are you? What does your company do?"
Pollster: "... if I could just have a minute of your time..."
Me: "You've already taken at least a minute of my time. Now who are you? What does your company do? Who are you affiliated with?"
Pollster: "... we are just trying to take a poll..."
Me: "Then tell me who you are. I know the main polling companies, and I don't recognize your name. That means you are almost certainly a company hired to take a poll, and that means you are almost certainly taking a push poll where you are going to be trying to influence me to answer in a particular way so you can claim your poll supports whatever agenda your client has. Now one more time, who hired you? Who is your client?"
Pollster: "... we can't divulge that information."
Me: "Hmmm. well, then neither can I. But at least I can keep you on the phone long enough that I cost your client some money and at least one more person won't get a call from you. Goodbye."
Of course that's been more or less my standard response for decades, so that's nothing new.
Larry Young, a professor of psychiatry at Emory University who studies the neurological basis of complex social behaviors, thinks human evolution has harnessed an ancient neural circuit that originally evolved to strengthen the mother-infant bond during breast-feeding, and now uses this brain circuitry to strengthen the bond between couples as well. The result? Men, like babies, love breasts.
I dunno about this. The theory being proposed here is that stimulating a woman's breasts (well, more specifically the nipples) causes a release of oxytocin in the woman's brain, which is supposed to make the woman form stronger attachments to the man stimulating her. Men supposedly evolved the fixation on breasts because it led to more nipple stimulation which then led to the woman's being more attached, which reportedly gives the children of the couple a better chance at survival.
I have a couple of problems with this theory.
1. It is well established, both culturally and scientifically, that women are almost as fixated on breasts as men are. In other words, experiments have shown that women ogle each others breasts almost as much as men ogle women's breasts.
2. Most men have an almost equal, if not greater, appreciation for women's asses. Women are also known, both culturally and scientifically, to have a fixation on mens asses. Yet there is no indication that massaging an ass stimulates oxytocin any more than massaging a calf does.
3. This theory would not explain why larger or more shapely breasts are preferred by most men (and women). After all, from an oxytocin perspective any breast will do.
4. I am really getting sick of explanations of human or animal behavior that rely on some sort of omniscient, omnipotent DNA powers. I just don't happen to think that DNA is that smart.
Besides, I know why I like breasts (and butts) and it has nothing to do with oxytocin release or potential genetic advantages of my children.
It's because boobs are frickin' AWESOME man.